Amazon.com Customer Reviews
MacAddict Not Worth It Anymore - Review written on March 02, 2006
Rating: 3 out of 5
16 customers found this review helpful.
I have Issue #1 and just received the lastest issue (March 06), but I've let my subscription run-out. MacAddict isn't worth it anymore.
First, I loved MacAddict for "the Disc." Back in the days of pre-broadband, the Disc was a godsend! Software galore! But now in the days of broadband, the Disc is not a good enough reason to get MacAddict. The only original conent on the Disc is the monthly staff movie, I think I watched one staff movie over the years.
Second, the magazine seems to have lost quite a bit of content over the years. The magazine started at over 100 pages and is now a slim 80 pager. Often there is one "feature" article and that's it. Lately I spend about 10 minutes scanning the magazine for anything worth reading and then file it with the others.
Third, the magazine has a pretty weird view of who "Mac Addicts" are. "Mac Addicts" are accomplished musicians (who use Apple's GarageBand) and accomplished cinematographers (who capture video with high-end digital cameras and use iMovie and iDVD on a near daily basis.) They're also people who have the latest and greatest hardware who upgrade at the drop of a hat. I don't do any of those things, and I wager that the majority of Mac users don't do most of those on a regular basis.
Forth, their review section is hit-or-miss. Sometimes, they review relavant products that a good majority of Mac users want to know about. Other times they review fringe products (MIDI accordion, anyone?) or products out of the price range of all but the independently wealthy. The rating system seems to suffer from grade inflation. Nearly every product earns a score of 4 out of 5. If they like something, it gets a 5, if they don't like something, it gets a 3.
On a positive note, Mac Addict is a "fun" magazine. And its news coverage is pretty good.
Excellent: fun, informative, and very economical - Review written on May 08, 2003
Rating: 5 out of 5
What a mag! I haven't read any of the other reviews, but i must offer my unqualified 5 Stars for this playful, interesting magazine.
From command line tips, to product reviews, to the silly stuff on the back page, this rag is a must have for any mac enthusiast. None of the other Mac magazines capture the apple-user spirit quite like this.
But dont let me confuse you, MacAddict is in no way frivoulus - droll, yes, but serious and quite insightful too.
My only qualm with the magazine is that it is monthly and not weekly. I usually read it - cover to cover - within the first 24 hours of delivery! maybe if it were a bit more drab i could make it last longer.
Not the great read it once was... - Review written on December 16, 2002
Rating: 2 out of 5
3 customers found this review helpful, 1 did not.
Having been a charter subscriber since Issue One, paying full subscriber rates, I am now subscribing disc-less at cut rate. Can't put my finger on it, but MacAddict has lost something. Too juvenile, too silly, too much waste of my time... I'm not sure. But I'm not ready to cut the cord just yet. Sorry, Rick. In the meantime, I'm putting my hard earned cash on MacHome, a much improved magazine with great promise.
Some helpful bits amid the sass - Review written on December 12, 2002
Rating: 3 out of 5
122 customers found this review helpful, 9 did not.
The ranks of Macintosh magazines have always been thin. After the demise of MacUser (the best magazine) and MacWeek (the best trade), MacAddict came out of nowhere to fill some of that void.
As an alternative to MacWorld, the venerable option for Mac users, MacAddict brings some life to the party. Offering the content of MacWorld, but written like Maxim, the enthusiasm for the platform definitely comes through.
MacAddict is not unique in content. You get product reviews, how-to's, tips, interviews, and such. (Depending on your subscription, it may also include a helpful CD loaded with freeware, shareware, video clips, and other goodies - it's the CD that gives the mag its raison d'etre.) All things considered, it's your typical computer magazine. What sets it apart is its insider, wink-wink, Gen X attitude.
And that's where the strength and weakness of the magazine lies. How much you'll enjoy MacAddict depends how much you like the attitude.
Personally, I find it a bit grating and in-your-face simply for in-your-face's sake. MacWorld may be a better choice in this regard. MacAddict tends to be a bit thin page-wise, too. It's about half the length of comparable computer magazines. Part of that lies in the fact that the Mac universe isn't as loaded with as much debris as the PC's, but still, MacWorld has more content. And that content does have some bigger names writing it, too.
One area in which MacAddict does beat MacWorld is that it seems to be on a tighter publishing schedule - getting reviews of new products ahead of its stodgier cousin. But when you consider what is available in this regard on the Internet, this advantage doesn't seem so helpful.
If you are a Mac fanatic - and can afford it - get MacAddict with MacWorld. But if you are a normal user, I'd tip the scales toward MacWorld.
Five stars for MacAddict ... - Review written on October 29, 2002
Rating: 5 out of 5
4 customers found this review helpful, 2 did not.
If you are a Macintosh user you deserve to live. But if you buy this magazine without the disc you deserve to have a PC...oh no, how I could, I wrote those two letters together. Well, don't misunderstand me, this is THE MAGAZINE for mac users, but without the the disc it's just like this: Mom, may I watch the t.v.? -Oh yes, honey, you can watch it, just don't turn it on.
Best Mac Magazine Bar None - Review written on July 07, 2002
Rating: 5 out of 5
7 customers found this review helpful, 1 did not.
If you're looking for a macintosh magazine and can't afford subscribing to Macworld, MacDesign, and MacAddict, get MacAddict. Not only has it been redesigned from the ground up, but they got rid of their insipidly stupid mascot Max in the review section. No longer are we faced with the blech, freakin' awesome, etc... of this tiresome cartoon character.
But more than that are its features, reviews (that everyone can understand), games sections, get info, and more. It's irreverant, fun, sometimes a little too juvenile, but you get the impression that the people who run this magazine LOVE using macs. I never got that impression from the other mac magazines (except maybe MacDesign) or from any PC magazine on the market. With that said, it also comes with a monthly CD (which I believe is about $1 extra) just brimming with demos, freeware, shareware, movie clips, and more. It's a great magazine and you won't be disappointed. You'll look forward to each and every issue and read it from cover to cover (too bad it's not twice a month!).
No CD = No Subscription - Review written on May 16, 2002
Rating: 1 out of 5
24 customers found this review helpful, 5 did not.
The one star is for this deal, not for the magazine: To offer MacAddict without the CD is like offering the New Yorker without the cartoons--it's an integral component. One of the main reasons to buy the magazine is to get the demos, updates, freeware, shareware, and staff movies. No doubt that the magazine is fun, a little irreverent, and mostly on top of things...but the magazine also is written with the disc in mind. So, please, Amazon, offer a REAL MacAddict subscription.
No Mac owner should be without MacAddict - Review written on February 28, 2002
Rating: 4 out of 5
1 customer found this review helpful, 1 did not.
My fist copy of MacAddict was issue 6 and I haven't missed one since. The subscription cost is worth it just for the Disc. Back in the days when 28.8 was a screaming fast modem, the Disc was a lifesaver packed with a weeks worth of downloads. That was also back when Apple let MacAddict put OS updates on the Disc but Steve put an end to that :( The How To sections vary from "Yeah Whatever" to "...Awesome" and some go where the vast majority of Mac owners should never venture (overclocking an iBook!!). Others, like some of the Photoshop tips, make the one year cost [worth it] compared to what you pay for a book. The content is thin sometimes and the reviews tend to cheerlead a bit but MacAddict is still head and shoulders over any other Mac magazine. If you own a Mac, you should subscribe for at least a year. After that, you should have a good collection of Disc's with the essentials (Stuffit, BBEdit, GraphicConverter, etc) and you can decide if you want more.
A must-have subscription for Mac users - Review written on February 07, 2002
Rating: 5 out of 5
6 customers found this review helpful.
If you are thinking about getting a Macintosh, have just bought a new Mac or if you just have an old Mac Classic in your attic, this Magazine is a must-have. I have every issue from the first one and I keep them all as references.
They have ads, but they are not full of ads like many of their competitors. Every single issue has a "get info" secion where commonly and not-so-commonly asked questions and/or problems are asked and answered.
Every issue has at least one tutorial on a major Mac product... from Photoshop to Quicken and everything in between. Many items are reviewed from kid's games, learning software, scanners, digital cameras, etc... in a language that mere mortals can understand.
Like any magazine, there are articles I could care less about, but every single issue has at least one article that makes having the magazine worth keeping indefinitely.
While they show off the features of the latest greatest Macs, they do not ignore the old beige Mac Classics and their siblings... how-to articles on upgrading different models are featured often and the accompanying CD will contain latest updates from Apple (so you don't have to download), shareware and freeware apps described in the Magazine and apps for OSX, Classic and older (pre OS 8) Macs are included.
I can't say enough how much I treasure my subscription to MacAddict.
A highly biased review from MacAddict's Editor in Chief - Review written on November 02, 2001
Rating: 5 out of 5
10 customers found this review helpful, 2 did not.
Hey, I'm being honest up front -- full disclosure, and all that jazz...
I'm the Editor in Chief at MacAddict, and I gotta say that if you're a fan of the Mac, you'll definitely love our magazine. Our monthly goal is to help you get the most out of your Mac, so we cram each issue full of how-to stories, tips'n'tricks, product recommendations, and bright shiny objects -- all written and laid out with that now-famous MacAddict attitude.
If you love your Mac and want to enjoy yourself while learning how to squeeze the last possible drop of fun out of it -- and bend it to your will when using it for actual work, as well -- you'll love our magazine.
And if you don't, tell me why -- maybe you've got some great ideas about how we could improve it.