Amazon.com Customer Reviews
Touching and beautiful - Review written on August 29, 2006
Rating: 5 out of 5
3 customers found this review helpful, 1 did not.
About this movie Man Facing Southeast that people are talking about: it's a total flop. Doesn't matter if K-PAX ripped the story or not, the movie is really bad. The actors can't act, the plot always looses it's focus and have some disgusting "surprises" that ripped all the potential of the movie. This doesn't happen to Iain Softley's masterpiece K-PAX, based in the Gene Brewer book of the same name.
K-Pax is thinking man's fiction/drama/suspense. It's a wonderful story about someone that calls himself "Prot" (Kevin Spacey, fantastic as usual) that claims to be an alien, and a psychiatrist (Jeff Bridges) that tries to convince Prot he's not an alien. However, the more they talk the more convincing Prot is about where does he comes from and who he is.
People who already watched this movie will notice that it's full of metaphors and hidden messages behind Prot's speech. But the real message behind this movie is love, hope and faith. It have a background in science fiction, but it's a movie about human beings. I can't talk more about it, because it would ruin all the surprises that other people are about to find in this beautiful piece of art.
Cast, direction, scenarios, script, everything on this movie is top notch and will make you really want to watch this all over again, many times.
If you are a human, if you have a heart, if you have a soul, or if you are just curious, take this product. And now excuse me, I have a beam of light to catch.
A movie for dreamers - Review written on August 24, 2006
Rating: 4 out of 5
1 customer found this review helpful.
K-Pax is a movie that is made to be enjoyed. From it's pre-credit sequence, there is a dream-like essence that floats about, sparkling and shining throughout the film. It is hard to watch if you try to rationalise the story, or judge the reality of it too much, but if you let your imagination come along for the ride, it is a truly lovely picture.
The acting is spot-on, from Kevin Spacey's touching performance as Prot, to Jeff Bridges reliably solid Dr Powell, and the wonderful support players all come together to make this movie what it is.
You should watch K-Pax if you like gentle, humorous dramas (there's only one scene where it all gets a bit nasty). You should own K-Pax if you like Kevin Spacey or Jeff Bridges, and you need to ocassionally escape the harshness of reality. You should avoid K-Pax if you like films to imitate life, and enjoy sitting at home making lists of why movies don't make sense.
It's one of the favourites in my collection, and I wish there were more films like it.
The Three Tasks - Review written on June 17, 2006
Rating: 5 out of 5
2 customers found this review helpful.
This is not a full review but a comment on one aspect of the film that struck me. Prot gives one of the patients three tasks that will "cure" him if he succeeds. 1. Find the bluebird of happiness. 2. Experience death. This one's complicated, but the patient strangles another almost to death which, in turn, awakens this "victim" to our powerlessness over mortality. 3. Stay here and be prepared for anything (referencing the hospital and a warning about expecting the unknown, be it tragic or joyful.)
These are the three tasks Prot himself is subjected to/embarks on. His marriage and family were his bluebird. The murder he encounters and the one he commits are #2. #3 he becomes a numbed but non-delusional wheelchair bound Robert again...he stays and may well be prepared for anything.
Yet Ellen, I think that was her name, is unaccounted for. This adds the twist of uncertainty about where conventional reality and our individual perceptions of reality may co-exist even if seemingly in conflict. Was Prot happier recreating his reality whereby, as an alien from a planet where there weren't even any families to lose, he could not have lost his family in the first place, annd therefore will not have to go through the painful stages leading to acceptance?
Extraordinary minds and hearts build elaborate castles of denial to avoid pain.
This is a very moving film.
"Early Stages of Evolution - Future Uncertain" - Review written on March 26, 2006
Rating: 4 out of 5
PROT's above description of our Earth seems to ring quite true, as do many of the off-beat utterances of this curiously serene being.
While the movie entertains, while it warms the heart repeatedly, K-PAX also does not fail to awaken a little sensibility in us to question the chaotic, almost frantic, oft-times silly ways of our times.
The Christ and Buddha PROT speaks of were men, yet were not 'of this earth' in any psychological sense, any more than was Kevin Spacey's role character. That's what makes people's interactions with PROT so interesting... the 'sane' people of the world cannot process the experience of meeting a being who is guilelessly free of all ordinary human conditioning. So they react to this Unknown taking refuge in small, ingrained habits they feel safe acting within. They need to feel they 'know what to do' even when reality shows them a real stumper, regardless of efficacy and the impact on others.
In contrast to these frantic-looking 'sane' normal people out in the world, the troubled 'sick' people at the hospital where PROT stays appear (with PROT's presence) to be nearer to the possibility of seeing themselves and reality. Perhaps this is precisely because they are unable to take 'normality' for granted. I think this perhaps conveniently idealizes mental illness for story's sake, and yet there may be a little something to it because yes, saints have been called 'crazy.' Yet a saint is something more than a man in how he truly lives.
There is a rock in the snowball here, a serious theme hidden in a seriously entertaining film even youths can watch. Enjoy it!
And to think I thought this was going to be a comedy... - Review written on February 28, 2006
Rating: 4 out of 5
3 customers found this review helpful, 1 did not.
This film was not what I expected, not better or worse, just not what I expected. The film revolves around Prot (Spacey) as he's being treated at a psyciatric facility. You see Prot claims he's from the planet K-PAX and that he's travled here using light rays and is studying our planet for a report he will submit when he gets home on July 27th. The question that follows is is he from K-PAX or is he just crazy? Jeff Bridges plays the doctor trying to get to the bottom of it. The problem is that as crazy as it all seems, Prot really knows what he's talking about. He knows of solar systems just being discovered and planets not yet discovered and he speaks with such confidence that he's almost convincing. Prot also, while staying at the hospital, has helped many of the patients recover from their flaws sort-a-speak. Herein lies the problem. The tagline on the front of the DVD says "it will keep you guessing till the very end" and the problem with that is that after you turn of the movie you're still guessing. Is he from K-PAX, is he from Earth? I still have no clue. There are many clues pointing the fact that he's just crazy, screwed up by a very tramatic event, but there is another very big clue that could suggest otherwise. I had a theory shortly after the end of the movie, but I squashed that. Just, while you watch, remember that he offers to take someone back to K-PAX with him. Now watch the movie and see if you can figure out just what the hell is going on. Maybe I should read the book... Regardless, the acting on all fronts was superb, especially Spacey...It's no wonder he's won TWO oscars. Spacey is one of the only actors who can command a role like he does, and I don't know, there's just something about this man but whenever he cries in a film I'm brought to tears. The standout scene in this film is the first time he goes under hypnosis...he commands two charactors and without skipping abeat goes in and out of each of them, without crossing his performance over into the other. It's amazing. All and all, this was a decent film and I would recomend it. I just wish that the ending were alittle more determinable. I'd like to know whether or not I was right in my assumption. Was he from K-PAX? I quess you'll have to judge for yourself...and then again, maybe that was the point entirely...
An Intelligent film for intelligent people - Review written on July 24, 2005
Rating: 4 out of 5
9 customers found this review helpful, 1 did not.
The spacamin "Prott" appears out of nowhere in a crowded NY transit stop. His claims of extraterrestial origin land him in the hospital. The Psychiatrist (Jeff Bridges), becomes enchanted with "Prott". Convinced "Prott" is delusional, the psychatrist sets out to show Prott, that his claims are impossible. However, Prott wins every challenge given him. He even awes astro-physicists with his knowledge of a distant galaxy, that only been recently discovered, and had not been picked by the media yet. In fact, Prott demonstrates to THEM that the orbit they've hypothesized is in error. Prott makes the necessary changes; changes that give KPAX's true orbit; and with a lock and key specificity, that is, PERFECT. The patients belive Prott, and he leaves them with more hope thaey've had since the day they were committed. He leaves in the middle of the night, from his room/cell, and continues to amaze at how much he changed every person he encounterd. Of course, the psychiatrist remains skeptical of Protts claim of his distant origin. Very good film. Thought provoking, and at times reminiscent of "One Who Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest". NOTE: Psychiatrists do not take their patients home with them to meet his family, and find out where they live. Splitting-hairs I geuss.
Is he or isn't he? All up to you... - Review written on May 28, 2005
Rating: 4 out of 5
3 customers found this review helpful.
Is he really an alien, or just crazy human? Or is he a crazy alien? Or is he in fact both an alien AND a crazy human? As you watch this movie, the questions begin to pile up and you WILL, as Bill Diehl states "keep guessing right to the end" (and even after that if you ask me). This is a great movie, both in its originality and the way it's filmed. Kevin Spacey and Jeff Bridges give us great and convincing performances. This DVD as a product is above avarage. Deleted scenes, featurettes, audio commentaries and alternate endings are always welcome. So what's wrong? Well, the commentary is kinda boring. I wish Iain softley would comment on the acual scenes, giving you more insight on the story, instead of just rambling on about everyting else around the movie like production specs and what Jeff Bridges said to him before shooting. Things like that. Also, (although just my personal opinion) the alternate ending is a bit of a disappointment. If you hope for an ending that will give that Answer with cap-A, you can stop hoping. The DELETED SCENES however, will give some more juicy tidbits to base your opinion on.) Over all, this DVD is well worth its price but only if you really, really love this movie - like I do.
K-PAX - Review written on April 13, 2005
Rating: 2 out of 5
5 customers found this review helpful, 1 did not.
Prot (Kevin Spacey) appears at a New York train station one afternoon, seemingly on a beam of light. The police quickly take him into custody and he is soon transferred to a mental hospital in Manhattan. Dr. Claudia Villers (Alfre Woodard), the head of the institute, assigns Dr. Mark Powell (Jeff Bridges) to help Prot. Powell is the type of psychiatrist who cares, really cares, about his patients, so much so that his family life is strained. Prot is the type of patient that instantly wins over all of the other patients and helps them makes changes in their lives. Powell realizes that there he has a limited amount of time to help Prot figure out who he really is, a mystery that will consume his every waking moment.
""K-PAX" is a great movie, just what our country needs right now". No wait, that is "Serendipity". ""K-PAX" is a patriotic flag-waver, just what our country needs right now". No, wait, that is "The Last Castle". As the current crop of movies get buried under excessive critic hyperbole relating their relative strengths or merits to the events of September 11, 2001, it is refreshing to see a film like "K-PAX" come along. "K-PAX" is a completely ordinary film. Directed by Iain Softley, the film is filled with so many psychiatrist-patient clichés that it almost becomes good for that reason alone.
Kevin Spacey, one of the more gifted actors working today, does a good job with the role. For the first two acts, Spacey is so into the character of Prot, that we begin to believe that he could possibly be an alien. He wears sunglasses throughout most of the film, because Prot is sensitive to the bright light on Earth. This allows Spacey to use his mouth and facial expressions to build subtleties into the character. It makes the character less showy and more believable. For this reason alone, the film earns a lot more respect from me. As the sessions with Powell continue and Powell decides to regress Prot, the Showier-This-Is-My-Shot-At-An-Oscar elements begin to shine through. First of all, I never once believed that Powell had actually hypnotized Prot. It seemed far too easy and far too quick and then when he does, Spacey has a difficult time making this believable. To the credit of Spacey and the filmmakers, they don't take the easy road with this, providing some interest, but these sequences just stop the film dead and remove the viewer from the world it has spent so long trying to create.
Bridges, as always, is good, but he really doesn't have a lot to work with. His character is concerned. He wants to help Prot because he is concerned. He want to have Prot visit his home because he is concerned. He flies to .... because he is concerned. It doesn't allow a lot of growth for his character. Powell's final moments, the hang-your-tears-out-to-dry moment, is also extremely predictable.
Amazingly, the filmmakers have managed to populate the ward of the hospital with every single character actor who has ever appeared in a film set in a mental ward. Either as a patient or a doctor, they are here. It is a virtual encyclopedia of both actors and clichés. Conchata Ferrell plays Betty McAllister, the big, gruff assistant in the ward. Alfre Woodard plays the head of the ward. Ajay Naidu plays an assistant in the ward. Peter Gerety (you may recognize him from the TV series "Homicide") plays Sal, the former doorman who thinks everyone stinks, literally. Celia Weston (you may remember her as the actress who replaced Polly Holliday on the television series "Alice") plays a patient who thinks she is a matriarch. I am just amazed at the originality on display in "K-PAX".
Despite all of my criticisms, I am still recommending "K-PAX", barely. The first two thirds of Kevin Spacey's performance earn the film enough points to help me disregard the rest of the thoroughly predictable film. After all, "K-PAX" IS just what America needs right now, a thoroughly benign peace of fluff.
Spacey and Bridges Quite a 1-2 Acting Punch! - Review written on March 21, 2005
Rating: 5 out of 5
1 customer found this review helpful.
This was a great film. It made one wonder about life in other worlds and how modern psychiatry may deal with such a scenario. According to a recent amazon review, "Dr. Mark Powell, the psychiatrist played by Jeff Bridges, is convinced that Prot is "a convincing delusional," but his cynicism turns to open-minded fascination as Prot's case reveals a combination of otherworldly insight and all-too-human trauma, prompting an earthbound explanation for Prot's allegedly alien origins. This picture allows Spacey to create a provocative and humorously eccentric enigma, while Bridges superbly conveys his character's compassionate empathy."
I agree that the movie sets up a series of very interesting contrasts, the alien's world and ours, our perception of mental health vs. normal and his, and the way we deal with someone different than ourselves. I'm not sure if this world is ready for someone like "prot." Good science fiction and good acting.
A Unique and Delightful Film - Review written on January 21, 2005
Rating: 5 out of 5
4 customers found this review helpful.
If you've read any of my other reviews, you know that Kevin Spacey (Usual Suspects, American Beauty) is my favorite actor in the world. And I must say that Jeff Bridges (the Fisher King, the Big Lebowski) is one of the most underrated actors in Hollywood. These two heavyweights are brilliant in this fantastic tale about Prot (Spacey), a highly advanced visitor from a neighboring star system. At least that is what he appears to be for most of the film... advanced enough to travel on a beam of light, to know the precise mathematical equations to describe the orbit of his planet, and to make significant progress helping his fellow mental patients, and his psychiatrist (Bridges) in a very short time. But what happens when Bridges begins to learn more and more about Prot's past ?
As soon as I saw K-PAX, I knew it was a must-own for my collection. The hard part was deciding whether to classify it under science fiction or drama. Although I decided on sci-fi, it's really more of a touching human drama, with warmth and caring, and just enough humor to make repeat viewing a joy.
Anyone who says the plot is weak is really missing the point. If you believe in the possibility of advanced extraterrestrial life, then the plot of this film is not weak or far fetched at all. Many of the ideas are quite unique and insightful, and this film is one of the most uplifting in my DVD collection. All it takes is a little imagination !
One Of The Best Movies I've Seen In A Long Time - Review written on January 05, 2005
Rating: 5 out of 5
6 customers found this review helpful.
My wife and I just saw K-Pax last night and both of us loved it!
We actually were so mesmerised by this film that we stayed up much later than we normally would during a week night. Typically we'd just stop the film and pick up the follwing evening, not with this movie, we had to see the whole thing. In fact one of the first things we talked about this morning was the film and that is quite rare.
If you are looking for an action picture, this isn't it, if you're looking for a fun light hearted movie, you are in the wrong place, if you're looking for mindless entertainment, search elsewhere.
The reason I'm saying these things is because a lot of previous reviewers that gave this movie a negative review seemed to base it on expectations that had nothing to do with this movie. Perhaps they thought "Oh, an Alien movie, maybe it'll be like "Men In Black" or something along those lines, who knows?
While I don't want to do a review on other reviewers I would hate for someone to miss out on the opportunity for seeing a movie that has tremendous depth, that certainly has it's share of lighter moments as well, but this movie will make you think and if thinking isn't enjoyable for you then you won't enjoy this movie.
This movie leaves many things unresolved and ends with a sense of mystery, a lot like the way many things in life are. Centered around "Prot" who is from the planet "K-Pax" he is sent to a place for people with Mental illness. Keven Spacey is incredible in his portrayal of this "K-Paxian" and Jeff Bridges is equally brilliant in the role of his Doctor.
Throughout the movie you will be as challenged as the Doctor in trying to come to a conclusion about whether "Prot" is just a nut-job with a "Savant like" intelligence or whether he is in fact an Alien.
I won't go into too great detail as many others have already, plus I don't like to give much of a movie away. But this movie is deep in the way "The Green Mile" is deep. I found myself waking up last night thinking about this film and that almost never happens. In fact, "The Green Mile" was the last film that had this effect on me.
There are some highly disturbing moments in this and I would not recommend this to viewers under 14 or 15 years old. So that being said, this is not in my opinion a family film.
For those old enough and with the right mindset this is a film I would HIGHLY recommend!
Mork and Mindy - Review written on November 27, 2004
Rating: 4 out of 5
2 customers found this review helpful, 1 did not.
Much like Mork left Ork to come to earth for the second time and visit Mindy McConnell, Prot leaves K-Pax to come to earth for the second time to visit Dr. Brewer, a psychiatrist who thinks that Prot is a crazy human but it becomes increasingly likely that he's the real deal.
But there is a mystery to Prot's background, a mystery Dr. Brewer is determined to unravel and the way he does so, with the minimal of clues (always the best in mysteries) is quite clever and interesting.
Kevin Spacey and Jeff Bridges (forever THE DUDE whether he likes it or not) are brilliant as alien and earthling. The whole movie is very beautifully made with wonderful use of rainbow colors, great editing, fun supporting characters and a delightful score by Edward Shearmur. Seriously, if you're stressed then this is THE movie to calm you down.
Movies about aliens fascinated by strange earth customs are always enjoyable. Spacey might not be running around wild like the manic Robin Williams, quite the opposite actually, but his grace and dignity are far more than most humans match up to.
K-Pax attempts some kind of ambiguity in the ending but if you hang around to the very end of the credits you'll realize that Dr. Brewer is still curious of Prot's origin's despite what his Robert Porter evidence is telling him.
The DVD is in 2.35:1 anamorphic widescreen with Dolby/DTS 5.1 sound and loads of interesting extras.