Amazon.com Customer Reviews
Best Indie Album of 2003? - Review written on June 12, 2006
Rating: 5 out of 5
2 customers found this review helpful.
There are those bands that you get addicted to for days at a time, sometimes weeks, if you're really lucky soemtimes months, but when you hear the Shins for tfe first time you wonder if you'll ever anything as good as them again. Chutes Too Narrow, The Shins second major release album, THIRD overall (first was under the name Flake Music, not the Shins), delivers an overall fantastic album and sure you can pinpoint one or two songs and that's how it is with cathcy bands like them but really it's the whole album that does it.
It was undeniably difficult to top such a fantastic album as Oh, Inverted World, but they took what they learned about releasing a major album and made each song on this album catchy, meaningful, and somewhat poppy (Sub-Pop is accurate in this sense). Saint Simon is maybe the best song on the album, but no where close to by a longshot. Everysingle song, from Kissing the Lipless to Gone for Good, has it's own unique mood but in the end you get a sense of being a little closer to complete. It's hard to describe what the Shins bring ino words, but that's why they write such great music.
The Shins are one of the few basement-recording-indie bands that have made it to big screen pictures and while New Slang is their most famous and best song written that doesn't mean the other's aren't right their with it. It's okay if you understand all their songs, they don't write direct lyrics like most bands. Worth noting, Kissing the Lipless and Turn a Square are two songs that don't recieve enough credit anywhere. Their new album is coming out this year, and if you love great music or anything that makes you understand this is worth buying.
it's real good stuff - Review written on March 15, 2006
Rating: 5 out of 5
1 customer found this review helpful.
i don't have anything witty or pre-fabricated like many of the reviews i've read on amazon, but, i can recommend the shins especially the "chutes" album. You'll find yourself humming and enjoying the melodies of a lot of these songs, or liking the catchy harmonies, or the "jangle" of the guitar might be to your liking. Whoever is writing the songs is extremely talented and witty. I grew up listening to Elvis Costello, Bowie, Petty, Cars, B52s, Clash, Blondie and 80s new-wave: if you are now in your mid-late 40s I guarantee you will enjoy the shins.
Warning: these songs will stick in your head! - Review written on March 04, 2006
Rating: 5 out of 5
1 customer found this review helpful.
I read about this band in a couple of different magazines, and I loved the CD the first couple of times I heard it. (I listen to a CD twice before I have an opinion on it.) I hear lots of influences with each song, and some remind me of other bands. Rather than list them, I'll leave it open to others to figure out.
There are ten great songs with catchy hooks and thought-provoking lyrics (the last song does drag a bit, but it's a minor flaw on an otherwise brilliant album). Yes, the album is short, but this is what the "repeat all" function is for! I listen to this CD often, but now the songs have become stuck in my head (see title)!
This is one CD that you MUST own! There aren't too many albums that anyone can listen to from start to finish, but this is one of them.
I put this on my new MP3 player, and I will never delete it!
Unbelievable! - Review written on December 22, 2005
Rating: 5 out of 5
1 customer found this review helpful.
Chutes Too Narrow is a must for any Indie enthusiast...and for anyone who loves good music! Definitely one of the most innovative albums I've heard. Kinda reminds me of early early Who and Kinks and early 80's new wave with a modern Indie sound. Most songs on Chutes Too Narrow are themed around acoustic guitar, altho, not like you would think....drums, bass, electric guitars and keys (mostly electric rhodes piano and organ) and the occasional violin or harmonica, fill in very nicely giving the music a very rich and rounded-out sound.
The album incorporates an abundant selection of slow and fast songs which, as a whole, flows very well. James Mercer, a very dynamic lead vocalist and the band's primary songwriter, is all up and down the musical scale....along with provocitive lyrics and melodic backup vocals makes the album enjoyable to listen to.
Even the packaging is creative...if you take out the inner sleeve (of the CD), you'll see that the front cover is actually a composite image of some of the other pages in the booklet - very clever.
I have to admit...I really didn't care for The Shins when I first hear them...but one day, something clicked...and now they're among my favorites!!
Highly recommended
Songs too narrow - Review written on December 15, 2005
Rating: 4 out of 5
2 customers found this review helpful.
I heard a lot of critical acclaim for the Shins, so I decided to check them out. While I didn't hear their first album, I can still see that Chutes Too Narrow is pretty enjoyable.
I'll also say that the Shins seem to be another band whose style has a more "classic" feel -- in this case, some of the songs are not unlike what we heard in the `80s. They kind of sound like a combination of Tears For Fears and the Cure, and they use this style to deliver nice stuff like "Turn a Square", "Kissing the Lipless", and "Fighting In a Sack".
One thing I noticed, though, is something I mentioned in the review title. A couple of songs are too short -- not that they aren't good, but you can tell they're building up to something but then the songs just end (see "Young Pilgrims" and "Gone For Good"). I also didn't like "Mine's Not a High Horse" as much as the rest of the songs. But Chutes Too Narrow is still ideal for having a knee-slappin' -- I mean, a SHIN-slappin' good time.
Anthony Rupert
A Creative, Beautiful, Poetic, Rockin' masterpiece! - Review written on November 02, 2005
Rating: 5 out of 5
3 customers found this review helpful.
This album is on my list of top ten albums ever. Basically every song on this album is worth listening to many times. I can't describe what The Shins unique sound is like, or who they resemble. But who cares? The first time I listened to I was hooked, which is unusual for me, because it usually takes me awhile to like a band. The more I listened, the more I loved it. Though the lyrics are sometimes a little strange, there are many poetic lines. Especially in track 7, "Pink Bullets". The coolest line is, "Since then it's been a book you read in reverse/You understand less as the pages turn/With movies so crass and awkwardly cast/Even I could be the star". I just love that. I personally think the best tracks are "Kissing the Lipless" and "Mine's Not A High Horse". "Lipless" is just a good rockin' song great to listen to in the car. And "High Horse" has this wonderful transcendant sound. I highly reccomend this album to anyone, no matter what kind of genre they're into. It fits into so many catorgories.
Dare You Disagree With Padme? - Review written on October 31, 2005
Rating: 4 out of 5
2 customers found this review helpful.
An acoustic driven album from the New Mexico quartet, Chutes Too Narrow sees The Shins maturing to a full on experience. As opposed to the sociopathic delivery and ultimate misrepresentation of false emotions and hypothetical situations by groups like The Darkness, Jet, and The Kings Of Leon, James Mercer has more invested in his lyrics. Just as catchy and easy to listen to, it sounds like more work went into this production specifically the careful studio touches and craftsmanship in each track. No doubt they're stuck in the post-Beatles sixties, but they manage to create a sound that's their own, even more so than the like minds of Apples In Stereo, while others seem content in merely changing a few chords of selected rock classics and calling them influences instead of the inspiration, creative force, and original sources they really are. Ah, the slowly dissolving difference between influence and plagiarism ... welcome to the Xerox Generation, ladies and gentleman. Sure, their lyrics may never have been put together in that particular order before but, as any true music aficionado will tell you, it wasn't just the lyrics Robert Plant sang that made him great but how he sang them and The Shins have that, lets call it, soul. They're no fly-by-night fad but a band invested in themselves regardless of us throwing joints and knickers at them, although I'm sure they appreciate it. They'll be here long after Jet and Justin Hawkins have been Posh-ed into retirement to live out their days swimming in their piles of ill-got cash and appearing on "Thought They Were Dead" television specials. Even if you don't like The Shins' psychedelic revival, happy, floaty with a touch of melancholy music, you have to respect the effort.
In a much different direction than "Oh, Inverted World", but easily as good - Review written on October 23, 2005
Rating: 5 out of 5
This album is just as good as "Oh, Inverted World" in almost every way, though it does have a problem or two. It has a strange theme throughout of starting songs with percussive guitar clicks.
1. Kissing the Lipless- a fantastic opening song. James Mercer's distinctive vocals wail away in a lament about about a "friendship scarred".
2. Mine's Not A High Horse- not one of the absolute best on this album, but it grows on you after a while.
3. So Says I- my personal favorite song on this album and from the Shins altogether. Definitely the most energetic Shins song out there. The small falsetto singing part following the first and third choruses just adds so much flare to the song.
4. Young Pilgrims- the most instantly ear-catching song on this whole CD. Its a beautiful acoustic piece with a very unique mood. This was the song that made me fall in love with the Shins.
5. Saint Simon- second best song on this album, behind only So Says I. The bridge on this song with the dueling violins is one of most beautiful pieces of music I have ever heard.
6. Fighting In A Sack- fast-paced almost punkish song. Not one of my favorites, but certainly worth listening to.
7. Pink Bullets- An incredible song, slow and sad, but with extremely catchy guitar and keyboard lines. The harmonica solo on this track is absolutely amazing.
8. Turn A Square- this song is almost bluesy, but then the chorus comes in with the familiar infectious Shins keyboard line.
9. Gone For Good- Almost highway country-ish, with its acoustic slow chords and electric slide guitar over it. James Mercer is certainly experimenting with different sounds and this song shows it. Great song.
10. Those To Come- the biggest problem on this album I think. They tried to end it with a slow, sad song, but they tried to hard. It doesn't sound real, but rather forcibly depressing. It's still an OK song though. I can NOT wait for the next Shins album.
Chutes Too Narrow - Review written on October 23, 2005
Rating: 5 out of 5
3 customers found this review helpful.
After purchasing Oh, Inverted World and thoroughly basking in its brilliance, I considered myself satisfied. So I waited a fair while before buying Chutes Too Narrow. Having finally bought it, I played it literally seven times all the way through in two days, and it rarely leaves my player now. Granted, it's a short record, only a slightly over a half an hour, but each listen provides a new way to hear the song and, in turn, a new way to enjoy it.
Chutes Too Narrow presents a large bound musically from Inverted World. Though nothing will ever strip the often heart-breaking naivety and always smile-inducing, eccentric melodies from their debut album, Chutes takes a slightly more restrained, starkly honest look at songs in raw form reined in but still at times hard to swallow--in a good way.
Without ever having heard the album, upon hearing the beginning strains of Kissing the Lipless I found myself grinning foolishly out my window without truly knowing what was making me so happy. The Shins have a way of making me feel as though I've known their songs my whole life, I've only been waiting to hear them. They fit so perfectly into life and all its bittersweet loveliness that it's shocking.
James Mercer's voice has also grown in strength. He really knows now just where to bring a certain tone to the song to hit you right in the heart. Take the gentle, almost inaudible questioning in his voice as he sings, "Will you remember my reply when your high horse dies?" in Mine's not a High Horse, or the right-at-ya frankness as he opens Saint Simon with the lyrics, "After all these implements and texts designed by intellects we're vexed to find evidently there's still so much that hides."
I won't even try to list specific favorites, because every time I go to do that I end up listing all of the songs. However, there is one song on this album that always reaches out and grabs me above all the others, and that's Pink Bullets. Something about its swinging gait, the nostalgic, mesmerizing harmonica solo by Mercer, and his voice, plaintive, mellow, and harsh at the same time, as he sings, "Over the ramparts you tossed the scent of your skin and some foreign flowers, tied to a brick, sweet as a song, the years have been short but the days were long."