Amazon.com Customer Reviews
Nostalgia is a preferable alternative to live action version - Review written on December 21, 2007
Rating: 5 out of 5
"Horton Hears a Who" is a good introduction to the Who characters, and is typical of Dr. Suess talent for incorporating clever rhyme and cute storytelling. The animation is equal to the story, no complaints.
The reason I purchased this DVD is because of the Grinch.
This is the year my 3-year-old daughter is discovering Christmas, and the Grinch is a focal character in what I hope will become a holiday tradition around here. We've been reading the 1957 edition of the book "How the Grinch Stole Christmas" because it represents the best of Dr. Suess (my opinion) and the MGM cartoon adaptation is clever, cute, and simple in its telling and plotline.
For small children (and for nostalgia saps like me) the 1967 video version of the story is as good as any video interpretation can get. Boris Karloff provides narration and the voice of the Grinch with just the right amount of sneer in his voice, and at the end, Karloff's natural accent describes the transformation of the Grinch perfectly.
Where the Ron Howard live action film is dark and creepy (the Whos look like something from a 1960's "Twilight Zone" episode), Chuck Jones' characters are light and colorful, the songs are simple enough for children to enjoy and remember. Thurl Ravenscroft (aside from having a very cool name) sings a great baritone "You're a Mean One, Mr. Grinch". My daughter pretty much has the book memorized and now she sings "Welcome Christmas" in all the right places when she recites the story.
Sorry, but it is kind of sweet.
So, my recommendation is to skip Ron Howard's over-produced, over-analyzed, and, I might add, rather creepy and nightmare-inducing, interpretation of "The Grinch" (let's leave the psychological implications Opie Taylor's Grinch to his therapist) and introduce the tots in our lives to something much more palatable for their impressionable young minds.
One of the 20th century's greatest works of art - Review written on December 01, 2007
Rating: 5 out of 5
2 customers found this review helpful.
Seuss and Jones, two masters of their crafts, combine here to create one of my favorite works of art, period.
The morals ring truer than ever, the voices are incredible (Karloff is legendary, Carrey's version is nowhere near this), and the artwork is perfection.
This may be the single finest cartoon ever made, all of Bugs B included. It is a masterpiece in every sense of the word, and has as much to offer adults as kids, maybe more in our incredibly selfish world. Seuss's take on pathetic Xmas commericalization gets truer every year. Watching this on tv surrounded by ads is one of the great modern ironic experiences.
Much better to just get this dvd. Paired with Horton, one of Seuss's other completely genius works, there's more enlightenment for your kid here in less than an hour than s/he'll get in a year of normal entertainment (or should I say marketing? Kids' stuff now is all one big ad, if it was ever otherwise). What Christmas cartoon would Jesus watch? The Grinch, no question. Might be tough to work the remote, though.
Grinch and Horton make so many deep comments on our culture and our species while looking gorgeously unique. Plus, they're as fun as they can be.
That's as good as art gets.
HIS MEANNESS IN GLORIOUS GREENESS - Review written on May 05, 2007
Rating: 5 out of 5
3 customers found this review helpful.
Wow! I just watched this newest edition of the Grinch, and what a difference! The COLORS are FABULOUS! He never looked better! The remastering is, well, masterful; and I never saw this wonderful Christmas feature so beautifully represented.
All the hundreds of times I watched this before have been in B&W by comparison!
"You're a Mean One-Mr Grinch! You have Termites in your Soul!"
Sung by the inimitable Thurl Ravenscroft (what a great name!) who also voiced one of the Ghosts on the Haunted Mansion ride, ( a Singing Bust in the Graveyard) lends a thrilling richness to the feature, as great as the voice of Boris Karloff as the Grinch himself.
An extra feature on this disc is the Making of...including interviews with Mrs Theodore Geisel, AKA Mrs Seuss, and Chuck Jones, who worked closely with his old friend Dr Seuss, at first reluctant to animate his story, but who thawed after seeing the drawings and hearing the great songs, esp the one on Christmas Morning.
Horton hears a Who is included, and this is just wonderful...so sweet.
One day Dr Seuss was sitting at his desk littered with sketches when a breeze wafted in and blew a drawing of an elephant onto a drawing of a tree, which set Seuss to thinking: "What is that elephant doing up in that tree?" which led to Horton Hatches the Egg.
Seuss's wonderful surrealist POV is the child's version of Dali, and another favorite Seuss work of mine is the sets he created for "The 5,000 Fingers of Dr T."
This set also includes Phil Hartman's Grinch special and pencil tests.
But the real star here is the incredible colors and how magnificent the Grinch looks in his splendid coat of bright Green. You've never seen this great feature so beautifully done until you get this version! The packaging is wonderful with sparkles all over the jacket.
Dr. Seuss's Original... - Review written on April 22, 2007
Rating: 5 out of 5
The 1966 cartoon version of "How the Grinch Stole Christmas" has rightly become a Christmas season classic. Its simple but evocative storyline is brought to life by the pairing of animator Chuck Jones with original artist Theodor Geisel. Boris Karloff's absolutely superb narration is the thing of genius that makes the whole movie work.
The story is familar to anyone who has been young in the last forty years: The Grinch, a Christmas-hater, lives near Whoville, populated by Whos, a cheery bunch who celebrate Christmas with abandon. The Grinch has the stoke of awful inspiration one Christams Eve to sneak into Whoville and steal all the holiday paraphanalia, and stop Christmas from coming. Disguised as Santa Claus, the Grinch makes away with all the presents, decorations, and food, only to discover that he has missed the point about Christmas altogether. His moment of relevation may be the highlight of the whole movie.
This movie is highly recommended as a Christmas Classic suitable for all ages.