Amazon.com Customer Reviews
Overblown and Overrated, Save Your Money. - Review written on July 28, 2007
Rating: 1 out of 5
19 customers found this review helpful, 2 did not.
The folks at Bed Bath and Beyond sold us on this flagship set from Calphalon, essentially telling us that these were the best and only set of pots and pans that we'd ever need. Like fools, we bought their line and the set. Here's the bottom line: We used them according to the manufacturer's instructions and 14 months later, they are falling apart. The Anodized Non-stick surface is flaking off and food sticks to what's left almost every time. You might be thinking that we probably used a brillo pad on them, let them soak overnight or put them in the dishwasher (all of these are no-nos), but we didn't. And honestly, the non-stick surface was a mediocre performer from day one. And who wants a set that you can't load up in the dishwasher anyway? And no soaking? Are you serious? Afraid so. We should have read all the fine print first (as usual).
Essentially you have to clean them as soon as you use them and when the no-stick surface turns out not to be, you have to use a dish cloth to "scrub" them out. Good luck with that. This is NOT a lifetime set. Maybe, MAYBE, it would be worth the price tag if it lasted 10 years, but it won't. The regular ol' teflon stuff is just as durable as the Calphalon Anodized One set, does better in the no-stick category, is workable in the dishwasher and oh yeah, it isn't $500+. If you are determined to go with Calphalon, I would get the regular steel/ chrome set. This less expensive set is far more durable, less finicky, less annoying and a better value all the way around. If you get these as a wedding gift, then be glad and take 'em back for the cash.
Fair, but there are better choices - Review written on August 14, 2006
Rating: 2 out of 5
7 customers found this review helpful, 9 did not.
I made the mistake of investing in a set of Calphalon about 4 years ago. Almost immediately, the pans began getting ugly scratches on the outside. It seems to happen no matter how careful you are. On the plus side, the non-stick coating is durable, and the cookware is quite heavy and made well. But for this kind of money, you should get a set of cookware that (A: You can toss in the dishwasher, and (B: Has a more durable exterior finish.
Note: To answer another person's comment, this is basically the same set I purchased some years ago at Dillard's department store. The handles have changed slightly, and Calphalon has added a polymer to help the exterior resist stains, but this set uses the same materials and finish as the one I had. And notice Calphalon still recommends hand washing??? You have to 'baby' the exterior finish....using a Scotch-brite pad to get out scratches and scuffs.
Great pans...If this is too much commitment, try a single pan first - Review written on June 02, 2006
Rating: 5 out of 5
7 customers found this review helpful.
A few years ago when I saw that Calphalon was coming out with their new "One" line, I was excited. I come from a family that loves to cook, and our Calphalon pans have been great in the past.
Spending $500 on pans is a lot, I'll admit. I started by buying some of the open stock pans, just to make sure that I liked the performance and quality. After an 18-month "test drive", I was sold.
I bought the 10-piece Nonstick set from Amazon, which arrived in fine condition with no damage to the box or any of the pans (though they are poorly packed, I will admit). I use my pans daily.
Some of my favorite things about the pans are the ability to cook eggs or cheese without lengthy clean-up. Just let the pan cool, and you can generally wipe them out with a paper towel.
great cookware - Review written on August 23, 2004
Rating: 5 out of 5
21 customers found this review helpful, 1 did not.
has only been 1 month since the purchase, but I love it. Also own a couple of All Clad fry pans, which I hate to use because everything sticks to them. With Calphalon, there are no stains on the bottom from gas flame, and although they are not DW safe, they are so-oo-oo easy to wash! The cookware is a little heavy, but I'm used to carrying my kid around, so that was not a problem for me. As for the price - I think it's OK, considering it comes with a lifetime warranty.