Amazon.com Customer Reviews
Incredible piece of music history caught on film - Review written on January 19, 2007
Rating: 5 out of 5
1 customer found this review helpful.
This has got to be one of the most fun exciting videos I have watched. I got the VHS format instead of the DVD(which I normally would)because of the many reviews claiming lousy sound on the DVD. My tape was factory fresh, still in the shrink wrap. It was incredible to say the least to see Carl Perkins in fine form along with George Harrison, Ringo Starr, and Eric Clapton. They were all young, good looking, and at the top of their game and full of fun and excitement to be there for one of their great friends & mentors. I can recommend the VHS format for sound and my picture was great although somebody should do this thing right on DVD to save it for posterity. I would recommend it to any serious fan of classic Rock and Roll, much less fans of the Beatles, Sun Records/Nashville, Rockabilly, etc.. Get it while you can!
5 STARS FOR THE SHOW. 2 STARS FOR THE AUDIO ON THE DVD VERSION. - Review written on January 09, 2007
Rating: 2 out of 5
15 customers found this review helpful.
Much has been said about how close to perfection the show is. And it IS. If ever an opinion was a fact, that's a fact jack. So let me be very clear - the show itself is above and beyond 5 stars. I want to instead rant and rave about the mediocre audio quality of this particular dvd transfer here. Anybody who doesn't complain never owned the VHS before, and so of course they must think the sound can't get any better. It CAN. The picture on the dvd is fine, the audio is not terrible, but OH, if you had the VHS before, you'd know what you're missing. I thought I just had ungrateful amateur ears until a) I looked on the second page and started seeing that other people were complaining about the sound on this dvd and 2) sellers are still selling the VHS at full price here on amazon because a lot of people must be complaining about the dvd quality. I assumed I would see a bunch of penny listings, but it's going to be worth it to me to buy the vhs back for $10-15 and transfer it to dvd, and now beg Eric Clapton and his people, Olivia Harrison and her people, Carl's family, Ringo - somebody - RE-RELEASE THIS AS A SPECIAL EDITION DVD WITH OUTTAKES AND LOADS OF SPECIAL FEATURES AND, ABOVE ALL, REMASTER THAT AUDIO. PLEASE! For all those who agree with this last statement, say you find this review "helpful."
Thank You, God.! : - Review written on June 02, 2006
Rating: 5 out of 5
6 customers found this review helpful.
Much has already been said in review of this DVD. So I won't repeat it over and over again....BUT:
I was surfin' the net the other night looking for a good old photo of Carl Perkins. (the original rock superstar). I happened across a grainy, faded shot of Carl onstage with George Harrison, Eric Clapton and Ringo Starr. The first thing that occured to me was that I needed to see if this was a good concert and was there a DVD (or even VHS) available.
I found it here on Amazon and read the outstanding reviews.... So I bought it....
LORDY, MAMA....!!! THIS CONCERT BLEW ME AWAY................!!!!!
Sure it's packed with superstars........and they all played really great.....(Trust me on this.... My wife calls me "Mr. Fussy").....So what if Ringo sings lyrics in any order he pleases... Who notices that stuff but me and a few other anal retentive types anyway.
What matters is the tremendous heart that is embodied in this, THE GREATEST, MOST RADIO ACTIVE, THERMO NUCLEAR, ROCKABILLY MIND BLAST ever put on tape.
Yes, it's grainy.... and the sound isn't digitally remastered or digitally computer circumcized by espresso sipping engineers........ THAT'S WHAT'S SO COOL ABOUT IT....!!!
It is unvarnished, pure 100% unadultered rock'n'roll joy...
If you are a rock-n-roll junkie of ANY age.... If you loved The Killer, Roy Orbison, Lil' Richard Penniman or anyone of that ilk. THIS CONCERT IS A MUST SEE.
It's EVERYBODY at their best... When Eric, George, Dave Edmunuds, Ringo, Roseann Cash and everyone else sit down in folding chairs and their idol (Carls Perkins) leads them in a real old time jam session... It is a sight to behold..... It's history in the making.
This thing RULES.
While watching the finale of "Blue Suede Shoes" I began thinking about the fact that Carl and George are both up in heaven. I just broke down and cried.... God bless them both. Thanks for the great memories.
Congrats also to Dave Edmunds... Super player, super concert producer.....
DON'T MISS OUT ON THIS PHENOMENAL CONCERT.
God Bless Carl Perkins.... God Bless rock-n-roll.
Timothy A. Di Pietro
Certified Django Junkie
Possibly The Greatest Rock n' Roll Show Ever Filmed...... - Review written on April 27, 2006
Rating: 5 out of 5
5 customers found this review helpful.
I borrowed this video from my uncle ten years ago while still in high school. Needless to say, I was blown away like the other reviewers here. What I thought was gonna be an average show by an aging rocker past his prime turned out to be the most enjoyable concert video I've seen to this day! This is Carl Perkins' finest hour, and it is a special show that vividly captures the driving beat, heart, and spirit of early rock n' roll. The music here, wonderfully directed by Dave Edmonds, is as vibrant and infectious as rock n' roll gets!
This is the kind of rare show we desperately need more of in American music today. It is everything that today's music is not. There are no angry thugs shouting offensive lyrics in your face, no scantily-clad girls gyrating across the stage to compensate for a lack of musical ability, no twangy morons in cowboy hats singing about a tractor being sexy, and no manufactured pop clones who aren't allowed to play instruments or write their own songs. What we have here instead, is one blissful hour of the most spirited performances and hottest guitar playing you will see from a group of rock n' roll legends on one stage. When all is said and done, this will stand as one of the best rock n' roll specials ever captured on film!
You can't help but like Carl Perkins after watching this video. Not only does he sing and play better than you've ever heard him before, but the warmth and sincerity of the man really shine here as he showers each and every guest with kind words of praise. What makes this concert so special to me is how Carl's spirit and enthusiasm brings out the best in everybody on the stage. Rarely have these guys performed with a greater sense of joy and passion which makes this a treat to watch!
George and Ringo sound more inspired here than they did with the Beatles, and watching Eric Clapton unleash some of the most ELECTRIFYING solos he has ever played is worth the price of the video alone! Clapton literally sets the stage on fire with his guitar playing on "Mean Woman Blues", and Carl's amazed reaction to Eric is priceless! If Clapton was the best guitarist on the stage that night, Perkins was certainly the best singer. His voice had matured since the 1950's and he clearly outsings all of his guests. The soul and feeling in his voice comes out in every song.
This video is pure musical joy from start to finish, but the best is saved for last in a truly dynamic performance of "Blue Suede Shoes" that is nothing more than rock n' roll at its joyful best!! The audience is up dancing all over the place as everybody on stage rocks their hearts out! George Harrison is so caught up in the music that he suddenly leads the band into a rousing encore of the song. Dave Edmonds sums up the electricity of the moment as he turns to Carl and shouts "ROCK IT MAN!". Perkins is moved to tears of gratefulness after sharing such a special night with his peers, and the total lack of arrogance from this rock n' roll legend is truly admirable.
The music world lost a fine musician and human being when Carl Perkins passed away in 1998. This unforgettable show will stand as a great tribute to his spirit, music, influence, and talent. If you love Chuck Berry's "Hail Hail Rock n' Roll" or Roy Orbison's "Black and White Night", this will be a priceless addition to your collection!
This Is Rock 'N Roll Heaven!, - Review written on April 17, 2006
Rating: 5 out of 5
4 customers found this review helpful.
Wow!
When i first watched this is the spring of 1999, I had tears in my eyes for much of the concert. On the second viewing, five days later, I still had moist eyes. This was almost too good to be true! I couldn't believe what I was seeing and hearing.
Now that I've watched this numerous times, I don't get emotional but I still love it. This is old-time rock 'n roll ("rockabilly," to be exact) at it's best with rocking short songs that if they don't make you tap your feet and get just about everything else moving on you, then you check yourself for a pulse. Only a couple of the 17 songs are slow, and they are decent, but the last few songs really cook and that's basically what this is - an hour of feel- good rock.
Carl Perkins, one of rock's early but lesser-known pioneers, still can sing here (he died a few years later) and play his guitar well. He also comes across as a genuinely nice guy. Perhaps that is what drew George Harrison out for his first concert appearance in 15 years. Perkins had tons of respect and love among rock musicians.
Ringo Starr is here to sing and play some drums; Dave Edmunds, a good friend of Harrison's and a decent performer in his own right, is here. So, too, is bass player Lee Rocker, who is animated and fun to watch....and then there is Eric Clapton, who is simply outstanding and even has Perkins shaking his head almost in disbelief at his guitar playing.
The finale was Perkins' famous "Blue Suede Shoes," and was really nostalgic with the host and then several of the other performers taking turns singing it. You could just feel the warmth between Perkins and all his guests. They loved the man. This is just rock 'n roll heaven! Great to have it on DVD.
Great Rock & Roll - Review written on March 29, 2006
Rating: 5 out of 5
2 customers found this review helpful.
This is a great show honoring the great Carl Perkins. I actually recorded this on VHS when it was aired on TV during the late '80's.
Highlights for me, like the others who have reviewed it, are Ringo and George who are clearly having a blast singing and playing with one of their heroes. Everyone's love and admiration for Carl P. is obvious and very moving. Final note: I agree with some others who have opined that this show captures the best playing Clapton has done in the past 25 years, or more. I know it's heresy to say that he usually bores me. Maybe he came to life here because of Carl's presence, or maybe I just like him a lot better playing rockabilly. Regardless, this is a show for Carl, a true founding father of rock & roll, and, like him, it's a great one.
TEN STARS - PURE ROCKABILLY BLISS - Review written on November 14, 2005
Rating: 5 out of 5
7 customers found this review helpful.
On second thought I wouldn't give it ten stars, I'D GIVE IT TWENTY. If you appreciate the REAL THING, true rock and roll with no pretense, no posing, no egos, no bull... if you're a fan not just of the wonderful Mr. Perkins (one of those that truly built the house we all rock in)... if you hold George and Ringo close to your heart... and if you like me think that Eric Clapton pretty much died when Cream broke up... then YOU MUST BUY THIS DVD. In fact buy two in case you lose one. Watching these cats trade licks and vocals across the tiny stage just TAKES YOUR HEAD OFF, and the love that flows between the artists for their hero is deeply touching. Dave Edmunds is brilliant. Roseanne Cash puts
most other "rock chicks" to absolute shame. Perkins' voice is sterling and beautiful, Clapton's solos are just SEARING, Ringo proves he's one hell of a drummer and extremely cool vocalist, George is a joy. Just watching him stare in wonderment as Carl plays a little tribute to Les Paul is worth the price of the disc alone. This just MIGHT be the greatest rock and roll set ever put on DVD. An essential part of your collection. God bless you Carl, may you be boppin' in the clouds and our hearts forever.
Rocking the House! - Review written on May 28, 2005
Rating: 5 out of 5
8 customers found this review helpful.
As an inveterate, avid, intense Beatle fan, I was thoroughly delighted with this dvd! Hats off to Carl Perkins not only for being a driving force during the inception of Rock & Roll, but for influencing George Harrison! George Harrison ROCKED! He tore the place up with his guitar playing! If you think he sounded phenomenal on this dvd, be sure to listen to "Beatles Live at the BBC" and George's guitar playing sets the place on fire! Check him out on "Youngblood!"
Although the transfer ain't great, the music and the artists are. Ringo keeps a steady beat and his former bandmate, the nonpareil George Harrison will have you rockin' your blue suede shoes or your Beatle boots off! His revival of his 1965 cover of "Everybody's Trying to Be My Baby" brought many smiles to many faces. Gear up that 1963 Ford Falcon and take a trip to 1965 with George!
If you love Rock & Roll, the Blues and some EXCEPTIONAL guitar playing, this is the dvd for you. It is just plain fun and you will find yourself singing along with it and don't be surprised if you find you've started dancing!
Carl Perkins Rocks With The Beatles and Eric Clapton! - Review written on April 19, 2005
Rating: 5 out of 5
12 customers found this review helpful.
I have just received this DVD and cannot stop playing it. As a fan of the Beatles when I was a kid I have heard tunes on this that I haven't listened to since 1966! And they're fun to hear again. I agree with the previous reviewers, this is a very poor, runny, VHS transfer. It was taken from an HBO series that was screened world-wide (yes even here in Australia!) in the mid-1980s. The sound is OK, but it really sounds "Live" if you know what I mean. The colour is also very runny and there are a few drop outs captured on the disc. Even the cover photo on the case is out of focus! Oh well this was 20 years ago but the content is pure fun.
The late George Harrison, who was a great Perkins fan, comes across well but his playing is down in the mix, his cool red Gretch Guitar looks the part. His version of "Everybody's Trying To Be My Baby" brought back a lot of memories! Clapton probably plays better on this DVD than any in the last 20 years except his Guitar Festival appearence last year. Ringo Starr does a great rendition of "Honey Don't" (Done by the Beatles in 1965, 11 years after the Perkins original at Sun). Perkin's strange and controversial chord progession on this tune is what makes it so different and wonderful (see the section about this on the "Good Rockin' Tonight" DVD).
Carl Perkins was an innovator. He was from Tennessee and came to Memphis with a plethora of new ideas from country and blues music. He was a different type of rock musician. He was once marked to be bigger than Elvis (hence Jerry Lee Lewis' opening comments) but was hampered by a car crash in the early touring days and poor marketing by Sam Phillips and then others. However, like Albert King in blues, players and purists knew talent and the real thing. His beat and style of incorporating shuffles into country-rock grooves (rockabilly) was truly cool. Also he liked to use blues ideas hence we hear hints of Arthur "Big Boy" Crudup, Blind Lemon Jefferson and others in his tunes. He was a gifted guitarist as well. Listen to his playing with George Harrison when he emulates the echo effect he heard Les Paul do in the early 1950s without any effects but his fingers! Extraordinary!
Lastly, this series should be remixed and released as a set. There are several great perfromances in the "A Session" concerts. The best, to me, is BB King's "A Blues Session" with Albert King, SRV, Paul Butterfield, Eric Clapton and others. The "Soul Session" has James Brown with Wilson Pickett, Aretha Franklin and others. When will these be released? (An update: both of these have just been released in 2005. They are also pretty poor in picture quality but they are fantastic and have very rare performances like the late Robert Palmer on "Soul Session" and Paul Butterfield and Albert King on "Blues Session". Get all three!!!)
Get this DVD it is delightful, fun to watch, has great playing and is historical. It's a little more pricey than the average Amazon DVD, but it's worth having!!
An unqualified favorite - Review written on June 24, 2002
Rating: 5 out of 5
4 customers found this review helpful, 1 did not.
If you like Carl Perkins, George Harrison, Ringo Starr, Eric Clapton, Rosanne Cash and Dave Edmunds, buy this DVD. Perkins is in top form here, as are all of the participants. His skills as a mature stage performer, guitarist, and singer are on full display. George Harrison sings and plays up a storm, too - if you love George's music, that's enough reason to buy this disc. A suprise favorite for me was Rosanne Cash's brief set, including a vocal duet with Perkins on "Jackson." It's all great music and great fun.
I concur... - Review written on May 23, 2002
Rating: 3 out of 5
3 customers found this review helpful.
Like the reviwer below, I found that this new DVD had picture quality superior to the import DVD that has been available for a couple years (in Japan) but I too was rather disappointed in the sound quality. It's not as awful as the other reviwer might indicate, and it's certainly not unlistenable, but it's rather muddy.
Still, since this is the only way most folks can acquire this great old performance, it's still a worthy purchase. Perkins himself is in fine form, playing and singing like he's a kid. George Harrison nearly steals the show during his set, showing again how deftly he took his rockabilly lessons. Even Ringo Starr is in rare form, reminding us how he's one of the last breed of rock drummers that knows how to swing.
Don't miss watching and listening to the great lead guitar and vocal work of Dave Edmunds. His devotion to this genre is as genuine and thrilling as the old masters.
If there's one less-than-wonderful performance, it's by Eric Clapton. Not that the guitarist doesn't play well - he does, terrifically, but this isn't his genre. His quicksilver riffs clash with the swinging range of rockabilly. Still, he's clearly enjoying himself and his bandmates appreciate him - after all, this is a celebration, so no real complaint.
Anyhow - unless you have a multi-code player and money in your pocket for the Japanese code "2" or the Hong Kong code "0" editions, this is as good as you'll get for this show. If you enjoy the old rockabilly music and the players appearing here, this belongs in your library.
Priceless - Review written on April 25, 2002
Rating: 5 out of 5
6 customers found this review helpful.
I recorded this on VHS when Cinemax aired it in 1985. I loved it then, and love it even more now that it's on DVD.
Carl Perkins owns a place in rock/rockabilly music history, but as is so common to the man, he played it low-key all his life. Carl was so energized and into this session, and obviously SO touched by the affection and admiration that the "youngsters" had for him, and that vibe is evident throughout. This show demonstrates how deep his influence was on so many players...most especially his good friend George Harrison.
As we know, George had shied away from concerts for a number of years, and so it was a thrill to see him at this show. Of course it's now bittersweet to see playing with one of his idols, but George's joy is also so clear to see and hear. Having George and Ringo singing and playing the Perkins' tunes they did as Beatles, and to be playing them with Carl...well, it just brought a big smile to my face. And hey, don't get me wrong: Clapton, Dave Edmunds, Roseanne Cash, Lee Rocker and Slim Jim...it wasn't exactly amateur night!!
And now that this has been released on CD, I feel that Carl Perkins has gotten his due. Rock on, you rockabilly cat!
Rollicking Good Time! - Review written on January 26, 2000
Rating: 5 out of 5
8 customers found this review helpful.
Want to have some fun? Belly up to this rockabilly show and let the 50's ooze all over those imaginary (or not) '55 blue suedes. Spirited performances from Perkins, Ringo, George Harrison, Eric Clapton (just a tad less spirit from Eric but major league pickin' nontheless), Rosanne Cash and the cast make this video an uplifting experience. Would really like to see this with dts surround. As it is, you want to keep playing it over........and over........and over....... The audience gets into it in the end; after watching the throngs gyrate in The Bee Gees One Night Only and Tina from Amsterdam, one can't help but think this crowd has lost it's sense of particiaption. During the last three songs, however, some true rock and rollers circa 1955 take to the floor for some serious juice. Awfully good stuff! And, you're going to really love Carl and his supporting crew giving tribute to Jerry Lee Lewis and 'Whole Lota Shakin' Goin' On'. This video dates to a performance fifteen years ago. The spiked hair (Roseanne) and dated fabrics only add to the interest. Go for this one.