Amazon.com Customer Reviews
Music's fine, but oh look. ANOTHER compilation. - Review written on August 14, 2008
Rating: 4 out of 5
This is the pinnacle of "marketing the same songs". I remember when Greatest Hits albums were it - you put one out and you were done. Now, there's repackaging, and new editions, updated remasters, and the phrase "Complete Greatest Hits" just strikes me as odd. I mean doesn't the concept of "Greatest Hits" mean that all of your good stuff is there? So why would songs on a "Complete Greatest Hits" as opposed to just "Greatst Hits" be as good? If those songs were as good as the original batch, wouldn't they have been on the first edition? This seems like marketing twaddle to me.
Anyway, the songs on here are fine. The Cars are one of those groups where I never really bought their material, since you heard almost all of it on the radio a zillion times anyway. But when I was going through and looking for some bands who I liked from the past, and had no material on CD at all from, I hit on this. There's just so many here I know and like, it's pointless in naming individual tracks.
Except this. Moving in Stereo. Phoebe Cates. One of the greatest cinematic scenes ever. ;)
Just What I Needed (and Wanted) - Review written on April 12, 2007
Rating: 5 out of 5
4 customers found this review helpful.
Looking back, I sometimes think of the '80s as kind of a wasteland of rock music--dominated by Duran Duran, Simple Minds, Tears for Fears and the like, but an impulsive, successful Karaoke rendition of "Best Friend's Girl" inspired me to buy this compilation of the best songs by one of the best bands of that era--The Cars. The band had a great mix--just edgy enough not to be pop, but catchy enough to grab your attention, without the sledgehammer hooks of the contemporaneous Huey Lewis and the News. The accompanying CD book describes well the evolution of the band and their sound. Overall, there's nothing here that will save the world, but right now a good mix of singable tunes artfully arranged, played with spirit (like "Let's Go") and sold at a reasonable price is just what I needed.
High Octane - Review written on February 06, 2007
Rating: 4 out of 5
2 customers found this review helpful.
Making a case for The Cars as brilliant singles band, "Complete Greatest Hits" is twenty songs that are all incredible. From 1978 till they dissolved in 1987, this Boston band helped to define what American New Wave music sounded like. A touch of Roxy Music, a dash of David Bowie, a really strong helping of melody and top that off with two solid lead vocalists in Ric Ocasek and the late Ben Orr, and you had the formula for the albums from "The Cars" classic to the lackluster final bow, "Door To Door."
As brilliant as the debut was, it is the most represented CD on this collection, with six songs. Of those, three were singles, with "Just What I Needed" being one of the most important top 40 records of 1978. (Oddly enough, this was about the same time Van Halen's cover of "You Really Got Me" cracked the charts - both of these bands arguably changed the state of radio.) The simple handclaps and harmonies of "My Best Friend's Girl" were irresistible. The debut's artier leanings were well represented on AOR radio (hey old-timers, remember that?) by "Moving In Stereo."
When the sophomore album arrived, it was with the brash mix of Buddy Holly and The Beatles that collided on "Let's Go." That probably remains my favorite Cars single, exploding from the radio in the summer of 1979. Even though it was never a single, "Dangerous Type" was a great radio song. It also pretty much hews to the blueprint of great Cars music. Enigmatic lyric, moody synths and hot solo from Elliot Easton.
The underrated "Panorama" followed. Ocasek had become interested in experimental music, like the art duo Suicide, and "Panorama" reflected that. The tricky key changes in "Touch and Go" were not the average hit single fare, and it's the only song from that CD. (I would have preferred the title track - surely one of the six songs from "The Cars" could have been sacrificed?) Ocasek's solo albums often had more of a "Panorama" feel to them, and I guess he needed to get it out of his system.
Then it was a return to popland. "Shake It Up," with its cheesy picture-disk styled cover art, produced the first top ten single for the group. "Shake It Up" (the single) was a prefect mash of Beach Boys sunniness and new wave dancablity. It also became a harbinger of the next album, as the moody ballad "I'm Not The One" set the stage for the band's biggest hit.
When "Heartbeat City" arrived in Spring of 1984, it matched the artiness of "Panorama" with the pop splendor of "Shake It Up" and the debut. Jumping from producer Roy Thomas Baker to Robert Lange, the sound went from arthouse to dancehouse, and the pop sheen was unmistakably Cars. Ben Orr rode that sound to the band's biggest single, "Drive," climbing to number three that summer. The videos for that song and the giddy "Magic," the Andy Warhol directed "Hello Again" and "You Might Think" (remember Ocasek as a human fly) were all over MTV that summer, and The Cars had their greatest success to date. Five "Heartbeat City" songs grace this CD.
The success also came with strain. Easton, Ocasek and Orr each releasing solo albums (with Orr charting a single with "Stay The Night") and only convening to record a one-off single for a Christmas best of in 1985. "Tonight She Comes" was a great double-entendre of a lyric, as were many of the best Cars songs. It was also their last top ten single. The Ocasek produced "Door To Door" found the band in a non-cohesive state, even dredging up songs written around the time of the debut. Only "You Are The Girl" managed to chart. Like much of "Door To Door," it only seemed to echo what the band had achieved before, but still sounds pretty good almost 20 years later.
"Complete Greatest Hits" is pretty close to a five star set. I would have maybe picked the title songs from "Panorama" and "Heartbeat City" over a couple of the album tracks here, but at the same time, putting this disc in the car will give you 20 songs of roadtime pleasure. More to the point, every single one of these songs stays with you. If you were a radio-geek (or an MTV geek) in the early 80's, this CD will take you back.
A baby band................... - Review written on September 26, 2006
Rating: 1 out of 5
3 customers found this review helpful, 79 did not.
The CARS were one of the most annoying, dumb, pathetic, lame, overrated, stupid, lousy, and awful bands ever came out in the 70's. Their lead singer RIC OCASEK sings horribly and sings like a baby. This greatest-hits album was a huge joke that each and every song is incredibly bad.
Their guitar playing is really bad. They are only recommended for loosers. Don't listen to the five star reviewers of this album and avoid CD's from the Cars, Nirvana, and AC/DC who suck. Listen to good bands like Foreigner and Dire Straits insted.
ps.the cars are for babies!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Great compilation, but don't stop here! - Review written on July 21, 2006
Rating: 5 out of 5
3 customers found this review helpful.
OK, let's get this straight. If you're looking for an intro to the Cars, a cheat sheet, get this disc. DON'T GET THE 1985 GREATEST HITS DISC! This disc sonically is far superior, has 20 songs versus 13 on the older one, and "Moving in Stereo", "It's All I Can Do", and "Bye Bye Love" among others. I find this disc routinely shows up for around $10 (and even less). I originally wrote this review a few years ago, and since then the older one is now available at a slightly cheaper price, and it has to be because warehouses are trying to clear out the older version. If you're finding yourself trying to choose between the older one and spending another couple of bucks on this one, it's a no brainer. It really is. Don't waste your time (or $$) on the other one. Having said that, hopefully after you purchase this one, you still get the Cars' debut. Sure, 6 of the 9 songs on that album are here, but there's a cohesion with that album that makes it necessary (and the 3 songs that aren't here are pretty damn good, especially "All Mixed Up"). And, if you like the 3 songs on this CD that are from the Candy-O album, get that album too. That one is another classic, start to finish.
One more thing. If you do decide to spring for the debut and Candy-O, get the remastered versions and if it's cheap enough, get the Rhino 2-CD version of the debut. You won't be sorry, although the first album is available as a single disc remaster that's well worth it, too.
Now, why they haven't remastered "Shake It Up" and "Heartbeat City" is beyond me. They're both good albums (not as great as the first two), but if they found a way to remaster "Panorama" (yeah, there was a Cars album between "Candy-O" and "Shake It Up" that most have forgotten, and for good reason) then come on.