Amazon.com Customer Reviews
Not nearly as good as they should be - Review written on April 21, 2008
Rating: 1 out of 5
4 customers found this review helpful.
I was initially very pleased, the first time I saw this line of pans. They had all the features I was looking for, and at a reasonable price (as opposed to the price gouging of All-Clad, Calphalon, etc...). But then I bought one and carefully made my inspection of it. To make a long story short, I went through FOUR of these skillets, and absolutely none of them made the grade. I'm not talking about being nitpicky about a tiny scratch somewhere. Two of the four pans had moderate corrosion pitting and black spots on the handles. One of them had damaged metal around the lip of the pan. And worst of all - three out of four of them were CRACKED at the weld joints at the base of the handle, on one of the two forks where they meet the plate that's riveted to the pan itself. I don't know about you, but a good price isn't worth the possibility of third degree burns down the entire front of my body on the day those weld joints give way completely.
These Cuisinart pans fall under the category of things that *look* really good for the price, but whose actual quality is far less than it appears. Maybe some of you have gotten very lucky in the batch of pans you received - and if I had gotten one bad pan, I could have chalked it up to a lemon - after all, everyone has them from time to time. But FOUR pans being bad? With THREE of them having a serious defect in the structural integrity? Sorry - they lost me as a customer of their entire brand, and I would caution others not to be blinded by the shiny looks of a poorly made pan.
You get what you pay for - Review written on November 16, 2007
Rating: 2 out of 5
1 customer found this review helpful, 1 did not.
I bought a 6-piece set that included this skillet. The price was unbeatable. I think I paid 59.95 for the entire set. Given that Cuisinart is a well-known brand, I didn't even hesitate to press that "Buy" button.
However, you really get what you pay for. The skillet conducts heat fairly well, but the problem that I have with this skillet is cleaning. The 2nd time I used this skillet, some burnt residue got on the surface and no matter what I do, I just couldn't get it off the skillet. I haven't tried metal scrub yet but if I have to try that hard to get the residue off the skillet, this might not be the skillet that I want to keep in my kitchen.
A good skillet will keep you company in your kitchen for a long time. In my opinion, it is a good idea to get a good one like Gourmet Standard Professional series or if you are willing to pay, an All-Clad. Even a Calphalon off-brand: Kitchen Essential is easier to keep clean. I have a Kitchen Essential skillet that I've used for 7 years and the surface is still spotless. Although there are some scratches, but no burnt mark ever got on it that required me to do any extra effort to clean it off. I just purchased a Gourmet Standard skillet and it is a really great pan. I've used it several times and it still looks like new.
After owning a cuisinart skillet myself, I wouldn't recommend it to anyone even though it seems like an incredible deal. It really isn't.
Not Good - Review written on October 16, 2007
Rating: 2 out of 5
I've used stainless steel pans for years, and this is not good. I bought this exclusively to cook eggs and omelets and it was a huge disappointment. Even on medium to low temperatures, it burns around the edges and always leaves residual marks from the food. I polished it every single time I used it, with a non-metal pad, but I NEVER ONCE was able to flip an egg. The egg just stuck to the pan like it was bonded with epoxy. After about 3 weeks I just threw it in the garbage (literally), since it did not do what I bought it for - to cook eggs.
That said, the pan itself is (was) build pretty solid, with good rivets, and a nice weigh and feel, (which is why I gave it 2 stars), but even if used for cooking less temperamental food than eggs, I would not recommend it. It has a funky heat distribution that easily burns and discolors around the sides, and leaves marks from the food each time of use, even at relatively low temperatures. This would have to be polished aggressively after EVERY use, or I'm sure it would quickly turn into a blackened lump of metal.