Amazon.com Customer Reviews
One of my favorite films of the 60's - Review written on January 27, 2008
Rating: 5 out of 5
2 customers found this review helpful.
Charade has it all: Mystery, romance, suspense, and a lot of dry, witty humor throughout. There is a magical quality to Grant and Hepburn's on screen chemistry. In this short review, I want to make a clear distinction between two of the available versions. Charade This edition, by Madacy, is a good quality product. It has good picture and sound and it will not disappoint those who watch it on an old fashioned standard picture tube. This is the one that most people buy and it is the best value for the money, especially as a used product. However, if you have an big screen HDTV like I do, you will see flaws in the picture due to a lower-resolution scan. You know what I mean, like a slightly compressed JPEG file on your computer. For those with a hi-def big screen TV, you must go for the Criterion Collection Charade - Anamorphic Widescreen Edition (Criterion Collection Spine #57). It is well worth the extra money for the clearest, cleanest possible picture and sound for large HDTV viewing. So which to choose from? It all depends on what kind of TV you have. I hope I have helped you to make the right choice for you. It's a great movie and I know you will love it!
Charade - Anamorphic Widescreen Edition - Criterion Collection Spine #57 - Clearly the Best Of A Confusing Assortment - Review written on January 17, 2008
Rating: 5 out of 5
2 customers found this review helpful.
1. This is a typical Criterion release. Meticulously restored in both the video and audio domains. A beautiful visual (at front-projected 720p) and pretty good sound experience (aferall, it was released in 1963--still the Stone Age of most film sound tracks).
2. This release allows you to focus on the performances of performers (not the quality of the transfer). Curiously, Hepburn gets more great lines that Grant!
3. As compared with junk quality (even by bootleg standards) releases such as the one by A2ZCOS.com "Timeless Classics" in a "Remastered Edition, " we are dealing with truth and reality. The release by A2ZCOS.com (and other off-brands) are turn-offs, if not expensive jokes.
4. Off-brand dogs present video that is several notches below what you might expect from, say, a cell phone video copy from a hacked-up, dirty 16 mm version. Audio is several notches below cell-phone voice quality--all that is missing is cell-phone drop outs!
5. Bottom line: As with all things DVD, beware of off brands from unknown entities.
William Flanigan, Ph.D
Horrible DVD ruins a great classic movie - Review written on January 05, 2008
Rating: 1 out of 5
5 customers found this review helpful.
Charade is a great movie that most people discover later in life (their 30s, or at least I did), and I've seen it between 10 and 20 times. If Cary Grant and Audrey Hepburn aren't enough, there's Walther Matthau, James Coburn, George Kennedy, Ned Glass, and Paris, plus a score by Henry Mancini and a plot that you won't see all the way through until the last scene.
But the Delta DVD is just terrible. There are no extras, just chapter selections. This alone isn't enough to deserve a pan, perhaps, but the introduction to the menu screen takes several seconds to loop through and can't be interrupted. Okay, so that's a minor annoyance.
The real problem is the movie. It's dark and muddy. There are several bad skips both in the opening credits sequence (one of my favorites, but ruined on this DVD) and several scenes of dialog. I'm guessing this studio used a worn-out copy of the film for its transfer rather than a master.
I bought this DVD because I didn't want to spring for the big bucks to get the Criterion DVD. But like they say, you get what you pay for. Apparently there are several versions of Charade available now, and I guarantee that the Delta copy is the worst.
Hilarious and Intense! Superb film-making! - Review written on December 13, 2007
Rating: 5 out of 5
1 customer found this review helpful, 1 did not.
I don't know what I was expecting from this movie. I've liked the lead actors in everything I've seen them in. Until recently I had not even heard of this film.
Now I know just how little I know about movies.
This one blew my mind. Few movies I've seen have been consistently good every second of the way. This one easily makes that list. The music (!), the colors, the suspense, and yes the acting too - all engrossing. It was intense when it needed to be (Tex and his matches come to mind), funny when it needed to be (and the jokes were actually hilarious!), romantic when necessary.
While some of the plot twists were obvious, I don't think that detracted from the suspense. After all, for any movie you've seen more than once (and hence must like?), you already know the plot in advance. This one is definitely rewatchable.
Worth viewing, good for this type of film - Review written on November 15, 2007
Rating: 4 out of 5
3 customers found this review helpful, 2 did not.
Nice mix of breezy romance, villains and suspense. Because of the complex dealings of her once, always busy husband, Audrey Hepburn is pulled into a world of obsessed, quirky and ruthless characters, all searching for the fortune (1960's value) left behind, somewhere, by her recently murdered spouse; a man of many aliases. The hunt for the prize keeps you guessing who's who in the zoo.
Although I try to outwardly present an image of a sophisticated moviegoer I still enjoyed it. If the seemingly out of place "black foot, white foot Indian?" metaphor had been left on the cutting room floor this film would have an even greater appeal to me. My personal sensibilities aside, this one is really worth your viewing time though. Good cast too, aside from the headliners.