Amazon.com Customer Reviews
Home Decorating Eye Candy at a Substantial Cost - Review written on November 26, 2007
Rating: 3 out of 5
9 customers found this review helpful.
Elle Decor is a nice magazine that concentrates its efforts on home improvement and overall enjoyment of life. This magazine believes in giving one's residence a certain unique charm and it has words of advice for redecorating every room of the home. In one issue, the reader may find some articles about bedroom furniture. Another article may focus on adding new towels and a matching shower curtain to the bathroom. The goal of these and other articles like them is to make your home look unique and interesting.
Many magazines offer a surprise or two and one of the big surprises with Elle Decor is that it isn't entirely about home decorating. There are other articles in each issue: Articles about food (often complete with recipes), travel, and other topics can be found in every copy of Elle Decor. But one thing I have noticed is that the travel articles still manage to combine some elements of home decorating. These articles talk about the travel destination, but they also point out the decor inside certain places of lodging, the artistic nature of certain landmarks, etc.
I like the design ideas presented in this magazine and I agree that many of them are eye- catching and interesting. However, I don't think I will be implementing very many of the changes suggested by Elle Décor due to the high price of the merchandise. The featured articles usually don't mention the price of the items on display, but the departments often do, and many of the dollar signs are jaw- dropping, to say the least. It is common, for example, to find things like a small bathroom cabinet selling for more than one thousand dollars; a kitchen range selling for more than three thousand dollars; etc . As much as I like the idea of home improvement, I don't think I am willing to spend money at these levels. There are a few less expensive items, but you have to search for them and they are usually nothing more than small objects, like a centerpiece for a table, a napkin holder, a pitcher, etc.
One other fact that will bother some readers is the number of advertisements in each issue. More than half the pages of each issue are covered with ads and it is common to find two dozen or more pages of ads at the opening of each issue. This is excessive saturation, and it gets in the way of enjoying the reading.
Overall, however, I still like Elle Decor and I will continue to enjoy the issues that arrive at my front door each month. There are some great ideas for home decorating in this magazine and some unique gift ideas as well. I won't likely implement many of these changes due to the cost, but I like the way things look and I like the presentation and writing enough to give Elle Decor a recommendation.
Style Ideas Galore - Review written on December 18, 2005
Rating: 5 out of 5
9 customers found this review helpful.
I love this magazine. I read many home magazines and pick up a few of the foreign editions of Elle Decor (the Italian one is great but the British one is zippy but very down-market), but the American one is my favorite. It's an amazing source book and is packed with ideas. I love decorating, and I have a modern city apartment and a traditional cottage at the shore, and there's something to catch my eye in every issue. I'm constantly tearing out pages with ideas for future projects. In fact, I often buy a second copy so I have one to save if I've ripped out a lot.
Some magazines are stuck in a design rut, the same old thing every month, but Elle Decor seems continually fresh. They show a really wide range of design styles, always in great taste, and lots of things to shop for without seeming too cataloguey. And I like that they feature some houses in far-away places (although they could look a bit harder to find some more good homes here in the south), and that they have a good travel feature in every issue.
There are some fun pages near the front that show new products and stores, and a great "top ten" shopping guide, plus articles on what you should know about in the world of art and antiques (I've learned a great deal from these, if you care about design, you should save them) but it's the interiors that truly inspire me-they might have a fancy, over-the-top house in the wine country followed by a tiny studio apartment in Paris. But even the grand places don't seem stuffy, it's all very personal and inviting, maybe because they photograph a lot of the homeowners and usually talk about how they live there and why.
If you like stylish people and places, and care about great decorating, architecture and design, this is the magzine for you.
over 95% ads, pricey furniture - Review written on April 28, 2004
Rating: 2 out of 5
6 customers found this review helpful, 4 did not.
The first Elle Decor that I got in the mail I sat down to flip through it page by page. After going through the entire thing, I had to go back to the table of contents to specifically look for any articles. Yes, there are articles, but you have to do some hunting, and even when you find the page number, the article is usually just a small paragraph in the corner of a page surrounded by ads. On the plus side, the magazine is nicely bound and thicker than most house decorating magazines.
The reason I am not giving it 1 star is because there are some good decorating ideas for someone with contemporary taste. The furniture is pricey (couple thousand for a simple plastic chair, for example) but easy to emulate for the frugally-minded person. You could easily find knock-offs at your local Target. If, however, you wanted the exact piece and had the money to pay for it, you would have to travel to select places in New York or California, or get in contact with the artist him/herself. That is just not practical for most homeowners.
The decorating style is very modern, with simple clean lines, minimal distractions, and 1 of 2 color schemes - either bright colors (think Todd Oldham of Target) or black/silver. Occasionally they will feature eclectic styles, such as log benches from one artist in CA. But for the most part, highly contemporary. The magazine is best geared towards professional interior decorators with elite clients.
Do not think twice about not buying this magazine - Review written on August 03, 2003
Rating: 1 out of 5
16 customers found this review helpful, 5 did not.
I mainly subscribed to this magazine for the good overall reviews I read here. I subscribed to it less than a year ago and I wanted to write this review from the first edition I received. The magazine does not contain any valuable information about decorating or anything else for that matter. The magazine is loaded with ads (that is related to decorating or not). For the August/2003 there are 89 pages of ads out of the 166 pages, which is more than half of the magazine!! (Excluding pages that contain half page of ad).
Do not waist your money on this magazine!