Amazon.com Customer Reviews
Alison Sudol Has The Potential To Be A True Star - Review written on September 22, 2008
Rating: 4 out of 5
2 customers found this review helpful.
Alison Sudol, a.k.a A Fine Frenzy, has created a very nice debut CD in One Cell In The Sea. While Sudol's lyrics, vocals, and piano playing are the centerpieces of the CD, they do not account for the entire story. This CD packs a fair amount of variety although some of it is subtle.
Lyrically, you will find familiar topics while Sudol also takes the road less traveled in some cases. This is most clearly evident on "The Minnow & The Trout" where Sudol makes a plea for people to put their differences aside using a metaphor of animals based on evolution. This is where the "one cell in the sea" reference comes in. However, there are also the typical songs of love and loss such as "Almost Lover" and "Ashes and Wine". Overall, One Cell In The Sea has a balance of concrete and abstract lyrics.
Vocally, Sudol is very strong as a pure singer. Her voice is very full even in the higher register as displayed on "The Minnow & The Trout" and "Whisper". I also thought that she gave good variety in her delivery. "You Picked Me" and "Rangers" have a more rhythmic pace on the chorus whereas "Ashes and Wine" is more straight ahead. She also uses dynamics well conveying earnestness on "Almost Lover" while using a much lower volume on the invitatory "Come On, Come Out". Among all of these variations, though, none of the songs lose continuity.
Instrumentally, One Cell In The Sea offers a fair amount of variety. "Come On, Come Out" and "The Minnow & The Trout" center on Sudol's piano playing while "Whisper" and "Ashes and Wine" make great use of strings. The strings on "Ashes and Wine" especially help create the melancholy mood for the song. "Borrowed Time" is an interesting piece as it has much more of a folk sound to it with the acoustic guitar. You will even find some electronics and synthesizers that work to varying degrees. While it works well on "Think of You", it winds up just being annoying on "Last of Days".
Overall, One Cell In The Sea is a solid debut effort for A Fine Frenzy. There is a lot of variety, but it is not always obvious. Two songs may sound similar, but the lyrics may have very different messages (see "Come On, Come Out" and "The Minnow & The Trout"). Other times the subject of the song might be the same, but the style is different (see "Almost Lover" and "Ashes and Wine"). It will be interesting to see on future releases if Alison Sudol keeps this level of variety, or if she gravitates toward one of the specific styles that she uses here. I think that "Borrowed Time" shows that she has very strong potential in the folk genre, and I would like to hear more songs from her along these lines.
Download this: "Borrowed Time"
One Cell In The Sea - Great Album - Review written on September 04, 2008
Rating: 5 out of 5
1 customer found this review helpful.
One Cell In the Sea is probably my favorite album released in the last two years. For a guy who buys hundreds of CDs a year and listens to every genre under the sun, that's saying something. Every track on the album is incredible. This is probably the best debut album since Third Eye Blind's debut masterpiece.
Even though I loved the album from the start, some of the songs didn't hit me at first. I was not a big fan of "You Picked Me," because starting your song off with "One, Two, Three" just isn't the way to win me over. Still, this song has grown on me too. I can forgive the counting off.
Alison's voice is amazing, and unlike a lot of the pseudo piano player musicians of today she can actually play. But most importantly, this is just well written music in every way, lyrics and accompaniment. If you haven't checked this out yet, you owe it to yourself. I can't wait for the next album.
I hope you give this album a try.
Enjoy!
'I Talk to the Trees' - Review written on August 02, 2008
Rating: 4 out of 5
2 customers found this review helpful, 1 did not.
There seems to be a surfeit of these earnest female singer-songwriters out there in the flux and fluctuating pop arena. Most are quite bad, but sifting through the rubble left on the battlefield, you can occasionally rescue small gems like A Fine Frenzy, hiding in potholes after the big guns (and we all know who they are!) have long finished discharging their infertile loads.
'One Cell in the Sea' is a tiny, slightly miraculous pop album. I'm sure supporters of Vanessa Carlton, Kate Nash and Colbie Callait et al can instantly tell their heroines apart and could fervently point to the varying merits of each, but for yours truly it needs something grabbing and different to raise the heckles and 'OCITS' has that special something.
'That special something' isn't anything mystical or other-worldly, it's simply well thought out words and ideas, presented straight and true in satisfyingly low-key but busy treatments. Nothing revolutionary or incendiary here pop-kids.
A Fine Frenzy (aka Alison Sudol) is a tiny, waif-like presence with a killer line in powerful melody and thoughtful wordplay. She's mainly piano-driven with layers of strings and acoustic guitar, and she's just dropped lucky - it all comes together for her (and fortunately - for us!). Even the lyric booklet is good. It's hippy woodland nonsense to a degree, with various colourful etchings of song-birds, (the only instance of vanity Ms. A Fine Frenzy indulges in) but in it's one-trip dream and romance world view, it finds this particular easily distracted commentator in sympathetic mode. It's merely an extension of 'OCITS's earthy lush-pop. A symbolic branch of it's mini-engine of creativity and mission.
Unsurprisingly, she's a quietly understated and beautifully stylish lady. She reminds very much of Madeline Smith, the fetching 70's Hammer actress, particularly in one gorgeous shot, where she's wearing a long, pleated, blood-crimson dress and is looking worriedly over her shoulder, as if the forest around her has just come alive, and is stealthily revealing it's sinister intentions.....
High points? Many, but the 'You Picked Me'/'Rangers'/'Almost Lover' triumvirate about a quarter in take some stopping. Deft and moving scopes of sound and thought, 'Last of Days' is suitably haunting, and the exceptional 'Lifestyle', the nearest thing we get to a 'rock' song, even has a "Yeaahh!" at one stage. Woah girl, deep breaths.
The album's not perfect. (although Alison probably is..) It goes on too long, there's a slight lack of diversity as it turns the last bend, and it sounds a bit one paced after repeated listens, but nothing that affects the effect of the many essentials. AFF will iron this out for her next album, importantly making sure she leaves in all the sleights and subtleties that make 'OCITS' one of the best of it's kind.
At the moment she's (deservedly) head and shoulders above the opposition, we'll wait see if she finishes there....
Excellent - pure poetry - Review written on July 16, 2008
Rating: 5 out of 5
7 customers found this review helpful.
A Fine Frenzy broke on the music scene just recently; indeed this is her debut album that came out on 7/17/2007. Well, it is easy to see what all of the hubbub is about! This young lady has an excellent singing voice that really gives her songs a haunting, soulful sound. The music is excellent with piano and other instruments. And as for the songs - pure poetry!
OK, do you think I am going too far? Well, it's true, this is excellent music. Ever since I got the album I have listened to it over and over again - in my car, and at work. Yep, I like it that much.
My favorite songs are The Minnow & The Trout, Liar, Liar, and Almost Lover. But, I love them all. I think that this is a great album, and I really believe that A Fine Frenzy has a great career ahead of her. I look forward to her next album, and I highly recommend this one!
Hauntingly beautiful - Review written on July 07, 2008
Rating: 5 out of 5
1 customer found this review helpful.
Absolutely, hauntingly, beautiful. Alison somehow finds a way to merge thought-provoking, totally relatable lyrics with melodies that are out of this world. There's a number of more melancholic songs on the album, but they're balanced out nicely with a few sweeping, spirit-lifting offerings like "You Picked Me", "Come On, Come Out", "Rangers", and so on. A song for every mood. In conclusion, this is a stunning, hypnotic record, and completely worth the price (and it's quite a bargain on here).
A Fine Debut... - Review written on June 03, 2008
Rating: 3 out of 5
2 customers found this review helpful, 2 did not.
Don't let my three star review fool you, I love this CD. I can listen to it all the way through and only skip one or two songs (quite an accomplishment for me). The lyrics are sweet and poetic; her voice is soft and sultry with a very pretty female falsetto. Unfortunately, she doesn't convince me. She has the vocal capability to reach a level of depth and passion that I just didn't find in this CD. She comes close in Ashes in Wine, one of my favorite tracks. Almost Lover is appropriately sad and (like many, I'm sure) the reason I bought the ablum, The Minnow and the Trout is an awkward but enjoyable stance on social relations, and Rangers finds a subtle Irish background mixed with prosaic lyrics, a good combination, but she sings it with slight lackluster and as pretty as the song is, I'm left a little unsatisfied. The meloncholy feel of the album is the reason I love it, but you can have meloncholy without monotony, and I think she rides a fine line. I truly hope that her follow-up album finds her doing some soul-searching. A voice that pretty is too good to waste on songs it doesn't deeply connect with.
"Not allowed to wear your freedom down..." - Review written on March 14, 2008
Rating: 5 out of 5
3 customers found this review helpful.
One Cell in the Sea by A Fine Frenzy is one fine album. Alison Sudol is her real name and I love that red hair! Alison has a sweet, affectionate, and unique voice, in some of the tracks you can hear a hint of a English accent and this girl is from the West Coast! Her songs, melodies, and lyrics are worth purchasing this album. Everytime I hear One Cell in the Cell, I feel like I am in another decade or place, Alison also plays piano on six of the tracks. Songs I cannot get enough of are: Come On, Come Out, Whisper, You Picked Me, Lifesize, Last of Days, Ashes and Wine, Hope for the Hopeless, and Borrowed Time. The two songs released Almost Lover and Rangers are hands-down the best tracks on the album. Rangers is a haunting song that gets stuck in my head all freakin' day, love it! I highly recommend A Fine Frenzy, can't wait to hear what she does next! Enjoy.
I've tried to connect........... - Review written on February 09, 2008
Rating: 3 out of 5
2 customers found this review helpful, 6 did not.
....with this album; I really have. I bought it because Amazon "recommended it for me", because I liked Colbie Caillat's "Coco". OK...I've already confessed a weakness for pretty redheads, and Miss Sudol is certainly that. She has a very pleasant voice, and the songs have a most enjoyable rhythm. And, the best cuts on the record, "Almost Lover", and "Liar, Liar" are absolutely superb. But.....
....I can't understand the words. If you read my five star review of the above mentioned "Coco", I praised Colbie for letting us hear every word. On this, I feel lucky to pick up one in ten. Sorry; a pleasant sound isn't enough.
This isn't a "bad" record....in fact, it's kind of engaging. I'll even keep trying, but I really do like to comprehend the lyrics.