Amazon.com Customer Reviews
This rating is subject to change at any time, for any reason... - Review written on August 10, 2008
Rating: 4 out of 5
1 customer found this review helpful.
I'm intrigued. I have put myself into the position of responsibility to purchase a wide range of music that I might not otherwise be familiar with, and Kala is just such a purchase.
Quite honestly, I love her accent, and I love her quirky sense of style and artistic chaos. And that translates to the music. The irony being that the music is so "happy" and up-beat, and contrary to the opinion of another (obviously rhythmically challenged) reviewer, it is incredibly dance-able. In fact, if you do not move, then you either detest the music, or you have no sense of rhythm.
From the perspective of a musician and a bit of a "purist", the concept of sampling is a turn-off to me. However, when looking at the genius of such artists as John Cage (love him or hate him, he was groundbreaking, and the real father of techno-beats) and other such innovators, I can appreciate someone who can take a wide range of sounds and styles and incorporate them all into one place (this album). Of course, it is a bit chaotic, but I think that's exactly what M.I.A. had in mind (have you SEEN her wardrobe?). She wants you to think. She doesn't care if you like it or not, she is more interested in getting a reaction... mission accomplished.
The Timbland track was just a marketing trick to get more exposure... genius, sweetie! She put it at the end, so it has no real affect on the overall feeling of the album, and still the name of the US artist will bring more people to her music.
Despite the concern that she was unable to spend time in the US working on this album, I think that was actually one of the best things that happened to her in this case. Had she come here, the sound would have been diluted and made entirely too common. Instead, we have originality.
No bones about it, girl can't sing. But she's not marketing herself as a singer, but as a musical artist. She is able to create tracks using the tools available, and not being a musician to speak of, she simply takes existing sounds and arranges them into a tapestry of sound that is jarring, pleasant, irritating and endearing all at the same time!
This is a study in sound variations. Good job!
Groundbreaking? Fresh New Artist to Hit The Scene? NO! - Review written on August 01, 2008
Rating: 2 out of 5
3 customers found this review helpful, 3 did not.
MIA has seemed to get a lot of publicity by magazines and by Amazon, so I thought I check it out. I consider myself to be diverse in most music, so I always try to give some modern pop/hip hop a fair chance. Most of it might wind up in my garbage can, but that is besides the point. I have to admit some of MIA material is somewhat catchy, and that is the only reason that I gave it two stars, but folks, this has been done before. I dont understand where this is ground-breaking. Am I missing something? This is pretty much sampling over synthisised vocal, which is fine, but its not something that hasnt been done before. As a fan of Electronica, I can tell you that this has been done, and it was done over 15yrs ago when Techno become more complex and starting using more then just a four on the floor beat. Juno Reactor, Plastikman, Orbital, Meet Beat Manifesto, are just some old-school electronica acts that incoporated beats and vocal into a mish-mosh of chopped up blips and bleerps. Even the Prodigy who some of you might remember from the late 90's when they finally broke into the world of pop (but they were together since 91 when Experience was wrote, and released in 92)used some of this format. Some catchy stuff? sure, is it very good? not really. I will listen to fifty different electronica artist before I come back to this, as some of it is just to damn poppy and absurd.
An intense, body-shaking, mind-bending album. - Review written on April 27, 2008
Rating: 4 out of 5
15 customers found this review helpful, 1 did not.
Over a few years, British musician MIA - aka Mathangi Arulpragasam - has realised far-flung ambitions.
Her 2005 debut album "Arular" proved an electric shock to the system, its ballsy mashup of street styles and pop hooks earning a Mercury nomination in U.K.
Mia's new album "Kala" is named after her mother, but like "Arular" it mixes up musical ideas from around the world and crams them into a club- and radio-friendly collage of tunes.
This CD drives her music in even more intrepid directions
In fact this time, rather than work with British producers such as Steve Mackey of Pulp and the pop guru Richard X, MIA travelled widely to authentically capture the world music that intrigues her.
The result is fantastic.
"Birdflu" features the sound of traditional Indian drummers, whom MIA recorded on a trip to the sub-continent last year.
"Down River" throbs with didgeridoo she recorded at a workshop for aboriginal children in Australia. The tribal pound of "Hussel", meanwhile, was recorded with a Nigerian-born London-based rapper, African Boy.
Whereas "Arular" was dominated by bouncy funk carioca beats, "Kala" feels like a more mixed, cosmopolitan affair.Recorded in India, Australia, Trinidad, Japan, Britain and Baltimore with producers including Switch and Blaqstarr, it sounds like an infectious international travelogue.
Looking at that luminous, vibrant front cover, or the ludicrously colourful video for "Boyz", M.I.A. seems more like a textile artist than anything else.
If the driving force behind her music is a restless, globe-trotting quest for identity, that makes sense - a collage is a beautiful way of drawing disparate pieces together to create a whole that exists as something important in itself.
"Kala" meets the critics head on, taking her dancefloor smash-and-grab sound global.
She twangs the boundaries of taste both lyrically ("Take me on a genocide tour/Take me on a trip to Darfur") and musically. But a knockout's a knockout, however messy the bout.
All in all, Kala is an intense, body-shaking, mind-bending album, far more ambitious than most pop around.
My favourite tracks are "Paper Planes", "20 Dollars" and "Turn".
Multiple listens are the road to fulfillment - Review written on March 31, 2008
Rating: 4 out of 5
1 customer found this review helpful.
My friends insisted that I, as a DJ, listen to this, probably in hopes that I would love it and fit it into as many sets as possible. They couldn't have been more disappointed, because I loathed it the first time I heard it--I could not, for the life of me, understand why M.I.A. was receiving so much industry buzz and artist acclaim. I still wonder whether she's a true innovator, and whether her star can rise any further than it has already. But regardless, an amazing thing happened. I couldn't get the CD out of my car player, and the more I listened, the more I was enamoured with the songs, the production, her quirky and oft-nonsensical lyrics, and the flow of the songs (Timbaland-produced "Come Around," "The Turn," and the vaguely Sneaker Pimps-sounding "$20" are the standout tracks). Perhaps the secret is Kala's deceptively simple-sounding arrangements; I don't know. But one is missing out on something irrepressibly fun, edgy, and savvy if one dismisses it at first listen Multiple plays will, I assure you, make you a believer in the end.
is this supposed to be good music? NO - Review written on March 03, 2008
Rating: 1 out of 5
7 customers found this review helpful, 11 did not.
It's always great to find a great "experimental", "ground breaking", "inspiring" and "imaginative" album that stands out of the common and top 40 music. Examples of this kind of music they are many (thank God), but this album is NOT. It is dull, childish, REPETITIVE, PREDICTABLE, no hooks, no melody, no great beats. Don't believe the hype, this is not COOL MUSIC to show your friends, you will end with a headache. Save your money and look elsewhere.
All Hail M.I.A.! - Review written on January 07, 2008
Rating: 5 out of 5
1 customer found this review helpful, 1 did not.
Attention! M.I.A., one of the most surprising hits of 2005, has released her sophomore album, Kala! And I am pleased to report that she has not been affected by the sophomore slump. This album features more tongue-in-cheek songwriting as well as top-notch production from the likes of Fidget House maestro Switch, and hip-hop powerhouse Timbaland.
Let me start at the beginning. Arular, the debut album from Maya Arul (we affectionately know her as M.I.A.) held some definite hits with Galang, Bucky Done Gun, and Pull Up The People, but it lacked an album cohesion that would have made the entire experience unforgettable. She has found that cohesion with Kala.
From the first song, Bamboo Banger, you can see she's onto something. While Bamboo Banger doesn't have the most expansive lyrics ever, what is truly cool about this song is the progressive beat that gets more and more complicated over the duration of the song. This leads quite nicely into Bird Flu, a pounding thumper with what sounds like a group of small children and something that resembles a swan being choked. As strange as that sounds, it works quite well. This is a great track. Next we have the lead single, Boyz, a track produced by Switch. While nowhere near as catchy as Galang, Boyz has its own undeniable charm. You may want to take time off between repeated listens, as I've found it starts to grate a little the more you listen to it. Luckily, you have the rest of the album to distract you! Jimmy, the next single off the album, is based on a song from Bollywood's Disco Dancer. This is probably the tamest song of her career, but it's great and should not be overlooked.
Other standout tracks include $20, which samples New Order's Blue Monday, slowed down to a nice hip groove overlayed at first with M.I.A.'s wandering but ethereal voice and then with her lyrics. This song is about the difference of $20 here and $20 where she comes from. A great lyric from this song is I put people on the map that never seen a map. Paper Planes, my personal favorite, is a happy tune with a catchy laid-back r&b beat. Wait, happy What Here is the chorus:
All I wanna do is
BANG BANG BANG BANG
And I
Click Register Sound
And take your money
How pleasant! And absolutely genius. I love this woman.
Summary - This is a DO NOT MISS album, one of the best of 2007, and immensely better than her previous album. This album will go places.
The Jungle Line - Review written on December 07, 2007
Rating: 5 out of 5
1 customer found this review helpful, 3 did not.
Glistens like the new Cibo Mato ("Paper Planes" = "Clouds") but, with agro ideology and sonic recklessness, hits more like the new PiL ("Bird Flu" = "Pied Piper"). Laptop grunge, exotica hiphop, bayonet beats, bipolar samples, schizophrenic squarewaves with menacing messages - rave agitprop. Imbricated din. Download, at once, "Bamboo Banger,""Boyz," "XR2" and "$20." If Arular was Devo, Kala is the Slits; less funk, more flange - "MIA coming back with power, power" - dangerous nursery rhymes, communist disco. Mathangi Arulpragasam is Tania set to OCD bpm. Up against the wall, bourgeois!
WTF? - Review written on November 24, 2007
Rating: 5 out of 5
2 customers found this review helpful, 1 did not.
How cool is this? They clearly do things a bit differently over there in Sri Lanka. (Yes, I know she's UK-based at this point.)
This is one of the oddest albums I've heard in many months, and exhilaratingly so. What with the electronic mayhem, mad tribal drumming, and political fury, it reminds me of nothing so much as the classic "Bonk" by the Australian band Big Pig -- but fed through a blender and amped up for a weirder and more dangerous millennium. "I'm knocking on the doors of your Hummer, Hummer"...you hear that, Gov. Schwarzenegger? I think she's coming for you.
Tori Amos, Imogen Heap, and Vienna Teng officially have a new rival for my fanboy affections. (I'm sure they're in great distress.)
Sophomore Smash! - Review written on November 20, 2007
Rating: 5 out of 5
1 customer found this review helpful.
M.I.A.'s first album "Arular" hypnotized me with incredible lyrics and outstanding beats, so I was beyond excited when I found out in a magazine that she was coming out with her sophomore album "Kala" over the summer. The day it came out, I dragged my mother to the music store near my aunt's house in Oregon and instantly bought it, and what an outstanding buy it was!
This album combines a mix of dance, electro-pop, techno, rock, hip-hop and reggae into one. Each song is combined with free-dance songs (Boyz) to slow, mellow, easy-listening songs (Paper Planes, The Turn) to club beats (XR2, Bird Flu) to a mix of every genre I think I've ever heard of.
Her voice is incredible, and this album is better than any album I have ever owned. It is better than the popular stuff people today are listening to. If you want something different and fun, this album is for you.
This is a must-buy! Incredible beats, incredible lyrics, incredible songs, incredible singer, incredible ALBUM!!! It's all incredible! You won't be disappointed with the result of this CD.
Welcome news from 'World Town' - Review written on November 16, 2007
Rating: 4 out of 5
Reading the reviews of this work months after its release is interesting. M.I.A. has created a singular work in Kala that seems to intoxicate and aggravate people in equal proportions. Ratings for this album could go from 0 (get this thing out of my house immediately) to 5 stars (why has this thing called "Bamboo Banga" taken up residence in my head?).
I gave it 4 stars instead of 5 because of the Timbaland track, which somebody else mentioned as the album's drawback. It breaks the spell the album casts over the appreciative listener. On the other hand, I understand M.I.A. put aside many other celebrity-supported tracks that could have appeared on the album and perhaps made her more money. Her comments that she would rather be about the millions without a voice rather than being about "me" seem genuine on Kala.
I don't know much about hip-hop or most current pop music--most of it's not made for the demographic of a 50-year-old white male. Kala does remind me of other, older works that would seem to have no relation to it on the surface. There's noise-as-music as in early Sonic Youth, for example. It may be mainly a dance record, but an appreciation of avant-garde and experimental music may also make you a Kala candidate.
That's not to say that the music is self-conscious or cerebral (But: "People think we're stupid but we're not," M.I.A. deadpans in "XR2"). This is more of a field recording for the digital age than a conservatory experiment. And Maya Arulpragasam has the first-hand experience and credibility to base her work on indigenous sounds without being a "cultural tourist."
Arulpragasam's father left the family to join the Tamil Tiger revolutionary movement in Sri Lanka, where civil war still simmers. Human rights violations have abounded there. Maya lived in Sri Lanka until 1986, when at age 11 she came with her family to live in the Phipps Bridge Housing 'Estate,' a notoriously crime-ridden London housing project of the old-school, high-rise variety.
So, superficially, the sound you might expect from M.I.A.'s background is something like a mixture of early Clash and Mickey Hart's Planet Drum projects. Music that alternately seduces with rhythm and pummels with attitude. That's true as far as it goes, but there's much more going on here.
M.I.A. hasn't shown great chops as a singer, but that's not required here. When paired with the barrage of percussion and exotic (to Western ears) instruments, her voice becomes incantatory, and the spell is woven more and more tightly as the repetitions build. And songs like the Bollywood send-up "Jimmy" are just a lot of fun, too.
Kala can be off-putting on the first listen, but if your tastes in music are adventurous, give it a fair hearing. It can be appreciated both on and off the dance floor.
Fresh fresh fresh - Review written on November 09, 2007
Rating: 5 out of 5
3 customers found this review helpful.
I can't stop listening to this disc. I'm what MIA refers to as a geezer. At 50 yo, I was in a Barnes and Noble listening to discs and hoping for something to grab me that wasn't more of the same, novelty, or lip gloss on a pig. Rarely happens, but I picked up KALA and even with the 20 seconds per song could tell this was just mouth wateringly fresh and exciting.
After hearing the entire disc (over and over) I think it's really fabulous for its originality, sense of style, point of view, political passion, playfulness, and just fun. It's funny how a prerequisite for any superlative disc is that it sounds like the performers had a blast making it. Clearly the case here.
I also later bought Arular and also enjoy it, but found Kala to be more refined, inventive, accessible and distinctive. But I'll take anything I can get from this remarkable artist. M.I.A. give me more and keep us geezers happy (along with everyone else).