Amazon.com Customer Reviews
Horsepower - Review written on February 26, 2008
Rating: 5 out of 5
1 customer found this review helpful.
Band of Horses seems to be the person at the party people are asking about the following morning. Sure, they were noticed, but nobody got formally introduced. Band of Horses seem to be showing up more and more, mingling with pop, indie, folk and the whole time mixing in a soft rock serenade that blends in thoughtful, prophetic lyrics like the track "No One's gonna love you" to edgier, catchy beats like "Ode to LRC" and "Cigarettes, Wedding Bands". The sophomore release seems to come under mixed recollections of value, much like the mysterious stranger at the party the night before.
If anything brings them to the forefront with the album "Cease to Begin", it can be found in the first track of "Is there a Ghost", which is a song that stays steady and strong while introducing a haunting feel that does not negatively counter the sweet, high notes of vocalist Ben Bridwell. A chamber pop persona resonates with lush, harmonious tones on songs like "Marry Song" and "The General Specific".
Gene Simmons of Kiss once said something to the effect that they didn't want to look like the neighbors next door, hence hinting to doing something to look different than the norm. Many might have missed giving a full, detailed description of the mysterious stranger that next day, but if what is coming out of the speakers when playing this album is true, appearances won't matter. Band of Horses seems to be stronger than many bands in this musical fly by night gauntlet of a music industry one experiences today, with talent and passion making for a much more interesting and full album. The songwriting is perhaps the most interesting element of all, mixing in varying subjects and themes.
I have to say, in a day and age where many bands spend nine out of ten songs telling us how dire the economy is, that the world revolves around oil or that war can be a bad thing (seriously, tell us something we don't know), its nice that a band can sound more universal and imaginative without directly quoting the latest headline from CNN. Welcome the stranger with open arms the next time they return, even if they comes back with a stampede.
-Leo Navarr-
Much improved sound for their second album - Review written on January 22, 2008
Rating: 4 out of 5
2 customers found this review helpful.
The opening track of Band of Horses' new release, "Is There a Ghost," was one of the few tracks that I actively sought out after hearing it on the radio. I was immediately hooked on this band's sound, a sound that was familiar but entirely new.
Band of Horses was formed by Ben Bridwell and Mat Brooke in 2004 Seattle. They're currently signed to Sub Pop Records, a Seattle-based independent label which also manages The Shins, Iron & Wine, and The Postal Service. BoH started out opening for Iron & Wine, and on the cusp of their October 2007 release they started playing their own, packed, giant shows.
Their popularity is merited. Cease to Begin is a notable improvement upon their debut Everything All the Time: It is more straightforward, more refined, more likeable. Lead singer Bridwell's voice had me confused upon first listen, thinking I was hearing a new MMJ track, as his voice is sometimes identical to Jim James's (especially in the reverb-soaked stuff James is so well-known for), only less dark and more pop-friendly. They sound like an amalgamation of My Morning Jacket, The Shins, and a little Coldplay. Their myspace bio claimes that "Band of Horses' woodsy, dreamy songs ooze with amorphous tension, longing and hope," and this is very true.
"Is There a Ghost," beginning with slow anticipation, builds into some powerful stuff, while the next three are very beautiful indie-pop songs about loss that are ironically optimistic. I've gotten into the habit of listening only to the first four songs--which are undoubtedly the strongest--but the rest of the album is quite good. The twangier "The General Specific" and the more upbeat "Island on the Coast" would fit perfectly on a Shins album, while "Marry Song" suggests an attempt at singer-songwriter-ism (MMJ, I&W), but suffers from being too repetitive and not seemingly heartfelt. "Cigarettes Wedding Bands" is another rocker, which sports a catchy chorus, and the closer "Windows Blues" is another slow song, which works much better, since they don't play around with harmonies which allows Bridwell's voice to shine through. It's a quick listen, at only 35 minutes, but it's definitely repeat-friendly.
Ceaseless to Impress - Review written on January 18, 2008
Rating: 5 out of 5
Cease to Begin; Band of Horses' second album. It's truly an amazing album, and shows improvement over Everything All The Time. Don't get me wrong, Everything All The Time was a great album, with songs such as Wicked Gil, Our Swords, The Funeral, The Great Salt Lake, and St. Augustine. I enjoyed every song on that album.
However, in Cease to Begin, it seems BoH has really found their style, and did it right. With songs such as the astounding Islands on the Coast, No One's Gonna Love You, Detlef Schrempf, and Is There a Ghost?, you really want to go back and listen to them again. This album really isn't one you'd want just one song from, every single one is beautifully done, and if you want to listen to one, you'd enjoy the others equally.
Excellent album, 5/5 stars. Band of Horses has done a brilliant job, and I look forward to what they come up with next. But at the rate they're going, I can already say that I'll be one of the fist in line when their next album is released.
A whole new Band of Horses - Review written on November 16, 2007
Rating: 3 out of 5
3 customers found this review helpful, 2 did not.
Band of Horses return for their second album Cease to Begin with a slick radio-ready sound, nearly abandoning the My Morning Jacket-like spacey production that dominated their debut, Everything All the Time. I suppose that this was a conscious effort on their part, perhaps representative of their cross-country move from Seattle to South Carolina. The only problem for me is that I loved every moment of their first album. I think I might have loved it for its very ramshackle-ness (that a word?) and spontaneity. Both of these are gone, for better or worse, on the new album.
Opener "Is There a Ghost" is probably my favorite track, and it is the song most reminiscent of their first album. Though it only has about two lines worth of lyrics, it builds with a steady intensity, dropping some truly catchy hooks along the way. The second track, "Ode to LRC" tries to capture the epic qualities of past songs like "Funeral" and "Great Salt Lake" but doesn't quite add up to the sum of its parts. There are a few too many shifts in the song, and none of the different parts really grabbed me the way the aforementioned songs did.
The middle of the album feels like a slump to me. "Detlef Schrempf" is interesting because of its title (reference to beloved former Seattle Sonics player) and its abandonment of guitars in favor of a soulful organ. The end of the album, however, packs a surprising punch. My favorite of these last few tracks is probably "Cigarettes, Wedding Bands" with some really sucker-punching lyrics and a bittersweet melody.
Cease to Begin may be an unpleasant surprise for longtime Band of Horses fans. The band really sounds like a whole new entity on this album, mainly because of the up-front production. Ben Bridwell's voice no longer cascades behind waves of reverb, and the guitars punch right through the mix instead of drifting and chiming among the other instruments. Personally, I liked the older sound of the band, but I think they still have a lot of potential. I suspect that the new radio prevelance of this album will earn Band of Horses a lot of new fans, and good for them! Just don't forget your roots, guys, and keep working on those epic crashing guitar scapes.