Amazon.com Customer Reviews
Be wary about using your Tanita in a bathroom. - Review written on May 22, 2008
Rating: 1 out of 5
5 customers found this review helpful.
Be wary of Tanita and their warranty claims. The product itself was decent, and fairly accurate, however Tanita is not a company that prides itself in customer service and product support. I used my scale in a normal bathroom environment, and after just 3 months you could see evaporation underneath the screen. I don't know if a gasket had a crack in it, or what the issue might have been, but the unit couldn't withstand the normal humidity of a bathroom. In fact, the unit was a good 20 feet from any active water, like a shower and tub.
I shipped the unit in, and without even so much as a courtesy call, the "customer service manager" returned my unit with a note that my warranty claim was refused, even though I had spoken to someone before about the issue, and said it would be replaced no problem. The customer service manager was nice enough, but said that even though it was well within the boundaries of his discretion, he was going to refuse the claim, because they refuse all like claims regarding evaporation. He even admitted that it happens fairly often.
Stay away.
His recommendation? Buy another Tanita, and not place it in the bathroom. Right.
people over 50 need not apply - Review written on March 26, 2008
Rating: 2 out of 5
6 customers found this review helpful.
I just got my scale and tried it out, and I have to say it really makes me mad that the designers of this scale see no reason to give anyone over 50 a metabolic age rating. To them, I guess a 50-year-old and a 90-year-old are both over the hill, so why bother making distinctions?
I spent the extra money primarily because this scale has been reported as being very accurate (repeatable) in the weight measurement, but since I spent so much money on the other features, I expect to receive them. I'm 60. As far as I can tell, I could be 10 years healthier than average, or 10 years less healthy than average, and I was looking forward to seeing what the scale said. But now I'll never know. I'm not sure if I'm more unhappy because I didn't get the information I expected, or because I feel that I've been treated with contempt because I'm at an age where they feel we can just all be lumped together. Either way, I'm disappointed.
Very useful - Review written on December 08, 2007
Rating: 5 out of 5
6 customers found this review helpful.
The only method to measure body fat reliably is hydrodensitometry weighing. However, there exist two kinds of accurate devices that are capable to estimate this measure and offer reliable results, bioimpedence and skinfold calipers. In order for them to provide with repeatable and dependable measurements, skinfold calipers ought to be used by professionals while bioimpedenzometric scales do not.
The science behind the Tanita BC533 scale is bioimpedence, which allows for a body composition estimate by sending a brief pulse of low voltage electricity through your body. The electricity that leaves your body at your feet is then read by the scale and your body composition is calculated and displayed for your convenience.
Because the estimate is done through electricity everything impacting on electricity and its conduction also has an impact on the results you get. For this reason, you need not to use the scale while your feet and/or your body are wearing isolating materials (shoes - especially plastic, and socks and sweaters - especially in wool), when your skin is wet (ie: after a bath or shower, when you have recently sweat), and when you have eaten or drank in the previous 3 hours. On top of that, because of circadian hormonal rhythms, weight changes within the day. My suggestion is to pick up a time of the day and stick with it. For even more dependable measurements, use the scale in the same conditions every day so that you can compare successive measurements and hopefully track your progresses.
This scale isn't any more difficult to use than other bioimpedenzometric device is, but you need to know the technology and its limitations in order to exploit it to your own advantage.
Pros: it looks stylish, it's very dependable
Cons: it needs to be set up, it requires a flat surface
Weighty Wonder - Review written on July 12, 2007
Rating: 5 out of 5
2 customers found this review helpful.
This is one heckuva scale. It does everything. It looks fabulous and actually stays clean in our bathroom. Other scales are hard to clean, have you noticed? Not this baby! Just wipe and shine! It is notoriously too accurate to please most members of my household! The display is large and easy to read, and placed far enough toward the outer perimeter that those of us that must peer over some unwanted personal girth, can actually read the sad results without falling headfirst into a bath, sink or toilet bowl. Actually, by monitoring my weight carefully with this scale and making notes of the mass ratios, I have been able to take my belt in by two notches (that's quite a reduction folks!) and lose at least fifteen pounds since we got it two months ago.
So, it's not just a beautiful decor item for m'ladies bath, it is also a very useful, beautifully made precision device that works exactly as advertised and should give years of good service. The only detail I would comment on is the tiny ON button that is labled "OFF" (???!) that one must try and push with a toe, before the scale will read your weight.
If you just stand on it, it remains silent, mute, sans display readout.
They could have either made a larger ON button that says "ON" or better yet, like one of the other Tanita models I own or the Taylor that my daughter has, simply stand on it! Small issue, really. We love it!
Very Good Scale - Review written on May 30, 2007
Rating: 4 out of 5
2 customers found this review helpful.
The weight seems to be very accurate. The scale looks great. It has a lot of other measurements/features that are nice. You enter your age, height, gender, and activity level. The activity level is defined in the owner's manaul-- 1 is sedentary, 2 is moderate activity of lower intensity workout and 3 is athlete/active. They define athlete as someone who excerices 10 hours per week and has a resting heart rate of 60 bpm or less. I wish they had a broader spectrum of selection. I would say that I am a 2.75 if it were a continuous scale. The problem is you have to select, in my case, 2 or 3. I select 2 and I get a 18.4% body fat. I select 3 and I am at 11.4%. I think I am much closer to 11.4%-- probaly 13% or so. I suppose I could do some linear interpolation, but that is a pain. It is very important to compare the numbers from the same time of day (I do it after I wake up, relieve myself and drink a glass of water). In the end it is all relative, so if you compare apples to apples you should get solid feedback on your diet/excercise efforts.
Surprised by the accuracy - Review written on April 15, 2007
Rating: 5 out of 5
5 customers found this review helpful, -5 did not.
I bought this scale to help me track my overall fitness. I was very surprised at the accuracy of the body fat content. I workout pretty regularly so I set it up for the athletic setting and the first time I checked it I also compared it to a body caliper measurement and they were very close.
The key though for accurate measuring is to follow the instruction manual. There can be a lot of variation within a single day if you take a measurement at the wrong time of day. You're not supposed to use the scale to measure body fat, etc. within 3 hours of eating, excercise, sleep, etc. It can be hard to find a time to get a reading, but if you follow the guidelines, it's pretty accurate.
Just a word of caution, a female friend of mine tried it once and it wasn't very accurate for her compared to caliper measurement. It may not work for everyone, but it's been a good tool for me.
A tell-all scale - Review written on January 30, 2007
Rating: 5 out of 5
1 customer found this review helpful.
This is an awesome scale that is easy to program and use. Our last scale (which was also a Tanita) quit working. We went to several local stores and tried several scales, but they were either difficult to program or some readings appeared to be way off. I finally searched online for a Tanita scale & noticed this was was a top pick in US News & World Reports, so I decided to give it a try. We loved our other Tanita scale & love this one even more. The only thing missing is the ability to store readings, but I can always save them myself in an Excel file. The ability to see an accurate weight, hydration level, body fat percentage, muscle mass, bone density, calories to maintain current weight, and metabolic age lets me know exactly where I am & helps give more motivation to stick with my exercise plan.
Tanita Innerscan Monitor - Review written on January 27, 2007
Rating: 1 out of 5
4 customers found this review helpful, 4 did not.
I have recently bought one of these. I feel like an idiot. I should have checked it out more and I hope I can get my money back. The weight seems accurate but everything else is a nonsense. No-one else has mentioned, in the reviews, the following: if you do the maths you will find that your bone weight, muscle mass, and body fat ( calculate it's weight from the percentage of your actual weight ) come to 100% of your total weight. Well what about your intestines, which probably make up about a quarter of your body weight, your lungs, which are quite heavy, your brain, which weighs about 8 lbs ?!!
Apart from this, I work out and am quite muscular and have negligible body fat, yet I get a bodyfat percentage of 23 to 24; a friend who has just won a body building competition and has a professionally-taken bodyfat percentage of 11 gets a 21% reading on my Tanita scales plus an average physique rating, and my husband, who does not do a great deal of exercise and has quite a bit more body fat than either of us ( by appearance ), gets a better bodyfat percentage and physique rating than either of us. This machine is nothing but a big con I'm afraid.