The remastering of the concerto's by brahms and tchaikovsky were not as good as what I had expected. If you are only looking for these two concertos, you may want to try the "living stero" version. The Scottish fantasy, chaconne, and sibelius in this recording sounds better than the brahms and tchaikovsky.
Overall, this is not the best cd for serious collections, but a good deal for those who want lots of songs for a bargain price.
Bruch's Fantasy is another favorite of mine, especially the final movement. Once again, Heifetz really digs into the music and pulls out all the stops, closing out with a final movement that will have you humming along to the wonderful tune. Sibelius's Concerto is his only full-length concerted work, and it's justly popular. As with so much of his music, it contains moments that just 'hook' you, and forgive me for being repetitive, but Heifetz shines here as well. He never lets up in the first movement, which is a mistake that many make, and the finale goes along at the perfect rate.
The Glazunov concerto is slightly different from normal, being a shorter piece played without pause. The once again the highlight is the finale, with its fanfare and what must be incredibaly virtuosic pizzicato work that Heifetz of course pulls of wonderfully. The final work is his own transcription of the Three Preludes by Gershwin, and they show off a different side of his violin playing, and come off well.
So, unless you are allergic to a bit of hiss, which is pretty minor compared to many recordings from the era these were done in, or simply hate violin music, there's no reason not to get this if you don't own any of the recordings here. For the newbie and vet alike, one would be hardpresses to find 2CDs of violin music with as constant quality, both in music and musicality, as this set.
But if you just want a nice collection of Heifetz music for a person who has none, this is a perfect start.
Even if you find his unique style of playing somewhat offensive, it must be admitted, his playing offers a different style of playing which only he can provide. He gives a new perspective on some passages in the violin repertoire. Perhaps the most controversial selection on this CD is the Chaconne, from Partita No.2 by Bach. It plays almost 50% faster (yes, 50% faster) than several other recordings, and it is here that Heifetz shows his characteristic style of playing best. Although I would not go so far to say as his style of playing the Bach is the best way to go about it, it certainly makes you think about the music.
This is a collection of incredible music. If you love great music, buy this!
These recordings span the years 1955 to 1970 and feature such orchestras as the Chicago Symphony (for the Brahms, Tchaikovsky and Sibelius), the New Symphony Orchestra of London (for the Bruch), and the RCA Symphony Orchestra (for the Glazunov).
The critics at the time had some quibbles with the recorded sound on one or two of these pieces, but they were all lavish in their praise of the performances: "incomparable," "this disc is a must," and so on. So what if you probably have all these selections on other recordings? At mid-price to get all this is heaven. And what a gift for discerning friends!