Amazon.com Customer Reviews
Bob Seger is back, and it's about time! - Review written on June 18, 2007
Rating: 5 out of 5
6 customers found this review helpful.
I found out about Bob Seger after I came back from Viet Nam, and I was pretty wild and wanted nothing to do with the establishment and "society". All I wanted was a big motorcycle, a willing woman, a bottle, good friends, and to never call anyone "sir" ever again. Among those friends I found Seger on the speakers and he pumped my brain full of fire and soul. We were the "live to ride, and ride to live" crowd, and "Horizontal Bob" was almost a life style. Well, all I can say is that I changed, and so did Bob. We both weathered the years, became respectable, and rounded off the rough edges. When Bob did a duet with Martina McBride behind a black piano, I thought it was over. But, with FACE THE PROMISE Bob Seger has opened a door to the past, and let is some fresh air amongst the sillyness that passes for rock and roll these days. He just turned 62 the other day, and a comic radio jock said, as I was commuting (yes, sometimes I feel like I've had a sex change operation) to work that "Bob had lost the lead in his pencil". Well, that radio "personality" has obviously never heard FACE THE PROMISE. If you are over 40 (or like me over 50), and want that hard driving sound and entrancing lyrics that do not have to be hidden behind shredding guitar, buy this album. Of course, you may find yourself buying a motorcycle, wearing black leather to break the wind, and heading for the promised land.;-P If this is your first Bob Seger, his catalog is available, and you have a world of serious and true rock and roll to experience. Rock on!
The Boys Are Back In Town! - Review written on April 11, 2007
Rating: 5 out of 5
2 customers found this review helpful.
Bob Seger And The Silver Bullet Band-Face The Promise *****
"The Boys Are Back In Town" just about says it all don't you think? When you think of rock n' roll what do you think of...tattoos, leather jackets, Elvis Presly...no no no....Bob Seger And The Silver Bullet Band is the epitime of rock n' roll, they live and breath it and im so glad that the boys are in fact back. Growing up a Detroit boy you are raised on Seger and the boys. If you don't know every word to 'Turn The Page' you cant call yourself a native to Michigen. The fact that he waited so long to release this album only made the first listen even sweeter. I wasted no time in buying two copies of this album one for me of course and one for my dad who introduced me to the man. On first listen I thought, "man he's still got it." After about 100 spins in the player since I first bought the album my thought is now, "man, he's still got it."
Face The Promise is maybe the second best Seger album. But at times it could be the best, possibly second only to Night Moves. He took ten years to work up his songwriting chops and guitar playing to make the best album he could being as this will more tehn likely be his last. Songs like the title track 'Face The Promise' 'Wreck This Heart' and 'Simplicity' show that Bob as well as the boys have lost nothing. If anything they are better then ever. For a sixty plus year old man he can still belt like the best of him. Ya still got some mighty fine pipes Bob! 'Wait For Me' and 'The Answers In The Question' showcase his incredible writing skills as a lyricist.
As if he needed it Bob Seger decided to bring in a couple artists for collaberations. Kid Rock, another native to Detroit who I could not stand until he recorded 'Real Mean Bottle' for this album. One hell of a track. Seger also brought into bluegrass legend Patty Loveless for 'The Answers In The Question.' Another great song that seems a little out of Segers vocal range but he manages to pull it off because he is amazing like that. These songs do add to the over all greatness of the album but it would have been just fine with out them, because Seger is more then capable of carring the entire album himself.
For those who have been hesitent to buy the album because of what ever your reasons are, dont wait any longer this album is a must own in any rock n' roll collection and anyone who calls themself a Seger fan cant be a true Seger fan and not own this album. Welcome back boys!
Mixed - Review written on February 04, 2007
Rating: 3 out of 5
1 customer found this review helpful, 1 did not.
I got this with a gift certificate. I don't regret having it, but I wouldn't purchase it unless I could afford to get something good but less than stellar. I'm living on a lower middle class salary so am very selective with my music purchases. I'm a Seger fan and he was the soundtrack to my youth. No one can touch him with rock anthems and the essence of Midwest urban/rural working class/lower middle class musical expression. He was a road horse early in his career. Obviously he ruined his vocal chords. It all makes sense now, listening to what he did then and what he can't do now. His lyrical, musical and stylistic sensibilities are still golden, but his voice is rust. I could barely make it out. Now I was playing this on my car stereo, so nothing fancy I can do to change the sound. Seems like nowdays there are things you can do with technology to compensate for some vocal deficiencies. Also compensate with arrangements and mixing. Doesn't seem to have worked with this album. I miss Bob, and only John Mellencamp and Bruce Springsteen and Tom Petty come close to touching him in my book. Wish there was an answer to this voice thing, but I know many other singers who have suffered the same fate and I know it is rough. Still, even with a shot voice you can still convey something, aka Warren Zevon's "The Wind." With all it's flaws, I loved hearing Bob again, he's been sorely missed.
Very Worthy Effort...all things considered - Review written on January 31, 2007
Rating: 4 out of 5
1 customer found this review helpful.
I read a lot of reviews before I decided to purchase this CD. I felt slightly obligated to buy it since I am constantly complaining about how artists of the last 15 years lack a fraction of the originality, creativity and enthusiasm of the artists making music from the mid 70's thru early 90's. Since I feel that time period produced the best music, I always support those artists by purchasing their later releases, including recent efforts by Billy Idol, Eddie Money, John Mellencamp, Tom Petty, Lynyrd Skynrd and others. The majority of these, other than the Mellencamp garbage, have been very good and a considerably better than anything that today's artists are providing yet I find myself still pulling out the old stuff when I really want to listen to great music.
Now that you know where I stand, I will give my two cents on the new Seger. Firstly, I think "Are You" is phenomenal but much like Skynrd's "Red, White and Blue", it will never garner the earned acclaim that is deserves because of the staid musical climate that we now live in. "Wreck this Heart" and "Face the Promise" are both quite good and definitely would have fit in with any of the classics on older albums.
I also think "Simplicity" and "Between" are very worthy efforts.
"No Matter Who You Are" barely makes the cut and "Real Mean Bottle" would be okay if it was the only cover/duet on the CD. Unfortunately, this is where I run into problems with the CD in that I get the distinct impression that the decision was made to try to appeal to other segments by both crossing over to country and by enlisting the help of Patty Loveless. Maybe I'm at fault here in that I am no more a fan of country than I am of rap and I think Bob Seger's music is strong enough to stand on it's own without Loveless or Kid Rock.
I don't care anything at all for "Wait for me", "Won't Stop", "The Answer's in the Question" and "The Long Goodbye". As far as the anti-war anthem, "No More", I find it dull and contrived and I skip it just like the others that I don't care for.
One other thing, "Simplicity" has a horrible static throughout the song. I exchanged the CD for a new one and it has the same problem. Too bad that the static was on one of the better songs instead of on one of the lesser songs. Nonetheless, their is enough great and good music on the CD to earn Bob a grammy in my opinion. I said that after the first time I listened to the CD and I still feel that way even though I only listen to six or seven of the tunes with any regularity.
Just like the Billy Idol, Eddie Money and Skynrd CD's I bought, I would rather have just had eight solid efforts rather than to add any filler but I don't regret purchasing any of them. By the way, I'll be thrilled to see Bob in Rupp Arena again on March 8th...Turn the Page!!