Amazon.com Customer Reviews
Don't Be Afraid of the CGI - Review written on July 13, 2008
Rating: 5 out of 5
I've wanted to add this title to my DVD collection for a while, but hesitated when I saw the controversy about the changes. Still, at $25 for the set, I thought I'd take a chance.
Personally, I think the CGI is great. It looks crisp on an HD screen, and not grainy like all movies would be from this period. It breathes new life into a good, but old movie.
I even wish they would have taken it a step further and updated some of the lo-res computer graphics in the movie. They look like Pong.
The puppets seem kind of campy looking today, and maybe they could have done a little something with those too.
I guess there's no way to cover up some of the stupid dialogue between Han and Lea, but that's another matter.
I do agree with others that both versions should be available, but I'm guessing that would be expensive. The whole "Greedo shot first" thing is pretty bad, and completely changes Han's character, but whatever.
The changes make the two trilogies fit together better, and make modern viewing a little bit nicer.
"I find your lack of faith disturbing"
-Darth Vader
Overrated, but overall, still great - Review written on May 21, 2008
Rating: 5 out of 5
1 customer found this review helpful, 1 did not.
The elements in the Star Wars films are not exactly original. Close to all the ideas are borrowed from different genres spanning from Japanese Samurai films, old Sci-Fi films/serials, Westerns, etc. Then there is the simplistic moral system of the Jedi. There really isn't much genius there. The genius comes from Lucas' knack for innovation of these cliche elements and innovation in general. The genius comes from even thinking of merging all these genres. Without Star Wars, I don't think there would be Shanghai Noon, Big Trouble in Little China, etc. Sure, the creativity is shallow, but it's fun.
I'll now go on to review the individual films.
"A New Hope" sets everything up. There's not much character development.
It's basically a deliciously shallow popcorn film. It leaves you wanting more...
"Empire Strikes Back" is when the story really gets interesting. Luke's force powers are getting stronger and more inner conflict arises. Han is winning over Leia, Luke's future looks a little shaky, and he discover's an awful truth. There's much more swordfighting and it's the best of the series (many will agree).
"Return of the Jedi" shows Luke a full Jedi. You're still not quite sure which way he'll turn. He discovers something that makes him change his mind about Leia, but he's still conflicted. With all the power he's obtained, the weight of responsibility is tremendous. Emperor Palpatine doesn't help much either. There's a fun speedbike race that to this day still looks good. This one comes in close 2nd with Empire.
All 9 Episodes In The Chronicles Have Now Been Released - Review written on May 21, 2008
Rating: 5 out of 5
1 customer found this review helpful, 5 did not.
A lot of people are going to disagree with me on this, but here is the list for the complete Star Wars chronicles- all 9 episodes we've been promised for ages- all now available on dvd:
1. The Phantom Menace (1999)- Episode One
2. Attack Of The Clones (2002)- Episode Two
3. Revenge Of The Sith (2005)- Episode Three
4. A New Hope (1977)- Episode Four
5. The Star Wars Holiday Special (aka Life Day Celebration)-
(Nov.1978) - Episode Five (Face it, it has the same real characters from
Star Wars- Harrison Ford, Carrie Fisher, Mark Hamill, Chewbacca, R2D2,
C3PO, etc., and it has a plot (a silly one) and is not a cheap
cartoon, therefore, it is considered part of the continuing saga.)
6. The Empire Strikes Back - (1980) - Episode Six
7. Return Of The Jedi (1983) - Episode Seven
8. Ewoks Adventure: Caravan of Courage (1984) - Episode Eight
9. Ewoks Adventure: The Battle For Endor (1985) - Episode Nine
(These 2 Ewoks movies are available on a 2-on-1 dvd. If these Ewoks
played such a huge part in the Return Of The Jedi movie, then why
can't these 2 movies be considered episodes 8 and 9? They are the
same Ewoks, not a cheap cartoon, and deserve to be part of the
continuing saga.)
Since George Lucas has now declared there will not be anymore Star Wars
episodes/movies (perhaps a tv series in the future), I have declared the above 9 episodes to now be the complete Star Wars chronicles- and it cannot and will not ever be changed.
Amazing films! Spectacular Quality! A wonderful and essential DVD experience! - Review written on January 26, 2008
Rating: 5 out of 5
2 customers found this review helpful.
THE STAR WARS movies are amazing. The sheer imagination that went into them is spectacular. The original film, A NEW HOPE, topped the charts in '77 and is still, today, the 2nd highest grossing movie of all time, and with good reason. The original STAR WARS trilogy is one of the top three trilogies of all time, and are a must-see for the whole family.
The bonus disc: This bonus disc is the best bonus disc I've ever seen. The main feature, a documentary called EMPIRE OF DREAMS, is spectacular. It's the greatest, most comprehensive look at the making of these magical films. The documentary is accompanied by 4 15-20 minute featurettes, trailers, stills, ect.
The films:
A NEW HOPE: The film that started it all. It's amazingly acted, directed, and the script is engrossing. It's really hard to discribe all three of these films, and that's really all I can say about this one. You have to see it to believe it.
THE EMPIRE STRIKES BACK: This film has to be one of the greatest sequels of all time. Most sequels to successful movies are just rehashes of the original, the work of a director trying in vain to recreate a masterpiece. EMPIRE is one of few exceptions. This sequel carries on the fight of the brave Rebels against the evil Empire. Things go darker this time around, though it's not hellish like the second INDIANA JONES film. The heroes lose a lot, and it leaves you hopeful that things will get better, though wondering how that could ever happen.
THE RETURN OF THE JEDI: This might be one of the greatest climaxes of all time. Great fights, chases, heroes and villains, and weird aliens, like the furry little Ewoks. Everyone reprises their role (thankfully), and you finally get to see the Emperor himself, and trust me, he doesn't disappoint. This is a great wrap-up to the amazing trilogy.
The quality: George Lucas adds to his visual stunning in this trilogy with new second-long shots of aliens and enhanced picture. This really ticks some people off, but I think it adds to the films without really changing much.
Overall:
Great! I recieved this box set a few years ago, and have simply adored it since. If you're a STAR WARS fan, this set is a must-own. And if your not a big fan, even if you don't buy this set, you should still watch the movies. Highly reccommended.
A little newer, but not as bad as you've heard. - Review written on January 14, 2008
Rating: 4 out of 5
1 customer found this review helpful.
OK, yes, Lucas added a whole slew of new stuff to the oroginal films. So what? I thought it was really kinda neat, some of the things that are in there! Truthfully, the only time in the first film that newness was even that obvious was the scene before the take-off from Mos Isley, where Jabba accosts Solo for money. That was obviously CG, but it didn't look that bad. Lucas brought us films that essentially revolutionized film and the way we look at them. What was there before Star Wars? I've read a lot of bad reviews because of the new cg effects, but cut the guy a little slack! He lost a lot to make these movies to begin with... Let the man have his fun with his films! Before you bite into the cg bashing that's been going on, see them for yourself. If you're a lifelong, die hard fan, remember how open your mind was when you first saw them. Relive the experience!
I got this as a gift for my sister and she absolutely loved it! The box was a little bent in at the corners, but there was nothing wrong otherwise. Just a packaging goof, I'm sure.