Amazon.com Customer Reviews
Utterly Brilliant, Subtle Detail, Heartwarming - Review written on July 04, 2008
Rating: 5 out of 5
1 customer found this review helpful, 1 did not.
I have watched this DVD several times, and each time I find new details that enthrall.
This is a truly heartwarming movie that I used to push back against the crushing weight of reality, a reality I do not control.
The two super-actors are at their best, but the young man who stars as the son of the gad-about lady is the real star. His smile, his behavior, are Oscar material.
Don't miss the dogs, the pig, and the lion. This is a "top ten" movie.
Great film- a rarity - Review written on July 02, 2008
Rating: 5 out of 5
In a world where so many films about sex and violence, this movie is the colored diamond amidst a sea of colorless ones. This is a film that you will remember. The actors are excellent, and the significance is very real- broken families, mothers who aren't really there, ostracism, finding a family, growing up, respecting and revering older ones, and you may find more themes. As a Language Arts teacher, and one that understands most of my students don't come from the conventional family, I plan on perhaps sharing this film with them.
A timeless movie for your top-ten list - Review written on June 23, 2008
Rating: 5 out of 5
2 customers found this review helpful.
I've watched this movie several times and still love it. The basic story is of a boy, Walter (played by Haley Joel Osment) who is dumped on his great-uncles Garth and Hub (Michael Caine and Robert Duvall) because his skanky, irresponsible mother, Mae (Kyra Sedgwick), is tired of being tied down by him. Garth and Hub aren't interested in Walter, and Walter seems, at first, to be a bit too beaten down by having an unloving mother to really care much.
But gradually Walter and his great-uncles start to get to know each other and to warm to each other. One of the things that helps is that the great-uncles seem to have led some very interesting and adventurous lives. They tell stories of things they did when they were younger (as each story is being told, the movie makes the transition from narration to showing the story unfold in live action). These stories are exciting and wonderful and all have core values about life very neatly underlying them.
One of the stories is that the great-uncles accumulated a vast amount of gold, though we don't know for sure whether it was acquired the way the great-uncles tell, or through a bank robbery. And it turns out that Mae, in addition to just getting rid of Walter for a while, was also hoping that Walter would find out where the money is hidden, and so she was coldly using him for that purpose.
When Walter finds out that it is possible that none of the stories are true, Hub tells him that it doesn't matter, giving a wonderful speech about love, honor, and goodness, and about how there are things worth believing in. (A brief excerpt: "...That people are basically good; that honor, courage, and virtue mean everything; that ... money and power mean nothing; that good always triumphs over evil...." Wonderful stuff. I suppose the more cynical and heart-hardened might call this syrupy or even unbelievable, but I call it core values.)
I don't want to give anything more away about the story, but I assure you it is a wonderful, warm, human story, womderfully told with great acting on the part of all three major characters (Caine, Duvall, and Osment). I love this movie and hope you will too.
Cute As A Button - Review written on June 13, 2008
Rating: 4 out of 5
2 customers found this review helpful.
I gotta get out more. I had never heard about this movie; never noticed it when it was playing in movie palaces. Channel surfing the other night (and I can press buttons on a remote with the best of 'em) I ran across this intriguing little gem on cable. Anything sporting Michael Caine and Robert Duvall (as brothers, if you can believe that) is worth watching; and SECONDHAND LIONS aptly entertains--even if the syrup is a bit sticky.
It's a plot that's been cooked before: A pre-teen goes to stay with wacky, eccentric relatives. Haley Joel Osment plays the adolescent, and when his manhunting momma dumps him on the doorstep of two great-uncles (Duvall and Caine), circa 1950s Texas boonies, the fun begins. The brothers are alleged retired big game hunters and adventure seekers, yet the locals believe they are instead retired bank robbers--retired gents sitting on a vast stash of loot. Predictably, as the story unfolds the once-terrified boy begins to appreciate his shotgun-toting elders; a lasting bond of affection, of family, develops.
Are there some drawbacks? Sure. The "flashbacks" of the brothers as adventuresome youths are cornpone supreme. Haley Joel Osment is stiff, wooden, and uninspired; he looked like he wanted to split to the nearest Hannah Montana gig. And the ending was. . .over the top. (Yet very emotional.) But come one. Michael Caine and Robert Duvall make this movie work, and work well; they bring believability, eccentricity, and big-time grit to their roles. SECONDHAND LIONS may have scooted past me when it made its theatrical run, but I'm sure glad I caught it cable surfing, and recommend it to anyone looking for fun entertainment.
--D. Mikels, Author, Walk-On