Amazon.com Customer Reviews
3-1/2 stars -- Decent, but needs a greater escape from "the usual" - Review written on December 09, 2007
Rating: 3 out of 5
4 customers found this review helpful, 3 did not.
Emo is one of those sub-genres that seems to have taken over mainstream radio over the past two years or so, and there are so many bands like that that a lot of times there are those who take a while to get a break. Such is the case with the band Boys Like Girls, whose self-titled album was released last summer but didn't really get any attention until "The Great Escape" started making waves THIS year. I listened to their album, and it isn't bad, but...
Boys Like Girls is probably one of the most uncreative names for a band (although the line "Will you find another boy to go kiss and tell/'Cause you know I never will" from "Five Minutes to Midnight" might make some wonder if they're crossing over), but the thing about them is, well, it's basically the same situation as a band like Cartel: they really don't do anything that distances themselves from any other emo band out there. That, and there a few times when things get a little corny, like "Dance Hall Drug" and especially "Thunder". The second acoustic version of "Hero/Heroine" is also unnecessary.
I also think that maybe the breakup songs shouldn't be all bundled together toward the end of the album (with only the aforementioned "Dance Hall Drug" able to break things up). Boys Like Girls' album is one of those albums that is a must have only if you like anything emo; otherwise, borrow it first.
Anthony Rupert
Great CD - Review written on September 28, 2007
Rating: 5 out of 5
7 customers found this review helpful, 3 did not.
I bought this album last summer (August of 06) after hearing Thunder on their myspace and seeing Hero-Heroine on Youtube. Since, I've seen them in concert twice (I highly recommend it, Martin is amazing live) and they've become the darlings of radio and MTV.
It's a great about-town album, something fun to put on that'll keep you happy and not likely to murder stupid drivers in front of you.
The Great Escape - 8.5/10 - Their second single, a really catchy made-for-radio song. Good.
Five Minutes to Midnight - 9.0/10 - one of my favorite to sing along to. Flows well.
Hero/Heroine - 9.0/10 - If I wasn't sick of hearing it all the time, the rating would probably be higher. A very light, airy song. Really good
On Top of The World - 8.0/10 - Not a bad song, but not one of my favorites either.
Thunder - 9.5/10 (album version) 10/10 (acoustic version) - Their first song they wrote together. The ballad song of the album, it's about a summer love, and missing her. Fantastic song, the acoustic version is one of my favorite songs.
Me, You, and My Medication - 7.5/10 - It's okay, I just feel it's waily at some points.
Up Against the Wall - 8.0/10 - probably the least listened to song on the album for me. Martin sounds different, it's more brooding. Not bad, though.
Dance Hall Drug - 9.5/10 - Really fun, really catchy, and really fun. I love it.
Learning to Fall - 9.0/10 - The lyrics are kinda sad, it's about getting over being dumped and seeing her with another man.
Heels Over Head - 10/10 - My favorite. The chorus can be sung over and over, and I wouldn't care. Also about being left by a loved one.
Broken Man - 8.5/10 - Something is different about this song. I can't place it, but it's not bad anyhow.
Holiday - 9.0/10 - Slower, but good.
All in all, I'd give the album a 9.5/10. It's fun, catchy, and has a great beat. I'm always smiling after I listen to it. I wholeheartedly recommend it.
Five Minutes to fall Head Over Heels for Boys Like Girls - Review written on December 11, 2006
Rating: 4 out of 5
9 customers found this review helpful, 1 did not.
I have been listening to boys like girls since the album released, i have never heard them in concert, and haven't been following them since the day the were born, so my opinion is strictly one of a music lovers. i cannot in good conscience call this band a 5 star band although the way some people rate music alround here i think i could easily justify it. However dispite a few minor debut flows that should be expected from a brand new band, i think the music flowing from this album is definitely unparrelleled from any other pop-rock band this year although some would say they are a knock off of cartel. Although somewhat similar, the vocals and hooks truly separate these two bands. If you don't like pop-rock then don't listen to the album and don't review the album b/c your opinion is biased. I don't go around rating polka albums, and im sure no one who like polka gives a crap about my opinion. The lyrics are somewhat high school, but i really don't see a problem with that. Most bands lyrics relate to the current times and situations that have experienced, thats what makes the lyrics real. I'm sure if they were all 40 they would be out singing with bono about world peace and their favorite traveling hats.
Not all the songs are jaw-droppingly original but i would say the album as a whole has enough "never heard that before" type of stuff that it's definitely worth a listen. Songs like "Head Over Heels", "HeroHeroine", and "Five Minutes to Midnight" are up-beat with quick-witted lyrics mixed in with deep passion. Songs like "Thunder", "On Top of the World", and "Holiday" are mostly about growing up and moving on two things that are easily relatable to. These songs are somewhat slower than the first 3 i mentioned but overall i think the album has a good balance. The other songs are not terrible but not super special either although i would probably give an honorable mention award to "Up Against the Wall" although it may be a little too heart-throb. Anyways check these guys out, if you like good music i'm sure you'll hang on to at least a couple of these songs for a long time.
Boys Like Girls...But Only Ones Who Manipulate Them - Review written on December 01, 2006
Rating: 2 out of 5
16 customers found this review helpful, 20 did not.
Boys Like Girls possess not one unique song on their self-titled debut. From the sound-a-like choruses to the predictable she-done-me-wrong subject matter, it sounds like a hybrid of Simple Plan and the All-American Rejects. They do have talent and work off each other brilliantly as musicians, especially considering they formed their band a mere year ago, but they sound like everything heard before from the pop-punk camp.
Charging through the album like his life depends on it, lead singer Martin Johnson has passion and grit, but the similarity of his vocals to those of Pierre Bouvier, the lead vocalist of Simple Plan, is mighty disturbing. Some songs have admirable lyrics like the conflicting emotions of "Hero/Heroine" or "Dance Hall Drug," where innocence is sadly lost, but by the end listeners will only know one thing for sure: These guys like girls, and usually ones who manipulate them.
These young men certainly have talent, but next time around they would benefit from offering something uniquely theirs. Until then, they have a record to make them blush when they turn 40.
my true age is irrelevant - Review written on November 09, 2006
Rating: 4 out of 5
3 customers found this review helpful, 1 did not.
Now mind you, Pop/Rock is garbadge. People complain about the exponential number of post-hardcore/hardcore with simliar bands that have clones and are a disgrace to music. Well, pop punk seems to be lacking clones, mostly becuase most of the bands suck in their own special way.
Fortunatly, this is not the case for Boys Like Girls. Dumb name? Yes. But it's appropriate for it's High School romance like lyrics and sound. A bad thing? Only if you're one of those people with a musical royalty stick up your butt.
Now, there isn't really a terrible song off this ablum, it's extremely catchy, they've mastered the art of the hook. But then again, so has most rap artists, so that's not saying much. None the less, I'm struggling to think of a pop/rock band better then them at the moment. They seem really in their element and for a debut, their experience level and ability to write quality music is beyond their years. Expect them to sell out soon. Until then, pick this up.