Amazon.com Customer Reviews
Everything Old is New Again - Review written on October 23, 2007
Rating: 5 out of 5
My purchase of this CD was sparked naturally enough by having seen Walk the Line. I went to see that based on my own childhood memories of hearing Johnny Cash on the radio growing up. He and June Carter were a staple of country music and he had a voice that was like the low rumble of thunder in a box canyon. His voice and his guitar playing were unmistakable.
So it was with quite a bit of glee that I picked up this collection and was transported back to a simpler, quieter time. It gave me an even greater appreciation for the job Joaquin Phoenix did playing Johnny Cash -- though their voices are distinct, somehow Joaquin managed to get that rumble into his voice that instantly was familiar.
While perhaps not the most complete catalog of Johnny's music, outside of a boxed set this would be the best treasure trove you could ask for. It gives you a broad spectrum of music, from the gospel to country to his collaborations with June, Waylon Jennings, Kris Kristofferson, Willian Neslon, and of course the funnier stuff he did ("One Piece at a Time", "Boy Named Sue"). Certainly a sampling of music worth listening to.
Essential - Review written on April 12, 2007
Rating: 4 out of 5
1 customer found this review helpful, 1 did not.
The A-side has a fine selection of tunes that bring back classic moments from Johnny Cash. However, on the flip, songs like "If I Were a Carpenter" and "It Ain't Me Babe" (there are others) make this comp less than completely "essential." Of course, there's a dozen compilations of various size, and everybody has their favorites. But in terms of presenting the essential tracks by Johnny Cash, this record goes only two-thirds of the way.
The good news is that listeners have abundant choices - and who know, maybe for a sizable plurallity, this selection might indeed be essential enough. Having been through a few comps, I've found that you have to pick and choose to find the perfect record.
A very good collection of his music from 1955 through 1993 - Review written on January 25, 2007
Rating: 5 out of 5
16 customers found this review helpful, 1 did not.
Look, I am a classical musician. I am not deeply into popular music, but I did grow up in America in the 1960s and the music of that time saturated our lives. Besides the Beatles and Elvis, I was quite attracted to the music of The Who. Johnny Cash was someone not only I didn't listen to, but someone I actively avoided. His style of half-singing - half-talking always seemed kind of odd to me. I simply did not appreciate his originality or his charismatic power. Frankly, it wasn't until I saw the video for "Hurt" that I was blown away. Still, I didn't buy the CD.
Then I saw the DVD of "Walk the Line" and became even more interested in Cash. My wife and kids bought me this double CD for Christmas. As I listen to it with fresh ears and being consciously open to what Cash is offering, I have to say I am quite impressed. As well as the actors did in the movie, you will want to hear the real thing to appreciate what was so special about this guy.
Cash has a very expressive way of delivering his material. The musical elements are very simple, but the arrangements have some elements that are quite surprising if you listen very closely. The way he keeps things fresh rhythmically and the way some of the sounds are made are interesting. But the star is always Cash's voice. It is not a beautiful musical instrument, but it is a resonant and charismatic medium for his own commitment to the material. It has a beautiful timbre, but his finding a way between pitches can be exasperating until you realize that this is part of what Johnny Cash is. It is his unique style.
The words are always clear and delivered with commitment. The vocalizations draw one in unless you actively resist them. This collection offers selections from the very beginning of Cash's career in 1955 (in mono) through the early nineties. Each disk has 18 tracks. A few of them have Cash singing with June Carter and the Carter family. A couple of the tracks are live and a few are duets with Marty Robbins, Willie Nelson, and even Bono!
In the end, I enjoy Cash as a wonderfully expressive vocalist who conveys his convictions with a kind of minimalism that works successfully for the musical art he is making. This is a nice collection. And while I don't think I will listen to his music every day, I will certainly get other CDs from Cash over time. Too bad I had to wait until he was gone to develop an appreciation for him.