The Shirelles - 25 All-Time Greatest Hits Reviews



Amazon.com Customer Reviews

Great, but.... - Review written on March 27, 2006
* * * * *
Rating: 5 out of 5
12 customers found this review helpful.

First point to make is that this is probably the best available Shirelles compilation. As others reviews say, the sound is excellent, it has all the right songs, and to get both versions of Baby It's You is a welcome bonus. But there are 'original' tracks here that may not be exactly what you're used to. The version of 'Welcome Home Baby' is not the same as that on the first compilation of Shirelles' Hits (called, reasonably enough, 'The Shirelles Hits'), which appeared in 1963. This version is more 'mellow'. Similarly, the version of I Met Him on a Sunday is not the same as the one that appeared on a mid-60s compilation (it's slower). There are certainly Shirelles compilations elsewhere (e.g. 'The Fabulous Shirelles' CD) that are definitely not the original singles, and perhaps the only conclusion is that after 40+ years it is hard to pin down the right masters. But this is the one to buy, anyway!
GREAT MUSIC GREAT SOUND AND A LOT OF MEMORIES. - Review written on November 03, 2005
* * * * *
Rating: 5 out of 5
15 customers found this review helpful, 4 did not.

I REMEMBER SEEING THIS GROUP WITH A SUPER ALL-STAR LINE UP AT THE BROOKLYN FOX THEATER,WITH MURRAY THE K. WHAT A CONCERT.ANOTHER SET OF GREAT CONCERTS TOOK PLACE AT THE R.K.O. KEITH THEATER IN FLUSHING QUEENS N.Y.THEY HAD MORE THAN 18 GROUPS,INCLUDING THE SHIRELLES.!!
THE SHIRELLES DISC UNDER REVIEW, CONTAINS 26 HITS NOT 25 AS LISTED.AND HAS MOST OF THEIR TOP 40 HITS,AND HAS EXCELLENT SOUND YOU CANNOT GO WRONG WITH THIS COLLECTION.THIS DISC CONTAINS 10 MORE SONGS,OVER THE RHINO 16 HIT COLLECTION,WHICH I ALSO OWN
One of the best! - Review written on October 25, 2005
* * * * *
Rating: 5 out of 5
2 customers found this review helpful, 3 did not.

The Shirelles were probably one of the few of the best "Girl Groups of the 60's
as good as it gets - Review written on September 07, 2005
* * * * *
Rating: 5 out of 5
1 customer found this review helpful, 3 did not.

Will you still love me tomorrow, much imitated but never ever surpassed. A true golden oldie
One immortal classic plus many other great songs - Review written on April 13, 2005
* * * * *
Rating: 5 out of 5
11 customers found this review helpful, 1 did not.

The Shirelles assured their place in history with their original version of the Goffin-King song, Will you still love me tomorrow, a classic song that has been covered many times in several different styles of music. From an examination of their other music, it is clear that the Shirelles were hugely influential and deserve to be remembered for more than one song.

Apart from Will you love me tomorrow, their best known song is Dedicated to the one I love. Originally written by a member of the Five Royales and first recorded by that group, it was only a minor hit for them. The Shirelles popularised the song, taking it high up the American pop charts, though it failed to chart in Britain. The Mamas and Papas covered the song in the late sixties, when it became a huge UK hit. So Brits finally realized what a great song this is.

Two other Shirelles songs (Boys, Baby it's you) appeared on the debut album by the Beatles. Other great songs include Tonight's the night, Mama said, Soldier boy and Foolish little girl.

Of all the girl groups of the early sixties, the Shirelles were among the best and most important. This compilation shows just how brilliant they were, including all the essentials and many other wonderful songs.
EXCELLENT - Review written on October 18, 2004
* * * * *
Rating: 5 out of 5
11 customers found this review helpful.

Great sound. Very good selection of songs. But the best thing about this CD is that it contains the original version of "I Met Him On A Sunday", the Shirelles' first release which was not on Scepter records, but first released on Tiara, then Decca. Most Shirelles collections have a remake of this song.
Excellent Compilation -- All Fans Will Appreciate It! - Review written on January 02, 2003
* * * * *
Rating: 5 out of 5
40 customers found this review helpful.

This is at heart a singles collection, one that contains all the hits (From "Dedicated To The One I Love", "I Met Him On A Sunday" and "Will You Love Me Tomorrow" to "Soldier Boy" and "Baby, It's You") plus lesser-known gems such as the sublime "A Thing Of The Past" (my favourite Shirelles song...and lead singer Shirley Owens's as well) and the swaying "Maybe Tonight".

The great majority of these cuts were issued as singles, that's how strong the material is. All are presented in their original versions and are digitally remastered, with the majority of the tracks appearing in stereo ("Baby, It's You" is presented both in mono and in stereo; as I'm a fan of wide stereo, it was nice to hear the difference). The sound is impeccable, the selection is nice (but where's "Blue Holiday"? Licensing issues?), and the price is just right. Highly recommended.

Let's Hear It For The Girls! - Review written on October 11, 2000
* * * *
Rating: 4 out of 5
14 customers found this review helpful, 3 did not.

My sister who is three years my senior is solely responsible for my love of the "oldies". I always wanted to be just like her and so her music became my music. The Shirelles were her favorite girl group and I have had a good time digging up CD's for her . We both really loved hearing the music and singing along with it . It bought back so many memories (we are in our 50's) and our grandchildren are singing the songs with us . The are great songs to sing and hear again. We were especially thrilled to hear "Pretty Words" and "What a Sweet Thing That Was". Then we realized that "Blue Holiday" was missing and my search has not produced it. As it doesnot appear on any of the collections I suspect there is a licensing issue. Too Bad. We are still happy to hear this and other old favorites and we especially like that the little ones like it also. One more thing to help bring the generations closer.
You'll know every song - Review written on August 10, 2000
* * * * *
Rating: 5 out of 5
5 customers found this review helpful, 2 did not.

The Shirelles are great. The entire album is upbeat and listening to it will just put a smile on your face. Since I'm a generation X-er, I got to know a lot of their music through film. For example I know there song "Baby Its You" from the movie "Stealing Home" with Jodie Foster and Kevin Costner. And I know the song "Will You Still Love me Tomorrow" beacause of "Dirty Dancing."