Amazon.com Customer Reviews
The Perfect Midsize Swiss Army Knife - Review written on November 21, 2007
Rating: 5 out of 5
7 customers found this review helpful.
First let me admit that I've loved Swiss Army Knives (SAKs) since my grandpa first brought me one from Switzerland when I was about 10. I've been through about 2 dozen of them. Some, I've lost, some, I've given away. One weakness in the design of SAKs is the plastic handle. If you drop the knife, chances are the handle will crack, fall off, whatever. This is not an issue with the "Silver Alox" (aluminum) handle versions like this one. These handles don't fall off, and they don't break. Also, Victorinox isn't trying to kid anyone by putting that ridiculous little keyring on this one. This is a real pocketknife. Compared to similar size SAKs, this one is not only more durable because of the handle material, but the blade is made from thicker stock. Losing the small blad in favor of an awl is a fair trade. After all, many people break their SAK blades by trying to pry with them. The awl is kind of a multipurpose tool. You can use it to punch holes in things, pry (a bit), dig around in things, widen (ream) holes, and many other things. Sometimes, I do miss the small blade though. That small blade was the one I would always keep sharp, no matter what. The large blade is used for heavier work, and the small one for light duty work that required a razor's edge. I also miss the toothpick sometimes. However, if you're only going to have one pocketknife, it has to be either this one or the Classic. This one for the more heavy duty type of person, the Classic for the more "business casual" type of person.
The can opener works brilliantly. The small screwdriver tip at the end of the can opener was a stroke of genius. The bottle opener works brilliantly as well, and the large screwdriver is as useful as the bottle opener. The "wire stripper" is all but useless. To use it, one has to first cut a ring around the insulation of the wire in question. The problem is that if you're doing it on the appropriate size wire, you're likely to cut yourself while cutting the ring. After one cuts the ring around the wire, one fits the wire into the groove, bends it over 90° while holding onto the piece of insulation to be stripped off, and pulls. It works, but it's clumsy.
I've been carrying mine daily now for a couple months. It's time to get a small classic size one, but with more tools, back into my daily knife rotation. This one is starting to feel heavy at my office job. But I do revel in the glory of always having a tough knife to open boxes with and a bottle opener to open a nice import beer. Heheheh.
Oh, a bit of history. This is the soldier model. Most SAKs have 'Victorinox Switzerland Stainless' on one side of the main blade and 'Officer Suisse' on the other. Those are "Officer's Knives" in other words: not as tough. This one doesn't have the 'Officer Suisse' on the other side. This is the SAK that started it all. Mine has '97' on the other side of the main blade, which was probably the year it was manufactured.
Finest Knife Ever Made....PERIOD!!! - Review written on January 29, 2007
Rating: 5 out of 5
1 customer found this review helpful.
You will never find a better knife than the Victorinox Soldier. It can do everything without being cumbersome. Some of the Victorinox series have more gadgets of course, but unless you are a freakin' astronaut you don't need them day-to-day. This knife resided in my pocket every day of my life for the past 9 years, until *GASP* it was lost in a movie theater seat.....F@&%!!!!! If you know what I mean. Every day since losing it about 4 months ago I've needed it...the reamer makes a fine mouse wheel cleaner and will cut open those annoying clear plastic packages things come in from walmart or target or wherever that house electronics, or whatever... the bottle opener is great for all types of beverages...hint hint....you will never need to leave a screw unturned ever again...the large screwdriver is just big enough, and the small screwdriver is just small enough to do phillips head as well as small flat head screws. You will never need to bring a screwdriver to the DMV ever again when you sell your car or get new plates. Trust me, it is WONDERFUL. The blade of course is fantastic, just long enough to be strong and functional but not long enough to be illegal, for the most part that is. The aluminum handles are awesome too, because the texture provides extremely good grip, plus doesn't scratch like the red plastic does....Needless to say I love this thing, and it is one of the most valued items I've ever owned....Buy it...don't think it over any longer just BUY IT!!!
Another absolute gem - Review written on June 30, 2006
Rating: 5 out of 5
11 customers found this review helpful, 1 did not.
I bought this knife to replace an older one that I "lost" at an airport security check (forgot to empty that pocket at home.)
It appears to be exactly the same knife as the Swiss Army Pioneer Pocket Knife, which I also bought ("just to see..."), except that this one has a key ring.
They are both absolute gems, each has a small variety of tools that are extremely useful and is not overloaded with "fun" stuff that just add to the weight and awkwardness. The metal is hard & sturdy enough that you can really do some prying without damaging the blades, the knife blade is sharp and will hopefully stay that way for a while (good metal), the can-opener works well, the shape of the small screwdriver lets you wriggle it into the smallest of openings to do the pry thing, and the blade remains un-nicked so continues to work well as a screwdriver afterward.
Also, the handle is metal, not plastic, so I can carry it (for years?) in the same pocket with my keys, with no chipping or loosening of the side plates. A very good design! and I'm grateful that the Company continues to make such a useful piece, when they undoubtedly earn a lot more profit from the big, fancy, multi-mega-bladed tools - which may be good in a toolbox, but not in a pocket!
Victorinox Beats Wenger In Quality - Review written on May 03, 2006
Rating: 5 out of 5
17 customers found this review helpful, 1 did not.
I am somewhat of an unqualified expert on the Victorinox Swiss Army Knives, I currently own 4 of them, and one Wenger Executive. If you are going back and forth debating which is better, in my experience the Victorinox is superior in blade quality and construction. The Wenger knives have more "wiggle" in the blade and just don't feel as solid.
The Silver Alox Soldier is a fine looking knife. I really prefer the look and style to any other Swiss Army red or black. It feels heavier, and the handle material isn't going to chip or crack. Good enough to put in your back or front pocket without being too heavy, and a nice mix of tools. I also have the Silver Alox Harvester, which is the same knife with a sawblade added. You wouldn't think it would make much of a difference, but the Soldier is noticeably lighter in your pocket, so if weight is a big deal for you and you can sacrafice the sawblade, this knife would be ideal for you.
Already my favorite knife - Review written on November 22, 2005
Rating: 5 out of 5
6 customers found this review helpful, 2 did not.
So after a few weeks of considering which Victorinox to buy, I finally decided on the Soldier. The selling point was its simplicity, and the metal sides. I liked the traditional aspect of the Swiss Army knife, and I loved the modern spin with the metal checkered side.
The knife is surprisingly light considering the metal and the quality of the blade and tools. I had it in my back pocket earlier (which I dont do with most knives, because I dont like the awkward weight and lump back there) and didn't even tell it was there. Honestly, the knife is so light you won't believe it.
The blade is of excellant quality. It doesnt take much torque to open it, though once it is opened it snaps into place and it held there until you want it shut. It dosent wobble from side to side or fold back in clumsily. It is also very sharp, cut through a sheet of paper like it wasnt there.
The bottle and can openers open like the blade, only they stop halfway, then snap to the open position. I love the fluency of it, you'll have to feel it to know what it feels like. The reamer was one of the few things I was a little disappointed in. I don't see a use for it, I would have had a smaller blade or something else. Then again I've only had the knife for a day, so it may be of more use than I thought. Also I would have preferred the standard tweezers and toothpick, but I can see how it would be hard to work into the metal handle.
All in all, 5 out of 5 stars. If you buy this knife, for yourself or as a gift, you will not be disappointed. I bought it looking for a good, sturdy pocket knife to whittle marshmallow stick and open Root Beer bottles. It is the perfect pocket knife.
Buy this knife!!! It's a solid essential! - Review written on May 03, 2004
Rating: 5 out of 5
2 customers found this review helpful, 1 did not.
I have both a Victorinox and Wenger "Soldier" knife. These are both Mil Spec from imported used military surplus from Switzerland. The catch is that I don't know if they are built exactly the same way for the Swiss Army as the civilian ones. Mine are used ones, Victorinox, is from 1985. The Wenger is from 1980. Both companies are required to print the year issued to troops on the blade, engraving the last two digits of the year issued. My point is that these knives are 19 and 24 years old and still are strong and feel like new. Weird thing is the one from 1980 is slightly heavier.
I was actually in Switzerland five years ago and bought a Victorinox "Nomad". Big mistake. It cost me about $45, I never use it and I wouldn't trust that knife with my life. The "Soldier" I would. Plus the nomad is illegal to carry concealed in Los Angeles City. The "Soldier" is one the least expensive knives the companies makes and is probably made the best. Not really a big surprise but I thought I should state it.
The test:
I have a friend who has had every knife known to man except a Benchmade, too expensive he says. Spyderco, Cold Steal, Buck, Colt, all dead. And all 40 to 70 dollars. So here is the test I am going to give him my Victorinox knife and if he manages to break it then I will come back and let you all know. I expect you'll never hear from me again.