Amazon.com Customer Reviews
Hitting Most Of The Obvious Notes - Review written on June 12, 2008
Rating: 4 out of 5
2 customers found this review helpful, 1 did not.
Purists have and will continue to argue this particular release into the ground with a host of complaints that range from "The audio mix is bad!" to "Lady Madonna was never number one on the charts!" But while it may come as deep shock to them, not every one approaches The Beatles as if they were holy relics, not everyone considers them "essential," and not every one feels it necessary to purchase every album the band made.
Quite obviously I tend to fall into this category. I like quite a few of The Beatles' recordings, but they never spoke me in a gotta-have-it way, and although I like "Come Together" I'm not going to buy ABBEY ROAD in order to obtain it. But while this compilation doesn't include every one of my favorites, it does include enough of them to make me willing to put a few of my hard-earned dollars on the table.
It is true that #1 is open to "number one according to who?" arguments, but even so the collection does gather twenty-seven of the band's best known and most popular releases--and also offers a fairly good overview of their style as they moved from mop-top-pop to psychedelia with plenty of innovation and serious musicianship along the way. It may be true that some of the songs sound better in original monoaural; it may be true that every selection could stand a meticulous remastering--but I personally had no complaints about sound quality.
This is really a recording for two classes of listeners: novices who know little about the band and would like to test the waters and old hands who like certain songs but don't like them well enough to go to the expense of replacing scratched up albums with CDs. You'll still have to do that if you want the likes of "Lucy In The Sky With Diamonds," "Strawberry Fields Forever," and "Octopus Garden"--but this collection really does hit most of the obvious notes.
GFT, Amazon Reviewer
In a word: timeless - Review written on April 16, 2008
Rating: 5 out of 5
1 customer found this review helpful, 2 did not.
I've had this album for over seven years and I never get tired of it. And if you're someone who appreciates good music, neither will you. Whether you're a casual fan, a die hard fan or even just recently a new fan, this will be a very worthy addition. For the new fan, it's the perfect introduction to one of the most influential bands in music. You can actually hear them grow with each track. Yet as superb as this album is, it only scratches the surface. The albums "With The Beatles", "Sgt. Pepper" and The White Album are not covered because there were no singles off those albums. "Nowhere Man" from "Rubber Soul" was released as a single in the U.S. but only went to #3. This undermines the fact that some of their most popular songs didn't top the charts or were not released as singles. For the long time or die hard fan this is worth getting for the packaging. The liner notes feature different picture sleeves for all the singles as well as release dates. Finally, all the tracks except the first three are in stereo.
John, Paul, George and Ringo have definitely left their mark on the world. This collection is proof of that.
Total Time-79:08
Confusing to newbies but still a great compilation - Review written on February 28, 2008
Rating: 5 out of 5
5 customers found this review helpful.
This CD takes the listener on a journey through the essential three periods of The Beatles' music. Since those tunes are radically different on each end, any newcomer to The Beatles (living on Venus? *.* ) might experience a little confusion as to how this may have happened. The answer to that is probably to listen to the "Anthology" on 6 discs.
In any case, these are the biggies that we heard on the radio, AM when The Beatles first got rolling. I savoured most of these early tunes on crystal clear powerhouse WOWO Radio AM, Fort Wayne, Indiana, which was hundreds of miles west of my home in southeastern Ohio, on warm summer nights. During the daytime, when WOWO powered down, we listened on WKEE AM ("KEE Radio," Huntington, West Virginia), which was one of the first rock stations to ultimately make the jump to FM in our region.
Nostalgia aside, I bought this CD practically on the day that it was released. If a person owned only one [The] Beatles album, I guess that this should be it. If one only cared for the middle, "psychedelic period," then they should probably go for either "Sargeant Pepper's" or "The White Album" (see my full reviews of those fine works).
Keep in mind that this is "Top 40" stuff so the listener definitely misses out on the brilliant nuances of The Beatles' more obscure works which is, in my opinion, what launched them as a mega-music-machine, given the additional boost by both Brian Epstein and George Martin. In the old "33 RPM" days, (and in the 8-Track ones... YIKES!!!), we listened to The Beatles albums in their entirety, not really honing in on a single hit song so much, (although the 45 RPMs were certainly available and popular with some).
Still, this is a super compilation and, albeit it comes off as a bit of a mix-match of tunes, I'm glad it's available as long as people know what to expect when they buy it.
Got A Good Reason - Review written on September 22, 2007
Rating: 5 out of 5
4 customers found this review helpful.
"And when I touch you, I feel happy inside," was the simple lyric that rocked my world during grade school days. The Beatles were an incredible band, unmatched in their ability to play off each other and creatively spark their listeners and hold their imaginations. From the tight harmonies and rocking tunes from their early days from "Love Me Do" to "I Feel Fine," they blazed across the Atlantic and touched the world. John Lennon's urgent voice singing, "I've been working like a dog ... I should be sleeping like a log, but when I get home to you, I find the things you do will make me feel all right" on "A Hard Day's Night" burst with incredible energy. "Day Tripper" has one of the most distinctive bass lines ever recorded with McCartney's genius in full bloom and Harrison's slamming lead guitar, "Got a good reason for taking the easy way out." The Beatles' middle period where they moved from a singles band to phenomenon where legions waited for each new album is reflected in the inventively different "Eleanor Rigby" with the stunning string arrangement, so incredibly different from the rest of radio. The Beatles were great businessmen, but they also were incredible artists. Looking back, I'm so pleased that George Harrison's "Something" reached the top of the charts. His emotionally charged guitar was always a tremendously important, if slightly understated, element of their success. "Somewhere in her smile she knows that I don't need no other lover, something in her style that shows me" is such an incredibly intimate lyric married to such a beautiful melody and Harrison's guitar sounding like part ecstasy, part teardrop. This collection is such an excellent single disc that it really is a pearl of great price. Enjoy!
"Here there and everywhere" - Review written on September 03, 2007
Rating: 4 out of 5
7 customers found this review helpful.
The four stars are for the #1 compilation itself, not a rating of The Beatles' music on the disc, nearly all of which is obviously genuine "5 Star" material! So, with over a thousand reviews here at the time of writing, why yet another? Because it needs to be pointed out that this is not a complete "Best Of" compilation nor a fair cross section of what the Beatles were musically capable, and that popularity (ie.sales) should not be a validation of worth. One thing that can be said with certainty is: A top numerical position on the charts does not necessarily mean that a compilation of these number ones is the definitive best of the Beatles. We DO get rollicking rockers such as "Can't Buy Me Love", "I Feel Fine", "Lady Madonna", and "Get Back" as well as the beloved ballads "Yesterday", "Hey Jude", "Eleanor Rigby" and "Something", both categories proving the band mastered those styles, but what about the superb in-between music played regularly by progressive radio stations everywhere and represented by the 'Rock Beatles': "Revolution", "Rain", "While My Guitar Gently Weeps" and psychedelic-era Beatles tracks - "Tomorrow Never Knows", "Lucy In the Sky With Diamonds", "I Am the Walrus", "Strawberry Fields Forever"? The answer is: Of course they're not here because they weren't #1 charting songs. (Though the non-#1 "Penny Lane" mysteriously IS, while "Please Please Me", a true Number One in many countries, is NOT.) If you want to enjoy the full glory of the Beatles' music and understand them more, you need these latter tracks...Still, #1 is a more sensible collection than the earlier ill-conceived LOVE SONGS and ROCK & ROLL compilations, but not as honest as the vinyl-only GREATEST HITS or import-only vinyl LIVERPOOL BOX. The BEATLES 1 set has other strengths, such as the beautiful and generous color booklet and fine remastered sound. Four-and-half stars: Slightly skewed selection but otherwise good value.