Over all the game was okay.
Everyone who bought it, including me was shocked. Did Sega forget that a great baseball video game is more than just graphics? When I got this game along with NBA 2K1 and NFL 2K1 I was amazed by the graphics. Preston Wilson looked, batted and threw exactly like he actually does and the stadiums were just breathtaking.
I couldn't wait to get into the game so I did an exhibition game. I was stunned! There was no maual-fielding option, hitting was nearly impossible and getting through an inning without getting shelled was just as hard. I played this game for about 10 minutes trying to figure out if it was just me that I was so bad and that there was no manual-fielding, but I realized that's the way the game is. After playing once or maybe twice I put this game away for good then traded it in along with a few other games for Sonic Adventure 2 and Soul Calibur. That's probably the best move I ever had made.
I now own World Series Baseball 2K2 because I knew it couldn't get any worse. The player graphics are worse, but the stadium's are more detailed. The rosters are more up-to-date, the gameplay is excellent, pitching is fun, hitting has been improved a lot and of course you can actually field unlike this game!
WSB 2K1 is a terrible game. If you want a baseball game for your Dreamcast get WSB 2K2. It's awesome!
The bad news, though, is that there are some INCREDIBLY big problems with gameplay. Number one: FIELDING FIELDING FIELDING. The worst are grounders through the "gap" between first and second. The first baseman is apparently unable to move even three feet to his right in order to snag the ball. Ugly.
Number two: baserunning. How many major-leaguers have *you* seen running on an infield popup with less than two out? Play this game at all, and you'll see guys who get paid more than the GNP of some small countries making that very same bonehead move. The player has to physically remind his baserunners to return to base on a pop-fly.
These two very large problems are enough to really take a lot of the enjoyment out of what would otherwise be a very good game.
There are some other problems, too: the little graphic that shows where the ball (tiny white pixel), defensive players (tiny blue pixels) and runners (tiny yellow pixel that is nearly indistinguishable from the ball) is almost completely useless. The fans in the stands look like something out of a Nintendo 64 game. There's no way to skip past the incredibly awful renditions of the national anthem at the beginning of each game. The replays aren't very interesting. The commentary is wooden and nowhere near as well-done as in, say, one of the excellent NFL games. The controls are not always very intuitive or responsive (especially irritating when you're frantically pressing B to get your idiot baserunners to return to base while they blithely jog along, finally realizing that Oh! You want them to DO something!). These are all pretty petty little quibbles, really, and none of them would be enough to really make this a bad game by themselves, but when combined with the fielding and baserunning problems, the annoyances just mount and mount until you want to chuck your controller at the TV.
(Barely) worth the $15 I spent on it used--for the graphics and to tide me over until WSB2K2 comes out in a couple of weeks.
Since I've bought this game I've gone 0-15 in season mode (with Boston.) Most of those games I was outscored by at least 10 runs. Mind you, the problem is not a lack of effort on my part, or appreciation for deep gameplay, but rather an almost total lack of control over my players.
The computer is omnipotent, and totally in control of the gameplay (it's and your's.) You have almost no chance of getting an RBI, much less winning. And if you are winning in the last few innings, the gameplay becomes totally contrived and the computer begins to hit the ball over second base again and again. Which wouldn't be a problem except that your second baseman is covering first!
I was up 2-1 in the 6th (computer's favorite turn-around inning) when the other team got 9 doubles through the same gap! And everytime my fielder threw the ball to second and my second baseman tagged the bag, instead of the runner!
Also, about all that great pitching that people are talking about- Why is Pedro out of gas after 40 pitches??? Why is it so hard to throw a strike on the outside of the plate??? Why is the ball movement so choppy???
Take my advice and burn your money instead. It will be less frustrating.
<<<< You do feel that the game is a little rushed. The seasons are last years, so you don't get this year's season, obviously. The replays don't have that much value to them. This also has no home-run derbuy like Sega said. <<<< If you are real baseball nut like me, I'd probably wait until your local video rental store has World Series Baseball 2K2. But if you would like a baseball game quickly and for a cheap price, I'd get this. Listen to these stats from World Series Baseball 2K2: spring training (for you grapefruit fans), create AND train players, home-run derby, better realism, and a more complex batting system so you don't hit a home-run every time you swing the bat. So, it's up to you. A better baseball game for $40, or a not as much fun game for $20. Pick what you think is the best for you. Hope you like it if you get it. God Bless! Colin
Let's start with the graphics. Besides AWFUL crowd designs, they are AWESOME! The players are as close to real as you can get, and the stadiums are breathtaking.
The sound... Well, the play-by-play is horrible, but it gets the job done.
Gameplay- No fielding. No fielding. No fielding. But, other than that, it is a very good baseball simulation. This game makes pitcher's duels possible, something that I have never seen before in a console baseball game. No more inflated 20-15 disasters that some call a baseball simulation. Scores no longer can be mistaken for football scores. I like the batting system and the pitching systems... you just have to get used to them. The base-running is tough, but isn't awful if you know what you are doing.
In closing, this game is worth the 15-20 dollars you have to pay for it (I got mine used for 17 bucks) and should last you up until you can buy WS2K2.
Pitching is awesome. Once you figure out the pitches, which naturally make sense (up for heat, down for change, side for slider, down and away for curve, etc.) you realize that you can have different levels of fastballs and curveballs which are most effective at certain times. Even though I've become an awesome pitcher, with Pedro, Hideo (and, well, Bartolo Colon got onto the Sox in my season, too), strikeouts are hard to get against the computer. You don't always want your fastball at the highest limit, for example. Aiming is cool because you don't have a cursor, you can be off, just like a real pitcher. Hitting is cool because the players are so real. You learn their stride, their swing, their timing, and you're ready to go. Pitch selection can be difficult to learn. Baserunning still ..., the players are slow to respond when you tell them to go in a certain direction, it's difficult to work with more than one runner, especially say, stealing second with a man on first and third, while trying to hit the ball as well. During a season, the staistics are kept well, but the All-Star game is a fluke, it just gives you the default rosters with players on their original teams, even if you've done trades during your season. Also, you should be able to play against people during a season and why not be able to play any game druing a season, like the old NBA Live games from Sega Genesis. In all, I am completely satisfied with this game now. The graphics are awesome and the game play gets better with time.