Amazon.com Customer Reviews
Another Repetitive Greatest Hits Collection - Review written on March 12, 2006
Rating: 2 out of 5
8 customers found this review helpful.
When I read Rhino was coming out with a Roberta Hits CD, I was really excited. At last, a complete Roberta Flack compilation - or so I thought. But this is so similar to Atlantic's 1993 "Softly With These Songs" hits package, it has to be deemed a major disappointment. The only plus is it does contain "Trade Winds", the much sought-after b-side previously unreleased on CD before. But where is "Jesse", "If Ever I See You Again", "Will You Still Love Me Tomorrow", "I'm The One", "Uh-Uh Ooh-Ooh Look Out", not to mention the 1996 club remix of "Killing Me Softly With His Song"?!!! That remix went straight to #1 on Billboard's dance chart yet has NEVER been available on CD and a MUST for all Roberta fans. What a LETDOWN! Even the casual Flack fan is forced to buy two CDs to get a decent collection. Sorry, Rhino! This time you really missed the mark. The songs deserve 5 Stars but Rhino's efforts for putting together what should have been the ultimate Flack greatest hits package is deserving of nothing more than a big fat zero! Without a doubt, this should have been a double CD. So I am still waiting for a comprehensive collection of her work! Maybe someday someone will get it RIGHT!
Felt Like Makin' Love - Review written on February 16, 2006
Rating: 3 out of 5
9 customers found this review helpful, 9 did not.
It seems to me that a the feelings of the music industry these days are definitely a bit more manufactured than realistic. That has been the case with so many of the younger divas like Britney Spears, Ashnati, Jennifer Lopez and especially Beyonce'. It is definitely unfortunate, because so many people don't seem to appreciate older acts that have been extremely influential for the backgrounds of music today. That has been the case for Roberta Flack. Although she isn't really as recognized today as she was back in the 70's and mid 80's, her songs remain as much of a guilty pleasure that still remains delightful to endure. But can there be a greatest hits package that can showcase her beautiful vocals?
The 2006 Best Of Roberta Flack, is a single disc retrospective of Roberta's well-received career and the achievements she brought ut in this industry. The songs here have all been remastered much better than her previous 1993 hits package Softly With These Songs. The album does highlight so many great clasics including Making Love, her last Top 40 hit, Set The Night To Music with Maxi Preist, And So It Goes, the duet classics Where Is The Love with her longtime duet partner the late Donny Hathaway, and Tonight I Celebrate My Love with Peabo Bryson. While the album does shine with so many great tracks, the album also does overshadow a lot of great songs such as Will You Still Love Me Tommorow?, My Foolish Heart, and so many other classics for die hard Roberta Flack fans.
All in all, Best Of Roberta Flack is a fair improvement to her previous hits package, but there still was a bit that should've been showcased that just wasn't there. Nevertheless, if you haven't heard of any of those classics Roberta Flack had conjured, than this would be a treat for you, but for die hard fans, you're just better off sticking with the 1993 hits package Softly With These Songs instead.
Album Cover: B+
Songs: C+
Price: B-
Remastering: B+
Overall: C+
Great songs, but leaves off way too many hits - Review written on February 10, 2006
Rating: 4 out of 5
40 customers found this review helpful, 1 did not.
Roberta Flack emerged on the music scene in the early `70s with a cool, soothing, precise delivery that contrasted greatly with the fiery vocals of established Atlantic labelmate Aretha Franklin. Her more refined style helped her establish a successful niche as a soulful singer-songwriter, ultimately recording 15 albums over 25 years (1970-1995).
Flack was most successful - and prolific - in the early part of her recording career, with the intimate, folk-oriented recordings "The First Time Ever I Saw Your Face" (1972) and "Killing Me Softly With His Song" (1973) both garnering Record Of The Year Grammies, while the sumptuous "Feel Like Makin' Love" (1974) earned a nomination in that same category. A series of duets with college chum Donny Hathaway were also well-received at this time, including the chart-toppers "Where Is The Love" (1972) and "The Closer I Get To You" (1978).
Outside projects and Hathaway's suicide in 1979 slowed down Flack's output thereafter, but she continued to make some great music. This included the gentle theme for the film Making Love (1982), the breezy chart-topper "Oasis" (1988) and top ten collaborations with Peabo Bryson ("Tonight I Celebrate My Love" - 1983) and Maxi Priest ("Set The Night To Music" - 1991). These latter pairings, by the way, are nice, but don't begin to approach the intensity that Flack shared on record with the mighty Hathaway.
This 17-track Very Best Of contains 12 overlaps from Flack's 1993 retrospective Softly With These Songs (which also had 17 tracks), including all of the aforementioned hits. Available on the earlier set only were a slowed down rendition of the Shirelles' hit "Will You Still Love Me Tomorrow" (1972) and the not missed, inane single "Uh-Uh Ooh-Ooh Look Out" (1989), while this new Very Best Of adds "You Are My Heaven," a posthumous R&B hit with Hathaway (1980).
While duplicates abound, several key tracks remain unavailable on a domestic Flack collection. These include early duet hits with Hathaway ("You've Got A Friend" - 1971, "You've Lost That Lovin' Feelin'" - 1971), top 30 solo ballads ("Jesse" - 1973, "If Ever I See You Again," - 1978), additional collaborations with Bryson ("Make The World Stand Still" - 1980, the adult contemporary staple "You're Lookin' Like Love To Me" - 1982), and the up-tempo boast "I'm The One" (1982). They all deserve to be anthologized and hopefully the folks at Rhino will see fit to include them in a double-disc Flack set in the near future.
ANOTHER INCOMPLETE COMPILATION - Review written on February 07, 2006
Rating: 2 out of 5
5 customers found this review helpful, 2 did not.
Don't get me wrong--I LOVE Roberta Flack. In this day and age
where singing 9 notes for one syllable constitutes "soul", she
is still the epitome of great R&B singing and is almost the
definition of "Quiet Storm". Her classic recordings are timeless
and still sound fantastic 30-35 years later. HOWEVER, I don't
really get the point of this collection (other than the great
photo on the cover!). Most of the songs were on her "Softly
With These Songs" CD from the early 90's. A few songs were left
off, a few new ones added. Some are welcome additions, like
"Don't Make Me Wait Too Long", written by the one and only
Mr. Stevie Wonder. But again, two of her very best songs,
which were also left off the 90's collection, are missing.
Where is "Jesse"? Where is "You've Got A Friend"? These are
songs that any Roberta fan would place in their list of her best
recordings. I have no idea why they were left off, but without
them, this does not seem complete, and is certainly not essential
for people who own any of Roberta's early compilations. Sorry!