Amazon.com Customer Reviews
Falls short - Review written on September 08, 2006
Rating: 3 out of 5
6 customers found this review helpful, 3 did not.
Order another latte, because a third meaningful Norah Jones CD will probably be a while in coming. "New York City" comes off as what it is: a mini set featuring Jones as a guest singer. While there's enough cool in spots to satisfy most fans, this appallingly thin collection doesn't add up to Norah's honed-to-perfection standards. Even worse, the seven listed tunes are really six with a reprise of track 1 -- hardly value for money.
Thematically, the blue-tinged atmosphere falls short of the best of "Feels Like Home" and "Come Away With Me." Jones's music is at its finest when her breathy vocals alternate between seduction and quiet despair. On her first two CDs she could pack in all sorts of images and feelings into one song; on "New York City" there's simply not enough room to develop a range of emotion.
A Norah Jones CD conjures up the sultry twilight of late July, porch swings, open windows and carnivals -- the bittersweet days of the small town world. "New York City" is a bit of a disappointment for listeners who were touched by, and are waiting for, the original vision.
One Good Number - Review written on August 11, 2006
Rating: 2 out of 5
5 customers found this review helpful, 5 did not.
I heard "Heart of Mine" in the closing credits for the movie Runaway Jury. After listening to the album, I found that was really the only tune I liked. Peter Malick is a veteran of the hard-charging James Montomery Band (who I have seen tear up stages of Northeast blues clubs), which is why the sleepiness of most of these pieces mystifies me. You could argue that he is going for a "relaxed" feel, to which I would repsond he succeeds all too well. Norah Jones can sing, and sing well- no argument there, but these songs are not great. The lyrics I found to be a little too clever, like some music student's term paper. For most of the album I felt like everyone was trying way too hard to do something deep and meaningful. Having said all this, "Heart of Mine" is an excellent record, and might even be worth the price of the CD. Of course, to get the one good track, you could try downloading it for a dollar from itunes or your favorite MP3 site.
A Great, Different Norah Jones - Review written on May 14, 2005
Rating: 4 out of 5
10 customers found this review helpful.
Like many people, I heard Norah Jones for the first time on her remarkable album "Come Away With Me." I was immediately captivated by her smoky, sultry voice. Once I got tired of that album (which, I might add, took a long time), I bought "Feels Like Home," which I liked almost as much, and which showcased a more country inspired artist. Smitten by her voice on those two albums, I began investigating whether Jones had a prior musical life, and I was delighted to discover that indeed, she had. "New York City" is a wonderful album that reveals yet another side of Jones; this album is definitely more bluesy and rock infused as compared to the other two albums. And yet again, Jones does not disappoint. Her pitch, phrasing and style are unerring on this album, and I therefore strongly recommend it. The only reason I did not rate "New York City" five stars was that I felt slightly cheated; there are only seven tracks, and two of the tracks are the same song, arranged differently. However, having said that, there are three or four gems on the album that justify its purchase.
Okayish!!!! - Review written on April 25, 2005
Rating: 3 out of 5
6 customers found this review helpful, 3 did not.
Once purchasing this CD, I had to come to grips with the fact that these tracks were completed before "Come Away With Me". Another thing, I had to come to grips with was this was Malick's album, with Jones as the featured vocalist. That being said, after listening to the CD, I was disappointed.
Norah's voice and blues doesn't really mix. The flirtation with jazz and country, suits her better, as her last two albums demonstrated. She was all over the place vocally here, but grant it, she was an unknown at the time. Personally, I think she sounds better doing what she does now.
Musically the album is one point, sad to say that Norah's voice does nothing for the band, as a whole. I can say there were two songs that I like, "Heart of Mine" and the title track "New York City", great songs, but falls short of what she's done afterwards.
If I had to do it over again, this would be a CD, where I would burn a couple of tracks off of, if my buddy had it. I'd midly reccomend purchasing this one.
Beautifully Diseased - Review written on February 18, 2005
Rating: 4 out of 5
4 customers found this review helpful.
"New York City" is an interesting collection. It's certainly not a "Norah Jones" set nor is it really a "blues" set, but it is an interesting blend. My favorite track is "Deceptively Yours" that is probably the most blues-oriented track. Norah's vocals on this assert a boldness that are reflected in the lyric, "I saw a black cloud, I didn't hear a sound, only the shell on the ground, there was a scream somewhere & in the thick night air I put the pedal down as the sirens wailed & I sat alone & prayed." Malick's guitar bleeds soulfully on this wonderful track. "Heart of Mine," penned by Bob Dylan and found on his 1981 "Shot of Love" set, is a wistful rememberance that Norah warms with an excellent vocal, "Heart of mine, be still; You can play with fire, but you'll get the bill." "New York City" is a pleasant piece with a meager melody and Malick's languid guitar. This is a good set that isn't purely blues nor purely Norah Jones, but is certainly a delightful listening experience. Enjoy!
Not the whole album - Review written on May 31, 2004
Rating: 5 out of 5
10 customers found this review helpful, 1 did not.
I can't give it a bad review as these are good songs well performed but this is only a subset of Peter Malick's 'Chance and Circumstance', an album that is so infectious it is almost never off my car stereo.
If you're only interested in the Norah Jones songs then fine, this is the one for you but for me 'Chance and Circumstance' is such a beautifully crafted work that anything less would feel like walking out halfway through the show.
Other people can review the musical style, I just wanted to let folks know.
NYC is a Disappointment - Review written on March 08, 2004
Rating: 1 out of 5
8 customers found this review helpful, 20 did not.
I borrowed this CD from my library in the hopes that since Norah Jones was featured on it, I would enjoy this album immensely.
I never imagined I'd listen to an entire recording with Norah Jones' voice and dislike it. Fans of Norah Jones' Come Away With Me probably wouldn't like this CD. I suppose a die-hard blues fan would like it, but I don't like the blues, therefore, this CD was a HUGE letdown for me. I liked New York City, but the entire album was enough of a disappointment for me to return to my library and forget about buying for myself. I would recommend Norah Jones' sophomore album before I would EVER recommend New York City.
P.S. This album really does not accurately capture the emotions of New York City. Really, it doesn't.
Struck Breathless - Review written on March 04, 2004
Rating: 5 out of 5
46 customers found this review helpful, 3 did not.
Norah Jones, stunningly beautiful, blues infused voice, and Peter Malick and his group have made a beautiful CD. It remains a mystery to me why "New York City" written by Peter and sung by Norah has not become a big hit. The glorious words sung by Norah are enchanting, and for everyone who has had a love affair with New York, you must hear this. Every time I visit New York I will remember this tune.
Peter Malick spent a lot of time in New York City listening to music, and he especially loved a little club called The Living Room. Here he found Norah Jones singing "Since I Fell For You", and he instantly knew that he had found a singer of his tunes. Norah agreed to sing some his music, and they played a couple of gigs in and around New York City. They ended up in a club on a lake in New Hampshire without much enthusiasm from the audience, but they entertained themselves, and decided to make a CD.
This CD is delicious. I found it by looking for Norah Jones new CD. I am so glad, I found it. Sam Maghett's "All Your Love" and "Heart of Mine" by Bob Dylan are stand-outs. Couldn't be better if sung by the maestros themselves. The favorite is , of course, "New York City".
"We were full of the stuff that every dream rested
As if floating on a lumpy pillow sky
Caught up in the whole illusion
That dreams never pass us by."
This is a little known CD and a real find. For you Norah Jones fans, a must buy. Peter Malick is a joy. A fabulous CD that is full of love found and love lost. prisrob
Unbelievable! - Review written on February 25, 2004
Rating: 5 out of 5
3 customers found this review helpful, 3 did not.
The album in general: Wow!
The song "Heart of Mine," specifically: Stunning!
The Emergence of Norah Jones - Review written on February 22, 2004
Rating: 5 out of 5
3 customers found this review helpful, 1 did not.
The emergence of Norah Jones on the American music scene breathes life and hope into this culture that has for the most part, been void of decency, real talent, modesty, natural beauty, and breathtaking vocal abilities that remind us how precious, sweet, angelic, and wonderful music really is.
Ms. Jones is an extraordinary breath of fresh air with her gifted voice and her clean, fresh, crisp, respectful, and charming appearance. Her stage presence and unassuming attitude are rare in an industry run amuck with ungrateful miscreants, malcontents, thugs, hoodlums, and "in-your-face" no talented, overpaid singer "wannabes."
She is truly a rare jewel in a sea of cubic zirconium. We pray she progresses well and watches her career very carefully to avoid burnout and mismanagement.
Ms. Jones is a true American icon, idol, and gift of God; may He keep her safe and well.
The Rev. James Walter Clifton
A must have for Norah Jones fans... - Review written on February 12, 2004
Rating: 4 out of 5
5 customers found this review helpful, 1 did not.
I was in the bathroom of this quaint little fish market with a converted restaurant when I first heard Norah's voice. I remember standing around in that humid little red bathroom through almost 3 tracks (not exactly good protocol on a date) totally enraptured by the the "not quite raspy, not quite silk" quality of her voice, the seductive cadence in her rythm, and delicious instramental accompaniments.
I was an immediate fan and bought her CD the next day. Norah singlehandedly branded my entire summer of 2002 as "romantic" with her first major work.
I was really excited, but mostly confused when this CD surfaced. It's release was not on my radar like "Feels Like Home" was. But of course I bought it, took it home, and devoured it. I remember thinking almost with every song "this is good, but missing something". Well, as I later learned, this CD was recorded before norah was NORAH. It was recorded when she was 21 and trying to make a name for herself. There's no Handsome Band (which I believe contribute greatly to the overall quality of her work), and it lacks the polish of "Come Away With Me".
But I really enjoyed.
Of course, her new CD just came out, and it's really fantastic. If I had to choose between both albums though, I'd choose "Feels Like Home" over this one. However, I don't have to choose, and, being a fan, there's allot to appreciate about this CD (I'd buy it just to have "Heart of Mine"; my favorite track on this album).
Hope this was helpful. Enjoy...