Amazon.com Customer Reviews
Good, but focuses too much on the later years - Review written on October 04, 2007
Rating: 4 out of 5
1 customer found this review helpful.
Elton's 2-disc greatest hits package is a good place to start if you're getting into Elton John, even though it falls short in some areas.
The Good: A great deal of Elton's best hits from the 70s and 80s are here: "Tiny Dancer," "Daniel," "Saturday Night's Alright For Fighting," "I Don't Want To Go On With You Like That," etc. The first disc and half of the second is toe-tappingly listenable.
The Bad: Around the middle of the second disc is where this collection loses steam. It focuses too much on Elton's adult contemporary period, where frankly, his music declined in quality.
What I would have changed: I would have ditched the songs from The Lion King, Aida, and "This Train Don't Stop Here Anymore," for starters. In their place I would have included 70s standards like "Take Me To The Pilot," "We All Fall In Love Sometimes," and "I Think I'm Going To Kill Myself."
Overall, a good collection that could have been stellar if not for the second half of disc 2.
Elton's Best at a Single Package - Review written on August 10, 2007
Rating: 5 out of 5
In the sea of existing Elton's "Greatest Hits" compilations, this 2-CD set is the one that better resumes his career's highlights in my opinion (surely not considering the post-2002 releases). No need to wonder which one of all those available today to choose from.
Personally, I found this release more complete than the others since includes not only his most meaningful hits (although I know a "Greatest Hits" doesn't necessarily include his best songs), but also a booklet which tells interesting facts about his career, including a bunch of photographs from his early years. By the content found both on the CDs and the booklet, one might think - not without a reason - that this release was made targeting specially the US market.
My favorites are: "Your Song", "Crocodile Rock", "Goodbye Yellow Brick Road", "Philadelphia Freedom", "Little Jeannie", "Sad Songs" and "Circle of Life". Today, this compilation costs a little more than the price of a single CD, contains 34 songs, so it's an interesting purchase from the cost-benefit standpoint. It's worth the investment.
you can tell everybody these are your songs - Review written on July 19, 2007
Rating: 5 out of 5
elton john's greatest hits 1970-2002 has 34 classic songs,plus a limited-edition bonus disc with 4 more songs. your song starts things off nicely.i also like the songs tiny dancer(later redone by tim mcgraw.),crocidile rock,island girl,sorry seems to be the hardest word, don't go breaking my heart,i'm still standing,sad dongs(say so much), can you feel the love tonight,iwant love,and this train doesn't stop here anymore.the bonus disc is good too. thanks for the music elton. ed wilson
Dollars and (common) cents. - Review written on June 12, 2007
Rating: 5 out of 5
1 customer found this review helpful.
I'm going to rate this CD based on a $1 per song cost to total cost for the entire CD (Apple and Rhapsody charge $1 per song).
Elton John is good. This CD is even better. I was disappointed to learn that he didn't write a lick of his own lyrics (Bernie Taupin did). Elton John just wrote the music. And I guess we need to hear great music before we'll listen to the lyrics of a song.
Amazon is currently selling the CD for $15. The good news is that there is $20 worth of great music on it. This CD is worth ever dollar and them some. The essential Elton John songs are: Disc 1 - Tracks 1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,11,12,13,14,15 & 16 (and I guess Candle In The Wind). Disc 2 - Tracks 1,3,4,5 & 6.
Hope this helps.
Darium June 2007
A wonderful collection of music - Review written on December 29, 2006
Rating: 5 out of 5
2 customers found this review helpful.
Before purchasing this album, I had had Elton John in the back of my mind for a few years as an artist with several songs that I liked. The number of songs by Elton that I liked grew (to include "Mona Lisas," "I Guess That's Why...," "Sad Songs," "Your Song," and others), and I decided that a greatest hits CD would be the best place to start.
Somewhat suprisingly, upon first listening to disc 1, I found that I enjoyed every song, even ones I had never heard before. Disc 2 begins with 6 amazing songs, including "I'm Still Standing" and "Little Jeannie." As the second disc continues, one can notice a change in the style of music. There are more ballad-y songs, and they sound more alike. The collection closes with 2 wonderful songs from Elton's latest album (at the time this was released), "I Want Love" and "This Train Don't Stop There Anymore." The booklet included in the package is HUGE and contains a biograpy, pictures, and discography of Elton's career.
Some of my new favorites are:
Levon
Honky Cat
Daniel
Someone Saved My Life Tonight
Sorry Seems to be the Hardest Word
Little Jeannie
I'm Still Standing
I Don't Wanna Go on with You Like That
This Train Don't Stop There Anymore
I love that I can listen to both CD's without skipping any songs (most of the time), but more than that I love that this album was a wonderful introduction to Elton John's music. I have since bought several other Elton albums and enjoyed them as well.
As a note, I would like to mention that as other reviewers have complained, there are many notable ommissions of Elton's greatest songs from these "greatest hits." However, I assume the purpose of releasing this collection was to sell more albums, and gain publicity, not to encompass all of his best work (is that even possible?). With that in mind, I think this release perfectly does just that.
>>>This is a perfect place to start an Elton John collection (I assure you, you will buy more from him after this).
5 stars *****