Amazon.com Customer Reviews
Standard issue noodling... - Review written on March 28, 2008
Rating: 3 out of 5
8 customers found this review helpful, 7 did not.
I've more a less a fan of Pat Metheny's early work..I saw him seven times between 1979-1987. His early work was innovative, inspired, and fresh. I lost touch with the 1990-2003 work, but have listened to The Way Up, which I found a bit less focused, but within the context of the Metheny Group(i.e, with Lyle Mays) he doesn't disappoint. Day Trip seems to be off the cuff, spontaneous noodling. Not a bad thing, and his supporting players are excellent, but nothing really memorable here. If you're a die hard fan, get this. If not, stick with American Garage-Travels, his best stuff.
a trip worth taking - Review written on February 18, 2008
Rating: 5 out of 5
the new pat metheny day trip cd is a nice work worth investing in, there is a new rendition of when we were free that is enticing, i went to see this trio back in october of 07 in glen ellyn illinois, the show was great pat always steps it up in live performances , at last your here is a sweet subtle tune ,lets move kicks it up a little, if your a pat metheny fan there is no need for anyone to sell you this cd you will buy it yourself all i can say is for new fans if your into jazz trios with imagination this should fit the bill, as for the reviews about the same old thing there were several moments i was astounded by different twist and turns of creativity within every song so i dispute that, listen for yourself id tell you to enjoy but im not worried about that is almost guaranteed pat metheny on guitar, christian mcbride on bass, after seeing chris live i was floored, antonio sanchez,on drums a jack dejohnette with the energy of a thirty something never a dull moment during this trip
Simply outstanding - Review written on February 15, 2008
Rating: 5 out of 5
1 customer found this review helpful.
What hits you square between the eyes on this disc is the warmth of Pat's guitar tone, his amazing telepathy & synergy with the rhythm section &, finally Sanchez' utter "completeness" as a percussionist (sorry, but this guy ain't just a "drummer", he's the complete rhythm colourist). As for the tunes themselves, they are generally down-tempo (which makes the many intra-tune mood & rhythm changes even MORE glorious) & although not instantly "memorable" I can almost guarantee most will seep into your psyche after a few listens. A brief track by track overview:-
Son of Thirteen: a decent opener, albeit without a memorable "hook" & perhaps a little too much of Pat's trademark "runs" before he virtually stops on a dime to comp behind a shimmering Sanchez "solo" which is well worth the wait & definitely "steals" the tune!
At last you're here: Excellent piece worthy of repeated listens; Pat shows off a number of tricks in the jazz guitarist's armoury here (including a fantastic progression from single notes to chords which gave me goosebumps on the first listen!) plus a stunning solo from McBride with Sanchez again brilliant.
Let's move: as the title implies, probably the most "straight-ahead" tune & perhaps my least favourite for that; rhythmically & technically excellent solo from McBride.
Snova: an underlying bossa nova beat (as the title suggests) & if you close your eyes you can almost imagine the warmth of Pat's guitar tone carrying you with him across the dance floor before the bassman tries to cut in! Incredibly evocative & romantic.
Calvin's Keys: great groove, reminiscent of early swing bands at first but then, by turns, funky, light-hearted & playful. I reckon they must have had great fun with this tune on tour. Listen to Sanchez' subtle & almost ever-constant rhythm changes underneath. Easily one of my favourites here.
Is this America? (katrina 2005): Stunning & heart-rendering acoustic piece with a gorgeous bowed bass solo by McBride. Totally compelling listening & even though I'm not even American, still brings a tear to my eye after several listens. (Enough said).
When we were free: I'm a harsh critic of artists re-interpreting their own material on studio discs; this is undoubtedly a great tune (& I must say seems to flow-on quite naturally from "katrina") but the original (on PMG's "Quartet") was perfectly fine & although this version is thoroughly enjoyable, I don't think it fully justifies the exclusion of a "new" piece (although Sanchez does his very best to try & sway my opinion towards the end!)
Dreaming Trees: only problem with this acoustic track is that whereas "Is this America?" is 10 out of 10, this is only 9.5!. Another great solo from McBride.
The Red One: Same opening comment as for "When we were free" except here I guess Pat's doing all the guitar work himself without Sco beside him. The middle section here is significantly altered from the original (quite a reggae feel actually) & this, plus the fact that it adds a nice contrast to the other material on this disc I makes it worthy of inclusion (just!).
Day Trip: fine but kind of sterile (dare I say "formulaic") when compared to what's gone before.
In conlusion, despite my nit-picking on individual tunes here is a master at the top of his form, accompanied by a simply outstanding rhythm section (with apologies to Bill S & Larry G). Quite possibly this is the best guitar trio disc ever, not to be missed & easily 5 stars!!
Stunningly beautiful - Review written on February 09, 2008
Rating: 5 out of 5
14 customers found this review helpful, 3 did not.
Guitarist Pat Metheny gets together with what he calls "two of the best people on earth"; drummer Antonio Sanchez and bassist Christian McBride - all three of them geniuses in their respective fields, if you ask me - for this beautiful set of 10 songs lasting just over one hour. I often find myself searching for words when reviewing any Pat Metheny project. What's there to say anyway, apart from, it's stunningly beautiful and just as good as (if not better than) I expected it to be? It is very true though, that no new musical ground is broken on this disc - hence the "more of the same" comment by a previous reviewer; a comment I tend to agree with - but that doesn't bother me much. I don't think I could ever get bored of music by Pat Metheny and the album loses no stars from me as a result.
Metheny plays electric guitar for the most, only choosing acoustic guitar on the thinly veiled political lament "Is This America? (katrina 2005)", on which McBride takes a bow to his bass, and then again on "Dreaming Trees". He also plays his trademark guitar synth on "When We Were Free", a cover of a song that originally appeared on the Pat Metheny Group 1996 album Quartet and again on "The Red One", another one I've heard before on I Can See Your House from Here, the 1994 album Pat made with John Scofield. Sanchez and McBride make sure the covers work, in that they both actually add something new to the originals, which were pretty awesome to begin with. Kudos to them.
The guitar/bass/drums trio format has always been my favourite of them all and this particular trio has not let me down. Pick this up if you're a Metheny fan or just interested in sampling some good jazz guitar. It's worth every penny.
One question though, Pat: When's the next PMG album due? It's been three years already!
More of the usual from Pat - Good/Bad? - Review written on January 30, 2008
Rating: 4 out of 5
8 customers found this review helpful, 3 did not.
Another overall solid record with a stellar band. Christian's solos are typically astounding in technique while still beautifully musical, and his sound lends itself quite well to this trio. Sanchez, like Stewart, keeps the beat alive and sharp. A sort of album that would fill the background nicely during dinner, but also will entertain you when listened to with concentration.
I've heard just about all of Pat's recordings since '75; he was one of the first cats that made me excited about jazz. At this point, however, it's hard for me to get that excited upon hearing this because it just gets old - the phrasing style in his solos and his tone; I'll attribute it partly to an excess of hokey licks, glisses and 8th-note runs without substance [don't get me wrong he's an incredible player who can also be very lyrical]. And his compositional style, while some praise him for mixing it up between his group and trio etc, ultimately fails to break out of the same general character. It's great that he has that unique character, it's worth checking out if you're not familiar with it, but over time it becomes predictable and thus not exciting, which may not matter for some. All in all, if you're new specifically to his trio music, there's no reason not to start here aside from chronological.
I agree with the first reviewer's use of "unmemorable" with reference to the actual tunes. But I beg to differ that "hard-core" jazz listeners would particularly dig this in comparison to other contemporary artists: let's just say Holland, Iyer, Glasper, Mehldau, Moran, all of whom I personally find much more exciting. Neverthless, I do plan on checking out this album many more times. This is quality jazz, and you can still find plenty of excitement from what these great musicians are doing.
Great stuff.. - Review written on January 29, 2008
Rating: 4 out of 5
35 customers found this review helpful, 2 did not.
The late jazz writer Richard Cook described Pat Metheny's enormous audience as a mixture of "progressive-rock listeners, fusion fans, and plain old lovers of guitar heroes". In other words, he manages to cover quite a few stylistic bases, but here's an album that will appeal most to the hard-core jazz listeners among Metheny's many fans.
'Metheny hooks up with his regular partners, Christian McBride on double bass and Antonio Sanchez on drums. As you'd expect for musicians who have played hundreds of dates together they're very comfortable in each other's company, with McBride's marvellously deep, rich bass really shining throughout'(BBC).
'In its early stages, "Day Trip" seems to fall into some familiar postbop traps (too much technique, overwrought themes) but it soon settles into some jubilant improvising from all three, on the kind of bluesy grooves, Latin swingers and inviting ballads that suggest Wes Montgomery has returned to life and found the hippest 21st-century world-music partners he could' (Guardian).
He dazzles on 10 new originals.
"Let's Move" is fast and boppish, "At Last You're Here" is a fine ballad, bound to become a classic - as might his bluesy "Calvin's Keys" and a bittersweet acoustic lament for flood-battered New Orleans, "Is This America?"
For technique, taste and originality, Pat's still the man.
He is alternately pastorally lyrical and hard-swinging, reminding us of his origins in the music of Wes Montgomery and Jim Hall respectively.
Apart from the unmemorable nature of some of the compositions, this is delightful stuff.
The Incredible Jazz Guitar of Wes Montgomery
Hallmarks: The Best of Jim Hall