Amazon.com Customer Reviews
Solid, stable workhorse - Review written on May 07, 2006
Rating: 5 out of 5
22 customers found this review helpful.
I bought this router in order to place it under a router table. Currently, it is mounted in a Bench Dog Prolift, which is, in turn, mounted to the Bench Dog Cast Iron router table. All of this is mated to the left side of my trusty table saw. I think the weight of the set up contributes to a vibration free cut. A vibration free cut makes for a very happy me!
The very first thing I did was to raise a panel with a 3.5" Freud bit. I had used this bit before with a Makita 2.25 hp router. The results were fine, but it took forever and I thought I might burn up my little Japanese friend. Fortunately, we survived intact, but it took a toll on my nerves.
Skip ahead to now, I was able to make the exact same cut in 3 stress-free passes. Then I noticed the most amazing thing: the floor underneath my router table was littered with the most beautiful little shavings of wood. Imagine the fine, translucent shavings you would get with a well tuned Lie-Nielsen bench plane. The cut was beautiful! obviously, just as with stationary power tools, weight is a good thing!
As for the router, it is a solidly made tool. The electronics that control power work well. Upon startup, the router revs up and then slowly winds down to the proper setting. Start feeding your work too quickly and you can almost hear the router grunt as it applies more muscle to the job at hand. Back off on your work and the router speeds up and then slows back down to the correct rpm. I'm not too sure how I feel about the power switch and speed selection switch. neither seem to be protected from dust. I really do not care for the base casting. It is quite rough, with that "made in China" feel to it. However regarding both of these points, I am sure that this router was designed and built with table use in mind. In that case, perhaps these little concerns aren't particularly important... all in all, I am quite happy with my setup. I feel safe in saying that when mounted in a table, this router will produce consistent, high quality work!
Consider carefully before you buy - Review written on February 22, 2006
Rating: 4 out of 5
The Porter-Cable 7518 and 7519 (it's fixed-speed cousin) are solid routers, but you should consider their advantages and drawbacks carefully before you buy.
Handheld, they are beasts, but that's true of all 15A (15 Ampere) routers. They weigh about 13 pounds, and using them is almost like weight training. That may be what you need in a production environment, where you'll beat the router to heck, but it's overkill for a home shop. For handheld use a 12A handheld router is plenty. The primary application for a 15A router is panel raising with large bits, an operation that should never be performed hand-held. (The Ampere rating is an indication of the power the router can safely deliver on a continuous basis without burning out. It doesn't describe the power the router normally draws, just the peak power it's capable of. With smaller bits, you'll never need the kind of power that a 15A router can deliver.)
The chief reason most of us would buy one of these routers is to use it under a router table. In my opinion, the best way to do that is to mount the motor in a router lift device. This enables you to adjust the router height from above the table, without lifting the router and router plate out of the table top (They're heavy and the handles nearly fill the opening, making removal awkward!) or struggling to work under the table. I recommend a router lift that can raise the collet above the table top to simplify bit changes. My choice was the Jointech SmartLift Digital. The JessEm Mast-R-Lift also raises the collet above the table, but I've never used it.
Even in a router table, you need 15A only if you're routinely spinning bits larger than about 2", which are mostly horizontal panel-raisers. A 12A router is fine for most router table use. A 12A router won't last as long if you're using large bits, however.
I can't imagine why anyone but a production shop would buy the 7519. The single-speed feature may provide very slightly higher reliability but it greatly restricts the bits you can use. If you shop, there's no real difference in price between the two models. For almost everyone, the 7518 is the best choice.
Porter-Cable should be ashamed for their unwillingness expend any R&D on the 7518 and 7519. Nowadays, every router has a self-extracting collet, but these are the only routers I know that don't have a locking spindle and therefore require two wrenches for bit change. (PC's latest 2 1/4 horse router has an auto-locking collet, so how primitive is one that doesn't lock at all?) I'd also blast their cheapness for not including a 1/4" collet. The location of the power switch on top of the motor housing can be awkward, since you have to remove one hand from the handles to cycle power.
When using the supplied base, the adjustment mechanism requires turning the aluminum-encased motor housing inside a huge aluminum screw in the base. (Few engineers would design with aluminum sliding on aluminum, particularly when the surfaces can't be lubricated.) Operation is rough and awkward, particularly under a router table. There's nothing to keep dust out of the adjustment mechanism, so the aluminum screw can collect grit, and under extreme conditions can jam. A router lift circumvents all these problems.
In summary, I recommend that you consider the 7518 and 7519 only if you'll be mounting the motors in a router lift. If you don't want to spend the money on a router lift, consider one of the newer routers that has built-in above-table adjustment. 12A routers are now available from Milwaukee (Model 5616-20), Porter-Cable (model 894PK), Freud (model FT1700VCE), and others. The Triton TRC001 is a 15A router that is reputedly excellent for use under a router table, but I haven't used it.
If you want a single router for use in router table and hand-held, buy a multi-base kit to make it easy to switch functions. It is very time-consuming to convert a table-mounted router to handheld use when the router is screwed to the router plate.
Almost perfect! - Review written on June 14, 2005
Rating: 5 out of 5
14 customers found this review helpful.
I am an amatuer woodworker. I bought the 7518 to put in my Bench Dog router table about 5 years ago. I did lots of homework on routers and a majority rated this router high on the list for router table use. I found that it has plenty of power to spare and will handle any bit that will fit in a 1/2 inch collet. It has five speed settings (10,000 to 21,000 rpm) which handle all of the cutting I have ever had to do. The on off switch is a rocker panel style (but I run my 7518 through a "Rousseau" switch that is mounted outside my router table). You do not want to be reaching inside a router table to turn off the power quickly. (The Rousseau is a better switch than the Bench Dog or any other method because it has a "crash bar" over the stop button that is near impossible to miss with hand or knee or anything else you might use.) If there is a drawback to using the 7518 in combonation with a router table, it is the inability of being able to raise the moter up to change bits as some of the newer plunge routers are able to do. (I solved this problem by purchasing the Benchdog Promax Router Lift from Amazon. Addmittedly, I could have continued using the router plate insert and just keep taking the router motor in and out by lifting if out of the table, but the Promax solved several other issues as well, thus justifying the money spent).
And, you need two wrenches (supplied by Porter Cable with the 7518) to change bits. It would be nice if this router had a collet stop locking button, such as found on other routers like the Hitachi MV12, which requires only one wrench to loosen the collet.
UPDATE 04/15/2006
CMT has been selling an angled wrench for Porter Cable routers. I bought one for my router table and the 7518. It helps in changing the bits, even with the ProMax router lift.
Great for table AND handheld routing - Review written on April 11, 2005
Rating: 5 out of 5
14 customers found this review helpful.
Don't be afraid to take this thing out of the table and use it in your bare hands!
This things works fabulously, both in the table and in my hands. For the table, it's a no brainer... this thing rocks and, being Porter-cable, you will NEVER have a hard time finding accessories. It is the standard.
About the hand-held use though: It's big, but the handles are great, makes getting a good grip on it super-easy. In fact, it's the most comfy fit to my hands that I've found (though I have not tried the Milwaukee 3.25hp router). Also, the weight, solidity, and power of the thing makes it such that it doesn't jump around and jerk like my lighter 1 3/4 HP Dewalt. Between its weight and power, it's actually a fantastic hand router, and cuts any wood (as a previous poster stated) "like butter".
I've used it for fairly delicate, precision work in tight areas as well and the really big stuff. Heck, The only time I've even made a bit chirp was when I was using a 2" long, 1/2" flush trim bit on the full thickness of solid 1.75" alder, and I was "trimming" just about the full diameter of the bit... that was just plain stupid of me. The router barely seemed to notice... the bit, however... well, it's resting in "piece(s)".
I would not necessarily want it as my only router in the shop. If it were my only one, I'd go with a 2 1/4 hybrid, because there are definitely times you do need something more manuverable for light trim work. But, if you have the option to buy two (or already have one) having a small packaged 1 3/4hp (or even PC's little 7/8"hp deal) partnered with this one, then you have a near unbeatable routing setup.
Excellent Router -- Too Much For Me? - Review written on September 23, 2004
Rating: 5 out of 5
18 customers found this review helpful, 6 did not.
When I purchased the Porter Cable 7518 I did so because of the great reviews. And it is a fabulous machine! But honestly, I think it's more power than I need.
When I took it out of the box and realized just how massive it is, I decided it would be my "table router" and I went shopping for something I could use by hand. I ended up with the Bosch 1617EVSPK, and I love it!!
In hindsight, I wish I had purchased the Bosch 1617EVSPK combo first. I think the Bosch would handle 75% of the projects that I plan to build.
For operations that require a small table, I think an excellent choice would be the Bench Dog 40-001 ProTop Contractor Portable Router Table.
For operations that require a large table... well, if you get to that point, then I think you should build your own. ;-)
If you're a beginning woodworker, like me, please consider the Bosch 1617EVSPK with the Bench Dog 40-001 ProTop Contractor Portable Router Table.
Good luck!
The Beast Itself - Review written on September 01, 2004
Rating: 5 out of 5
13 customers found this review helpful.
In a sense this is the most straightforward of routers. It has five running speeds - 10,000, 13,000, 16,000, 19,000 and 21,000 rpm. It has a straightforward design reminiscent of the 690, and it has enough power to turn the hardest wood into sawdust. In fact, it has more horsepower (but less torque) than many shapers. Despite the soft-start feature there is a definite jerk when you start it up - this is a big machine. Too big for most home hobbyist needs, as a matter of fact.
The 7518 weights in at 18 pounds, which means you will need to be muscle bound to use it for delicate work. For hand-help purposes I prefer one of the new 890 series, which offer 2.5 horsepower in a smaller package. But where I find the 7518 unbeatable is in a router table. Here you can take maximum advantage of its power and precision - especially for the rigorous tasks like running big panel-raising bits. Used this way, I have nothing but superlatives to say for the tried and true 7518.
Be aware though that no router loves being upside-down. If you are depending on the base for height adjustment, you will need to regularly remove the router from the table and clean it. Also try to set up so that sawdust is quickly removed from the table. I use a solid mechanical lift and a dust collection system, which helps a great deal, but good woodworking habits are critical to making the best of the 7518 or any other stationary router as well.
[Part V of 'How to Build a Really Expensive Router Table']
Make sure you read what's included - Review written on May 04, 2004
Rating: 4 out of 5
11 customers found this review helpful, 4 did not.
I think it's criminal that Porter Cable has chosen not to include both the 1/4 inch and the 1/2 inch collet with this $300 plus router. This collet can't cost more than fifty cents; yet it's retailing for around $12. This is especially true since Porter Cable has joined the ranks of other companies, manufactoring their blades and bits in China. I have a number of Porter Cable tools, and they've always been first rate. I was really surprised when I received my new 7518, and it only had one collet. If they're going to rip you off on a collet, who knows what corners they're going to cut inside the case.
Aside from the collet problem, this appears to be a first rate router. I bought it without comparing it to other routers in it's class because I have several Porter Cable tools, and I trusted their quality. I can't say I have the same level of trust anymore. In the future, I'll definately make some serious comparisons before I buy another Porter Cable product.
Life is sweet!!!! - Review written on June 12, 2003
Rating: 5 out of 5
9 customers found this review helpful.
The Holy Grail of table mounted routers. This is a premium router without the premium price tag. At 14+1/2lbs and 15 amps the Porter-Cable is a substantial Proffessional grade tool. Capable of powering large bits without complaint.
The large base opening will accommodate panel bits without modification. The five speeds will run all bit sizes safely. The heavy duty windings on the motor will sustain prolonged heavy use.
There are no fancy bells or whistles on this baby. It just does one thing, and does one thing well. If you appreciate quality workmanship and materials, buy this router.
Note: READ and follow the cleaning/maintenance instructions included in the operators manual.