Amazon.com Customer Reviews
Trees in the sky! - Review written on March 27, 2008
Rating: 5 out of 5
2 customers found this review helpful.
Like trees in the sky!
Well ...as I read, much has been said about this beautiful concert but, if you permit me, I`d like to add a few words about it from this part of the world. I used to listen to it in LP recording when I was 15 or 16. I'm 46 now. So, the old LP somehow scratched now, I got a remastered CD a few days ago and....Wow!!! This is what I remembered...and more! Maybe the interesting part is that I studied music, so as a professional musician I somehow retrace my steps asking the key question: was there anything here worthy of my awakening music perception? And the answer is YES! These are not just romantic memories of my adolescence. No. There are beautiful melodies and poetry in Morningside, a lovely, somehow Haydn inspired, treatment of the strings in the Prologue, inspired orchestral arrangements in I am I said, a strong "pathos" in the rock-gospel interpretation of Holy Holly, the great percussion of Denis St. John....you name it. But, above all that, and somehow illuminating all of it, this was 1972, and still the spirit of the 60's! I find it touching to read that Neil Diamond's last album, still unreleased, is called "Home Before Dark". Home and dark are not clichés or empty words for someone who has "seen the light" or dreamt with the "Dear Father" through his own poetic sky, not so "lonely looking". It sounds suggesting. This man has been singing for 40 years now and in good company: these were the times of Luther King and of Peter Paul and Mary, the times of Serrat in Spain and Caetano in Brazil, the times of Joan Baez. Young generations: will you ever get the picture? This people sang from commitment and from the heart's mystic daimon, ( no miss spelling) as the Greek would say it. This was still the spirit of Kennedy, not Bush, the spirit of make love, not war, the times of melodic and harmonic richness expressing the true longings of a generation, not of silly and elementary beats on two chords, expressing the greediness of the pop market.
No, this was much different; this had roots and spirit: Neil, the trees you saw in the sky, that August 24 beautiful night, are still there! With all of us. And, yes, they are BEAUTIFUL!
Thanks again for sharing them with us.
Santiago Zuleta.
Unsurpassable, A Happening, A Walk Down Memory Lane... - Review written on November 19, 2007
Rating: 5 out of 5
1 customer found this review not to be helpful.
When we baby boomers are rugged up in our pj's at the Home for the Nearly Departed, one of the subjects we'll discuss will be the day we first heard Neil Diamonds immortal "Hot August Night", what a magnificent moment it was (and still is) and how thrilling it is,still, to hear this digitalised, and extended version through our ear plugs on the ipod,or our hearing aids - which ever may be the case.
A great live album allows those listening to get a feel for the night,the excitement, the enthusiasm, the waves of love flowing back and forth from entertainer to audience, an electrifying atmostphere.
All that is patently obvious on Hot August Night as Neil Diamond sings with passion and finesse, talks to the "tree people" present, (I've often wondered, did they pay?) and gives an awesome performance - singing all of his greatest songs, Crunchy Granola Suite, Cherry Baby, Solitary Man, Sweet Caroline, and the gentle Play Me, plus Cante Libre, Song Sung Blue and good ole Cracklin' Rosie. A few extra's were thrown in for good measure on this CD, Stones, Walk On Water, were not on the original vinyl,
but are welcome extra's just the same.
A great night, and a special, unforgettable, moment in history.
The Second Best Live Recording - Review written on November 03, 2007
Rating: 3 out of 5
1 customer found this review helpful, 9 did not.
Actually, the Gold live album, which was earlier, was better because his voice was stronger. If you listen to Gold, you will understand why his voice is so shot on this cd. His live albums got worse and worse, but this one still had moments. The Prologue is tremendous, and Cherry, Caroline and You'll Be a Woman Soon are great versions. If you are a fan, you already have it, but if you are a casual fan, there are better places to go than this.
Diamond at his very best - Review written on March 22, 2006
Rating: 5 out of 5
6 customers found this review helpful, 1 did not.
Not many artists are able to perform live as well as they do in studio. Of the top of my head I can honestly only think of Bruce "the boss" Springsteen who may even be better live than in studio. Many live albums are available with Neil Diamond and he's never bettered this exceptional performance. It's like here everything fell completely in place; Neil's vocals are top-notch, the band sounds great and even the audience contribute alot. Diamond classics such "I am, I said, Play me, Stones, And the grass won't pay no mind" sound even better here than originally heard. Upbeat songs such as Sweet Caroline, Holly holy and especially You're so sweet sound MUCH better here than in their studio incarnations.
Neil Diamond isn't for everyone, he has devoted fans and people who really don't like him. For a devoted fan this album is a must, for the casual fan it's highly recommended and for a non fan; give it a chance, you'd be surprised.