Amazon.com Customer Reviews
Monk rubs the lotion on his hands, as Stottlemeyer would say! - Review written on May 13, 2007
Rating: 4 out of 5
1 customer found this review helpful, 1 did not.
My wife, Jen, likes to wash her hands. Let me explain further. Every time we eat, touch a stray cat, lick the trashcans, or just plain hug, she likes to wash those cute little nubbins of hers with anti-bacterial soap. Strange? How about this personal story. Dented cans. Heard of them? Well, every time we are at the grocery store, when it comes to the cans, we must inspect, feel, and insure that no dents are hiding for fear of a little disease known as botulism. These are the things I love the most, but I wouldn't call them crazy - to her face at least. With these little idiosyncrasies in place, we have been itching to see a TV series that has been awarded several accolades through its already planned six seasons, aptly titled "Monk". It is a simple show, or at least the first season is, in which a highly intelligent detective overcomes his phobias (as far ranging as they are) to solve crimes and give us the classic "Scooby-Doo" ending, where Monk typically pulls the mask of some unsuspecting criminal. As stated before, this is a simple show, not your run-of-the-mill "CSI" where bodies co-exist with blood and scantily clad women, this is more along the PG rated level, but please, don't be discerned, this is smarter, funnier, and more exciting than Grissom saying, "There is always a clue". In my eyes, there is always a Monk.
Tony Shalhoub, who typical stands behind the leading man in most films, takes helm of this originally small series, and transforms it into a masterpiece. He masters the mannerisms of someone that may be experiencing the phobias and compulsions that do exist in the modern world. Alas, he at times does over-push the limits, but it works because it isn't some big name star trying to outwit himself each time. There is a heart to Shalhoub's character, which, in my eyes, makes for better watching than gritty realism. This first season doesn't even begin to scratch the surface on the possibilities that Monk has in store for us. What brings this series into full swing, and pulls the viewer closer to Monk is the unknown of his past. Through each episode we are given small nibbles of the past; how he lost his wife, the birth of his condition, and his reasoning for being discharged from the force. We grow with this in the first episode, and it only gets better in time ... I mean with each episode.
If I were to complain, it would be a very small two - meaning I only have two small issues with the show. The first being the change of structure from the original premiere. Originally, we didn't see the culprit until the very ending, allowing Monk to bask in the glow of his own discoveries - I liked this opportunity. It allowed me to solve the clues with Monk and see if his eyes were similar to mine. The second has to do with continuity, and I feel that this may be an issue with my own personal preference, but I would have liked to have smaller sub-plots which would have led to a surprising cliffhanger of a season finale. I loved the story of Monk and his lost wife, but I wanted more to do with this, more meat to go with the potatoes of the show. There was one episode, "Mr. Monk meets Dale the Whale" in which we are given a glimpse of the darkness surrounding the events leading to Monk's wife's death, but that is it. It was almost as if that episode went too far, and afterwards they pulled back too quickly. Again, those were small issues compared the the impressiveness of this first season. It has plenty of room to grow, and I think each of our main central characters, Disher, Stottlemeyer, and even Sharona will continue to impress as we grow with them.
Overall, I am eager (yet, oddly, not jumping) to begin the next season. I wanted a stronger finisher than what was presented, but with "Monk" it isn't about the bells and whistles, it is about solving crimes and overcoming obstacles that maybe are normal challenges in our lives. The bombardment of celebrity involvement near the end (Willie Nelson, Amy Sedaris, and Tim Daly) only shows the growth and popularity that this program was already beginning to see near the end of the first season. Again, I am excited, but not "Lost" excited about our next season. I want to see "Monk" grow - it has the potential - let's see if the creators take it to that next level.
Keyboards kinda gross - Monk would be disappointed.
Grade: **** out of *****
Monk peps me up. - Review written on March 20, 2007
Rating: 5 out of 5
1 customer found this review helpful.
I love Adrian Monk. Oh, not romantically. No, Adrian is like your first cousin on your mother's side who is admired by the family for his great mind, but is pitied because he has that 'little problem'. Being just a tad OCD myself, I can identify with his need for things to line up straight...most of the time. I adore Monk because he's still 'married' even though Trudy has been dead for several years. His loyalty may not be the best thing for him, but it's strong and true. The series often has poignant moments that make me want to cry for him, but for the most part, Monk is a peppy, fun show that I keep on hand to make the world go away. Let's not forget Sharona. She's the best, and along with Leland and Randy, what could be more perfect?