Amazon.com Customer Reviews
This is not a trilogy, but a legend! - Review written on June 07, 2008
Rating: 5 out of 5
This is the most amazing movie trilogy I ever saw.The story begins nicely in the fellowship of the ring, with many beautiful sceneries and imaginative places,presented in the most beautiful way.It's very sad to see the fellowship beginning to break at some points,but nevertheless the movie flows beautifully.The two towers is the middle story, with the return of one of the main characters.The battle at Helm's Deep is magnificent with more than 10000 characters in one screen.The story takes some turning points in this movie, continuing the marvelous flow.Finally, the best movie out of the three is The Return Of The King, still remaining the most amazing movie I ever saw.The special effects and mass armies are nothing short of genius.Tears came to my eyes as I saw the final part of the movie, and it stayed in my mind for sometime.I highly recommend this trilogy for fantasy lovers,and after watching this, I think people will start loving fantasy stories.Buy this movie set,and I guarantee you that you will not be dissapointed.
The unquestionable apex of modern fantasy gets a marvelous movie treatment - Review written on May 23, 2008
Rating: 5 out of 5
2 customers found this review helpful.
Of course these can't compare to the original Lord of the Rings trilogy. Considering the depth, breadth, scope, and originality of Tolkien's creative vision, how could they? It's a daunting task to make a movie out of the Lord of the Rings, since Tolkien wove a world just as realistic as our own. As such, the only attempts we had seen before The Fellowship of the Ring was adapted in 2001 were cutesy kiddie adaptations of the Hobbit and Return of the King (never mind that there are, you know, two books in between them) that featured characters with unnaturally large noses, and an odd retelling of The Fellowship of the Ring and about half of The Two Towers that had a vague, impressionistic art style and barely audible dialog. (There were also plans of a version starring the Beatles, which I, an avid Beatlemaniac, would be interested in seeing - John as Gollum, Paul as Frodo, George as Gandalf and Ringo as Sam). Needless to say, neither film has much value beyond "novelty" in this day and age.
However, I have to commend Peter Jackson for doing an excellent job with it just the same. I've more or less been a lifelong Lord of the Rings fan, and I'm impressed by every aspect of this film.
For one, the casting was perfect. Ian MacKellan (one of my favorite actors) as Gandalf, perpetual villain Christopher Lee as Saruman, Viggio Mortenson as Aragorn, Orlando Bloom as Legolas, Elijah Wood as Frodo, Lawrence Makoare and Andy Serkis collaborating for a truly ominous Witch-king of Angmar (the Nazgul Lord), Cate Blanchett as Galadriel... great choices all around. I'm especially impressed by the Gandalf-Saruman confrontations, which shame any lightsaber battle. Oh yeah, the battle scenes - Moria, Helm's Deep, Gondor - are truly epic, outstripping any others I've ever seen by a long run. True cinematic achievements!
Cutting-edge CGI technology is another point in this film worth bringing up. Gollum (played by Andy Serkis) is a cinematic revolution, essentially a CGI actor. The directors famously filmed Serkis' movements while he was attached to several video cameras, and adapted those into Gollum. Similar effort was put into the Great Eye of Sauron, and other denizens of Middle-Earth, such as the dragonlike steeds of the evil Nazgul; the cave trolls; and especially the fire-demon Balrog, a true feast for the eyes.
Oh yes, feasts for the eyes. How about that scenery? The Shire is beautiful, Gondor is majestic, the Dead Marshes are desolate, and Mordor is downright foreboding. The choice of location for the Mines of Moria alone is one of the most breathtaking sets ever chosen. Most of this was filmed in New Zealand, which means I have to go there.
Amazing soundtrack, too. I liked it so much, I actually BOUGHT it, and I'm not one who generally likes soundtracks. But this... this is different. It's never just your typical Hollywood soundtrack schmaltz. It's actually heavily rooted in Celtic folk, and I think that's very cool myself. Plus Saruman's theme is one of the few themes I honestly find menacing.
Now, for the most important part. Peter Jackson definitely leaves a few plot points out (Where's Tom Bombadil?), but on a whole I think he really gets deep into the heart and soul of the Lord of the Rings, in my mind the greatest book (and I say "book" because it was meant to be a single novel, and is only broken into three because of a publishing error) ever written. That's the key here. This is a guy who knows and loves Lord of the Rings, working with a cast of characters who do the same.
If you've never read the books, do so. If you have, this makes a wonderful companion. Each of these movies are three hours, so it's a big commitment to sit down and watch one. But there's a great chance that you will be rewarded.
"Q: Where Would You Rather Be? A: Anywhere But Here..." - Review written on July 20, 2007
Rating: 1 out of 5
2 customers found this review helpful, 24 did not.
Follow in "The Lord of the Rings" creator's (J.R.R. Tolkien's) footsteps. Project a malevolent universe. Invent a world and animate it with creatures in conflict. Make the conflict a battle between good and evil, but don't identify clearly the moral value or purpose of either side. In fact, remove morality's essence altogether by eliminating the power of choice for your characters. Emphasize the corruptibility of men. Glamorize the supernatural. Dwell interminably on the preparations for and the wreaking of violence and destruction, on the fragility of hope and happiness. Name the scene of action: Middle-earth. Sound like an environment you'd care to envision? Would you "live" there? If so, fate alone will decide its survival and your own. You can visit this predetermined "paradise" by watching/enduring/suffering Peter Jackson's elaborately filmed adaptation of Tolkien's epic trilogy, which concludes with "The Return of the King."
I hold it is true that what is not worth contemplating in life is not worth contemplating in art. For its dismaying lack of meaningful moral definition, its pervasive pictorial ugliness, the quantity of its scenes of mind-numbing graphic violence, and its minimizing of the value of happiness, "The Lord of the Rings" films--including this one--ought to be shunned and damned.
Needs a couple more stars - Review written on May 08, 2007
Rating: 5 out of 5
1 customer found this review not to be helpful.
Peter Jackson pulled off this incredible story almost to perfection. I could have done without Gollum or Frodo's blindly following him. I loved all the "tour New Zealand" epic shots. Music was really good, and fit so well. Kate Blanchett, to me at least, wasn't pretty enough to be the Sorceress she was supposed to be, and only when she was being tempted (and digitally enhanced) did she look the part. All the folks played their parts very well.
A couple of spots were weak, such as Legolas commenting to the camera while on the run after the Uruks. Massively epic battle scenes, mostly bloodless, which I personally appreciated, as I had tired of such massive bloodiness in films (such as Braveheart.) Made the whole thing a bit easier to watch.
Still, the best films I've seen, in my life. 7 stars!
The Best Movies Ever! - Review written on January 15, 2007
Rating: 5 out of 5
3 customers found this review helpful.
WOW! These films are AMAZING! They are full of action, adventure, friendship, battles, loyalty, treachery, fun, and imagination.
The plot follows a middle-aged hobbit named Frodo Baggins (Elijah Wood), who inherits a magic Ring from his uncle Bilbo (Ian Holm). He discovers that it is the One Ring, created by the Dark Lord Sauron. If Sauron finds the Ring and takes it, all of Middle-Earth will plunge into darkness. With the help of the wizard Gandalf (Ian McKellen), the heir to the throne of men, Aragorn (Viggo Mortensen), his gardener Sam (Sean Astin), two hobbit friends, Merry and Pippin (Dominic Monaghon and Billy Boyd), another human named Boromir (Sean Bean), a dwarf named Gimli (John-Ryhes Davies), and an elf named Legolas (Orlando Bloom), Frodo must journey into Mordor, Sauron's kingdom, and destroy the Ring. The Fellowship must face many dangerous enemies, including the evil wizard Saruman (Christopher Lee), and the creature Gollum (Andy Serkis) in order to destroy the Ring and save Middle-earth.
Peter Jackson and company have created a wonderful adaptation of the marvelous books. Though full of action and battles, Lord of the Rings contains a highly entertaining and meaningful story, worth watching over and over again. Trust me, I never get tired of watching it. The special effects are spectacular, and I have never seen more believable acting. If you miss seeing this trilogy, you'll be very sorry!
The Greatest Fantasy Movies of All Time - Review written on January 10, 2007
Rating: 5 out of 5
2 customers found this review helpful, 1 did not.
There are certain movies that redefine the genre they represent. Star Wars brought science-fiction to a new age. Harry Potter took the child's fantasy/magic genre. The Matrix trilogy redefined what an action movie should be. Pirates of the Caribbean showed that movies for the whole family can still be enjoyed by all viewers. If you give someone a list of all these masterpieces, and ask if you forgot any, most will probably mention at least one: The Lord of the Rings Trilogy. These are true epics that will be treasured for generations to come. Enthralling storyline, beautiful filming, mind-blowing special effects, and too many other things to name make these movies superior to almost all others. They are individually rated below:
The Fellowship of the Ring: The beginning of the amazing trilogy, Fellowship was what started it all. Peter Jackson took J.R.R. Tolkien's masterpiece and brought it to life. The main characters are brought out so well by their individual actors, it's like they were all born for their roles. Although it's a three-hour movie, the viewer will be so drawn into the story that the time will seem non-existent. The movie centers on young Frodo Baggins, or more importantly, what he holds in his pocket, the One Ring. Created by the evil Sauron, the ring is the secret to all Sauron's power, he lost it a millenia ago, leaving him in a spirit form, but now his power is growing, and he wants it back. Frodo's wizard friend Gandalf (played superbly by Sir Ian McKellan), knows of Sauron, and sends Frodo on a mission to Mount Doom, the only place where the ring can be destroyed. Helping are three of Frodo's best friends: Sam, Pippin, and Merry. Along the way, they team up with Aragorn, Gimli, Legolas (you will LOVE this guy), and Boromir. The group is faced with many perils on their journey, and by end the viewers will be more than ready to see...
The Two Towers: The introduction of one of the most pivotal characters...GOLLUM! This movie is a lot more intense (and even scary for younger viewers) than the first. Now that the characters have all been introduced in the first movie, the real story unfolds. Saruman's army is on the march, and it's up to Aragorn, Gimli, and my personal favorite, Legolas, to form an army, then kick some major orc tail. Meanwhile, Frodo and Sam continue their journey to Mount Doom. On the way they meet the bipolar Gollum, a former hobbit who owes his double personality to the ring. Gollum is the personality that wants the ring for evil and deception, and Smeagal, the other personality, is a pitiful, heart-breaking little guy who just wants the voice in his head to go away. After meeting Frodo and Sam, the voice DOES go away... for a little while. As the movie progresses, Aragorn and company, along with an army of men and elves, protect a fortress that holds one of man's last civilizations. As for Frodo and Sam, they continue their journey, being shown the way by Gollum, and it all leads up to the ultimate movie...
The Return of the King: OH YEAH! HERE WE GO! The most amazing one of them all! Peter Jackson really out did himself for this one. As Aragorn and company continue their seeminly never ending battle against Sauron's forces, Frodo's little trio continues toward Mount Doom, where he will not only have to face orcs, Sauron, and many other obstacles, he will also have to face something far more deadly... himself.
Again, these belong in any movie-watchers collection. Please do yourself a favor and buy these. You will NOT be sorry. May your swords stay sharp, and enjoy the show!
Going Down Down Down in a Ring of Fire - Review written on January 05, 2007
Rating: 5 out of 5
1 customer found this review helpful.
I spent the equivalent of a full day's waking-hours in front of my big screen TV this past winter break with just the 2 sets of the four Harry Potter movies and the three Lord of the Rings movies.
I am NOT a couch potato.
Well, at least it was time well spent. Finally...some movies that really make the grade. I've been hard-pressed to find a good 5-star movie that I haven't seen. And here I've had these two sets of films that have been out there all this time that that for whatever reason I've had an aversion to. Silly me.
The Lord of the Rings Trilogy was movie making at its best. Especially considering that the movie had very high standards to live up to after more than 50 years of building such a loyal, cult following of the classic J.R.R. Tolkien book.
Hobbits, Elves, Men, Dwarves, Wizards, Orcs all co-surviving, albeit without much harmony, in Middle Earth. And all lust for the great Ring of Power made by the Dark Lord Sauron. But only little Frodo Baggins controls its Destiny. Thus is the 9-hour epic saga of the Lord of the Rings Trilogy: The Fellowship of the Ring (2001), The Two Towers (2002) and The Return of the King (2003).
There is a terrific list of A-list actors giving A-list performances. It's a long one: Therefore, most notably you have Elijah Wood as Frodo, Sean Astin as Sam, Ian McKellen as Gandalf, Andy Serkis as Gollum (what a performance!), Viggo Mortensen as Aragorn, Orlando Bloom as Legolas Greenleaf and John Rhys-Davies as Gimli. I know. I know....How could I not mention Christopher Lee, Liv Tyler and all the others??? Well, that's the point. The whole cast was awesome. Even the no-names that played Orcs.
Kudos to Director Peter Jackson for going beyond the Hollywood standard of 120 minutes to tell each chapter of the story. Jackson kept a lot of the character development that usually isn't transferred from novel to movie adaptation. And Jackson was a master not just at directing his cast, but at getting the special effects perfect. The Lord of the Rings movie adaptation will be as classic as the novel because of Jackson.
If you somehow missed these movies as I did until recently for whatever crazy reason, I hope that my little review has encouraged you to add them to your cart. As for Harry Potter...well that's another review entirely, of course.
Frodo Lives!