Amazon.com Customer Reviews
Neil Diamond's latest is hard for me to get into so far - Review written on June 28, 2008
Rating: 3 out of 5
This was a longed for comeback album, though it can be paired with 12 Songs, as both were influenced totally by Rick Rubin. And the songs have a Johnny Cash/Rick Rubin produced sound. Almost as if Neil sat there and wrote songs and arranged them according to Rick's specifications. Something was just off for me, and the overall tone was - and I hate to say this, but it was indulgent. I could see Rick telling Neil to just let it all hang out, so this does not seem like Neil's own idea. I love Neil Diamond, and have for over 40 years, but in buying these 2 latest albums I realized I loved Cherry Cherry, Solitary Man, Forever in Blue Jeans, Kentucky Woman, and about 5 other songs, but the rest, not so much. Why? I find these new songs are not so memorable. Yes, they are deeply philosophical and confessional, but it is not enjoyable listening to them. It's uncomfortable, for the most part. So I won't say anymore. I'll just play my Solitary Man - one of the most perfect songs ever written - and put the new ones back on the shelf for now.
What I did enjoy on 12 Songs was the duet with Brian Wilson, and on this one, Pretty Amazing Grace. It's a beautiful song and the only truly memorable one. I was blown away by it. Maybe if I listen a few more times the rest will grow on me?
Great voice wasted on vapid lyrics - Review written on May 28, 2008
Rating: 2 out of 5
1 customer found this review helpful, 5 did not.
I've listened to this once, and that's probably the only time I'll ever listen to it. From a songwriter of Neil Diamond's caliber the lyrics sound like they were written by a high school freshman in his first creative writing class.
Example:
All I want
Is to do it once more
Let me get through that door
Cause I still do believe that I can
Want that one more bite of the apple
And just a chance to taste it once again
Been around the world a time or two
Everywhere I've been I thought of me and you
I was hoping you'd remember how it used to be
And maybe that you'd still remember me
And that apple just as sweet as it could be
Reach right up and pick one of that apple tree
Just vague "you" and "me." Who's singing here about apples, Adam to Eve? "Remember how it used to be." What is "it?" The Garden of Eden before The Fall? His recording career? A relationship between two people? I want back through "that door?" First mention of a door comes at the end of the song. What's that about?
Neil's voice has never sounded better, but it's frustrating that it's wasted on such inane lyrics.
Things are gonna get serious.
What a waste of a chance for the two of us.
What can I do?
Is it so mysterious?
I would be much less than I am
if I couldn't have you.
Neil, you say you would be "less than I am," but you never say exactly what that is. What is it that this other person did that made you what you are? S/he was your "friend" and "by your side," but why, specifically--in the set of circumstances that precipitated this song--did you need a friend by your side? Rick Rubin also produced Johnny Cash's cover of "Hurt," and he should've made Neil listen to it every day, forcing him to tighten up his songwriting.
Neil seems to be drawing from a well-used group of metaphors and similes: "I was an empty vessel, you filled me up inside." Plato was using "empty vessel" as a metaphor way back then.
Some of my first albums growing up were Neil Diamond albums. I'd listen to "Hot August Night" through headphones, over and over. Compared to that album, this just seems like phoning it in.
Five stars for Neil's voice, zero stars for the album averages two stars, rounding down, just because I can.
Awsome and The Best - Review written on May 27, 2008
Rating: 5 out of 5
What Fun! It may take many years, but Neil Diamond is really Cool again.
His music has always struck a wonderful chord with me personally, and I know for others too. But, this CD - is surely his best. What beautiful music, what beautiful lyrics and the Wow in arrangments. All of the songs on the "Home Before Dark" are songs we can all sing to. They all keep ringing in my head. I just can't seem to keep them out.
I am so happy that this CD finally made the Number #1 Album. I am hoping that he will receive his just rewards; an emmy, and finally I hope that he will be inducted in the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame, but I will not hold my breath on that one.
It all started with "12 Songs" I loved "12 Songs" and it began at the Number # 4 on the charts, but because of spyware trouble it had to be taken off the shelves which did harm to Neil's CD, and to the computer's. That was just a terrible time for Neil. But, he kept at it and now he is receiving the kudo's he so rightly deserves. I beleive so much that "12 Songs is very much connected to "Home Before Dark", and it is a way of saying "Yes, to Neil". You are Number 1, and it is also Number 1 in the UK, and no dobut Number 1 will continue while he is in Europe touring and singing his beloved songs. Horray for Neil Diamond.
We Love You Neil.....the Poet of our Time.