Amazon.com Customer Reviews
A long awaited return to form - Review written on August 20, 2008
Rating: 4 out of 5
The Departed is a consistently engaging crime thriller from director Martin Scorsese. It's also the Scorsese film that I've been waiting for since Goodfellas, and I'm sure others feel the same way too. This film is a remake of the Hong Kong film Infernal Affairs, however this review will make no comparisons to that movie. Leonardo Dicaprio and Matt Damon play two moles. Dicaprio plays Billy Costigan, a rookie cop who goes deep undercover to take down mob boss Frank Costello (Jack Nicholson). Matt Damon plays Colin Sullivan, the man working for the state police as Costello's mole. The film also features Mark Wahlberg, Martin Sheen, and Alec Baldwin. Wahlberg gives the best performance of his career and nobody can play the sinister bad guy like Jack Nicholson.
Martin Scorsese is the master of the crime drama, as he as proved time and time again. His previous two films (not counting the Bob Dylan documentary Nor Direction Home) The Aviator and Gangs of New York had their merits, but they were missing something that the classic Scorsese films contained. Aviator was an interesting bio pic. while Gangs was defined by an Oscar worthy performance from Daniel Day Lewis. The Departed however is a return to form. Its main strength lies in the story telling, Throughout the film and especially in relation to the Damon and Dicaprio characters. You don't exactly know who's good or who's bad. It constantly keeps you guessing as any great Drama should.
A big-name total bomb - Review written on August 11, 2008
Rating: 1 out of 5
1 customer found this review helpful, 11 did not.
What were the reviewers thinking when they hyped this film? Do they automatically go for anything with Jack Nicholson? The film was contrived, hokey, packed with inexplicable behavior and major plot elements left unanswered. How did DiCaprio find the police shrink? Do all undercover officers use police shrinks to score tranquilizers? Do police shrinks really go on dates with men who spent the prior five minutes angrily yelling at them? Do attractive, young, female psychiatrists really sleep with pill-popping patients who have nearly zero time for a relationship? What happened to the envelope DiCaprio gave her? Regarding Damon's first encounter with the shrink in an elevator, does repeatedly using the F-word in public really work to impress female strangers?
Shouldn't the cops have, like, duh, wondered why a car packed with thugs just happened to show up to kill the cop captain that Damon ordered tailed? At the very least, wouldn't that have been a REALLY good time to take Damon off of his assignment? Would the cops tailing their boss really stay in their vehicle when they knew a gang of thugs had just entered the deserted building he was in? Is the murder of a state police captain so routine in Boston that no action was taken to find the killers? Why did DiCaprio feel that he had to be the one to arrest Damon, with zero backup? Oh, wait, I forgot, he did that so there would be another dramatic confrontation between two big stars.
I was riveted to the TV while watching Goodfellas and Casino; but then, those were dramatizations based on actual events. The Departed, on the other hand, has no bearing on reality at all.
EXCELLENT! - Review written on August 03, 2008
Rating: 5 out of 5
3 customers found this review not to be helpful.
I just happened to see this movie the night before the Academy Awards. I'm not going to spoil the film for those of you who haven't seen it by revealing the ending but I was blown away by the end. Totally unexpected and just the way a movie should be.
Leonardo DiCaprio is superb here. His growth as an actor is amazing. Jack Nicholson is, well, Jack Nicholson, often reminding me of his role in "The Shining". And Matt Damon "mans up" in a way that will surprise all. Everyone in this flick does a masterful job. However, although the only signigicant female, Vera Farmiga, was out of her league here. If the plan was for her role to be downplayed, it would have worked better if she wasn't even in the movie - no one would have missed her. Again, another part that could just as easily been done as a "phone in". And, while I love Anthony Anderson, he also seems like he just wandered onto the set so Martin Scorsese factored him in.
This is one of the very best movies of all time. I'm glad that Scorsese finally won an Oscar, but it's hard to say if this was his best, with "Goodfellas", "Kings of New York", "The Aviator", and the magnificent "Raging Bull". WOW! Who needs an Oscar with a body of work like that?! Don't worry about statuettes, Marty - keep getting your name on checks!!
Exhilharating - Review written on April 17, 2008
Rating: 5 out of 5
1 customer found this review helpful.
Movies don't get much quicker than this head-spinner. If you know the Whitey Bulger story from South Boston, you'll enjoy Jack Nicholson's twists. After you watch this, most other movies will seem slow and dull by comparison. Great soundtrack, as usual, for Scorcese, a music lover. But how many times can he recycle "Gimme Shelter"? The cat and mouse game at the movie's center is riveting, if silly. And the fake Boston accents by all except Mark Wahlberg, whose accent is real, will make you cringe if you're really from Boston. Even so, this one is a keeper.
Heaven Holds the Faithful Departed - Review written on April 07, 2008
Rating: 5 out of 5
1 customer found this review helpful, 2 did not.
Martin Scorcese is definitly a brilliant director, there is just no question, but many were angry that this was the movie for which he was finally recognized at the Academy Awards. I enjoyed this movie immensely, watching it over and over.
The thing about this movie that is so genuis to me is there are two characters living very different lives coming to the same result.
Leonardo Dicaprio and Matt Damon enter state police training. Matt Damon passes with flying colors and is immediately made into a sergeant. His secret, he is friends with Jack Nicholson,(Costello) a very evil mastermind that generates just about all of the cities crime. He is based on a true character of that time with a few small changes. Scorcese even recruited the police chief that worked on the case for a small part in honoring the new state police which I found to be very noble. Leonardo DiCaprio doesnt quite make it through the state police due to his background they don't quite trust him with the responsiblity. As he fails that, and is told he could be an astronaut not a statey, he is recruited to be undercover in Costellos crew to finally catch him and his gang once and for all. Costello ends up liking him, while questioning his motives.
Excellent movie, lots of decisions to be made which leads us to a very complex conclusion. Superb acting from many of our leading men including Matt Damon, Leonardo DiCaprio, Jack Nicholson, Martin Sheen and Mark Wahlberg. Definitly worth your time, and worth owning.
Nice one: An Oscar staple - Review written on April 03, 2008
Rating: 5 out of 5
2 customers found this review helpful, 2 did not.
Scorsese, Nicholson, DiCaprio, Kietel, Damon, Baldwin, Wahlberg, etc... Believe me, I think it's hilarious that Marky Mark is up for an Oscar for best supporting, and I KNOW he will NOT win. His nomination is enough, but jeez, he just friggin' annoyed me in this movie. It's been so long, I don't even remember if he lived or died. Hopefully died, I guess.
Damon & DiCaprio were wonderful as the two cops who were good or bad, or both. Who knows? I didn't. Nicholson is Nicholson, and he's always good, even when he's playing bad, which he does so good in this movie. It's a relative travesty that Wahlberg got the nod over Nicholson.
When I saw American Beauty in 1999 I walked out of the AMC 24 and I KNEW it would be an Oscar contender, which it was. Scorsese's ready. He's the turkey and the timer has popped. It's his time. But what else will it win? Can he pair his best director with a best picture? We surely will see. It's a front runner, that's for sure.
The film is a cross between Pulp Fiction and Batman - Review written on March 28, 2008
Rating: 1 out of 5
2 customers found this review helpful, 4 did not.
American movies have moved so far in the direction of unconscious self-mockery (think of "big-time" wrestling) that they and most of their viewers are not aware of just how far they have moved.
My last review of this film used so many asterisked expletives, simply to describe the verbal content of the film, that it did not pass the Amazon censors. Therefore, in this review I will simply say that the film is so replete with the expletive that describes the act of human procreation, used in all possible forms, that, well, it is boring and embarrassing.
The plot can be satirically summarized as four or five rat-like beings getting into a black van and trying to make a getaway while being shot at by ten or twenty of Boston's finest (cops.)
The cops do NOT succeed in shooting out the tires, even though they fire off at least a hundred rounds of ammunition. And that is the extent of the "verisimilitude" of this film.
There is a scene where Martin Sheen falls out of a very tall building and lands at the feet of Leonard DiCaprio. He lands on his back and still manages to look like Martin Sheen even though he has fallen at least ten stories. His face is still quite recognizable.
I had the improbable thought that Sheen might simply have taken a few punches in the face from Ted Kennedy for a very bad imitation of Kennedy's Boston accent.
The movie is about as creative as Jack Nicholson's backside but has obviously pleased the video game crowd. If you want social realism, avoid this film. If you want adrenaline rushes from fantasy criminals and cops, go for it.
I believe it was officially condemned by the Pope and the Boston Police Department but I'm not certain. You'll have to Google to verify it.
A Good Movie Overpraised - Review written on March 22, 2008
Rating: 4 out of 5
That Martin Scorsese had not yet been honored by the Academy is a crime. That he was honored for this enjoyable mess is just silly. Comparable to when Denzel Washington was belatedly honored for a good performance in a mediocre movie. Scorsese not even being nominated for Taxi Driver and losing to Robert Redford (Ordinary People vs. Raging Bull) & Barry Levinson (Rain Man vs. Goodfellas) are just the more head scratching of the Academy's decisions concerning one of the best directors of the last forty years. Alas, the Oscars is more about popularity, promotion, nostalgia and feel-goodism than awarding the best work. The other 2006 nominies weren't much to write home about either.
The Departed is entertaining enough if you don't worry too much about the flabby script, Matt Damon's awful performance, Nicholson's lack of screentime, & Marky Mark's fun but overrated stock character. Scorsese seems to let the name brand actors direct themselves far too much and relies far too much on violence and profanity to do his storytelling for him. Scorsese has always had mixed results directing women and The Departed is no exception. DiCaprio gives an excellent performance. Of course, he wasn't nominated. Nicholson is always fun to watch. The movie is fun but not very thoughtful or compelling and curiously uninvested in its own drama.
In a weak year for movies, The Departed was an acceptable Best Picture choice, not a great choice and certainly not a ringing endorsement for the quality of work being put out by Hollywood these days.
more or less FLAWLESS... - Review written on March 17, 2008
Rating: 5 out of 5
4 customers found this review helpful, 1 did not.
This was definitely one of the most gripping and well-crafted cop/crime thrillers I've seen in years---easily on par with the now-classic "The Usual Suspects" though quite a bit darker in tone. Certainly one of Scorsese's best films in a long time, though a lot of the soundtrack seems very, very familiar if you've ever watched "Goodfellas."
Sidenote: why in God's name they chose a terrible, awful remake of the Pink Floyd classic "Comfortably Numb" instead of simply using the studio original eludes me. This remake features Van Morrison (argh! this is just NOT his natural style or genre) and Roger Waters (who doesn't sound much like himself at all) and just sounds totally cheesy and weak.
Other than that, my only other quibbles about this film are with a couple of rather implausible plot twists during the final 10 minutes, and a somewhat Tarantino-esque (think "Reservoir Dogs") ending.
All very minor quibbles, indeed. The script, by William Monahan, is flat-out perfect, as are all of the ensemble cast's performances, and when combined with Scorsese's trademark brisk pacing and snappy transitions, makes for a film which had me totally absorbed from the opening credits. Stark contrast to how most films have a clearly defined "setup" first third which is kind of slow, then builds into a big second act where the conflict is played out, and slows again into a short third act plot resolution. "The Departed" is just a hyperkinetic, grab-you-by-the-a$$ movie from the get-go all the way to the closing credits.
A big part of its genius, and the reason it's a movie that you can watch over and over again, is that the characters are quite rich and mostly opaque, rather than being easily identifiable, focus-grouped stereotypes as in most mainstream Hollywood films these days. Also, the dialogue is just stunningly well-written. There's a lot of detail that you notice with repeated viewings, a lot of things that seemed a bit blurry or uncertain slowly become clearer. The plot is quite intricate and best of all, totally unpredictable---refreshingly, I had no idea what was going to happen down to the very last frame.
Another brilliant feature of this movie is that it has a very morally ambiguous subtext or perspective: there really are no clear good or bad guys, no knights in shining armor or innocent angels. Every major character retains an extremely engaging element of darkness, shadow, and surprise and unknowability. The cops and Feds and gangsters are all equally and comically, profane and violent...they're just on opposite teams, or most of them at least. Even the Vera Farmiga character (this actress is a strangely dazzling and exquisite woman as well as a top-notch actress), has her own darkness. What a delight, to enter a world of deeply imperfect and more or less impenetrable human beings, rather than good guys on white horses and bad guys in black hats...gasp! Why, I'll be damned, it-it-it's just like...REAL LIFE!!!
In short, this film is definitely a keeper, most definitely worth owning. One of the shortest 2 and 1/2 hours I've spent in a very long time...
Superb acting on top of brilliant storytelling - Review written on February 26, 2008
Rating: 5 out of 5
Please don't make negative comments like some of the aforementioned people have been doing if you haven't seen the film yet! I have seen it, at a press screening last week. Not only is it the best film of the year so far, it marks a return to form for Martin Scorsese, and ranks with the likes of GOODFELLAS as being one of the best in his canon of films.
I'm a fan of the Hong Kong film, INFERNAL AFFAIRS, upon which this is based. While THE DEPARTED keeps the basic structure of the original, it is very much its own movie, so much so that the screenwriter, William Monahan, didn't even watch the original film while adapting its screenplay, thus enabling him to infuse the script with his, and Scorsese's, respective visions.
All the actors are first-rate (yes, even Leo, for all you DiCaprio bashers out there), and turn in some of their best performances to date. THE DEPARTED is sure to garner a host of Oscar nods, if not wins, including (hopefully) Scorsese's long-overdue statuette for Best Director. Plus, with actors like Martin Sheen and Alec Baldwin playing supporting roles, that says a lot about the quality of the film they signed up for! THE DEPARTED is tough stuff, not for the faint-of-heart. That said, it is a must-see for adult viewers who long for intelligent, gritty stories to grace our movie screens once again.
Trust and betrayal: integrated case studies - Review written on February 22, 2008
Rating: 5 out of 5
2 customers found this review helpful.
Trust -- and its flip side, betrayal. Personal, professional, familial. Scorsese weaves an intricate tapestry of double-dealing, double-crossing, deceit and dishonesty, mixed in with an inordinate number of head-shot executions, in the seamy Boston underworld.
What does the movie ultimately say about trust? First, that there's not a whole lot of it for either cops or robbers, but second, that not all trust is misplaced, and honesty will at least be vindicated, even if it can never be fully compensated.
But forget the movie's theme for a second. Picture this plot: a determined, Donny Brasco-type mole inside an Irish gangster's criminal empire, combined with an equally determined dirty cop trying to find him. Cat and mouse action, generous helpings of violence, a semi-demi-plausible love triangle, lots of coke and Chinese gangsters all make appearances in a surprisingly coherent and entertaining mix. Great action and performances abound with the all-star cast as well.
Awesome! - Review written on February 20, 2008
Rating: 5 out of 5
2 customers found this review helpful, 1 did not.
This is one of the best movies I have ever seen! The cast are some of the most talented actors in Hollywood today. The Departed put Matt Damon on the map for me. And Leonardo Dicaprio...forget it. He is absolutely amazing as the tortured William Costigan Jr. I have seen this movie no less than 50 times. I'm actually watching it right now. I'm not a huge fan of "gangster" flicks, but this one is perfect. As the viewer, we know everything that the characters are trying to figure out, but what keeps us on the edge is wondering how it's going to be played out. Will the cops figure out who Costello's rat is? Will Costello figure out who's undercover? There is so much cursing, too, which is wonderful!! Personally, cussing is a constant in my circle, but if you have sensitive ears, you might need to steer clear...
The soundtrack is also terrific. The Dropkick Murphy's Shipping up to Boston is a key element and just seems to fitting to this movie. I love everything about this movie.!!!