Amazon.com Customer Reviews
Best of the Chicago Compilations - Review written on January 02, 2008
Rating: 4 out of 5
This is the best of the Chicago comps for a couple of reasons. Mostly that the bulk of the songs are album versions, and the other is the breadth. Thirty-nine songs over two discs, covering from 1967 to 1995. Disc one will likely tickle your nostalgia bone. When the band started, they were a power force between AM and FM radio, rocking with horns on "25 or 6 to Four" and with power ballads like "Searching for So Long." Heck, they even helped to resurrect the Beach Boys by having them sing backups on "Wishing You Were Here."
But from the albums Hot Streets to Chicago 16, the band went cold. The two albums between aren't even here. When Warners/Full Moon signed the band, it seemed like the height of folly. But the band veered sharply into Adult Contemporary land with wedding ballads like "Love Me Tomorrow" and "You're The Inspiration." Suddenly, with help of super-producers like David Foster and hitmakers like Diane Warren, the band was bigger than ever. They just jettisoned the progressive rock and horns for Peter Cetera's blue-eyed soul ballads. (Who eventually bolted for a solo career.) The band continues to soldier on, making ok albums and touring with original members Robert Lamm and James Pankow.
Still, this is good stuff. Missing is "Harry Truman" (could have easily replaced "Take Me back" or "Happy Man"). Even the 80's stuff - if you check the chart positions - often topped the charts. If that is what you're looking for, "Only The Beginning" will satisfy.
"I've Been Searchin' So Long" for a Chicago best of this good! - Review written on August 11, 2007
Rating: 4 out of 5
As the author of the Jefferson Airplane book "Take Me To A Circus Tent" and a former radio disc-jockey, I am often asked to write and or discuss various music supplies and recordings from the 60's and 70's.
"The Very Best of Chicago: Only the Beginning" was released by Rhino in July of 2002 with great anticipation because it promised to be the first best of that would finally bring all the hits/radio songs together. The good news is excluding "Harry Truman" it certainly delivered on the promise but there are unique edits on "Make Me Smile", "Does Anybody Really Know What Time It Is", and "I'm A Man." If that doesn't deter you the ride to Chicago will be the most pleasant one you've had.
Opening the 39-song celebration is "Make Me Smile." A terrific choice as it symbolizes the great diversity the band offers. Mixing rock, jazz, pop, and improvisation with drummer extraordinaire Danny Seraphine the first phase of the band would give the world a plethora of hits and radio staples forever. "25 Or 6 To 4" to this day explodes from the speakers as the opening power chords are thrust upon us. "Does Anybody Really Know What Time It Is" is a lesson on how people seem to chase nothing and do it well. "Questions 67 And 68" is one of the bands finest and most underrated works. The perfect mixture of vocal and instrumentation create a gem for the ages. "Colour My World" wasn't simply a hit but commandeered many a radio station when it was riding high on the charts. The now defunct but legendary New York City radio station WXLO had a "Colour My World" weekend. The song was played several times an hour over a two day period because of the mass appeal. "Lowdown" is another song that you may not remember until you hear it on the CD player but it will soon be getting more than the occasional spin. "Saturday In The Park" is one of the best examples of words painting pictures. Especially on a warm summer day you can picture yourself walking through the park and seeing everything the tune described. The beauty that "Another Rainy Day In New York City" creates can't be described with words, your ears must be the ones to experience the wonders of the composition. The myriad of tracks also capture phase two of the band when the sound became more adult contemporary in its configuration but there was one more rocker that could make even the oldest of individual feel young again for three minutes-thirty seconds, "Old Days" is tremendous. Everything laid out in simple fashion and yet it is so profound. "Take Me Back To Chicago", "Alive Again", and "Hard To Say I'm Sorry" represent the next phase of the band. The final cut on the best of will get your attention. Chicago covers Louis Prima ("Sing, Sing, Sing") with the help of the Gypsy Kings!
The Chicago Transit Authority proudly welcomes you to the Windy City. Have a great time.
Enjoy the music and be well,
Craig Fenton
Author of the Jefferson Airplane book "Take Me To A Circus Tent"
God, I needed this! - Review written on March 28, 2007
Rating: 5 out of 5
3 customers found this review helpful.
I graduated high school in '76,so CHICAGO was a huge part of my musical formitive years.Have to admit I was somewhat of a musical snob-all about the musicianship,and CHICAGO fit the bill perfectly.So edgy,raw,and powerful.Even their ballads back then had such soul and substance.
This is the music that got me through the rough times,takes you away to a whole different place.When I saw this set on Amazon,I had to have it;and I've not been dissappointed.When I played disc 1,I got chills just like back in the day. Rhino's remastering kicks serious a--!Rich,clear and full sound.I know the few edits are kind of a pain,but hey-no biggie.Just sit back,crank up the headphones and FEEL the music. Now I know what you other hard-core fans are saying-"What about disc 2?" I've got a tip for you-when you listen to the second disc,just listen to it for what it is-not as a CHICAGO fan.It's really pretty good stuff.Besides,the 1st disc is worth the price of the whole set anyway. Those of you who are not too familiar with the group,here's what you'll get-superior musicianship,powerful horns,extraordinary guitar work(Kath),a very strong,much overlooked rythum section and wonderful vocal harmonies.A band with incredible range and versatility. What else can I say! Five stars-easy!
BIG DEAL ANOTHER GREATEST HITS COLLECTION. THERE ARE OTHER CHICAGO ALTERATIVES........... - Review written on January 07, 2007
Rating: 5 out of 5
3 customers found this review helpful, 1 did not.
You could buy all the Chicago Rhino record remasters with fine linear notes, if one or a few of your favorites are missing. I like the remastering on this Chicago collection, I hate that Rhino edited a few songs. Yeah! I know no "Harry Truman" is missing, what a mistake that was. A nice Chicago collection if you just want the hits spanning their nearly fortyone year career. The beginning of the Chicago band was the best, actually the first nine years with Terry Kath and James William Guerico producing all of the Chicago recording output, up to Chicago XI, 1977, (output from 1969 to 1977). Ironically Chicago XI would be Terry Kaths last record with Chicago before his untimely death in January 1978. Wheather you like or hate the 1980s, 1990s material, this greatest hits collection, still speaks for Chicago as a band that has lasted since its conception in 1967. I like some of the 1980s material, despite Chicago being Peter Ceteras backup band at this time. I like 2006 release Chicago XXX, which I really thought had some of the old Chicago sound despite some ballads. Chicago still has four original members in the band as of 2007. I wish the bad blood with Peter Cetera and Danny Seraphine would clear and both would rejoin Chicago, fat chance at that happening. This is a nice Rhino remastered "Chicago Greatest Hits" Remaster with a few flaws, that I remedied by getting all the Chicago Rhino Remasters.
The Very Best of Chicago Was The Beginning - Review written on July 30, 2006
Rating: 4 out of 5
2 customers found this review helpful.
In the very late 1960s and 1970s, Chicago was one of the hottest musical groups in the world. A tight horn section, Lamm's piano, Kath's bass, Cetera's vocals - the whole cast was right on the mark with their albums and single releases. Like others, I had all their albums and played them until the phono needle screamed for mercy. Then Terry Kath died and, I believe, like other major groups that have had the untimely death of a key member, the music (and group dynamics) changed so that the Old Days couldn't be put back together again. After a couple more albums, I never bought another Chicago album - until this one. It has the great old songs on it, the ones that I went off to college with, and the newer ones that I never really could get into, although many were very popular in their time. I think that's why I would recommend this album: it would satisfy the fans of the old and new Chicago sounds, the old harder edge and the newer softer edge, but also give an insight of the songs that the old and new fans might not have, opposite the time that they enjoyed listening to the group.
I like both!! - Review written on April 09, 2006
Rating: 5 out of 5
4 customers found this review helpful, 1 did not.
Only Genesis seems to divide fans even stronger between eras. I love the jazz-rock stuff from the 60's and 70's as well as the power ballads of the 80's.
As someone who thinks both versions of the band were great, even though a lot of the magic was lost when Cetera left in 1985, they still had a number of good A-sides through the rest of the decade, "Look Away" was one of their biggest ever hits, and Cetera was gone by then.
This is some of the most beautifully produced and structured music ever recorded. From the sonic beauty of "Wishing You Were Here", to the hard rock of "I'm A Man" through to encompass such bystandings as disco (Alive Again) and 80's rock (Stay The Night), Chicago are true innovators and a group that made a little something for everyone.
If you only like the jazz-rock, Rhino recently reissued "Chicago IX-Greatest Hits". If you only like the 80's power ballads, "Greatest Hits 1982-1989" is still in print (the 1981 "Greatest Hits Vol. 2" which covered the middle years of 1975-1980, including such big hits as "If You Leave Me Now", "No Tell Lover" and "Baby What A Big Surprise" is inexplicably out of print). However, to me, this collection supercedes the three previous collections into a nice, relatively inexpensive package and is definately the one to get if your horizons are open to liking both "Does Anybody Really Know What Time It Is?" and "Hard Habit To Break".
Why do we call them the 'good ol' days'?? - Review written on March 16, 2006
Rating: 2 out of 5
10 customers found this review helpful, 16 did not.
I have to admit that I feel somewhat embarrassed at having bought this two-disk set, but I guess it serves as a testimonial to advertising. Had it not been for my 10-year old son seeing the television commercials for this collection and then asking me to buy it, you can be quite sure that I never would have seen the inside of this jewel box. Besides, I already owned a slew of early Chicago albums (the first up to Chicago IX) and I had not given them much attention in the past, oh, thirty years or so. There's a reason for that. The two-disk sets that they released habitually back in the early seventies were mostly bloated affairs, full of good playing but lousy music, with the exception of the radio-friendly hits that were interspersed throughout.
I guess that it comes as no surprise, then, that this collection is also a two-CD set, but with precious little padding. Throughout the seventies, Chicago virtually defined pop radio. If you were to draw a timeline of their career, they could easily be fingered for abandoning FM for AM, thus sounding the impending death knell for progressive radio. For these and a few other reasons, these guys were never favorites of mine, so I hesitated to buy this for my son, until the discounted price reeled me in (I paid $18). For the money, this collection does a remarkable job of covering the band's hits, offering 39 songs, almost all of which were top 40 at one time or another. The question is, do you care any more than I do?
Essentially, Chicago were/are two completely different bands. The `classic' Chicago is represented on disk one, with obvious hits like "Saturday in the Park", "Feelin' Stronger Every Day", "Colour My World", "25 or 6 to 4" (whatever that means - after three decades, I still don't know - or care) and "Make Me Smile". Arranged chronologically by chart appearance, some songs survive better than others; "Lowdown" still sounds pretty cool, and the new edit of Beginnings" balances out nicely. Dated as all hell, these songs at least work well as nostalgia.
The real problem here is disk two. Some time in the late 70's, Chicago dropped their stylistic calling card and became one of the most flagrant abusers of compression in the business. By taking a mediocre melody and drenching it in studio bombast - echo, reverb, and that ridiculous cannon-shot snare drum - I can hardly tell any of these twenty songs apart. Nevertheless, somebody was buying this stuff, if chart position means anything ("Hard to Say I'm Sorry", "Hard Habit to Break", "You're the Inspiration" "Will You Still Love Me", "I Don't Wanna Live Without Your Love" and "Look Away" were all top three singles). I don't care. I still think this stuff sucks, but hey, the disk is cheap. You could buy it, bring it home, break out the old photo album, and play disk one. You can use disk two as a coaster for your cocktail. B- Tom Ryan
I miss the old Chicago - Review written on February 24, 2006
Rating: 2 out of 5
4 customers found this review helpful, 5 did not.
My friend told me that Chicago didn't really do anything good after Chicago II except the song Saturday In the Park, and I agree with him. Back before they became soft-rock icons, Chicago was tough blues-rock band, as displayed on their debut album, which featured rockers such as Introduction, Poem 58, South California Purples, Someday and I'm a Man. Chicago II lost the rock edge a bit, but still gave us rockers with 25 or 6 to 4 and the It Had Better End Soon suite. After that, they just died. Just like that. Became dull soft-rockers, churning out sleep-inducing, elevator music-ish ballads such as You're the Inspiration, If You Leave Me Now, Along Comes a Woman, Will You Still Love Me Tomorrow?, Stay the Night, What Kind of Man Would I Be and countless others. Protest this drivel! Buy Chicago's first album, back when they had some spirit and weren't just in it for the money. Flame me if you will, but Chicago has been dead for decades now.
CHIGACO "TRANSITION" AUTHORITY - Review written on December 20, 2005
Rating: 3 out of 5
3 customers found this review helpful.
CHICAGO-THE VERY BEST OF CHICAGO-ONLY THE BEGINNING: In the beginning, Chicago Transit Authority was the best and most popular horn band of the rock era, charting constantly with such peppy RNB-laced fare as 25 OR 6 TO 4, SATURDAY IN THE PARK, FEELIN' STRONGER EVERY DAY and the occasional tasty ballad (COLOUR MY WORLD). Then in the 80s, like their peers ZZ Top, Dr. Hook, and J. Geils, Chicago radically compromised their musical principles and altered their style to suit bland mainstream tastes, sacrificing credibility for mega success. Peter Cetera's easy listening croon was featured on wedding song after wedding song, while Robert Lamm's earthier, more soulful vocals and the mighty brass section took a backseat---a HARD HABIT TO BREAK indeed. In short, disc one of this definitive career spanner will put you in a step-lively mood, and the second disc will put you to sleep. Ah Chicago, how your true fans long for the OLD DAYS!...RATING: THREE TOOTS
The greatest hits, and then some. - Review written on November 21, 2005
Rating: 4 out of 5
1 customer found this review not to be helpful.
I recently picked up "The Very Best Of" after deciding their 80's "Greatest Hits" was just way too little. This 2-disc collection includes everything the "Hits" album had, and a ton more, obviously their earlier material. I was extremely happy to get my hands on "25 Or 6 To 4", "Does Anybody Really Know What Time It Is?", "Just You 'N' Me", and "Feelin' Stronger Every Day". It's also wonderful to now own "Baby What A Big Surprise" and "If You Leave Me Now", which is possibly my favorite of theirs. There's no doubt that I enjoy the Cetera-sung tracks the most, and in truth I could have narrowed this down to 20 tracks. However, even though I believe the better stuff begins with "Saturday In The Park", it's all good. Hey, I'm a child of the 80's, what can I say. These songs remind me alot of visiting family in Illinois, and they still "Make Me Smile" today.
POSSIBLY THE GREATEST OF ALL BANDS EVER! - Review written on October 27, 2005
Rating: 5 out of 5
3 customers found this review helpful, 11 did not.
I LOVE CHICAGO, MAN THIS STUFF ROCKS AND ROLLS INTO NEXT WEEK...ITS MASCULINE YOU CAN FEEL THE PULSATING VIBES FROM THE SILVER DISC, ITS SO GOOD WHEN HE SINGS THOSE HIGH PARTS..."if you leave me now<> OH BABY PLEASE DONT GO!" BEAUTIFUL CLASSIC BRILLIANCE, I LOVE IT. THIS COLLECTION IS A GREAT COLLECTION IT BRINGS TOGETHER THE VERY BEST OF THE TRAILBLAAZIN' GROUP, IF YOU LEAVE ME NOW, IF SHE WOULD HAVE BEEN FAITHFUL, YOU NAME IT..ITS ALL HERE.. AND AT SUCH A GREAT PRICE WHY ARGUE?? A LOT OF PRETENDERS OUT THERE CLAIM THAT ROCK IS ONLY GOOD IF YOUR LONG AND COMPLICATED AND OVERTLY ANGRY ALL THE TIME, WELL CHICAGO IS THE LOVE SIDE, THE SIDE OF LOVE THAT IS IN ROCK ITS ALL ABOUT THE WAY THAT HE SINGS TO HIS GIRL, YOU KNOW?? HES GENTLE AND DELICATE NOT ALWAYYS BANGING AND SHOUTNG AND THEN GET UP AND LEAVE..THIS GUYS A GENTLEMAN. IT ANNOYS ME WHEN I HEAR SOMETHING LIKE "OH HE KILLED HIMSELF BECAUSE HE WASNT A MASCULINE MAN" OR SOMETHING EQUALLY IDIOTIC, HE WAS PLAYING A GAME OF RUSSIAN ROULETTE AND HE ACCIDENTALYL GOT KILLED, BECAUSE THERE WAS A BULLET IN THE CHAMBER, THATS MASCULINE THASTS VERY MANLY TO RISK YOUR LIFE IN PURSUIT OF SOME GREAT TRUTH..
BUT LOOK ENOUGH OF THE 'DEEP' DISCUSSION, THIS ALBUM ROCKS AND ROLLS END OF STORY. PINK FLOYD WOULD HAVE KILLED TO HAVE EVER MADE ANYTHING HALF AS GOOD IN THEIR PATHETIC LITTLE CAREER, MONKEY? GIVE ME A BREAK...TIME? WHO HAS THE TIME TO LISTEN TO THEIR TRASH..NOT ME THATS FOR SURE! TWO DISCS, GREAT PRICE, GREAT TRACKS, GREAT LOVING MASCULINE FEELING, HE LOVES YOU, BUT NOT IN A DIRTY WAY WITH GREAT LOVE AND CARE THROUGH MUSIC.
THIS SLAYS ALL PRETENDERS......................
Remastered Classics except for stuff after Chicago 14! Good retrospective but... - Review written on September 04, 2005
Rating: 4 out of 5
1 customer found this review helpful, 2 did not.
This is actually a very good remastering of the old Chicago stuff but for some reason, the stuff from the 16th albums onwards don't sound so good and it's as if they weren't remastered like the rest. Also, there's nothing from the 13th album like "Street Player" and the brilliant "Life is What it is". Granted the album was a critical dud, still, there are some good tracks there that should have been included. Also missing are tracks from the 14th album like "Thunder and Lightning". These are critical omissions given that they included "Sing, Sing, Sing", and lot of the forgettable Jason Sheff stuff instead. Also, "What Can I Say" from 16 is a great song that should have been included too.
Overall, though, 4 stars because the pre-16th album stuff have never sounded so good given the remastered treatment and the one member that people always forget, Terry Kath, gets a good representation on "25 or 6 to 4". His solo is absolutely brilliant and no less a personality than Jimi Hendrix who once heard him play stated that Terry was a better guitarist than him; no small compliment indeed. Just wanted to say a few words about an important member of the group that is frequently forgotten whenever Chicago is discussed.
Recommended though for those who want a sampling of the band but don't want to get all the albums.
Never Quite Did Find Out What 25 Or 6 To 4 Was... - Review written on May 13, 2005
Rating: 5 out of 5
2 customers found this review helpful, 1 did not.
For those who found the boxed set a little to overreaching, "The Very Best Of Chicago: Only The Beginning" is with out a doubt the perfect substitute. Containing nearly 40 of Chicago's best, this is a conscise look at the band's long and fruitful career.
Disc 1 contains all of the band's biggest hits from 1969 to 1976. This is when Chicago, in many people's opinion, recorded most of their best stuff, and in the case of songs like "25 Or 6 To 4", "Beginnings" and "Just You 'N' Me", this assertion is pretty hard to argue with. Even when they started to become more of a soft rock band with songs like "Wishing You Were Here" (dig the Beach Boys' harmonies) and the megahit "If You Leave Me Now", Chicago could still be counted on to deliver quality rock music (even soft rock).
Disc 2 picks up with 1977 onward, up to 1995. The only exception is 1975's "Old Days", the only track not in chronological order. Then we jump to 1977's hit ballad "Baby What A Big Surprise", one of my favorite songs they ever did. The eerie "Take Me Back To Chicago" comes next, a tribute to Terry Kath, the band's founding member. I've always liked this song. "Alive Again" is next, and it's probably the closest the band ever came to disco. "No Tell Lover" remains a MOR soft rock staple to this day. I never really liked "Love Me Tomorrow", but the next track is the 1982 megahit ballad "Hard To Say I'm Sorry". And what can I say? This is a true classic. I never liked "Get Away", that much. The rest of the album is all their big 1980s' hits, such as "Hard Habit To Break", "Look Away" and my all time favorite Chicago song "You're Not Alone". All of them are excellent songs.
This cd is a must have for anybody who enjoys quality music. Brilliantly done collection. Pick it up today.