Amazon.com Customer Reviews
Milwaukee gets it right--well mostly - Review written on November 21, 2006
Rating: 4 out of 5
3 customers found this review helpful.
OK, I've been using the multi-bay charger almost every day for over 3 months now. Note that not everyone will have exactly the same results as I did. Also, my opinions on it are just that, opinions. Here's are some of my conclusions:
1.When the top-off maintenance charge is complete, pull the battery off the charger as soon as possible. As a test I tried leaving a known good 18 & 14.4V battery on for a few hours after solid green lights and they both seemed to lose some of their charge. This doesn't seem right to me and I believe that Milwaukee could have put some kind of discharge block in the circuit to prevent bleed off after full charge. I believe the charger should be smart enough to sense a fully charged battery and automatically switch to a tiny charge current to prevent any discharge at all. Or perhaps even shut down entirely, preventing accelerated drain.
2.It can bring new life to old/tired batteries but only to a certain point. I had an older (dead) 18V battery that I hadn't used for over 8 months and it _did_ charge it when the single bay charger didn't even sense it. However, the battery didn't hold a charge for very long, even after completing a lengthy (4+ hours) maintenance trickle charge. I realize there are a limited number of charges in every battery.
I'm convinced this charger is superior to the single unit and absolutely does a more complete charge. However, I'm concerned about the apparent discharging issues. For a company as deliberately thorough (and frustratingly slow to release new product) about quality as Milwaukee is, to let a substandard tool slip through is thought provoking.
A quick note on batteries: I've found that the newer, "black" stripe batteries _seem_ to hold a charge longer than the older "red" stripe units. Your mileage may vary.
In conclusion, if you can afford this unit, it's a worthwhile investment especially if you have many batteries and use them all day. Follow the instructions for proper charging procedures to the letter and you'll be very happy with your battery life. I know Milwaukee would never publicly own up to any issues but I'm pretty convinced there are some flaws in the circuit design. I hope they got it right with the new lithium ion charger/battery system.