Amazon.com Customer Reviews
A classic collection - Review written on January 20, 2008
Rating: 5 out of 5
This product is the same greatest hits collection that has been available for a decade, but now packaged in a slimline case rather than the old bulky double-CD case. The tracklist is identical, and I don't notice much audio quality difference between the two.
The tracklist is as good now as it was 1o+ years ago. Sure, there's a little fluff in here. "Touch Me" has never sounded at home in this tracklist. I've never really liked "Roadhouse Blues" or "LA Woman", but they were hits and I guess it's nearly obligatory that they be included. Still, the rest of the tracklist is outstanding. In the iTunes-era, we aren't really bound by a pre-selected "greatest hits" lineup anyways. For the current price of $10 for this product you'll get 19 great tracks, and you can then supplement it with a few singles here and there from iTunes or Zune marketplace to build the essential Doors collection. This product contains the two long tracks, "The End" and my favorite "When the Music's Over", that cannot be purchased as single mp3's because of their length, so this collection is probably the best way to get those songs.
When you're building a collection of psychedelic rock, you have to include these songs. What Donovan was to psychedelic folk, what the Zombies were to psychedelic pop, so the Doors are to psychedelic blues. This is a great value for a great record.
He's hot, he's sexy and he's still dead, - Review written on March 23, 2007
Rating: 5 out of 5
11 customers found this review helpful.
I got into The Doors kind of late into my long musical appreciation life. It may have something to do with the fact that, while in college, I was next-door to a guy who was Morrison-nuts...the kind of guy that insisted that Jim Morrison had faked his death and was just waiting for the right moment to come out of hiding. As such, he blasted The Doors' albums incessantly for the school year 1981, and I was over the whole thing pretty much by the time I'd graduated.
However, time has unburdened me of this irrational Doors-disgust. Which means that I was really happy to see this CD reissued as a precursor to the massive Doors campaign of 2007. A new box set, all the individual albums remastered, etc. But as a casual fan, "The Best of The Doors" is all I really need. It covers all the obvious radio hits along with some choice album tracks. (And just as obviously, ignores the postmortem Morrison records, 1971's Other Voices and 1972's Full Circle.) It also re-established Morrison's shamanistic personality. There was a deep, deep charisma about the man and it comes through on all the songs here. The other 3/4 of The Doors were just as unique.
Jim Morrison's ghost and the subsequent collapse of the band after his death - not to forget the incessant squabbling since - tends to cloud the surviving members' contributions. Ray Manzarek's keyboards are one of the reasons The Doors never needed a bass player. Those psychedelic swirls and heavy foundations provided The Doors with their pulse. Guitarist Robbie Krieger added classical fills next to Manzarek's keyboards and also wrote many of The Doors' biggest hits (including "Light My Fire"). John Densmore was a jazz drummer who brought that influence to the band, and he remains the member most opposed to the "reunion" projects. The Doors were always greater than the sum of their parts, and once the cloaking charisma of Morrison was gone, the atoms just blew apart.
The band, as members to a whole, mixed all those influences up. From the pop sense of "Light My Fire" to the Oedipal weirdness that fueled "The End," they were totally fearless about following their collective muse. They responded to accusations of pop-sellout by going to the deep blues of "LA Woman" and by nailing a cabaret number like Brecht/Weill's "The Alabama Song." They even managed one of the most paranoid mellow songs ever in "Riders On The Storm."
That is what makes "The Best Of The Doors" worth it. You may find yourself tempted to get some of the singular CD's later (I'd suggest the debut and "LA Woman"), but for a load into the MP3 player, this double CD set fills the gap. Jim Morrison remains a mystery, a loaded question that exited the world before the answers had time to form. (Or he got old enough to be boring.)
Obligatory "Wish it was on this set" songs: "The WASP," "Running Blue" "20th Century Fox."
Hello. I love The Doors. The End. - Review written on January 28, 2007
Rating: 5 out of 5
3 customers found this review helpful.
Great art transcends all. Do I really care if artists like Beethoven or Picasso were decent people in their times? It helps but not really (ok, to be sure neither committed any heinous acts of the human flesh kind). Two hundred years from now no one, except perhaps a few musicologists, will be concerned about Jim Morrison "the man". The music will (I hope) prevail and continue to speak loudly, although know-all sites like Wikipedia may spell the death of a person's actual life story through rumor and gossip run amok (inarguably fodder for future discussions.). In spite of, or perhaps because of (?) his tortured life and difficult personality, Jim Morrison the vocalist (backed by equally talented and magical keyboardist Ray Manzarek, guitarist Rob Krieger. and drummer John Densmore) did their own thing; and whether they knew it or not they blazed a trail that is outlasting their generation. The anthemic JM "voice" has moved on through other acts (some great in their own right) such as Ian McCulloch (Echo & The Bunnymen), Chris Cornell (Soundgarden), Eddie Vedder (Pearl Jam). If you are familiar with and enjoy these more recent performers but are new to The Doors do yourself a favor: get with the program and buy this excellent album.
Ok, so I never heard the Doors, I admitt they are good - Review written on November 08, 2006
Rating: 5 out of 5
3 customers found this review helpful, 2 did not.
I was a kid when Morrisn died... and now, after 40 I listen to this great cd, good collague, sounds dated, but there is music there!! that I have to tell you, great concepts were explored, you get the deep ones and the not-so-deep, yet the combined effect makes it a good collection.