Amazon.com Customer Reviews
Norah diminished - Review written on December 21, 2005
Rating: 4 out of 5
4 customers found this review helpful, 1 did not.
I am not sure if it is insecurity, or simply being sweet to the members of her band, or a strong willed manager, but Norah has absolutely lost my appeal to her live shows and DVD's, as she seems to now be a sidekick to her band. We want Norah, not all of the noise that drowns out her beautiful, rich soulful voice - it is so sad, but many musicians seem to succumb to that temptation. For instance, I was so grateful seeing James Taylor send his band away at some point during a concert and and simply sit there on the stage and play his guitar solo - it was absolutely spine tingling. I hope that some day Norah will regain her rightful position, and put the rest of the band where they need to be, which is in support of her, as opposed to some type of unneccessary substitute for her. Please give us Norah back so that we can hear her and her piano, and turn the rest of the band down !
A disservice to her voice! - Review written on February 14, 2005
Rating: 2 out of 5
9 customers found this review helpful, 3 did not.
Norah Jones has the most profound voice in music (I will NOT call it Jazz after hearing this DVD) since Joe Cocker (just saw his Woodstock performance-awesome) and Josh Grohban.
In this DVD, and I'm echoing many of the other reviews, there were so many problems with the quality of the sound. Yeah, her voice was STILL powerful and smooth, but the listener could not here the band and much of the richness of the songs were completely lost. The drums yes, sounded like congos, simply awful! This is one reason I don't call it Jazz as this drummer should have been using brushes. The use of drumsticks reek of 'pop' music. Additionally, the songs were over almost as soon as they started with little to no improvisation. That is not Jazz, either.
The Video showed her to upclose (the glitter on her face or whatever was not pretty and her nervousness was obvious. There were so many things wrong that the DVD did a disservice to her voice.
I got this DVD to compare to Diana Kralls two DVD's (Live in Paris and Live at the Montreal Jazz festival). These were TOP QUALITY productions and her backing musicians, well, are probably the BEST (John Clayton-Bass; Anthony Wilson; electric and Jeff Hamilton; drums) in the world.
Norah Jones' voice, however, is one of a kind and she should settle for nothing less than Diana Krall's backing musicians. I would love to see Norah singing along with Diana's group (plus Diana). This would serve Norah and us better.
Good Music, Good Musicians, good natural sound engineering - Review written on April 26, 2004
Rating: 4 out of 5
14 customers found this review helpful, 2 did not.
I'm going to make this one short. This DVD is very very very intense. It is incredible that Norah and her band are able to execute so agressively at such a low stage volume. It blows me away. The film is okay and it's fun to watch, but I am very captivated by the ability and talent of the group to deliver such intensity at subtle levels. I wish more groups in the popular music arena would be able to deliver such stellar results. The engineering is pretty damn good, and even though the songs are 'quiet' and 'subtle', i recommend that you crank the hell outta this DVD and listen to the subtle nuisiances. The upright bass is captured nicely. The drums are killer as well, I'm a fan of the sound they captured. Good job guys! Not to mention, I enjoy the way Norah has a knack for her slinky timing. I would die to hear more keyboardist have the ability to 'slide' in time the way she does. Kudos Norah! You have won my applause. Your talent makes me sick, but in a good way. I don't want to step out on a limb, but I think the timing and execution of the band as an ensemble is pretty stellar... maybe for Norah it is genetic to have an aptitude for a good internal clock, having a dad who is a sick tabla performer. Her drummer is very expressive as well, he uses some mallets and his brush work is creative and I think the engineering of this DVD does it capturing his style and technique justice... Hell, the whole band is damn good and I am glad i picked this one up. (...). Like I said crank this DVD up and let it roar, you will learn a lot about intensity and how it is possible to play quiet and intense. It would be a great learning tool for younger musicians and if i was still teaching music, I would probably use this as a reference. All I can say is this is one intense group and getting to see them up close and observe them utilize thier instruments is pretty damn cool.
Let me iterate again... Even though this ensemble might not appear to have the testicular fortitiude of a group such as Korn (i know its like comparing apples and oranges he he)... I would argue and suggest that those not usually atune to 'quiter' music take note and realize that this performance is actually more intense than the majority of groups in popular music. Maybe it has something to do with the BlueNote connection... i dunno...
just my two cents, since everyone else has great comments...
Outstanding Concert Experience - Review written on March 14, 2004
Rating: 5 out of 5
10 customers found this review helpful, 1 did not.
Beautiful vocals meet beautiful instrumentals for a night at the House of Blues! What more could you want? Many of the live versions on this DVD are cleaner than the album versions. The sound quality is outstanding and the video is, of course, DVD-crisp. The songs which are not on the album are exceptional. Bessie Smith and Tennesee Waltz (the Encore) are worth the price alone!
P.S. For all the reviewers who are talking about Ms. Jones sweating....it's not sweat! It's sparkly stage makeup. I know this because my sister was a ballet dancer and still wears the stuff....
Delightful show. - Review written on February 23, 2004
Rating: 5 out of 5
16 customers found this review helpful, 1 did not.
Definitely Norah Jones is a first class singer and a very good proof of her talent is this amazing DVD.
This show was captured in New Orleans few months before she won 8 Grammys with her debut album, the Multi-platinum, #1 "Come away with me".
The show starts with "Cold, cold heart" and from there you go through a wonderful experience all the way to "Don't know why", the song that closeses the show.
The atmosphiere in this show is very simple but intense, don't imagine a show like Cher's with lots of lights, change of custumes and all that. This was taken at the House of Blues in New Orleans but it's really amazing. Norah's music if you don't know it very well is soft but delightful, you can listen to her for hours, days, months...all your life and never get tired and if you know her music or have one or both of her cds, this is a must have.
You'll find here almost all her "Come away with me" repertory and some unknown songs. You'll also get the change to see her "Come away with me" video as a special feature and the encored "Tennessee waltz".
I recommend the songs "Cold, cold heart", "Nightingale", "Seven years", "Feelin' the same way", "Come away with me", "Lonestar" and "Don't know why".
You won't be sorry with this DVD.
Nice Video Poor Audio - Review written on February 22, 2004
Rating: 3 out of 5
7 customers found this review helpful, 3 did not.
I want to start this with a disclaimer - I am a big Norah Jones fan. I love Come Away With Me and enjoy Feels Like Home, but that's another review. I agree with just about everything positive that's been said about the video portion of this DVD, especially the lingering close ups on the instrumentalists and of course Ms. Jones. As for her performace, well, it's been said before - live performing isn't her strong suit.
I want to make the point, in contrast to others it seems, that the audio on this DVD is terrible. No, it's not like experiencing a good live session either. The mix is very poor on most tracks. Typically the drums are far too loud and the acoustic guitar is nearly lost, although some cuts are better than others.
The worst, however, is the recording of Norah's vocals (not the vocal performance itself). Easily the worst job of capturing a vocal I've ever heard. She sounds like she's standing 5 feet away from the mike in an empty, echoing auditorium ill-suited for sound. This is probably not so much the mix as it is miking that seems to be capturing at least as much reflecting sound as direct but I'm just a listener, not an audio engineer. For two very different examples of good quality miking and mix of live performances try James Taylor's Live at the Beacon Theatre or Roy Orbison's Black and White Night.
This must explain why the DVD is so cheap. For Jones fans, in spite of the poor job on the audio portion of this dvd it's probably still worth the purchase.
INTIMATE NORAH - Review written on February 08, 2004
Rating: 5 out of 5
4 customers found this review helpful, 1 did not.
A wonderful DVD capturing Norah's gorgoeus and effortless voice, simple yet elegant band. The camera angles capture her talent on key boards, both a standard Steinway grand and moody Wurlitzer organ.
My only demerit is for Norah's unsteady and nervous stage presence which is understandable and almost cute, considering her age and meteoric rise to international stardom.
Excellent performance - Review written on November 03, 2003
Rating: 4 out of 5
2 customers found this review helpful, 2 did not.
I really enjoyed this DVD. I have Norah's album and think she is a talented singer, but, based on some live performance downloads from her web site, I prefer the way she sings live. The album songs are more slickly produced but she is SO laid back; live she loosens up a little. Some reviews have compared her to Diana Krall but personally, I would much rather listen to Norah. DK is an excellent musician and performer, but her style seems to be more for the jazz purist, which I am not. In addition, she is rather cold and steely in here singing. Norah, by comparison has a warmth that I really love and her lack of stage banter seems to suggest that her show is about music. Had I come for banter, I would have sought out a comedy show. This early in her career, it's hard to tell whether she will be able to sustain this level of excellence, but I hope she does. I also like her band, which had a minimalist touch that is perfect for her light, breezy, eclectic style. I cringe at the thought that whe would adopt slick gowns and string sections as some reviewers seem to suggest. It's been a number of years since I was so enthusiastic about a new singer.
Some fine tunes from a fine singer - Review written on September 21, 2003
Rating: 4 out of 5
6 customers found this review helpful, 14 did not.
I purchased this DVD without ever having heard Norah Jones, or at least I thought I hadn't. After playing it, however, I did recognize two of her hits. I bought it because of the genre and because I was hoping she would be similar to Diana Krall, which is one of my favorites.
The two artists are similar in many respects, the most obvious being that they are both vocalists, pianists, and have a similar style.
I do like this DVD. Norah Jones is a great talent. But she's not yet up to par with Krall. Compared to Diana Krall's "Live in Paris" concert DVD, Jones's lacks polish and class.
Although her music is fine, the overal performance seems almost like a practice session. Primarily, her accompanyists are not nearly up to par with her singing ability. The drums sounded like a cheap toy set. And, compared to Krall's full orchestral accompaniment, Norah Jones's accompaniment was a tad sparse.
Krall's sleek black dress, suit-clad musicians, and polished style contrasts sharply to Jones's casual attire, garage-band musicians, and relaxed demeanor. Their respective pianos are metaphors for their shows. Both are Steinways, but Krall's is brilliantly polished and reflective while Jones's is dull.
Not having a large number of accompanying musicians, it is not surprising that the Norah Jones DVD's 5.1 surround sound does not have enough separation. It is basically in stereo, with the surround speakers being relegated to applause from the audience.
Still, Jones is an excellent pianist with a great Blues quality to her voice. I did enjoy the DVD as I'm sure all Norah Jones fans will. Though not as polished as Diana Krall, the concert was still entertaining.
Easy listening; smooth artistry; excellent show - Review written on August 05, 2003
Rating: 5 out of 5
4 customers found this review helpful, 2 did not.
That Norah Jones has one of the most soothing voices and easy-to-listen-to song repertoires is far and away the major selling point of her music. "Live in New Orleans" delivers a nice compilation of smooth tunes in an intimate setting (House of Blues) that is likely to impress anyone who checks out this recording.
I'm not sure how to classify Norah's music, but her voice is the most enchanting to come along since Sade landed in the early 1980's. Naturally, the focus of this DVD, both musically and visually, is on Norah herself, but in no way does the rest of her Very Handsome Band get left in the shadows (literally or figuratively). The camera images tend to fade in and out from close-ups of Norah's face, to a couple measures of a bass/guitar/drum lick, to Norah's hands on the keyboards, and back again. It's very simple, but not necessarily monotonous. I applaud producer/director Jim Gabour's efforts in leaving out any glitzy or contrived visual aspects: the performance is as easy to watch as it is to listen to.
Save for four songs plus the encore, the musical selection (15 songs total) is entirely from the "Come Away With Me" album. I liked every track of this DVD; thus I'd rate this a very strong performance overall. As with all great live concerts, parts of many songs contained different twists or improvisations, and I loved the way Norah eased into "Don't Know Why" without everyone noticing right away. Oddly enough, I don't think we're seeing the entire show (run time is 67 minutes). You can tell this by some of the edits, but the big giveaway is after "Lonestar," when Norah remarks to the band's tour manager and backing vocalist, Daru Oda, that she'll be back on stage later in the show. Unfortunately, that's the last we see of Daru.
Concerning the band, the guys stay pretty tight, even without the preponderance of interaction that is so common in jazz performances. My only criticism (a minor one) of the sound quality is that the percussion crashed a little too loudly on a couple numbers. Perhaps this had to do with the way Andrew Borger's drum kit was miked, but I'll make an allowance for the character of the venue. Still, you might have to turn down your sub-woofer a tad to avoid an occasionally boomin' bass drum.
CD "extras": 1) one encore song, which could have been placed in-line with the other tunes in order to avoid having to access it by flipping through menus; 2) video of "Come Away With Me," which is well done.
Excellent - Review written on June 05, 2003
Rating: 5 out of 5
5 customers found this review helpful, 1 did not.
I was not sure if I'd like jazz music. I'm not really into jazz. However this DVD is great. The 5.1 sound mix is terrific and the small quaint club setting really makes you feel like you are there.
Norah has a very nice voice.
One reviewer commented on how sweaty Norah was during the concert. I find all that perspiration makes her look really sexy.
very good, but i'm not sure about the replay value - Review written on June 05, 2003
Rating: 4 out of 5
34 customers found this review helpful, 6 did not.
This is the sort of DVD that you really only need to listen to in order to enjoy it. This is not a knock on it, but just a comment on the style of music and the presentation of the concert footage. The feature is an hour long performance by Norah at the House of Blues in New Orleans. She has a backing back, but the show is pretty much just Norah at the piano. She does some cover songs as well as stuff from her album "Come Away With Me". She also mentions that some songs are only on her previous EP, which she expects that most people do not have.
If you have listened to her album, you have a pretty good idea what to expect from this DVD. She doesn't talk much between songs, usually only to introduce the next song or to say who she is covering on a song. This may be a good thing if she doesn't have anything interesting to say, it would only detract from the performance. This is a fairly low key performance, but her playing is amazing. Norah Jones is a very gifted musician with a beautiful voice.
The only comment I have in closing is that while I really enjoyed listening (and watching) to this DVD, I don't think it is something that I would watch very often. I'm glad that I rented it, but it isn't worth purchasing (for me).
Approachable, comfortable performance - Review written on May 30, 2003
Rating: 5 out of 5
4 customers found this review helpful, 1 did not.
I was surprised to read a previous reviewer's comments that this DVD didn't give us much of an idea of Nora's personality... that is exactly one of the reasons I enjoy this DVD. This DVD pleasantly presents Nora with her humble, laid-back style.
I too have the John Mayer DVD and I agree it displays an artist with more humor and a quirky personality, but I think that is because that is John Mayer's personality - he's funnier and quirkier. Likewise, the Nora Jones DVD displays HER personality as a relaxed, honest and ego-free performer. I wouldn't knock Nora for not being John!
Anyway, this DVD is fairly true to the album, but not totally. While Nora doesn't take many piano solos, vocally, she does take more liberties in the live performance. Also, it is interesting to see the variety of methods the drummer uses to provide rhythm for the various cuts.
The concert has an intimate, friendly tone. The musicianship is fairly good and the sound and presentation production is good as well.
This was a good buy for me.
Only REAL Musicians and Audiophiles Need Apply - Review written on March 25, 2003
Rating: 5 out of 5
18 customers found this review helpful, 4 did not.
I am so glad I bought this DVD. After reading some of the reviews, I wasn't sure. It just proves that you can't trust everyone's opinions here at Amazon!
If you are an audiophile, this DVD is of exceptional quality. The audio mix is stellar! The room ambiance as well as the instrumental mix are so well done. It really pulls you in and makes you feel like you are there experiencing it live. For a Dolby Digital 5.1 mix (vs. DTS) I was really surprised at how great it sounded. The vocals and instruments are in perfect proportion to one another. And unlike some other recent live recordings put out on DVD (ahem..Dixie Chicks) this recording is NOT overly bright or harsh. For the audio alone, this disc is worth the price of admission. Great demo DVD (if you have a sweet audio setup).
Next if you are a true musician you will appreciate the wonderful display of talent. Norah is not just a great singer. She plays the piano with such great style and technique, always matching her vocal cues and the rest of the band. The drummer must be some awesome "studio cat" because he oozes technique as well...playing with mallets, brushes, sticks and even his hands. He was so cool to watch. Every nuance of his playing coming through and perfectly accenting the rest of the music. Skilled and tasteful musicianship.
If you are into the 80's big hair and pyrotechnics rock show...and lack any real musical taste, you won't appreciate this DVD. Norah doesn't put on a "show" by jumping around or pumping up the crowd. She really doesn't even talk much. Personally, that's O.K. with me...as long as the music speaks for itself. In this case, it DOES...and how.
Only REAL Musicians and Audiophiles Need Apply.
Norah's shining moment - Review written on March 21, 2003
Rating: 4 out of 5
18 customers found this review helpful, 3 did not.
Norah Jones may not have the keyboard proficiency of Dianna Krall nor the polished vocal range of Sade but she has what the others don't have - eight Grammys. Whether the Grammy was a one-hit-wonder glitch or a confirmation of her talents is a moot issue.
What is obvious in this New Orleans performance is her artistry -- no embellishments, just simplicity and grace. Norah exudes femininity which is sometimes hard to convey in a jazz setting; her voice, oftentimes soulful and melancholic, comes across intimately in Lonestar, Bessie Smith, The Painter Song and the surprise encore Tennessee Waltz. Her now familiar "Don't Know Why" and "Come Away with Me", performed live, are enough reasons for having this DVD.
In the musical world where artistic integrity are often compromised, it is nice to have for more than a 'brief shining moment' a lone star like Norah Jones.