Amazon.com Customer Reviews
Better Than JOHNNY CASH AT FOLSOM PRISON! More Relaxed, Energetic, and More Variety! - Review written on April 13, 2006
Rating: 5 out of 5
7 customers found this review helpful.
I like this live album, JOHNNY CASH AT SAN QUENTIN, more than his more famous, previous live prison concert album, JOHNNY CASH AT FOLSOM PRISON. They each have their different aspects to make them both worthwhile, but the AT SAN QUENTIN performance has more musical variety, is more relaxed (less serious, less nervous, more humorous), and is more fun to listen to.
JOHNNY CASH AT FOLSOM PRISON seems more famous because of his early, classic hit, "Folsom Prison Blues," and it is prominently featured in the 2005 movie, WALK THE LINE; but JOHNNY CASH AT SAN QUENTIN is the album containing the debut of another, equally famous song, "A Boy Named Sue," and it was a bigger hit on the sales charts when it first was released, nearly 40 years ago.
This re-issue, re-master is a very nice CD! It has the entire concert, for the first time, and is nearly one hour long! It has more guest musicians, beyond June Carter, there is also her mom and sisters, and also the Statler Brothers.
Some of Johnny's very early songs seem more appealing to me on AT SAN QUENTIN. Some of his lesser known songs from the 1950's sometimes seem very dated to me, but they seem more revved up on AT SAN QUENTIN, and with repeated listening, I like them more each time I hear them on this live album.
I also like that AT SAN QUENTIN has many Gospel tunes, many of my favorite Johnny Cash Gospel songs, at that! Though sometimes the backup vocals are mixed a little too low in volume, you can still hear the pitch perfect harmonies of the Carter women--beautiful singing, indeed!
The drummer and guitar player are more energetic and dynamic on AT SAN QUENTIN, than on AT FOLSOM PRISON. Sometimes they almost get too rowdy, but mostly they complement the songs well. The guitar player has an added edge of electric guitar distortion, which really gives the musical texture a little more of a rock-n-roll attitude.
The CD booklet has many b/w photos of the day, and tells a lot about the event, (similar to the AT FOLSOM PRISON re-issue, re-mastered CD).
There is some cussing, so be aware of that. Apparently, this concert was being filmed for the BBC from England, but their cameramen and crew get in Johnny's way, onstage, and block Johnny from his audience of prisoners, so he gets irate. There is a photo of Johnny angrily flashing his middle finger.
I would recommend buying both AT SAN QUENTIN and AT FOLSOM PRISON, but if I had to choose only one, I would start with this one, JOHNNY CASH AT SAN QUENTIN.
I can also highly recommend Johnny Cash's spoken word reading of the entire NEW TESTAMENT of the Holy Bible! This is a 16 CD set, that is priced very reasonably (at about $2 per disc, total). My favorite Gospel CD by Johnny Cash is GOSPEL GLORY, which is also a bargain priced CD, and it has many classic Gospel tunes, some of which are played on AT SAN QUENTIN!
THE LEGEND OF JOHNNY CASH may be the best CD to start with if you are new to Johnny Cash's works. It has tons of famous songs from his entire career, and is a CD collection from recent years, so presumably the re-mastering and technical aspects are as modern and as perfect as possible.
If you liked the WALK THE LINE film, or are a Johnny Cash listener, then you will thoroughly enjoy JOHNNY CASH AT SAN QUENTIN!
Fantastic Live Album - Review written on March 09, 2006
Rating: 5 out of 5
4 customers found this review helpful.
Most people know about this album and rightly so, as Cash really delivers somthing special here. Throughout the recording not only does Cash perform his songs exactly as you would expect but his personality really shines as he banters with the prison inmates. It is clear from this album alone why Johnny Cash was so popular with all sorts of people. In between songs he jokes around, tells brief stories and, most importantly, connects with his audience. You can tell he has their full support all the way as they cheer and clap during just about every song.
Standout songs are Boy Named Sue, Folsom Prison Blues, Ring of Fire, the Closing Medley and of course San Quentin. The latter song being performed twice in a row to the request of the inmates who immediately love the song. You can feel the prison guards anxiety as the song causes the inmates to get lively to the lyrics cursing everything about the walls that hold them in.
If you have never heard much Cash before then this isnt a bad place to start as it has a few of his more famous tracks. If you have not heard Cash playing live then this is the perfect place to start. For me this is better than Folsom Prison, thugh that is mainly due to tracklisting. I would think most people would like some aspect of this album, you dont have to be a fan of country music in general (I am not) and nor do you have to know much about Johnny Cash. You never know, if this is your first taste you may end up being a Johnny Cash fan for life.
My dilemma...which is better, this or Live at Folsom? - Review written on February 28, 2006
Rating: 5 out of 5
9 customers found this review helpful.
When I was a kid, I bought a special "two-fer" double LP that contained both LIVE AT SAN QUENTIN and LIVE AT FOLSOM PRISON and I always listened to them as companion pieces. Both crackle with incredible energy, raw and passionate performances, stellar singing and playing, and a tangible sense of danger.
To separate these two albums and try to choose a favorite between them is virtually impossible for me. Let's just say that both the FOLSOM and SAN QUENTIN recordings on CD are indespensible for me...definite "desert island discs." There's nothing stale or formulaic about the SAN QUENTIN, though it comes hard on the heels of the success of FOLSOM. It still sounds fresh and feral, as Johnny races through moments both sacred and profane.
As with FOLSOM, Johnny has incredible rapport with his "captive audience" who were actually anything but--as they listened to Johnny for those few fleeting moments, these prisoners were free indeed. Johnny wasn't going to do anything "by the book" just to satisfy the suits...proof of that is ample but most clearly illustrated when he immediately, deliberately, and gleefully reprises the snarling, intense title track after singing it through once.
Johnny sings many of his own standards and other well-known chestnuts as though he was performing them for the first time, with freshness and vitality. Of course, "Boy Named Sue" WAS being performed for the first time and it remains a hoot, even after all these repeated listenings 37 years later. And don't miss the great Gospel medley at the end, which is totally heartfelt and sincere...and fun. No maudlin sentimentality here; just an alive appreciation for the truth and comfort of the words and the significance of their context.
The packaging and liner notes here are tremendous. Overall, this is a stellar presentation that is not to be missed by any Johnny Cash fan or anyone interested in the core history of country, rock, Gospel, folk, rockabilly, and 20th Century American music.
Middle Instalment of a Brilliant Live Trilogy - Review written on December 31, 2005
Rating: 5 out of 5
8 customers found this review helpful.
Johnny Cash's Prison Albums (Folsom & San Quentin) have long been the stuff of legend, but with the relatively recent release of Live At Madison Square Garden they form a remarkable trilogy: terrific live performances from '68,'69, and late '69, each with a different feel, and an evolution in each of the famous Johnny Cash-June Carter romance. At Folsom, they've yet to wed, at San Quentin, they have, and at Madison Square Garden, Cash proudly announces that June is home because she's pregnant with their son John Carter.
San Quentin stands as perhaps the best summation of these performances and this era, and what is all the more remarkable is how different it is from its Folsom Prison predecessor. There are but two songs overlapping the two ("Folsom Prison Blues" and "I Still Miss Someone") and the musical approach is significantly altered from the bare-bones, ragged-but-right stint at Folsom. For starters, the band is much larger, with Bob Wootton standing in at lead guitar for the tragically deceased Luther Perkins, in addition to the great rockabilly embellishments of Carl Perkins. The Statler Brothers join in on backing vocals, as do the Carter Sisters (providing an unbelievable trumpet imitation on "Ring of Fire"). This results in more fluid performances (no laughs in the middle of a line here), though the atmosphere is still about as volatile as Folsom Prison. This leads to some priceless between-song comedy ("If any of the guards are still speakin' to me..." and in response to the inmates jeering said guard, "Oh, you don't really mean that."), and with the dual performances of "San Quentin", the feeling that there could really be a riot.
Virtually everything there is to love about Cash can be found on this album. The songs display his reverence for contemporary songwriters (the Dylan-penned "Wanted Man" and John Sebastian's "Darlin' Companion"), his deeply authentic faith ("He Turned The Water Into Wine"), and his remarkable ability to sing for, rather than to, his audience (the aforementioned "San Quentin" and "Starkville City Jail"). More casual fans will be glad to see the presence of several Cash classics, including "Big River", "I Walk The Line", "Ring Of Fire", and the then-new "Daddy Sang Bass" and "A Boy Named Sue". For "Sue" fans, be sure to check out Live At Madison Square Garden for Cash doing a hilarious play on the bleeped/unbleeped versions of the song.
Johnny Cash At San Quentin has proved to be one of the most replayable discs in my collection. It's an essential purchase for the Cash fan and an ideal indoctrination for the Cash newcomer.
A little bit of everything from Cash - Review written on December 15, 2005
Rating: 5 out of 5
3 customers found this review helpful.
It's one of those oddities in music history that Johnny Cash's most famous albums are his live concerts at two maximum security prisons, Folsom Prison and San Quentin.
Folsom Prison is quite a different album from San Quentin. Johnny Cash's voice is better in San Quentin, but Folsom was a tightly constructed concert with most of the songs being about prison life. There were a few light moments, but the overall tone of the album was melancholy and serious. One example from the Folsom album is "The Wall," with lyrics like "The newspapers called it a jailbreak plan/ but I know it was suicide."
San Quentin, OTOH, has a little bit for everybody. There are Cash's famous commercial hits, like "I Walk the Line," "Ring of Fire," and "Folsom Prison Blues." There's a rather sentimental duet with June Carter Cash called "Darlin' Companion." There's some gospel-themed songs, like "Peace in the Valley" and "He Turned the Water Into Wine." There's a rather funny "A Boy Named Sue."
And then of course there are the prison songs. San Quentin, with lines like "San Quentin, I hate every inch of you," gets roars of approval, and has to be encored. "Starkville City Jail" and "Wanted Man" are more prison songs.
One great bonus about this cd is that it contains the complete concert because of the longer cd format. You get Johnny Cash speaking to his audience, and also songs not in the original album: "I still miss someone," "Folsom Prison Blues," "Ring of Fire," "Daddy Sang Bass," and "The Old Account Was Settled Long Ago."
If forced to choose between the Folsom Prison album and the San Quentin album, I'd choose Folsom Prison, simply because I like how the entire album is built around a concept. San Quentin is more of a mish-mash.
Still, I would not be without either album.
Lacks the immediacy of FOLSOM, but more than satisfies - Review written on November 17, 2005
Rating: 4 out of 5
2 customers found this review helpful, 1 did not.
Like FOLSOM before it, AT SAN QUENTIN captures Cash and his band playing live before about 1,000 rowdy and emotional inmates, feeding off their energy to create another memorable performance. There is a bit of a staged feeling to this one that I didn't find in AT FOLSOM PRISON; the song selection focusing on prison life and gospel music, with a double shot of the song "San Quentin" that made the prisoners happy but felt a bit forced to me. But there are many highlights here as Cash's energy continues to build from his take on Shel Silerstein's "A Boy Named Sue," that became a novelty hit for Cash, to the wild "The Old Account was Settled Long Ago" where everyone gets into the act and closing with a hard driving medley of hits that ends the concert at full tilt. While it lacks the immediacy of AT FOLSOM PRISON, AT SAN QUENTIN serves as a valuable companion piece and a reminder of the power this man had over an audience.