Amazon.com Customer Reviews
this album almost killed me when i first heard it... - Review written on November 13, 2007
Rating: 3 out of 5
3 customers found this review helpful, 1 did not.
having been a fan of motion city since their stellar debut in 2003 "i am the movie", while also loving their follow-up in 2005 "commit this to memory"...i was putting a lot of anticipation on the band's third album "even if it kills me". after being bumped back a few months of it's release date in july, i saw the artwork for the album and that said it all to me. the album cover looked poppy and it looked like something a highschooler or middleschooler would salivate over.
however, i heard the first somewhat single (teaser) "broken heart" and i really enjoyed it. it sounded like your typical MCS song with a great chorus and clever lyrics. after hearing that song my attitude toward the album changed once again to anticipation.
well, sadly my first gut instinct was right all along. this album is a straight-up pop album. there is nothing interesting going on with the guitars, no angst in justin's voice, and the lyrics seem to be lacking from their previous "commit this to memory" which was their best release thus far. i mean it sounds like their trying to be weezer but also fall out boy at the same time. MCS use to be one of my favorite bands but they just went backwards on this release instead of progressing from "memory..." sure, the songs are extremely catchy and will probably do well on the radio and be eaten by the scenesters, but hardly any of the songs are memorable like "hold me down" or "my favorite accident" from previous albums. not to mention, almost half the songs sound weak and like filler where as every single song on their last album was strong and going somewhere.
i think a factor could be the vocalist's choice of being sober throughout the recording. he admitted in articles that he was always wasted/high when they made their previous records but he cleaned up on this album and you can tell. the songs are also cleaner and not gritty like before. the lyrics are lacking and not as clever. and the songs are simple, straighforward pop songs with no complexity to them whatsoever.
however, don't get me wrong...it's not a bad album or terrible by any means. it's a fun, simple album full of catchy upbeat songs that fans of weezer or fans of fall out boy will love. its just that the band went backwards and made their weakest album to date. hardcore MCS fans might have a problem with this album like i do but if you like the band somewhat and like pop music with no depth, then you will probably enjoy this album. there's been questions circulating about this bands continuance in the future due to the lead singers drug problems, so i hope they can stick together for one more album so they can go out on top. this would be a bad way to go out IMO. thanks for reading.
An Album That Gets Better Over Time - Review written on November 03, 2007
Rating: 4 out of 5
4 customers found this review helpful.
Motion City Soundtrack's new album, Even If It Kills Me, is the type of album that gets better with every listen. If it's a Motion City Soundtrack record, then the music that's about to blast through those speakers is guaranteed to be extremely catchy highlighted by amazing vocals and infectious keyboards. This record is no different.
Songs like, "Fell In Love Without You," are a good example of what the band does best. Songs that are fast paced, have heavy keyboard and moog elements, loud guitars, and vocals that sound effortless yet fit the song perfectly. "Point of Extinction," falls under the same category of being fast paced, upbeat, and incredibly catchy. The band tends to step outside their comfort zone more often than not this time around. Whether it's utilizing heavy ooo's and aah's as background vocals like in, "It Had To Be You," and, "Can't Finish What You Started," to songs that thrive on piano, incredibly harmony, and vocals that actually sound emotional like in, "The Conversation," the band has grown up since the last record and they're here to display how they've matured.
"Antonia," and, "Last Night," aren't your typical Motion City Soundtrack songs either. "Antonia," sounds like one on the surface, but the lyrics are sung in a way that are almost spoken and sound like they were written to gloat about Justin Pierre(the lead singer)'s significant other. "Last Night," is another slow song that brings the piano into play once again, but is surrounded by low guitars and clapping. The album also has lyrics that anyone can relate to and a perfect example is in, "Last Night;" "I still don't know exactly who I am. I never will. Amen."
Motion City Soundtrack has always had a strong closing track on all their records and Even If It Kills Me is no exception. It's a little slow at first before it builds up and is then broken down again. The lyrics, as I mentioned, are the highlight of the record. One of my favorite lines is from this song; "I'm really not as stubborn as I seem/said the knuckle to the concrete." Motion City Soundtrack has always been able to use vocabulary that other bands wouldn't even consider(like including, "plethora," in the lyrics on their last album), but they outdo themselves this time around by referencing Transformers twice on this record. They've always been able to utilize depressing vocals or songs dealing with depressing issues(like break-ups) that wind up contradicating themselves and usually display the final product in an upbeat way.
This is the type of album you listen to once, forget about, then come back to a few days later. The songs get stuck in your head and the album grows on you. The drawing appeal to this album is the lyrics. Most of the songs are about going through hard times and dealing with them. My life is a mess right now, so this is kind of like the soundtrack to help me through that mess. I think anybody can find something to like about this band, whether it's the heavy moog and keyboard elements that they're known for, Justin Pierre's incredible vocal talent, or the fact that they have lyrics anyone can relate to. Motion City Soundtrack is definitely a band that should be given more than a second glance. Even If It Kills Me is as good as part as any in their catalog to do just that.
its not that great guys... - Review written on November 03, 2007
Rating: 3 out of 5
1 customer found this review helpful.
I have been a diehard fan of motion city soundtrack since their first album dropped. i have seen them live numerous times, and i have all but played out their first 2 cd's. needless to say, i was quite excited to get my hands on this as soon as possible.
perhaps i just set my expectations a bit too high for this cd, but it just seems like they all kind of lost the spark to make music for this one. sure, there are some good, standout tracks ("broken heart" and "where i belong" come to mind), but there is also a bit too much filler ("calling all cops" and "the conversation") when compared with their older albums.
lyrically, i would say that this ranks just as high as their previous work. sure, some of them are slightly more quirky than they used to be, but they are all still just as endearingly cathartic as well. musically, however, it sounds like they just got bored writing their own songs at points.
all in all though, its still a pretty good album. more good songs than bad. it's much better than say, anything that nickelback could ever write. its definitely worth a listen or two.
This album is for real - Review written on September 19, 2007
Rating: 5 out of 5
17 customers found this review helpful, 2 did not.
Over the years, Motion City Soundtrack has gained quite a following, blossoming from unknowns to staples in the indie world and borderline mainstream. It's always difficult for a band to toe the line between staying true to their original style yet still evolving without "selling out." I hate that term, but when bands like Fall Out Boy and My Chemical Romance do a complete 180 in terms of their musical style after they got famous, you have to wonder what spurred that. Luckily, I think that with this album, Motion City Soundtrack has successfully pulled it off.
I have to admit, if you are looking for a punk sound, you may be disappointed. While a lot of their old stuff (songs like Throwdown and many tracks on I Am The Movie) had a grittier sound, Motion City Soundtrack has definitely gotten a little poppier. You can tell the difference in production and polish on this album than on I Am The Movie. Yet they have done so in such a way that their punk roots are still slightly evident, though the "pop" of "pop punk" is definitely the headline here. I think this evolution to a poppier sound was evident in Commit This To Memory, and they do it again here. Don't get me wrong, I'm not saying the sound is soooo different from their last album. It's a small change, and it works.
If you've read the Alternative Press article, then you know a big theme of this album is the sobriety and feelings of Justin Pierre, the lead singer and songwriter. This is very evident; many of the lyrics are more personal than in Motion City Soundtrack's past work. As a result, some of the songs are a little softer and more expressive, and there is more use of piano, most notably in "The Conversation," which is very Ben Folds-like. But they still retain their fast-paced, synthesizer rock sound. Lyrically, I think this is their most mature album. Songs like "This Is For Real" and "Even If It Kills Me" deal with themes like drug use and trying to get your life back on track, while tracks like "It Had To Be You" have the fun, goofy lyrics that MCS is known for. The quality of Justin's vocals (one of my personal favorite points of this band) are still very high, and the rolling drums that pushed the beat in old songs like "My Favorite Accident" and "Everything is Alright" is still here, like in "This Is For Real" and "Broken Heart." And while some songs are more mature, the pop sound has required that the Moog synthesizer remain of the band's focal points.
All in all, it's good to see a band successfully cater to their old fans while adapting their style to fit their changing musical tastes and abilities. If you ask me, I think this album is going to blow up (and for good reason).
Personal favorites: "This Is For Real," "It Had To Be You," "Where I Belong," "Point of Extinction," "Antonia," "Even If It Kills Me"