Amazon.com Customer Reviews
"THE ROCKTOR" (Lima, Peru) Master of Masters: Steely Dan - Review written on June 04, 2006
Rating: 5 out of 5
5 customers found this review helpful.
Few musicians have the ability of blending jazz textures within a rock context, and then put in some pop flavor instead of showing off (which is a normal tendency when you mix jazz and rock). That's what Becker & Fagen, 2 gifted musicians, did. And the results are unique: from the subtle changes of time signatures in "Deacon Blues", a monster of a song with sax solos and brass and wind sections appearing here and there, and great bass lines; the straight rock and roll of "Bodhisattva", with a duel of keyboard and guitar solos; the latin percussion that opens "Do It Again", not as raw as Santana's and more elegant; the rocking tunes "Black Friday" and "Reeling In the Years", showcasing great vocal harmonies in the chorus, steady drumming and killer guitars; the minimal feeling of "Rikki Don't Lose That Number", with its commanding piano; and the melancholy of "Bad Sneakers".
Music like this, very well crafted and executed, is not done anymore in this days of other musical styles with no substance. A big pity. But, those who were fortunate to listen to it in its heyday, don't forget them; and for those who don't know about (specially the kids), it's time to show them. And this record, a fine compilation originally in vinyl and now on CD, is a great starter for it.
My respects for Steely Dan, master of masters of great music.
Not Deep Enough - Review written on September 01, 2005
Rating: 3 out of 5
2 customers found this review helpful, 4 did not.
First, East St. Louis Tootle-Oo seems like a random pick, but it's a good song just the same.
Anyway, this is one of the many Steely Dan comps on the market. Show Biz Kids, Best of Steely Dan, Gold, Then And Now, Reelin' in the Years, and this one. Although Show Biz Kids is by far the best. This is still good. The question is, DO YOU NEED THIS? If you're new, and on a budget or want just their best-known songs, go here. It's balanced, unlike Show Biz Kids. Each album is represented by two songs except, unfortunately, Royal Scam, only given one (Kid Charlemagne).
The main problem is it doesn't dig very deep at all. The choices are completely obvious (Do It Again, Reelin' in the Years, My Old School, Rikki Don't Lose That Number, Peg, Hey Nineteen), and Peg isn't all that good in the first place. Not even compilation standards such as Show Biz Kids, Doctor Wu, Fez, Haitian Divorce and Pretzel Logic made it. And that's not even skimming the surface of the treasure trove that is the Steely Dan's catalouge.
If you want just the big hits, go here, but if you want something a little more, get Show Biz Kids or just BUY THE FREAKING ALBUMS!
Nice twist - Review written on February 26, 2005
Rating: 5 out of 5
4 customers found this review helpful, 5 did not.
For those that were in the likes of Outkast, Chicago, Simply Red, Tribe Called Quest, Kanye West, Miles Davis, Barry White, Stevie Wonder, Marvin Gaye, Kool and the Gang, Jon B., Alicia Keys, John Coltrane, Ronny Jordan, Norman Brown, Boz Scaggs, The Doobie Brothers and others, you must include this to go into your music collection.
Matter of it is I love Steely Dan and I'm a huge fan to them from the beginning. I first started off w/ the song "Peg" which is my all-time favorite and I started singing and then after that, I started listening to their entire compilation I never heard of. Once I became a fan to SD, I knew they had an album coming out which was 2000's "Two Against Nature" and soon inducted to the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame, I was blessed that they'll go in rock history.
The group never had a problem mixed a lotta styles of music they grew up on for instance Donald Fagen (who is the keyboardist and lead member of the group, and now a talented solo artist and a good saxophone player), also had his style like others to Daryl Hall of Hall and Oates, Miles Davis, Barry White and others w/ a good groove and talented message. And there came his partner Walter Becker (the 2nd and last member of the group that plays guitar, piano, keyboards, bass and everything) is always hot on his solos and everything. One thing I like about Steely Dan is that they do an instrumental break on every song and album they did after singing from verse to verse or whatever. Pretty amazing.
Long story short, they formed in '72 or '71 and first founded the group off a lunch box from a porn movie or something. May have to lookup their history a little bit more. I actually love all of their greatest hits they did which was amazing.
Favorite songs I like are: F.M. (the theme song to the movie), Black Friday (kinda reminds me of Miles Davis' "Kind of Blue" or Duke Ellington of course), Babylon Sisters, Deacon Blues, Hey Nineteen (that's one of my old school song w/ nice feel to it), Peg, Kid Charlegmagne, Bodhisitavva, Do It Again and the remake of Duke Ellington's classic "East St. Louis Toodle-Loo".
That's all I can think of at this moment. But I recommend this for fans of John Mayer, Outkast, Kanye West, Common, The Roots, Maroon 5, Stevie Wonder, Brand New Heavies, Miles Davis, Jon B., Simply Red, Nelly, Twista, Guru, Brand New Heavies, Jamiroquai, and others.
1 of many SD comps, but one oddity helps this disc stand out - Review written on January 03, 2005
Rating: 5 out of 5
6 customers found this review helpful, 1 did not.
Steely Dan, a definitive soft rock/ jazz rock group, have had a lot of greatest hits/ best of compilations released over the years with a lot of recycling of the same tracks. "A Decade of Steely Dan" was originally released in 1985, & it manages to somewhat stand apart from other Dan compilations such as "Gold" and the 1978 "Greatest Hits". With Steely Dan's 1972-1980 output being, in general, so astonishingly consistent and filled with brilliant songs, plus the fact that their biggest hits do tend to rank among their best work, it's pretty hard to screw things up when assembling a Steely Dan greatest hits/ best of. The tracks on "Decade" are not presented in chronological order, however there is at least one track from each of their '72-'80 albums, & with the track selection being as as strong as it is, this is a great listen and an effective overview of their career. The only inclusion that's particularly questionable is the Duke Ellington/ Bubber Miley-penned instrumental "East St. Louis Toodle-Oo"--yes, I like it, & it's certainly clever, but it's a questionable choice when such total Dan classics as "Any Major Dude Will Tell You", "Any World (That I'm Welcome To)", and "Haitian Divorce", among many others, are missing in action. Still, like I said, this is an effective overview of a band who had boundless creativity when it came to sophisticated, arresting compositions. The thing that really sets this compilation apart is that it contains a version of the soundtrack tune "FM" that has a haunting, extended song-ending guitar solo passage from Walter Becker; this is the only Steely Dan CD I know of that contains this superior version of this classic song--the "Citizen" box set, the 2 CD "Show Biz Kids" set, and the aforementioned "Gold" CD all contain the inferior version that ends with an extended sax solo instead. Also, the musician/ performance credits for each individual track are a solid bonus. With a band like Steely Dan, obviously there's a lot more you need than just what's on this disc, but still, it's filled with great songs and is an effective compilation.
(P.S. Somewhere along the line the "A Decade of Steely Dan" CD was indeed re-released ("original recording remastered" as they say), but the packaging remained extremely similar. The sound quality on the older version certainly isn't BAD, so it's a solid bargain if you see it around for a couple bucks somewhere. I wouldn't recommend spending a LOT more for this newer version.)
That funky, glorious 70's feel. - Review written on October 31, 2004
Rating: 5 out of 5
1 customer found this review helpful, 1 did not.
This album is a wonderful laid-back compilation of the incredible sounds of Steely Dan from 1972 to 1981, which graced so many parties and poolside sunbathing during the Golden Age of the 1970's and beyond.
Each song runs nicely into the next, as jazzy melodies, or rythymmed disco hits.
My personal favorites are F.M (1978), Bodhisattva (1980), Deacon Blues (1978), Hey Nineteen (1980), Rikki Don't Lose That Number (1974) and the classic Reelin' In The Years (1972).
This is classic modern jazz at it's very best, and some of the best music of it's time.
Always with that funky, glorious 70's feel.
For the Listener Who Only Wants the Hits - Review written on April 06, 2004
Rating: 5 out of 5
1 customer found this review helpful.
The later released 2-disc set "Show Biz Kids" was for the fan who wasn't ready for a relationship, yet still wanted a lesson in the musical tapestry of Steely Dan...but "A Decade Of" is strictly for the listener who wants only the radio favorites and none of the details. These 14 songs document Steely Dan's first era before their 1980 dissolution, with two tracks from each album, except "The Royal Scam" which is only represented by one. If you don't want a musical commitment, or are on a very tight musical budget, "A Decade of Steely Dan" is for you. You'll get the hits and steal a small glimpse at the minds of their creators, Walter Becker and Donald Fagen; the pop of 'FM,' 'Babylon Sisters,' 'Peg,' and the gutters of 'Black Friday' and 'Kid Charlemagne' will still teach you something.
Really Good CD - Review written on August 28, 2003
Rating: 4 out of 5
1 customer found this review helpful, 1 did not.
Though I really don't know why, this is a really good CD. I've only given one of the 14 tracks an excellent rating, but fully nine tracks get really good ratings. Three more get good ratings and only one gets an OK rating. If I try to deconstruct each song into its lyrics and type of music, I ought to not like this CD at all. However, maybe because the music came out in my college days, taken as a whole, I like darn near everything. My specific track ratings are:
1. F.M. -- 4 Stars
2. Black Friday -- 2 Stars
3. Babylon Sisters -- 3 Stars
4. Deacon Blues -- 4 Stars
5. Bodhisattva -- 4 Stars
6. Hey Nineteen -- 4 Stars
7. Do It Again -- 5 Stars
8. Peg -- 4 Stars
9. Rikki Don't Lose That Number -- 4 Stars
10. Reeling In The Years -- 3 Stars
11. East St. Louis Toodle -- 4 Stars
12. Kid Charlemagne -- 3 Stars
13. My Old School -- 4 Stars
14. Bad Sneakers -- 4 Stars