Amazon.com Customer Reviews
A pale, weak, sticky shadow of its former self - Review written on October 11, 2008
Rating: 1 out of 5
3 customers found this review helpful.
My mother had a waffle maker like this one, passed down from her mother. Shortly after I became an adult, the heating element of hers finally died and I was left waffle-less for several years. Then I found this. I was happy.
I don't know how, but the quality has changed dramatically over the years, despite looking essentially the same. My mother's/grandmother's waffles NEVER stuck to the plates--even a few times when they were left in until completely charred, they peeled right out without any trouble. THIS product, however, has the ability to permanently glue any substance into its tiny crevices, regardless of how well cooked. Even better is the fact that BOTH plates have equal sticking power, making it such that every time you open the iron expecting a waffle, you instead get a view of the inside of what should have been your waffle.
Others have mentioned that no amount of oil will prevent sticking--I'd like to qualify that: if you use 2-8 tbsp of crisco on each plate prior to making 1-2 sets of waffles, you will _probably_ be able to peel at least the first one off.
Perfect for Paninis - Review written on September 07, 2008
Rating: 4 out of 5
I've never owned either panini maker or waffle maker so keep this in mind when reading this review.. it means that I'm not comparing it to other products owned in the past. I'm reviewing this product based on my own requirement and not on anything else.
My requirements and desires for this product were 1) makes a good panini quickly (about once a week for 1 or 2 people, not a family) 2) washable plates 3) inexpensive 4) option for making waffles if ever I wanted to try.
The machine has fulfilled all of the requirements above. As I've only dabbled with the wafflemaking option, I won't rate its performance on waffle-making - strictly on panini-making.
Warm up - it takes around 10 minutes for this machine to pre-heat the metal plates. Once the machine is pre-heated it is quite hot which makes for quick work of panini making. However note that the exterior metal of the machine also gets very hot and you must take care not to touch anywhere except the black plastic parts after the machine has been turned on. Because of this, I would caution parents not to have small children anywhere near this device when it's on.
Additionally, as other reviewers have noted, the plates are fastened to the device by metal clips and could have been constructed better. I would have been more comfortable if the clips held the plates snugger. Although I've never had an experience of the plates coming declipped, the wiggle room of the clips does contribute to nervousness and caution that although may be wholly psychological is not especially welcome.
Panini-Making - Once the griddle is heated, the sandwich is inserted and pressed. The B&D machine performs quickly, evenly heating sandwiches and leaving a tasty crust layer.
What I like best about it is that when some of the fillings spill out of the sandwich and onto the grill (leaving what one would expect to be a gooey mess), it's actually quite easy to clean. I just let the plates cool and by then, the "goo" which sometimes contains hard to remove cheese - comes right off without much effort.
All and all, the machine has met all of my requirements and I am happy with it.
So, in a nutshell:
Pros: Easy to clean, portable, does a good job making paninis. Like the looks of it. Removable plates. Gets hot.
Cons: Clips holding plates could be stiffer. Exterior of machine gets hot. Not best for household with small children.
Awesome Waffle Maker! - Review written on August 31, 2008
Rating: 5 out of 5
1 customer found this review helpful.
This is the traditional waffle maker I am accustomed to! We sued to have one of these when I was a kid, and I loved waffles! Not sure what happenned to it, but I have one again, and am loving it!
I have not used the grill/griddle side of the plates, but that is a great feature to have! The unit will actually fully open up, so both grills are available, but you do have a gap between them. Swapping the plates out is easy too! There is a metal clip you press to release the plate, and it can pop right out. Just make sure it is cool! I worried that the clip would allow the plates to pop out unintentionally, but they hold in tight!
This waffle maker makes the traditional style waffles, kind of akin to those you can buy frozen at the store. They are great! Nothing like fresh waffles!
I am really happy with my Black & Decker Waffle Maker, and if you want to make waffles, you should give it a try!
I must have a bad one...it is terrible! - Review written on June 14, 2008
Rating: 1 out of 5
Based on the other reviews, I thought this would work for me, but it really is barely sufficient in doing either job. First off, the heat is very uneven from the front to the back. The front browns much more quickly than the back, leading to uneven sandwiches on the grill side, but worse yet, undercooked waffles on the waffle side! I use an old recipe for waffles that I have made for years, and I have NEVER tasted that recipe taste as badly as it did on this thing! Overdone on the outside edge of the front two, and underdone on the back two, to almost uncooked on the back edge. Besides this, it did not allow the waffle batter to rise, which made the waffles dense and chewy, and cooked what it did unevenly too! (overcooked was speckled) Nasty!
My advice is to keep looking! If you just want something that (sort of) makes a grilled cheese sandwich, this may work for you, though honestly a pan on the stove is quicker and more convenient in clean-up. But if you want something that really does the job it is advertised to do, this is not it, by any stretch of the imagination!
I give this a 1 star only because it turns on and heats, but will be the first thing I return to Amazon! Most times if something I buy doesn't work as well as I expect it to, I give it to Goodwill. But I would not do that to some unsuspecting person if they bought this thinking it would do the job for them!
Oh, and this is the SECOND disappointing Black and Decker product bought in a month! I think I see a trend here, and I will no longer consider anything made by Black and Decker.
Disappointed ... - Review written on June 04, 2008
Rating: 2 out of 5
I was excited to find the Black & Decker Waffle Baker. I've been looking to replace my mom's 50 year old waffle iron for some time. Lots of research, lots of price ranges. The Black & Decker was made exactly the same. Try to find a "traditional" non-belgian square, 4 slice waffle maker is hard! I've seen the others in stores and frankly, they looked cheap!
So, probably caught up in nostalgia, I was very disappointed when the waffles didn't cook evenly. They were spongy not crisp even at the highest setting. The removable plates, which could be used for grilling, did not stay in place. Everytime I opened the iron, the top plate would fall out. The steel hinge holding the plates in weren't very secure. Plus, I noticed the non-stick coating chip a bit. That concerns me.
Needless to say, I'm returning the item. I'm disappointed. Maybe a cheaper one will do the work!
A Waffle Iron That Really, Really Works! - Review written on May 08, 2008
Rating: 5 out of 5
4 customers found this review helpful.
My wife and I spent a great deal of time researching and comparing waffle irons, evaluating each on price, performance, ease of use, and durability. Part of our research involved reading other customers' reviews, which were nearly all favorable, but our evaluation, except for durability, is based upon our experiences.
First, it's great to have a waffle iron that actually gets waffles done--i.e., crispy on the outside and tender on the inside, with a golden-brown appearance. The "Done" indicator light actually works and is, incredibly, accurate, too.
Second, this waffle iron produces large, square waffles with partitions to enable the user to easily divide the waffles into four. These fit very nicely in a toaster, so it's easy to freeze them and warm them anytime you need a "waffle fix."
Third, the plates are removable for washing, and they slip easily in and out of the frame, to which they are secured by small metal clips. The only negative comment we saw on this product was that the clips did not seem to work very well and needed to be bent to function. This has not been our experience: the clips on our waffle iron work exactly as they were intended.
Fourth, comparisons with other waffle irons left them in the dust: this product was clearly superior to others costing between two and five times as much.
Since we have not had our waffle iron for a long time, we cannot judge its durability, but other customers have indicated that it is good for the long haul, and, as far as we can tell, we will eventually agree.
In sum, this is a great product! It does exactly what it is supposed to do, and does it well, and much more cheaply than many others. We highly recommend it.