Amazon.com Customer Reviews
Krups Toaster - Review written on July 30, 2008
Rating: 3 out of 5
3 customers found this review helpful.
This is a really nice looking toaster, but I wasn't expecting to have to try a bunch of tricks to get a decent slice of toasted bread. The only way that the bread toasts well is if I push the defrost button, otherwise, it comes out sort of toasted on the bottom, toasted on the top, and unevenly toasted in the middle. I don't remember having this problem with my $9.97 toaster that finally burnt out after years of use.
When using the defrost feature for its intended purpose, it works well with unthawing and heating up frozen waffles. The slots are large enough to accommodate the width of the supersize waffles made with my Krups Wafflemaker. Krups FDD912 Expert Waffle Maker with Rotary System I do have to cut them in half because they are longer than the standard waffle. It will also accomodate large bagels, and it seems to toast those better than it does a slice of bread.
The toaster has 8 different browning levels, but in my opinion, using it on anything below 5 takes lightly toasted to a whole new level! I started out on 4 and had to retoast it because it was really light. I finally settled on 6.
I used the warming area once or twice, but since I don't keep the toaster on the counter it's easier to just wrap a croissant in a paper towel and heat it in the microwave for a few seconds.
The cord corral is a nice feature as long as you make sure it's fully extended before using the toaster, otherwise it may get singed or burned from the heat of the toaster. The other feature that I like is the crumb tray. It pulls out for easy cleaning, so yea! no more holding the toaster over the sink or trash to get the crumbs out.
The toaster has a few nice features, but if you are particular about your toast, you may want to try a different toaster because this one will probably cause you grief! I'll make do with it, but I wouldn't buy it again and would only recommend it with reservations.
Short slots - fits standard bread only - Review written on June 10, 2008
Rating: 3 out of 5
I've always joked that I'm such a careful shopper, I'd probably spend a week just researching a toaster purchase. Then, when our old toaster died, I did!
Several review sites gushed over this toaster, but we were most disappointed to find that the slots are even shorter (back to front) than our old toaster. Even slightly larger than standard sandwich-size bread has to be pushed down into the slots. Longer Italian or other rustic breads have to put in end-wise.
Now, I wasn't expecting a long-slot toaster, but for the slots to be even shorter than our old Cuisinart is just nuts! How much could it cost to make the slots even an inch longer? (Two inches would be better!)
Other than that, I do have a minor beef with the side-ways lever. (I find it annoying and awkward to push it down to the right.) But that's really a minor issue, that I would have completely overlooked it had it not been for the stingy slot length.
In its favor, I love the bagel setting for bagels and hamburger buns. And the big tray-top is a great idea.
But we like breads of various sizes so much that I'm afraid the search is on again, and this one will be heading to the Goodwill.
Krups vs. Breville - Review written on May 30, 2007
Rating: 4 out of 5
19 customers found this review helpful.
After some research, I narrowed my choices to the FEM2W (White), the Breville Ikon, and the small $30 Cuisinart CPT-120. Went to Bed, Bath and Beyond to see what they looked like. They only had the Cuisinart. Ordered the Breville and the Krups. Returned the Breville, kept the Krups. The Cuisinart looked nice, but I thought the Krups looked better, and I liked its features. The Breville was not bad. I didn't like it because:
1. It was difficult to set the browning control to the right level, and there was no way to return to that same setting later if I strayed. The Krups knob has 22 clicks, every third of which is labeled with a number.
The Breville did not click. True, it has a nice digital display, but I did not find it practical.
2. The crumb tray is on the left, the browning control is on the front, and the push-down handle is on the right. The Krups has everything on the same side. I also preferred the Krups position on the counter.
3. It was not nearly as attractive as the Krups.
Both toasters toasted pretty well. 6 on the Krups was about the same as 4 on the Breville, a nice light brown. The Breville was slightly darker at these settings. (I used standard size whole-wheat.) Both had the same problem of not browning the bottom third, but they did well when I put the bread in upside-down. I suspect this has something to do with the moisture content of bread kept in the refrigerator.
If you like English muffins, you might prefer the Breville.
When you take the Krups out of the box, you have to run it twice at the highest setting with no bread in it. This is to burn off the factory coating. Directions say to ventilate the house. This is definitely a good idea. Open a window and turn on an exhaust fan. It stinks!
I suspect those who had problems with streaking and sticking failed to do this.
The burn-off was not necessary with the Breville.
With both toasters, browning was not 100% consistent. I think this is because they are wide-slot toasters. Even though they have the holders in the slots, they only hold the toast at the top. The bottom of the slice does not get pushed to the center.
My 25-year-old eight-dollar Proctor-Silex was more consistent and more even, but it did not have wide slots.
Both toasters cost $60. If you find a cheaper one, it is probably reconditioned.
I agree, $60 is too much for a toaster. If you don't want to spend this much, look at the $30 Cuisinart. It has a good review in Consumer Reports. (The $15 Proctor-Silex has had some problems.)
All in all, I think the Krups is very satisfactory. I really like the way it looks on my counter, and I like how it works. I recommend it.
October 2, 2007: Krups toaster still works as well as it did the first day; no changes; no problems. I have yet to try a bagel or an english muffin. I keep it set on 5 plus one click. This is a little on the light side. When I go up one click, toast is substantially browner but
consistency varies more (according to brand and age of bread). Moisture and density of bread appear to be factors. I continue to put the bread in upside-down for best results.