Amazon.com Customer Reviews
Solid - Review written on September 07, 2008
Rating: 2 out of 5
I found that the film was not at all as I expected- a staid Merchant-Ivory type production mixed with a hint of Masterpiece Theater. This was both good and bad. On the positive side is the very dramatic structure of the film, being told from Mozart's inferior rival's, Antonio Salieri's (F. Murray Abraham), point of view. On the down side is the over the top performance by Tom Hulce, as Mozart, especially with that pointlessly distracting guffaw. Also, as the DVD delineates which scenes were altered, extended, or added in toto, it becomes obvious that director Milos Forman's original cut was the superior, as none of the added scenes adds palpably to the thrust of the film. Yes, I liked the added scene of Mozart's wife, Constanze (Elizabeth Berridge), getting naked to try to sexually please Salieri, to advance her husband's career, for Berridge was certainly a major hotty with the body back then, but, despite my prurient interest, the scene is pointless.... Unfortunately, in either version, this is nowhere near a great film. It's a fun, solid romp, but the American accents and slang that infiltrate Eighteenth Century Viennese society are just too much, as is Hulce as Mozart. No, a staid portrayal of the man would have been dull, but a genius as idiot savant, or a step above, is not worthy of this dramatic treatment, either. That it only heightens Salieri's frustration is dramatically defensible, but since the whole notion of Salieri's envy and hatred of Mozart is a historical fiction, there really was no reason to go so over the top in the first place.
The rest of the cast does fairly well. Berridge as the clueless wife, Jeffrey Jones, as Emperor Joseph, is a dolt with a heart, who doesn't understand how to run his own life, much less a nation....All in all, I would recommend the film, but as a light diversion, not a serious inquiry in to art nor the artistic mindset. That film has yet to be made.
An Unforgettable Classic - Review written on August 20, 2008
Rating: 5 out of 5
Amadeus is a gripping drama based on the wonderful play by Peter Shaffer. This is an unforgettable film which explores the universal theme of mediocrity in the face of greatness. Antonio Salieri, (F. Murry Abraham), is court composer in the court of Emperor Charles of Vienna. He is loved by everyone and esteemed because of his musical creations. However, a new genius comes on the scene: Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart, (Tom Hulse). Salieri immediately recognizes the genius of this extraordinary man, although he is appalled by his brusque and uncouth manner. Salieri's admiration is surpassed by his consuming jealousy, and he will stop at nothing to destroy his rival. This movie brings into question the fairness of divine justice. Why are some people blessed with greatness while others have to struggle? Salieri angrily questions God as he prepares to exact revenge upon Him through abusing His instrument. "You say God is not mocked. I say: Man is not mocked!"
This film is truly exceptional! All of the performers portray their characters excellently, particularly Abraham, who won a well-deserved Oscar. The movie contains beautifully rendered examples of Mozart's work, and portrays the characters as human beings. We can all relate to these characters: Salieri, the mediocre and overlooked individual brings to mind all of our failures. Abraham makes us empathize with this despicable individual. Hulce makes us feel empathy for Mozart because we witness his fall from greatness into despair as a result of his poverty.
Please give this film a chance.
Enjoy the show but remember its fiction! - Review written on June 20, 2008
Rating: 4 out of 5
This is an enjoyable if grossly historically distorted account of Mozart and those around him. Please remember not to believe it! The pianist Moscheles who visited Salieri during his last illness in 1825 related that he tearfully protested his innocence to the last! Here we are continuing to believe in this nonsense.
Mozart's letters show him capable of vulgarites, but nonetheless reflects a generally sober and ambitious young man at times too full of himself, and prone to imaginary enemies, like his dad Leopold. Thus rivals are unnecessarily maligned e.g Clementi, and in this movie, Salieri. Contrary to the portrayal, Salieri was a prodigy, if not on such dimensions as Mozart. He was extremely successful as a composer, not quite overshadowed by Mozart in the 1780's yet, and considered by Gluck to be his true heir (indeed a fair assessment). At the time of Mozart's death, both Mozart and Salieri had fallen out of favour at court, since the new emperor Leopold II had no time for them but prefered his own favourite Cimarosa. Thus indeed there was no reason for Salieri to murder Mozart! In fact during this time they actually became good friends. Only some time after Mozart's death did senseless and malicious rumours start to spread about Salieri's poisoning him. It resulted in Pushkin's play, Dargomizshky's opera, and now in our times Amadeus. In fact Mozart died of overwork because he was trying to make enough money to support his expensive lifestyle (he detested being looked down upon by the nobility). What do we know of the true Salieri? He was highly respected, and Beethoven sought in out as a teacher. He was also generous towards his pupils, giving lessons to Schubert and young Liszt for free because they could not afford the fees.
Constanze did not fsir so badly. But still there were untruths, such as she abandoning him during his illness. He only fell ill after she returned from her treatment at the spa (yes she was ill, not going for fun). After his death, she proved to be an astute business woman and great custodian of his music, ensuring not only his lasting fame but also that their children were never in want. The world thought badly of her as a result of her father-in-law's and sister-in-law's relentless campaign against her.
Mozart's Middle Name was Much More Impressive - Review written on May 01, 2008
Rating: 4 out of 5
This is a great film. I missed the theatrical premiere of Amadeus in 1984 as I wrongly assumed that it was a thinly veiled documentary on the life of Mozart. AMADEUS is a beautiful film that succeeds in adding depth to the two main characters. It is not a musical documentary.
AMADEUS was derived from the 1979 play of the same name and is loosely based on the life of Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart. The film focuses on the alleged rivalry between young Mozart and the Viennese Court Composer Antonio Salieri. The story is told from the point of view of an aging Salieri. In the movie Salieri, committed to an asylum after attempting suicide, confesses Mozart's murder to a priest. In doing so Salieri recounts his association with Mozart and thus the story of Mozart's rise and fall.
In watching the film you find no hard evidence of a homicide unless murder is defined as Salieri's infrequent attempts to stifle young Mozart's career. Indeed the only assassination activity we witness is Salieri confessing to the crime. Unlike the 1830's Russian Opera, Mozart and Salieri where there is no doubt that Salieri poisoned Mozart, the closest Salieri comes to harming Mozart is his mysterious appearance in dark costume to commission an a requiem - thus playing on Mozart's guilt over his father's death - and the all-nighter perpetrated after Mozart's collapse during the operatic The Magic Flute. The bottom line is that Salieri's plots were little more than egotistical unrealized schemes and boasts of unfair divine intervention.
AMADEUS can hardly be considered biographical other than occasional inclusion of historical events. Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart was admirably portrayed Tom Hulc, who a slightly older 20th century generation will remember as freshman Larry Kroger from 1978's ANIMAL HOUSE. Hulc played the part of Mozart stressing the composer's eccentric behavior and erratic mood swings in between his moments of genius. In Mozart we discover a composer with a musical photographic memory able to commit finished great works to paper without so much as a rough draft.
Mozart was multitalented pianist and composer of operas, symphonies, and concertos. He departs Salzburg for better prospects in Vienna. Unfortunately Mozart's inability to humble or ingratiate himself before Antonio Salieri's incurs the court composer's wrath.
F. Murray Abraham won a coveted Oscar as best actor for his portrayal of Salieri. In AMADEUS Salieri is torn between his outright admiration for the gifted young composer and his jealous envy of Mozart's talent. Salieri becomes obsessed with Mozart to the point of employing spies to report back on Mozart's work. Despite Salieri's best efforts to derail or retard Mozart's popularity with Emperor Joseph II, Mozart brazenly forces his way. As it turns out Salieri is one of Mozart's biggest fans and, though he often occupies obscure and low key vantage points at Mozart's performances, attends every one religiously.
At this point in the film we sadly witness the downfall of Mozart. The composer lives in excess of his financial means. As such he is constantly fretting about his debts, yet that does not stop him from additional binge spending. Mozart disdains the usual income generating scenarios of the day, specifically earning money through the musical tutoring of wealthy pupils, to the prolific production of works and displays of his talent at non-traditional venues such as an outdoor concert. It is a great way to advertise talent, but hardly a means to pay the rent.
Mozart is unable to come to grips with his father's disapproval of his marriage and his lifestyle. He immerses himself further into guilt after the death of his father. At this point in Amadeus, by means of the housemaid-turned-spy's report to Salieri, we are treated to the first hint that Mozart is not in good health. He is reported to be guzzling medicine by day and alcohol by night. This disclosure is the first clue that Mozart's days are numbered based on natural causes, not Salieri's baseless plots. Still Salieri formulates what he thinks will be the ultimate irony in donning Mozart's father's former costume and mask and appearing anonymously at the Mozart apartment door. In doing so he evokes both Mozart's fear and guilt over his deceased father, which only adds to Wolfgang's depression. Salieri's plan is to clandestinely commission Mozart to complete a requiem. His ultimate goal is to take possession of the completed requiem, claim it as his own work, and arrange its performance at Mozart's own funeral.
Mozart however, has the last laugh in that he is persuaded by another associate to compose a lighthearted opera. He puts aside the unfinished melancholy requiem and produces a successful performance. By this time his unknown illness has itself reached its climax and Mozart is felled during the performance. Escorted home to his empty apartment, Mozart is attended to by Salieri who offers to transcribe for Mozart and help finish the requiem. Mozart's wife, who returns only moments before an exhausted Mozart dies, foils Salieri in his attempt to snatch the requiem. The film then returns to an older Salieri recounting how his own music has been largely forgotten while Mozart's works have achieved legendary status. Adding insult to injury the maestro is then wheeled down a hallway (looking more like a dungeon) housing some of the other more obvious insane inmates of the lunatic asylum.
The AMADEUS soundtrack is chock full of beautiful segments of Mozart symphonies, concertos, and operas. The majority of the movie was lensed in (what was then) Czechoslovakia to provide period realism. The environs of Prague survived the Second World War without signficant damage and many of the historic buildings required little in the way of set dressing.
Although the film is part history and half fiction, it is a great introduction to the life and times of Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart. It certainly spurred me to pursue additional research on Mozart and his music.
What ever happened to Tom Hulce? ... - Review written on February 25, 2008
Rating: 5 out of 5
2 customers found this review helpful, 1 did not.
So what can really be said about a film in a review that arrives 24 years after the film's first release?
First, I cannot believe that it's already been that long. I saw this film in a theatre in England as a boy and it was one of the highlights of my movie going youth. And yes, I'm that old ... or young. Take your pick, dear reader.
So, what did become of Tom Hulce? He was absolutely shocking in this movie as a portrayal of one of the greatest composers / humans ever to live. Well, for the record Tom Hulce, kind of decided that it must be cool to put on some weight, because that's exactly what he went and did. He also became a producer doing projects of his own liking. He was also recently in Stranger Than Fiction, but if you don't look fast you just might miss him.
Regarding the film ... a lot of viewers often come away with the belief that this is an intensely accurate story about the life of Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart, which in fact it is a story about Mozart, but it is not all that accurate. This is a movie that was based upon a stage play called "Mozart and Salieri". What it does capture though, is period set design, wardrobe and atmosphere and it does it so well that any story told within this shell could be utterly believable and engrossing.
However, all these things aside, this is an incredibly strong film to say the least and one of my all time favourites. The music is beautifully woven throughout this to carry you back to the life of a would-be madman and reckless drunkard. It's a blessing that he did not wallow in obscurity and is still esteemed as highly as he is today, for WAM, so deserves it.
If you are the type of person that prefers accurate portrayals in their bio-pic features, then you should probably see Immortal Beloved, as it is about as true of an account of that Composers life as you're going to see and is wonderfully captured by Gary Oldman.
I cant believe I didnt see this movie earlier... - Review written on January 13, 2008
Rating: 5 out of 5
I cant say I know the times I saw this movie standing there on the Blockbuster stand... but believe me when I say there were a lot. What do we know about Mozart? Well, almost any human being can tell he was a great composer, but I bet you couldn't say at least 3 songs or operas made by him...
Finally a few days ago I decided to give it a chance, well I must say that I have been missing a masterpiece for quite a long time.
The music, the actors... everything is just perfect. Tom Dulce makes a perfect interpretation of Mozart, hi laugh is just so original and so unique... showing his unique personality and the fact that as almost any genius of our history, Mozart raised some enemies and was not understood by his peers.
I really liked this movie, and if you haven't seen it, you should, I know it lasts 3 hours but they are worthy. You won't find too many notes on this movie...
If you have seen it, then buy it and see it as many times as you want...
Maybe, as happen to me, you will end up wanting to know more about Mozart, because I even got some cds and a biography to read...
Like a gift from the gods, `Amadeus' is simply heaven-sent... - Review written on January 02, 2008
Rating: 5 out of 5
1 customer found this review helpful.
`Amadeus' was one of the most refreshing spectacles I have had the pleasure of witnessing in quite some time. I was personally blown away with what I was presented with and have thus concluded `Amadeus' to be one of the best motion pictures in the history of motion pictures. If you have not had the privilege of witnessing this powerful film then please, stop everything you are doing and track this movie down, order it straight from this webpage if you need to, but please watch this movie immediately. I don't think I've been this passionate about a single film since I saw `The Godfather' for the first time. Truly all the praise and admiration that has been associated with this masterclass of a film is well warranted. `Amadeus' is astounding from start to finish, a truly mesmerizing and utterly flawless production. Milos Forman is God; seriously.
As the film opens we meet Antonio Salieri, a man gone crazy. He is living in an asylum and claims to have murdered Mozart. In the opening scenes of the film Salieri is met by a priest who wants to hear his story and so Salieri proceeds to tell him how it was that he came to meet, grow to despise and eventually kill Mozart.
Antonio Salieri was an aspiring composer who has reached a certain level of fame as court composer to Emperor Joseph II but he has achieved nothing in comparison to the fame and recognition as the esteemed Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart. Salieri himself feels that Mozart's music is divine, something sent from God above (kind of the way I feel about this movie) but when he has the chance to finally meet this messenger of God he is let down. Mozart is not the noble gentlemen he had expected but instead is a pompous arrogant vile thing that sends shivers down Salieri's spine.
How could God use this disgusting man in such a beautiful and miraculous way?
It becomes apparent that the Emperor is smitten with Mozart's talent though and this bothers Salieri, not to mention others close to the Emperor. Salieri then decides that he is to make it his life goal to destroy Mozart, to strip him of his power and social standing and ruin him, yes, kill him. He concocts a plan all his own to accomplish this and sets it all in motion, waiting for the time to be right to strike and make his dreams come true.
`Amadeus', as I mentioned earlier, is perfect. I seriously cannot find a single flaw. The script is deliciously absorbing and never loses the interest of its audience. The direction is nothing short of phenomenal and the acting across the board is superb. The two leads are brilliant. F. Murray Abraham, who won the Oscar for his performance, captures the very dire frustration and conflicting emotions that drives Salieri to madness and Tom Hulce (who should have won the Oscar in my humble opinion) dominates as Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart, completely fleshing out his talent as well as the demons that choked out the flame that was his life. Elizabeth Berridge was sorely robbed of an Oscar nomination. Her portrayal of Mozart's doting wife Constanze is brilliantly crafted and expertly executed.
The only word I can use to describe this film is ecstasy; pure, unbridled ecstasy. Since seeing this film I've thought of nothing else and have a feeling that I will think of nothing else for quite a while still to come. Please, I beg of you, experience this film for yourself. You will not regret it.
Consider me entertained.
One of my Favorite Films ... and I know nothing about music - Review written on December 16, 2007
Rating: 5 out of 5
2 customers found this review helpful.
I'm a good test of the appeal of Amadeus. I know nothing about music. After I saw the film, I bought the sound track and set a couple of my radio buttons to classical stations. Through the years, I've probably watched the movie over twenty times; counting seeing it in theaters, on VCR tape, and on DVD. I prefer the theatrical release. Like novels, films need editors, and the Director's cut frequently just puts back in what should have remained on the floor.
I probably never would have watched the film even once if it didn't tell an interesting story, from an unusual perspective - at least for a movie. When an author begins a novel, he has to decide on a point of view. Not so with movies. The nature of the media usually dictates a distant omniscient POV. Amadeus is told from the single perspective of the antagonist.
Shooting an entire film as a flashback is a common Hollywood technique (for example: Saving Private Ryan (Special Limited Edition)), but Salieri doesn't bookend this story. He returns time and time again to remind us that he is narrating the film. Although not unique for film, this unusual technique allows us to see the amazing talent of Mozart, not from a distance, but as seen by through the eyes and ears of his contemporaries. (I'm talking about storytelling, not historical accuracy.)
Amadeus deserved the Academy Award for Best Picture. The acting, sound track, set design, costuming, and writing all work together in a rare demonstration that Hollywood occasionally produces art.
The Shut Mouth Society
The Shopkeeper
What BYU-I students think - Review written on December 14, 2007
Rating: 4 out of 5
AMADEUS
It is important to remember that this movie, being "based" on a real person will definitely have it's theatrical additions. Keep in mind that this film is portrayed through Salieri's (the king's royal composer) eyes.
The movie accurately shows Mozart expounding upon or making better several works that were not his. Another historical accuracy was the portrayal of Mozart as a young child performing in different courts all across the country where his fame started to spread as a young, budding composer. The great thing about this movie is that it has enough historical accuracy to be an interesting fictional drama that leads the viewer to have a desire to learn more about Mozart and his life.
We found the movie to be a bit long and questionable in parts, However, overall it was very entertaining. This movie is full of the flair and brilliance accustomed to Mozart's time. The movie had many amazing costumes and the actors did a wonderful job of presenting the story.
One might ask, why Amadeus? Why not Mozart, Wolfgang, or Wolfie (as his wife calls him)? Amadeus means God's Love. The symbolism in this is not only was this Mozart's middle name, but also a recurring theme throughout the movie.
Salieri was bitter about Mozart's talents, he wanted to be able to write wonderful music, but his was only mediocre. Salieri cursed God and said that he wouldn't believe in God anymore a few times, but kept coming back to the love of god during the course of the movie so the title Amadeus is portrayed through symbolism throughout the movie.
The movie showed Mozart playing the clavier, the piano, etc. Most of the music for the movie was Mozart's and the film showed Mozart working on his operas, namely, The marriage of Figaro.
There was a constant theme of religion and of God. Salieri, a competing composer in Mozart's time, often claimed it was God's work that he had the constant desire and urge to create beautiful music but that he had been made "mute" compared to Mozart's talent. Throughout the movie, he questioned why God would work though this crude, arrogant, inappropriate person. Just the fact that the story is based on Salieri confessing to a priest is another contributing factor to this theme.
Revenge, another theme, is portrayed as Salieri strives for a way to bring about Mozart's death The interesting thing is, throughout the movie, Salieri's work is constantly being recognized by. This is a classic example of jealousy and how a person should be content with what they have.
Don't miss it! - Review written on November 11, 2007
Rating: 5 out of 5
This is one of the greatest films ever made. Period. Well directed, well acted, great music (obviously), and a story with characters that will wrench your heart.
No, it isn't historically accurate, for the most part. The huge storyline isn't, but a lot of little details actually are. Only musicologists care about things like that, though. But the story that is presented is wonderfully evocative and enrapturing. Any fan of film would love it.
This edition is the way to go, as well. It has restored over a half hour of original footage, including Costanze's meeting with Salieri, and Mozart's endless quest to find regular employment. The commentary is insightful and worthwhile, and all the other special features are well worth the time. Buy this. Now.
Purely fictional account of Mozart's character and life - Review written on October 17, 2007
Rating: 3 out of 5
3 customers found this review not to be helpful.
This film certainly is entertaining; this film has its funny moments; this film has beautiful music and sets; however, this film's story is also purely fictional.
No, Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart was not a funny guy. Let me put it this way: while perusing a bonafide bio of Mozart, I read that an old lady once thought he was "dull." He was a rather prosaic man in person, and not at all a mad genius, and hardly a buffoon, as pictured in this film.
If anything, I've noticed a trend in which movie producers/directors, etc., all from Hollywood (no surprise there), wish to portray some of our greatest artists as debauched characters. Either this is for selling a film, or a combination of this, and jealousy. Why would you want to besmirch a great man? Because it makes you, the smaller man, look somewhat better in comparison, right?
Again, Mozart was not the same person portrayed in this film, but, if you want good entertainment, then by all means, this film is meant for that.