Amazon.com Customer Reviews
The "Independence Day" of climate change, fantasy not science fiction! - Review written on July 12, 2008
Rating: 1 out of 5
3 customers found this review not to be helpful.
Science fiction involves speculation or rational extrapolation based on current science or technology, so scientific rules have to be obeyed up to certain degree. Then, there is no choice but to classify The Day After Tomorrow as fantasy, because the science was so exaggerated and full of factual mistakes that not even the man-made global warming tribe was willing to defend it. Famous environmentalist George Monbiot called it "a great movie and lousy science." Realclimate.org compared it with State of Fear for addressing "real scientific issues and controversies, but is similarly selective (and occasionally mistaken) about the basic science."
The only positive comment has to do with the special effects, they are as good as their sister movies Independence Day (Single Disc Widescreen Edition) and Godzilla, from the same film Director. Besides from SFX buffs and disaster movie fans, the only others who could really enjoy this movie is the small band of radicals, who in the name of a number of good causes, covertly advocate for industrialization, capitalism and globalization to end as the only means to save our planet. And this film makes their dream come truth, as the modern Ice Age forces most of the citizens from developed countries who survive to march as refugees to the Third World in exchange for their foreign debt. The Independence Day of climate change!
However, to be fair, it has to be noticed that The Day After Tomorrow was a big hit in the box office, so, unquestionably most moviegoers really love the combination of fantasy, good SFX, action, and disaster movies! This also explains the paradox of why so many Amazon reviewers agree on the exaggerations of the movie, but some rated it as five stars while others just one.
Wasting Today's Time - Review written on April 03, 2008
Rating: 3 out of 5
The Good Things
*Smashing special effects. Very detailed, vivid, and exciting.
*Some memorable scenes.
*Storyline is relatively engaging; hardly boring.
*I suppose this is somewhat relevant to today's issues concerning climate change.
*Acting was not too bad.
The Bad Things
*Highly unbelievable. Even if supercell storm systems have some kind of wierd cold air front, there's no way helicopters could freeze over in seconds and crash. Some parts are downright silly; people were literally running away from growing frost.
*Sometimes, the characters act dumb; a few parts where you could yell at the screen for the people to run and seek shelter. However, some of this stupidity is believable.
*Heavy focus on drama can be seen as sappy.
Only a step better than other disaster movies like "The Core," this film has a typical plot with typical characters. It is well made, with fantastic special effects, some interesting imagery, and adequate acting. Some aspects can also be relevant to modern-day issues in climate change (and possibly immigration). It is still a little shallow and highly unbelievable. Fans of disaster films, or people who like good special effects, should probably check this out. Otherwise, it is quite weak.
Don't go outside.... - Review written on March 29, 2008
Rating: 4 out of 5
2 customers found this review not to be helpful.
Here we are with another love it or hate it film. "The Day After Tomorrow" was done by the same crew who brought you "Independence Day".
Well, it's July 5th, and all h**l is breaking loose.
It all starts with the Larsen "B" ice shelf breaking up and falling into the Ocean (which was a real event, I might add). What happens from here, is best described as pure fiction (Science Fiction?).
Baseball-size hail in Japan, snow in India, tornadoes in Los Angeles, Helicopters freezing in flight above Scotland and a 100+feet storm surge in Manhattan. I think the only thing missing was fish and frogs raining from the sky in Kansas! All this leads up to three "superstorms" that signal the beginning of the new Ice Age.
Much time is given in the film to it's actors explaining away these occurrences, with Dennis Quaid leading the charge to think proactively, to protect the citizenry of the U.S. (it seems our government is only interested in money-WOW! big surprise, there!) The dramatization of the characters seems superfluous at times, with dialog that's just banal enough to put one to sleep. All the actors in this film make brave attempts to lend credibility to the story, but just can't get past the weather, which is the real star of this film.
The crazy weather IS interesting, though, especially when the choppers froze in mid air. The guy flash-freezing at the hatch of his helicopter is pretty good, and where better than Los Angeles, to get the "Wizard of Oz" treatment! Manhattan always seems to get the brunt of damage in disaster flicks, and one wonders why it's still standing!
It might seem that I'm bashing this film. On the contrary, there IS one thing that saves this film, and it happens to be my favorite part. It's when the "new" President of what's left of The United States gets in front of TV cameras and microphones, and ADMITS his fault in the handling of the disaster! I love it!!
The Scientific Community essentially dismissed this film outright, because of it's most glaring errors- The weather. Some said it was an "overly severe" example of the coming of the next Ice Age. Some even went so far as to say that many of the anomalies would not even occur! While I'm no scientist or meteorologist, "The Day After Tomorrow" is a pretty good example of "Escapist Reality"!
Some of the extras are interesting. There is a breakdown of the sound elements of a specific scene in the film, the usual deleted scenes, and commentary tracks. The Making-of segment is accessed by DVD-ROM.
Horrible plot, decent acting, good effects - Review written on February 09, 2008
Rating: 1 out of 5
Unless you really enjoy extreme weather footage/effects, this movie is not worth it. really cheesy plot, acting was "ok,", and I must say some of the effects were cool - but that's about it. A waste of time if you are looking for a good, fun, entertaining movie. I got bored, and I'm not the type to get bored.
Feculent pile of dog squeeze - Review written on November 11, 2007
Rating: 1 out of 5
6 customers found this review helpful, 3 did not.
The environmentalist whacko left, having condemned millions of Africans to malarial death via "Silent Spring", is now trying to reduce us all to pre-medieval peasant status by a general attack on Western industrial civilization. Behold its latest ouevre, "The Day after Tomorrow". "The Vomit after Diarrhea", in my humble opinion.
This movie is so bad, in so many ways.
First off, the acting is completely overwrought. Regret and sadness practically ooooooooze from everyone's pores. Scene after scene of people staring in glassy-eyed horror at some new disaster, big or small. Gutenberg burned for warmth, as tears of regret flow. Wolves hunting in cities. Monster, city-destroying storms. Americans fleeing to Mexico.
Then, the science is completely wrong. That much climate change, that quickly? Pah! Completely unbelievable.
Finally, Americans feeing to Mexico? Not a chance. The Mexicans would gun down every American crossing the Rio Grande.
I hope MST3K comes back so they can feature this. I wish Amazon had a "minus star" rating, for things like this that actively subtract from the joy of life through unmitigated dumbness.
UPDATE: I'm watching this again on FX (11/17/2007 11:45 PM). It doesn't get any better. I cringe for these people, that they should have survived this. We definitely are living in an age of mediocrity, and these actors are leading the way.
I'm surprised people liked this movie - Review written on November 04, 2007
Rating: 2 out of 5
2 customers found this review helpful, 13 did not.
You can almost see the guys sitting around a table planning the movie. They want disasters. Lots and lots of disasters. Lets do a tornado. No, that's been done. How about a bunch of them all at once? Great idea! And there, let's have high winds. What about earthquakes? Do we have time for that, while we're putting all of New York under ice? Hey, Frank, how long did the other ice ages take to start? I dunno Bill, but didn't I read somewhere that geological time is like a thousand times faster than normal time? Yeah. Something like that. Let's see now, do you think we should put in some science to try and explain it? Uh, okay, we'll say it's, uh, that's it's due to global warming! Yeah! And it's believable, that's what I like about it!!
Come to think of it, maybe I'm being too generous with the 2 stars.