Amazon.com Customer Reviews
Good knives will rust - Review written on August 28, 2004
Rating: 4 out of 5
6 customers found this review helpful, 6 did not.
I haven't received these knives yet, but the fact that they will rust helped convince me to buy. High-carbon steel blades do that, they also hold an edge better than other alloys, typically. If a knife is too "stainless" then the nickel content is so high that it's use as a knife is compromised. It's a trade off, but most higher end knives require to be kept clean and dry, and kept out of the dishwasher to avoid having the temper slowly baked out of them. A good knife holds an edge reasonably well, and is durable against chipping or breaking (another compromise) but also is easy to sharpen once it gets dull (another compromise). There are exceptions like exotic ceramic blades, other non-iron alloys, or cheap stamped steel serrated "ginsu clones" which are really more of a saw than a knife. I'm picky about knives, but I liked the price on this set and took a gamble.
Good, but more work to maintain. - Review written on August 17, 2004
Rating: 3 out of 5
26 customers found this review helpful.
These knives are good. Not the greatest, but good. I've been using them for a couple weeks now and they're fine for what I need. I have two complaints, though.
1. I have found that I need to hand wash and towel dry them IMMEDIATELY after using them. This is somewhat of a pain in the you-know-what. Why do I need to wash and dry them? See #2.
2. A couple of my steak knives developed small rust spots on them after I left them in my sink overnight. A couple other reviewers mentioned this and I just assumed that it magically wouldn't happen to me. In the end, I was able to scour them off, but it makes me worry. My mother says this has to do with the quality of the steel, but they're forged (not pressed), so I thought this wouldn't be a problem.
Other than that, they WERE sharp right out of the box. And, if for some reason yours aren't, it COMES with a sharpener, so you don't have to go out and spend all kinds of money on some fancy blade sharpener.
I really enjoy all the knives/tools that this set comes with. Yeah, it's a pain to wash and dry the knives right after using them, but it means I'm taking better care of them. Hopefully, this means they'll last and really, really long time.
A Big Disappointment - Review written on June 05, 2004
Rating: 2 out of 5
4 customers found this review helpful, 3 did not.
I'd read great things about these knives -- they were even rated a Best Buy by Consumer Reports. However, having now owned them for a week, I can say they are a big disappointment, and I would not recommend them. Contrary to what others have written, the knives are comfortable, well-balanced and feel great in your hands. However, they are very very dull -- you can't cut anything with them the way they arrive. I ended up spending $ 120.00 dollars on a knife sharpener to try to make this set usable, but while that improved things, the knives still don't feel that sharp. Finally, the knives don't appear to be "stainless" steel. After one hand-washing, three of the knives became discolored, and now have "rust"-like spots on them that will not come off. It looks like things get worse and worse with each use and washing. Overall, it would have been worth it to spend $150.00 to $200.00 more dollars to get something decent, and I could have afforded that with the money I had to spend on the knife sharpener!