Amazon.com Customer Reviews
Good Transmitter - Limitations Obvious - Review written on February 19, 2007
Rating: 4 out of 5
6 customers found this review helpful, 1 did not.
I purchased one of these after over a year of stalling due to all of the poor reviews here and elsewhere. I was concerned about 2 primary issues: sound quality and reception. I finally bought one with a gift certificate since I wasn't willing to risk hard earned cash on it.
I drove with this model in my Mercury Mountaineer driver-side cupholder for nearly 400 miles. I ran the player for about 8 hours straight through 3 very large metropolitan areas and also through the country. I used the batteries (wish they had included a power adapter in this model).
On first setup, I turned on the device by holding both tune buttons down. I located a station range in the lower FM 90's where I could not find a clear radio station for 0.4 or so on the FM dial. I then tuned my TuneCast right in the middle of those. I turned up the sound on my car and pressed play on my iPod. I was instantly greeted with poor signal and tons of static as reported by many on the internet. I was pretty mad, then I realized my iPod volume was turned down a bit. I turned this up to about 95% and instantly the sound came pumping through my car's system clear as a bell.
On my trip I had to change the station 3 times as I moved in and out of massive metropolitan areas. This became evident as the signal would slowly gain static. All I did was first locate the closest station with no or little radio broadcast signal (tons of static), then I dialed the TuneCast to that station. It worked perfectly each time and only took seconds, so this did not bother me at all. When I came back the same way a few days later, I didn't have to change the station once.
With regard to battery life, I found that my TuneCast ran on the 2 AAA batteries for about 8 hours. When the batteries died, they died instantly and my signal was lost within seconds. I simply replaced, and was jamming again in a minute.
Possible problems people could have with this are (1) poor placement relative to your car's antenna (good in Mercury Mountaineers), (2) small signal strength of audio player - iPod (20GB, 4th gen) at 95% is pretty loud in earphones and it's possible not all players can go loud enough to eliminate much of the static in the FM broadcast, (3) trying to tune to a station that already has a radio broadcast in the area or has an FM band close to the one you're using - find one to use with some room on each side for little static, (4) songs that use intense ends of the frequency spectrum like extremely low basses or high-pitched whooshes from cymbals, etc - I found that songs with a lot of bass and crashes had some static in those spectrums (a limitation of FM in general, but not really an annoyance to me; your radio station overcomes this with special compression).
Overall, I gave this device a 4 because of the power situation. I would have liked it to come with an adapter. Things I really like are the small size, 0.1 FM resolution on the entire range, batteries optional, auto-on/off feature (works great!). This device may not work for everyone, but you need to understand the limitations of this technology before you go calling it a piece of junk. Small devices like this have Federally mandated operating powers so that they don't override your local FM stations for everyone else, otherwise I'm sure they would have a strong enough signal for anyone's car configuration (and heck, entire neighborhood for that matter).
Save Your Money - Review written on January 22, 2007
Rating: 1 out of 5
3 customers found this review helpful.
I purchased this product because I had been told it was one of the better FM transmitters on the market that does not operate off your car's cigarette lighter (and, therefore, can be used both in a car and on a home stereo). The price isn't too bad. The problem is it simply did not work. I tried it first of my home stereo and was able to at least get it to produce some sound, but the quality was extremely poor, similar to when you're driving out of town and losing your radio station - in other words, extreme static. Next, I tried it in the car, where I thought I'd have better luck, but I could not get the thing to broadcast at all, on any of the available stations. The sound quality was zero, because there was no sound at all. I also agree with another reviewer who stated that the available stations are a problem, as most larger cities will already have these taken. I ended up returning this and going back to my old cassette adapter, which works a thousand times better. I don't think I'll ever try another FM transmitter, because after my experience with this one, I don't think I'm ever going to find one that works as well as a much cheaper cassette adapter will.
It really barely works, but there's a different one that does work - Review written on August 09, 2006
Rating: 2 out of 5
15 customers found this review helpful.
This thing has a range of about a foot, with really poor quality sound. It may be as good or better than other transmitters that are available, but it's still pretty lousy. Not really as good as standard FM, probably halfway between AM and FM, and interrupted by the occasional static. I modified it as described in the websites that describe how to do such things, but the sound is so crappy, that it's hardly worth the price. The modified range is about 50 feet.
I realize that it solves a problem of allowing an MP3 player to work in your car, and there aren't any good alternatives, but but this isn't going to make anyone really happy. It's just a barely passable solution. It does what it's supposed to, and if you modify it, it has much better range, but it's really not a great result.
UPDATE: I really wanted a product like this, so I bought the "whole house transmitter" right on Amazon and it works. Near FM quality sound, decent range (about 40 feet). It only broadcasts on one of 6 channels, but at least the quality is acceptable if you can find an open one, and it punches through weak stations so the channel doesn't really have to be completely clear. It's 3X the price, but that seems to be what it takes to get decent quality sound.