Amazon.com Customer Reviews
Believe in 'The Gospel' - Review written on September 18, 2006
Rating: 3 out of 5
4 customers found this review helpful.
'The Gospel' is not a music extravaganza with a story tacked on. Nor is it the opposite. It has a good story with fine gospel music added intermitently throughout. Both aspects complement one another, and the whole experience is uplifting. The acting is decent, neither over the top nor Oscar caliber, but everyone makes it an authentic experience all the same.
The story is one of redemption. David Taylor (Boris Kodjoe) rushes to the side of his dying mother in a hospital while he is begging God to spare her life. She is unconscious, but passes away under his watch. His father, a minister, shows up after the fact, tardy because he was at a bible conference. David is bitter at God and his earthly father, so he takes a different track in life. Moving from his native Atlanta to Los Angeles, he finds all the trappings that the secular world has to offer. Money, fame, music, and women enrapture him as he becomes a rap star. He seems comfortable although it isn't perfect. He starts to lock heads with a fellow artist who claims contract privileges with his music. The street wiseness puts in a minor damper and a bit of fisticuffs for David. That is until his own father's health starts to fail... Then, David interrupts everthing, including a contractual tour, to go home and investigate. One of the best aspects of the movie is how it demonstrates the disparity between the faithful and the wayward. It isn't all clear cut. The church members aren't all judgmental hypocrites, and the sinners aren't all noble and wrongly maligned. Rather, we see the skeptical reactions as the son of a preacher comes home to try and heal divisions of his father's church. Understandably, many don't take him seriously when his biggest hit is "I'll Try to Undress You". Bridging the gap, he falls in love with a regular attendee, but he quickly learns that being on the prowl doesn't work with this church woman. Similarly, as David responds to his father's ailing health and the need for a new church, he also changes. His priorities become new and different. The movie plausibly and likably show how relationships change as his father is dying and his successor takes over the church. The way they resolve the plot is worth the time to see "The Gospel".
Perhaps the most compelling reason most see the movie is the inspiration. The music is uplifting, and the camera angles showcase a splendid jamboree. I think there is a temptation to think of this movie as a slightly glorified made-for-tv project, but the editing and the splendour of the church singing beg for a labored response. 'The Gospel' does all it sets out to do and does it well.
Okay, but could've been better - Review written on June 13, 2006
Rating: 4 out of 5
1 customer found this review not to be helpful.
The main character, Boris Kodjoe, wasn't really that superb in this film. Although he's a good television actor, he wasn't really ready for the big screen. I think the producers used his looks to attract the females to seeing the movie more so than his acting. Someone said in an interview that he did all off his singing...false. It was so obvious that he was lip-syncing over someone else's deeper voice. And Tamyra Gray...that was a no no having her as a lead actress and singer. Did you not hear her when she opened with the Star Spangled Banner for the American Idol finale' season three...a big NO NO! She's not developed as an actor to do big screen yet, and her singing could use a fine tuning. She has a way to go before she becomes believable as a serious actress. Again, something to draw men to the theater. I understood where the movie was trying to go, and anyone who's read the bible or even been to church knows the story, but the movie just didn't take you there. I enjoyed the music because I'm a singer, but the movie just didn't take you where it should've. There were too many holes in the movie. Plus, it didn't really teach anyone who doesn't know about the Gospel. To me, it even made the veteran actors look like amateurs. I did enjoy seeing Omar Gooding stretch his wings and show versatility. I would love to see him in more versatile roles in the future. He's really a great actor when he gets great scripts. I think the singing and the major singers is what drew people to see this film because the acting was really bad and unbelievable, and the over dubbed singing was horrible. It was so many times that the music and the singers were not linked. I'm a analyzer when it comes to movies and a movie buff (owning overr 600 movies), so I definitely saw the flaws in this film. I still love the producers because I own some of his movies, and they are superb at what they do, but the actors where just not believable and had no chemistry with each other.
Lots of potential, but relied on the wrong "stars" - Review written on March 22, 2006
Rating: 3 out of 5
1 customer found this review helpful, 3 did not.
I commend Rob Hardy on what he attempted to do - make a movie about blacks that didn't involve a great amount of sex and violence. Bless him. Unfortunately, it's still a subpar film with plot holes the size of the Grand Canyon and a ton of dangling plots. I can't even talk about the plot holes because that would give so much of the movie away.
The main problem aside from telling a story that didn't need retelling for the 80th time (the Prodigal friggin' Son!?!?) is that Hardy hitched his wagon to the wrong stars, feeling that pretty boy Boris Kodjoe and American Idol wannabe Tamyra Gray would bring the people in and pimped them as such. Maybe they did, and don't get me wrong. They didn't embarass themselves. But compared to the rest of the cast, they were easily the weak links. Had Hardy had more faith in the other cast members, he would've had a much more compelling and original story. Donnie McClurkin made an excellent addition to the cast - who knew he could at act all, let alone act so well? (And who knew he was so BIG?) Too bad he's a minister, because I would LOVE to see him play a straight-up gun-toting bad guy. Aloma Wright and Clifton Powell are acting veterans, and it showed. Idris Elba and Nona Gaye - fingers crossed that they reunite in the future to do a REAL film. It's been a while since we've seen a black couple onscreen with equal parts chemistry and conflict that didn't completely fall completely flat. (Plus, they're just really, REALLY pretty people.)
The whole music angle could've been completely tossed - in fact, the movie probably would've been better without it. In my opinion, the film should've concentrated on Bishop Taylor's announcement of Rev. Frank taking his place, leading to a clash with Min. Hunter. Think of all the unanswered questions. Why DID Bishop Taylor choose the much younger Frank over Min. Hunter, who ADMINISTERED Frank his minister's test so many years ago? How did the minister justify his blatant jealousy seeing that one of the commandents is "thou shall not covet"? How did the Bishop feel about his term as bishop coming to an end BECAUSE of the way it was coming to an end? And seeing that Frank and his wife were having martial problems, was Frank ever tempted by women in his church (especially with his new ego)? Why did Frank want the role of pastor so much, anyway? We know that Frank really, REALLY loves the Lord - his ambition almost consumes him - but we never know WHY he was so driven. What about Charlene's problem? Was it mental, medical, physical, and when did it start? When Charlene ultimately had to make a choice between her cousin and her husband, why did she make the choice that she made? And when it backfired, how did she feel? Speaking of feelings, how did Bishop Taylor feel years ago when Frank decided to marry his niece? It's obvious that he loves/respects Frank as a minister, but how about as his nephew-in-law? Did he choose Frank BECAUSE of his marriage to Charlene, or was that a coincidence? What was the status of Bis. Taylor's relationship with Charlene, seeing that she called him "Bishop" and not "Uncle"?
All of those questions could've been answered in a great film, but no...we have to pander to the common ground. A story we all already know, and singing. Lots of singing. GOOD singing, but singing nonetheless. May as well have been rap, or basketball, or whack poetry. It felt like Hardy didn't trust that blacks would come and support a movie without a "gimmick". And don't get me wrong, "The Gospel" is still an engaging film with strong acting - very refreshing to see new faces onscreen - and a wonderful soundtrack. Had it had another writer/director with a different vision but the same cast, it probably would've been MUCH better, hence my frustration. Then again, this guy gave us "Trois", so I don't know why I'm surprised.
3 stars largely for the music - Review written on March 19, 2006
Rating: 3 out of 5
5 customers found this review not to be helpful.
I just saw "The Gospel" on DVD -- where I suspect most people saw it since it stayed in feature realease all of a hot half-a-minute.
My initial reaction to this prodigal-son tale was that the music alone made the film worth its admission price: Yolanda Adams, Tamyra Gray, Fred Hammond, Hezekiah Walker, Donnie McClurkin.
I was wrong. The music is pretty much all that's good in this flick.
There are some decent performances. Patriarch Clifton Powell ages gracefully and credibly as a terminal cancer patient.
Mildly villainous Idris Elba is compelling each time he's on screen, as is Tamyra Gray with the added bonus of her powerful and at times angelic singing voice.
Even Omar Gooding takes a break from his usual buffoonery to be taken seriously.
Good music and more than enough eye candy (somethin' for everybody). But what this thing really coulda used was a talented star. And a fresh script.
Boris Cujo didn't pull off leading man. When folk stop droolin', what else you got, Son?
Cujo is insufferable as a (literally) no-singin' singer (he lip-synchs over dubbed vocals). I guess his "big moment" comes during a clichéd graveyard scene where he goes off on God. Brothaman, please.
Actually I was pretty much through when they decided to put on the big show to save the church!
But the music is exceptional, and at least the other singers really sing. Especially Yolanda Adams on the show-stoppin' "Victory."
Great movie about the realities of living the gospel - Review written on February 27, 2006
Rating: 5 out of 5
3 customers found this review helpful.
This is one of only a few movies that I have ever seen that show the realities of the Christian life. "The Gospel" shows the tensions and struggles that occur within the church and church family among people trying to live for God in our culture.
"The Gospel" may at times seem low-budget compared to some of the blockbusters we see in theatres, but it compensates with truth and emotion. The characters are real, their struggles are real and the presence of God in this movie is real.
The music throughout this movie is exceptional. Regardless of your musical interests, I think you will enjoy the songs.
"The Gospel" has been labled a modern version of The Prodigal Son--it is that and more as we see the pastor's son torn between secular success and salvation at home in the church, and we see a young, fresh pastor decide whether he is going to work for his name or God's name. There are tensions between the sexes, between friends, between fellow ministers, and especially between a man's will and the will of God.
I didn't know anything about this movie before renting it, but I am truly proud of the people who made it and acted in it for presenting such a profound version of the gospel. Now I'm going to buy the soundtrack.
Craig Stephans, author of Shakespeare On Spirituality: Life-Changing Wisdom from Shakespeare's Plays
Disappointing, but entertaining. - Review written on February 27, 2006
Rating: 3 out of 5
1 customer found this review helpful.
Poorly developed plot. Even more poorly developed characters. Really bad acting in the lead role. The dialog between characters just doesn't explain the plot, and you are forced to guess what's going on half the time. A woman who can't have sex apparently because of some medical condition (but you never find out why), the same woman who at first seems good, then betrays her cousin, then somehow turns good again. The beginning of the story has the lead role's mother dying, but you never find out why, and her husband never bothers shedding a tear or acting surprised that he arrives to find his wife is dead. This movie really should have been more carefully planned, and a better lead role cast. Despite all this, I gave the movie a 3 because it does manage to be entertaining with the gospel music and with what script it has to work with. The storyline for the movie is a great one, and done in this light it could have been much, much more with a better script and a better lead actor. The camera work is really good, and slightly unusual in places. I hope a remake is made someday with a better budget and script. It's worth seeing, but it's not something I would buy if I had it to do over again.
The Prodigal Son retold with Great Gospel Music - Review written on January 29, 2006
Rating: 5 out of 5
8 customers found this review helpful, 1 did not.
The Gospel tells a simple story that doesn't twist and turn, but rather falls naturally from the believable characters created in Rob Hardy's screenplay and under his direction. Hardy has wisely filled his movie with absolutely glorious Gospel music created by electrifying choirs and real Gospel greats like Fred Hammond and Yolanda Adams. The movie is never more than one scene away from one with glorious music and as soon as I finish this review I'm going to order the soundtrack.
The story is not difficult to follow. Clifton Powell as Bishop Fred Taylor has built a thriving church in Atlanta, and he is a devoted Pastor. So devoted that his son leaves home as a young man when the Bishop's wife passes away while the Bishop is conducting church services. In the opening scene we see the son, David, telling the Bishop "I hate you. You always have time for the church, but you never have time for us", on his way out of the hospital.
15 years later we see that David Taylor has become a hip-hop singer right on the cusp of megastardom. He's played by Boris Kodjoe as a handsome, brooding man. He has a manager, played by Omar Gooding (with more than a slight resemblance to older brother Cuba) named Wesley who keeps "D.T." supplied with gigs and women. David gets a phone call from his father's secretary, Ernestine (played by Aloma Wright), who tells him that the Bishop has become ill and could David come home.
Against Wesley's wishes, David interrupts his tour as it's gaining momentum to return to the church, where he finds his teenaged friend Charles Frank has become a Reverend as well - associate pastor to the Bishop, married to his cousin Charlene, and the heir apparent to the church.
The Reverend Charles Frank is an arrogant man who is quick with a discouraging word for his wife. Another associate, Minister Hunter (played well by singer Donnie McClurkin), can't understand when the Bishop decides to turn the pulpit over to the brash Reverend Frank, but agrees to stay with the church at the request of the Bishop.
This is the part of the movie that builds sympathy for wayward son David, who returns home with different eyes and sees the noble, charitable work that his father has been doing for decades. He accompanies his father to a retirement home where he's told that the Bishop always comes, at least twice a week, even though everyone there knows he doesn't have time for it.
The movie builds as a battle between the worldly David, who returns home as the performer of sexy secular songs, but builds in determination to not lose the legacy of his father, and Reverend Frank, who "stayed true" to the church and the Bishop, but now seems to have lost the vision of anything except himself in the church spotlight.
By the end of the film the words and body language of all the characters are that "it's all good", and that the strife that has filled the hour and a half preceding is resolved. We know that real life doesn't work that quickly, but we can believe that in real life, it may work out just as well. The music helps. It's reassuring to see a mainstream film made about people of faith and their real-world struggles. If not for the fact that the final scene seems out of place with several rapid "changes of heart" I'd give the film 5 stars. As it is, it's well worth your time - I'd say mandatory if you want to hear some glorious gospel music.
"*" FOR DEFECTIVE DVD & "* * * * *" FOR THE MOVIE - Review written on January 25, 2006
Rating: 1 out of 5
3 customers found this review helpful, 8 did not.
My fiance, Jay, and I loved the movie. It's an excellent movie. The music is the best! We give the movie 5 stars but we give the DVD 1 star or 0 stars. We bought the DVD a couple of weeks ago at Walmart.
THE DVD IS DEFECTIVE!!!!!! It doesn't perform properly in DVD Players/Recorders. We tried to play it on Jay's Sony Combo DVD Player/VCR but it wouldn't play at all nor show a menu. We tried it several times and it wouldn't work. HE'S HAD THE DVD PLAYER FOR 3 YRS & WE'VE HAD NO PROBLEMS PLAYING OTHER DVDS ON ANY OF OUR OTHER PLAYERS.
We tried playing it on his Lite-On 5005 DVD Recorder (had for over yr). The first time we put it in the player, we got backqround noise that was very snowy and sounded like a CB on the Recorder's menu. He took the DVD out and reloaded it. It played all the way thru with no problems.
I took the DVD home and played it in a Cyberhome DVD player (had for 2 1/2 yrs). It played fine for the first 120 minutes of the movie but it started freezing. I tried hitting PLAY, REW, & FF, but it wouldn't unfreeze. I had to go back to the menu and select the last scene I saw. It played until I got to the same spot again and it froze. It started freezing up every few seconds in the movie.
Sometimes it wouldn't unfreeze at all, even if I tried to push STOP or turn the power off it wouldn't let me on the remote and the unit itself. I had to go behind the TV and flip the power switch off the surge protector strip to cut the power off. Then I'd turn the switch on & tried to play the DVD again. I had to repeat this procedure of turning the power off behind the TV a couple more times.
It took 1 1/2 - 2 hours just to get thru the last 20 minutes of the movie because it kept freezing up.
I took the movie back to a different Walmart & exchanged it for another one, this time for one with a different sticker that said it had a free CD. We tried playing it on the Sony Player and it still wouldn't play.
Don't buy the DVD. Wait awhile to buy it or rent it and see if it will play in your player.
Not a bad film and the songs were GREAT!!! - Review written on January 24, 2006
Rating: 3 out of 5
4 customers found this review helpful.
There is something about THE GOSPEL that makes you want to like it: some fine actors (Boris Kodjoe, Idris Elba, Clifton Powell, Tamyra Gray, Aloma Wright, Nona Gaye) and good gospel singing.
Writer/director Rob Hardy stretches the biblical tale of the Prodigal Son to the updated story of the son of a bishop of an evangelical church who runs away to become a R&B singing star only to return to his father when cancer of the prostate signals the end of his life. The 'other' son has inherited the mantle of the bishop with special interests deflecting his commitment to the bishop's origins and the Prodigal Son finally finds acceptance in offering his talents to further the original dream of his father.
The movie contains good snippets of music from ensemble choirs and well-known gospel singers. The movie had a plot with these songs intertwined, yet because the songs were kept short, it did not overload the movie with music. (However, if you are a gospel music lover, I think you'll still be pleased.) Yes, some may write it off as predictable, and a bit sappy, but that's also what got me about it. The movie speaks to you without feeling like it's preaching to you
The script is conversationally pedestrian but the actors did their best to make credible characters. There is a sense of commitment from the cast of extras that leaves a warm afterglow, but in the end this is a light story saved by some fine music.
An exciting film about the church - Review written on January 17, 2006
Rating: 5 out of 5
11 customers found this review helpful.
The Gospel, one of the most exciting movies ever released about the black church, is now available on DVD. Boris Kodjoe (Soulfood), stars as David Taylor. David, the son of a popular minister, leaves the church after the untimely death of his mother and goes on to be a successful R&B singer. After his father, portrayed by popular character actor Clifton Powell, becomes ill, David returns to the fold of the family church which is in financial crisis. Not everyone is glad to see David return. Some members of the church, particularly his former childhood friend, Reverend Charles Frank, don't know if it's such a good idea to have a well known secular singer in the fold. David finds himself comfortable back in the church and implements his ideas into rejuvenating the congregation. In addition to his new role with the church David also finds love with a church member named Rain (Tamyra Gray). David's manager Wesley, (Omar Gooding), spends his time trying to get his artist back into the lifestyle they have become accustomed to and back on the road.
The Gospel is an excellent film and includes cameos from some of the biggest names in gospel music including Fred Hammond, Donnie McClurkin, and Yolanda Adams. Despite the big names that have small roles in the film, it's the newcomers such as former American Idol contestant Tamarya Gray and Idris Elba who offer surprisingly good performances. Boris Kodjoe also shows and proves that he is much more than just a pretty face with his performance in The Gospel.
There were just a few little things about the movie that irked me. Oscar, Tamarya Grays other love interest was always shown in his uniform for the most part. As a military spouse, I think it's a bit odd that they showed Oscar in his uniform so much even when he wasn't working. Also, there was an underlying storyline of strife/sexual dysfunction between the Nona Gaye character and her husband Reverend Charles Frank. This storyline wasn't well developed. Other than those two things it's a great film.
DVD Special Features
-Filmmakers Commentary
-Deleted Scenes
-Making-Of Featurette
-Extended Musical Performances
-Photo Montage
the gospel? are you sure? - Review written on January 09, 2006
Rating: 1 out of 5
7 customers found this review helpful, 8 did not.
unfortunately, this movie should not have been called "the gospel" or anything close to the gospel. it did not glorify the reason for the gospel (the good news),which is Jesus Christ, and didn't even come close to expressing anything that would spark anyone's curiosity into the actual gospel.
part of the plot in this movie was when the church needed a new building and did not have the funds for it. there was hardly any prayer involved or church participation to raise money. boris kodjoe's character saved the church with HIS talents and with HIS money. the church was of no use to him,but he was used by the church. in essence,his character was glorified,not Christ's and sends out the message that the church will put a stamp of approval on practically anything, so long as it benefits the church. never mind the condition of your soul,or how your life is as a christian: you can be living however which way you want,call yourself a christian and the church will look the other way as long as you are benefiting their "needs".
at the end, David the main character,surrenders his life to GOD--but who specifically is he surrendering it to? nowadays,the mention of GOD doesn't necessarily mean a thing. we all know that, yet the movie is called "the gospel".
all i'm saying is there is a boatload of other titles the writers and producers of this movie could have chosen to name this movie, like "the gospel music entertainers" or "the somewhat prodigal son". if you're going to call the movie, "the gospel" then make it about the gospel or put accurate facts about the gospel in it as your primary point,with your secondary point showing black american church culture or gospel entertainment. otherwise, it just falls flat and it becomes another entertaining,toe-tapping attempt to portray humanism, not christianity/the gospel.
Clap Your Hands - Review written on January 08, 2006
Rating: 4 out of 5
19 customers found this review helpful, 2 did not.
A story of redemption, pride, jealousy, and reconciliation. STRONG cast with a stirring gospel soundtrack. Although others have criticized the camera work and editing, those aspects of the movie neither bothered me nor detracted from my enjoyment of this uplifting film. I found that the acting, music, and story were engaging and enjoyable. The singing performances of the choral groups and such gospel stars as Yolanda Adams, Fred Hammonds, Mom Winans, and Martha Munizzi combined nicely with, and elegantly complemented, the fine dramatic work of Idris Elba, Omar Gooding, Nona Gaye, and Clifton Powell. AMERICAN IDOL finalist Tamyra Gray shined in her acting and singing roles and showed that she has a bright future. Not an award winning film, but very entertaining. 4 solid stars.