Amazon.com Customer Reviews
Kermit and company do Dickens, with just enough humor and drama. - Review written on December 23, 2007
Rating: 4 out of 5
1 customer found this review not to be helpful.
Jim Henson's ever irresistible Muppets takes on the famous Charles Dickens "Christmas" classic, with genuinely pleasing results. The story, as everyone probably knows by now, centers on one Ebenezer Scrooge, a greedy and mean-spirited moneylender who thinks only of money and can only respond to Christmas with "bah, humbug!" On Christmas Eve, he receives an unexpected visit from his deceased business partners, who warn him that three spirits will transport him to his past, present, and future. Grudgingly, Scrooge goes along with the spirits, and eventually realizes that his selfish acts will provide not only drastic consequences for himself, but for the welfare of his long-suffering clerk, Bob Cratchit, and his sickly son, Tiny Tim.
The film follows the original tale faithfully, and more importantly, keeps most of the dark, sometimes dreary tone of Dickens' tale. Since the story has its share of heartbreaking moments, it is surprising that this movie, skillfully directed by Brian Henson, manages to handle them in a very emotional way without coming across as forced or out of place. Scenes such as Scrooge witnessing the departure of his former love Belle and an even more devastating sequence where the Cratchit family mourns the loss of their beloved, frail son (keep in mind that this is only a vision) all manage to tug at the right heartstrings effectively.
Naturally, the Muppets do sneak in ways to provide a bit of humor in various places, but in an adaptation like this, it is most welcome. Actually, most of the laughs come from the Great Gonzo as Charles Dickens, who narrates the story to a skeptical Rizzo Rat as the latter questions about whether the "scary stuff" is appropriate for children. "That's all right, this is culture," explains Gonzo, er, Dickens, respectively.
It is a treat to see Kermit the Frog and Miss Piggy as the Cratchits and even more amusing to see those old tycoons Statler and Waldorf as the ghosts of Scrooge's deceased business partners, but the whole weight of the movie rests on the performance of Michael Caine as Mr. "Bah Humbug" himself. He plays the role flawlessly, somehow managing to blend in with his Muppet and human co-stars. Also noteworthy are the creation of the spirits themselves: Christmas Past is a ghostly-like child, Present is a jolly, Santa Claus like giant, while Future is a dark-robed, faceless figure who is made all the more scary by the fact that he is mute. Paul Williams' musical numbers are also very sprightly and infectiously catchy, well-suited to both the spirit of Christmas and the story itself.
All in all, THE MUPPET CHRISTMAS CAROL is great family entertainment, but even adults may find a lot to enjoy too.
mixed reaction - Review written on December 05, 2007
Rating: 4 out of 5
4 customers found this review helpful.
Having watched 50 years of versions of "A Christmas Carol", I believe that Michael Caine is the best Scrooge ever, topping even Finney. The muppet casting is perfect for the original characters of the story. The humor is satisfying (even the fifth time around) and the direction is well done so it has become a classic that I pull out each Christmas. Hence the four stars (which should be five to this point).
What's the Disappointment? Although I have the 2002 version, I bought this one for the "widescreen" and hoping it would be digitally remastered. What a disappointment! I think what they must have done to get the 'widescreen' effect was go in closer on the Pan-and-Scan because you have the tops of 'people's' heads hitting the top of the screen. Some scenes seem remastered, others not.
Cutting the song, "When Love is Gone", is jarring. I am not a fan of the song but Michael Caine's grief at what he has lost is the turning point in the movie for Scrooge, as Caine himself says in the 2002 interview which is not on this DVD revision (why not?). You have lost the whole point of the story if you cut this scene. I could not believe it!!!
Walt Disney understood family and children in a way that his successors do not. Jim Henson understood the value of all the emotions and the necessity of humor as few others have. Neither of them would have cut that scene. Artistically, I cannot believe that Brian Henson would have wanted it cut and I cannot believe that the Disney studios of today care two hoots about children (the shoddy productions of the Disney Channel are enough of an argument, I think.) Therefore, my recommendation is buy the 2002 version until Disney wakes up and does the justice to this film that it deserves.
Best Christmas movie ever - Review written on October 17, 2007
Rating: 5 out of 5
1 customer found this review helpful.
I normally don't like the Muppet movies. They just don't hold their value, meaning in later years I tend to think they feel dated and not very funny anymore and so on.
However, this movie is AWESOME, my favorite christmas movie by far. Christmas movies are normally cheesie, and certainly this movie has a level of cheesiness, but it's ok, it's a christmas movie. Caine is a perfect scrooge, and the characters are well-placed.
"And how does one celebrate Christmas on the UNEMPLOYMENT LINE?"
"HEAT WAVE!! This is my Island in the sun, Oy!, Oy!"