Amazon.com Customer Reviews
great 2 CD collection - Review written on January 20, 2008
Rating: 5 out of 5
1 customer found this review not to be helpful.
BTW, the Christina Aguilera 2 CD collection, Back to Basics, is highly enjoyable. I've been listening to it at work this past week, and it's certainly my popular music highlight of this year, so far. (Yes, I know, the year is young, but last year felt a little weak in this regard.) The music has a bit of a jazz feel to it, and this feels natural...unforced...one gets a sense of evolution in Aguilera's musical style as a result.
If you want modern R&B, this is definitely close enough. - Review written on December 22, 2007
Rating: 4 out of 5
1 customer found this review not to be helpful.
It's not really soul music at all to be honest. It's pop music with an R&B twist here and there, as well as a handful of clever hip-hop samples from time to time and some ballads. The are also some songs about rough times. But that's no surprise - We've come to expect just a little depth from this 26 year old fireball. But whatever Christina is doing, she's usually speaking her mind and never holding back, which I, as others, highly admire.
She delves sort of deep and gives you her all. I appreciate that she is contemporary pop's best voice and probably will remain for a while. All the luck to her really.
The lyrics to this CD are pretty good, especially for pop music but she still has room for a little growth. She can also do without so many songs about her lovely hubby, Jordan. We got the point before this experience was over.
It has its moments where it really shines, but honestly, nobody but hardcore fans should have to pay the 17 bucks amazon and other stores are selling it for. Just because it's a double disc doesn't mean you're getting extra stuff, besides a lousy video or so. I have seen amazon in the past, selling it for 11.99 which I thought was fitting, but now it has skyrocketed back to its over-bloated price. >_>
It's a shame that her and Scott Storch went through it because he helped her write some great songs on her last outing. He also produced a great amount of the songs there.
What are my favs here?
Disc 1
Ain't No Other Man
Understand
Slow Down Baby
F.U.S.S. (Interlude)
Here To Stay
Disc 2
Welcome
I Got Trouble
Save Me From Myself
Like I've mentioned before, she's got the vocals, she's got the incredible, almost Mariah Carey-like range (which I find amazing, and she can do it better, with the better voice and all) and she's got the skills to write a decent song to pass the time.
I have written a review about this CD before but am much prouder of this one. I hope you can find this for 15 bucks or less, because that would be money well spent.
Recommended if:
You like the sounds of modern R&B
You have yet to own one of her CDs
You like producers who sample
You want a nice, voice of pop that isn't going anywhere any time soon
You love your boyfriend/hubby a lot, and want something to relate to
You want a fresh artist who speaks her mind (look for Nelly Furtado's Whoa, Nelly! and Folklore albums too; these girls have many similarities!)
I believe this to be her weakest entry. Back To Basics << Christina Aguilera < Stripped
Cover Art: A
Inside Art: ?
Songwriting: B-
Vocals: A-
Vocal Emotion: B
Vocal Acrobatics: A
Production: A
Length: C+
3.8 stars.
Overall: C+
Because exploiting the voice is more important than making good music - Review written on November 09, 2007
Rating: 1 out of 5
3 customers found this review helpful, 6 did not.
My main problem with "back to basics" is the blatant ego of the singer that infests this album. Christina is not even close to the greatest singer, even in this current day and age. It's fairly obvious that she loves her own voice and wants to express the alleged greatness of it-- not just by riding the scales like Space Mountain but by one of the most narcissistic songs I've ever heard in my life. One of the said tracks, Here to Stay, portrays this beautifully. Also notable is the "Thank you" track, which serves more as a dedication to herself than the fans and their unreal testimonials.
What makes this joke of an album even more laughable is that of all the ditched efforts of making it actually good musically were invested in the appearance of the album cover art, tracklistings, credits, and whatnot. The music is utter garbage. The first disc is a compilation of boring songs that serve no purpose but to show off the singer's supposedly majestic, powerful voice. Something that can't be drilled into our heads enough; in fact it passes on to the second disc. The second disc samples the type of music that it's advertised to be inspired from, but fails to create a memorable listening experience. Why? Because it's nothing NEW.
And another thing: just because one was inspired by talented, soulful, legendary singers of the past does not make anyone a legendary soul singer in their own right. By listening to this album, you are hearing the voice of a girl who never had to break a sweat trying to break into this industry. Now that Ms. Mickey Mouse Club alumna has a man to rest her little head on, it surprises me that she's still hinting about her childhood past. It's easy to assume that she literally has nothing to say about herself, besides her boring relationship with her partner, yet her overt narcissism desperately tries to manipulate listeners into pouring out their sympathy to her. You're hearing the voice of a conceited little brat who thinks she's original and innovative when throughout the span of her career she has done nothing that hasn't been done by somebody else.
Yes, Christina may have a better voice than some of her contemporaries, but that's the result of the fact that people are aiming REALLY low these days. Try out the less marketable but exceptionally talented, TRUE r&b singers who are doing wonderful things in music. Such as Keyshia Cole and Teedra Moses. A great jazz singer and saxaphone player that may be of interest is the lovely Mindi Abair. Go check her out as well.
Am I the Only One - Review written on August 27, 2007
Rating: 1 out of 5
1 customer found this review helpful, 4 did not.
Who enjoyed Christina better when she was the (how to put this in a printable manner?) the more risque X-Tina? These songs are a menage of Big Band jazz, pseudo-R&B, and just not fun to listen to. I know, for so many people this album is some grand homage to Aretha, Diana Ross, Sammy Davis Jr. and that's fine if that's what you wish to listen to. But for me, when I want to hear Christina, I want the "Genie in the Bottle" "Dirrty" girl who rocks the hell out of any modern lyrics. I adored her when she first came out as an antithesis to all of the little pseudo-virgin pop tarts who had come out at the same time but who had no substance to their music (or personalities) and who served as nothing more than Lolita-esque fantasty bate for the 40 something fathers out there. Ms. Aguilera has mind blowing pipes, great soul, a harsh background which lends credibility to her songs of pain and sorrow. This album shows off her very impressive vocal range. However, I simply feel that the material feels too retro (go ahead, blast me for this) and doesn't allow her to produce some great songs for the modern era.
Getting back to the basics - Review written on April 15, 2007
Rating: 4 out of 5
1 customer found this review helpful, 1 did not.
You can tell how much Christina Aguilera has grown in regards to her style when it comes to this new release. The old school, jazz/soul type music Christina used for inspiration in Back to Basics is sexy, sultry, and very catchy, but it still is very modern in flavor. ...In my opinion, there are only two or three songs that really capture the 40's, 50's, and 60's flair. I really love this CD, though - fans of hers shouldn't be disappointed, though some newer ones may have trouble adjusting to her new, maturer sound.
It just gets better with time... - Review written on April 06, 2007
Rating: 4 out of 5
In my opinion, Christina Aguilera never had a bad album (a bad PROPER album, anyway; I never heard Mi Riflejo or My Kind of Christmas, so I can't comment on them). But each album seemed to be a tad better than the last. She took a very long break after her second album Stripped (probably to get married and concentrate on the first stages of THAT), but she still managed to make a modest comeback with Back to Basics.
This album is a double-disc because, I guess, Christina wanted to make up for lost time between album releases (or maybe she realized that separating the work is sometimes best; after all, Stripped clocked in at 78 minutes). But each disc seems like it takes its own form, as disc one is primarily produced by DJ Premier, while Linda Perry handles disc two. This accounts for why there is a more hip-hop-flavored feel to the first disc, upon which produces such highlights as "Ain't No Other Man" and "Without You".
Disc 2, which appears to follow a circus theme, would probably have to be the stronger of the discs though. Not that Disc 1 is bad, but I just have more favorites on the second disc. One song that immediately jumps out is "I Got Trouble" (the song that was used at the beginning and end of the "Ain't No Other Man" video), and for some reason I was surprised to learn that that song isn't a cover. And Christina also shows her sensual side on her latest single "Candyman", which is immediately followed by the even more detailed "Nasty Naughty Boy".
This two-disc set isn't without its flaws, however. I don't know if I'd say there are any truly "bad" songs, but there ARE a few weak selections. For example, "Back In the Day" features too much sampling and not enough singing. "Still Dirrty" doesn't go anywhere, and while it's unfortunate the way Christina's father treated her and her mother, I'm not sure it's necessary to mention that on every album (see "Oh Mother"). Finally, the necessary dedication to fans, "Thank You", is mostly an unstructured collection of fan-made voicemail messages; in addition, a song like that would fit better at the end of the final disc, not the first disc.
But there are enough good songs to overshadow the questionable ones; and anyway, 4 errors out of a 23-song album is definitely no cause for alarm. Back to Basics just shows that Christina is still continuing her exceptional skills, so pick it up if you haven't already.
Anthony Rupert